Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
Former Indian Ambassador Dilip Sinha speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on his recent book “Imperial Games in Tibet: The Struggle for Statehood and Sovereignty”| SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
Follow
10/24/2024
Former Indian Ambassador Dilip Sinha speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on his recent book “Imperial Games in Tibet: The Struggle for Statehood and Sovereignty”| SAM Conversation
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
Welcome to SAM Conversation, a program of South Asia Monitor. It is our pleasure to
00:15
welcome Mr. Dilip Sinha, former ambassador, whose latest book, Imperial Games in Tibet,
00:30
is worth reading. It's very, very educative because the gobbling up of Tibet by China
00:41
is something which has not been described enough or written by enough scholars and writers.
00:57
It's a catchy title. That's a very significant one, Imperial Games in Tibet, because Tibet
01:07
was the result of the great game between the British and the Russians. India is one of
01:23
the countries which also got very, very seriously affected and till date it is suffering from
01:32
the effects. And over the years, this great game has maybe, you know, it's got another big player,
01:42
the US, and another big player which was there, Russia, is not now immediately in the picture.
01:50
The equation between India and Russia is different now. But I think all who refer to India,
02:05
who refer to the India-China border, need to be corrected. It is the India-Tibet border,
02:13
3,488 kilometers long, and referred to by India as the line of actual control. And if you take a
02:28
larger look at it, from the Chinese side, it's a line of no control, a line which they are trying
02:36
to control. That's just a personal comment, but it's one which comes with having studied them
02:45
from the time one was a schoolboy, and I had an elder brother who was in the army in 1962.
02:52
I'll end soon. The Dalai Lama or Tibet, mention of Tibet, one has realized its experience. Very
03:12
often when discussing it with Chinese, they see it's like a red rag to a bull, particularly if
03:21
it's a Chinese government official like army or a scholar sponsored by the government. In 1975,
03:31
in Tulungla, Arunachal, there were four personnel of the 5th Battalion of Assam Rifles who were
03:43
captured by the Chinese PLA. They were tortured to death. Mainly why? Because it is the 5th Assam
03:52
Rifles Battalion which escorted the young Dalai Lama inside India, guarded and escorted him,
03:59
and that is not forgotten by the PLA. I'll briefly show some photographs which I have
04:12
included in my book on China. These are from my book in 2022, China's Bloodiest Bulletless
04:29
Borders. Anyway, I will not take any more time. Dilip sir, your book is very interesting and
04:40
very informative. Well, thank you for having me on your show. It's a great honour to be present,
04:48
to be able to talk about my book and to present the cause of our largest neighbour, Tibet,
04:55
which is currently under Chinese occupation. As you have very correctly pointed out,
05:01
we have never shared a common border with China. Our border historically was always with Tibet.
05:07
It was only in the 1950s that the Chinese army got stationed on the India-Tibet border. India,
05:19
of course, recognised Tibet as being under the suzerainty of China. But on account of this
05:26
admission of India, China not only claims Tibet but also large parts of the Himalayas, the sub-Himalayan
05:37
terrain, which has traditionally had close religious links with the Dalai Lama and with
05:46
Tibetan Buddhism. So, it is regions like Ladakh and Sikkim and Bhutan and Arunachal Pradesh,
05:53
these are all areas claimed by China. So, we have to be extremely careful about the policy that we
06:02
pursue in Tibet because it has implications for our own security. Now, Tibet has been historically
06:11
our largest neighbour. You mentioned the length of our border. It has been historically the longest
06:17
land border that we have had with any country. But what is interesting is that it has also been
06:23
the most peaceful border because historically we never stationed any troops on this border.
06:28
We didn't need to station any troops on this border because the border was very broadly defined
06:33
as borders were in those days and very few people crossed them, never did an army cross,
06:39
of course, perhaps except for one or two occasions which are negligible in this long history that we
06:46
have had. And historically our relations with Tibet have been extremely close, so close in fact that
06:54
the longest serving dynasty in Tibet which served from about 2nd century BC to
07:03
the 8th century, 9th century CE, that dynasty called the Yarlung dynasty according to
07:10
Tibetan tradition was founded by a member of the family of Mahatma Buddha. That is the kind of
07:17
linkage that Tibet sees with India and of course subsequently Buddhism travelled from India to
07:25
Tibet and all the Tibetan scriptures are translated from Sanskrit and Pali into Tibetan and not only
07:37
translated into Tibetan, historically Tibetans have had very close links with their northern
07:43
neighbours, Mongolia, the Manchus, to a certain extent even China and the Buddhism that travelled
07:50
to Manchuria and to Mongolia was through Tibet. It was the Tibetans who translated their texts
07:59
from Tibetan into their languages and that is how Tibetan Buddhism spread into other parts of
08:05
Central Asia. In China, Buddhism went both directly from India across from eastern Turkestan
08:13
through people like Wen Sang Xuan Zhang whom we all know about but also separately through Tibet.
08:21
So it is this but today China aims to monopolise Buddhism and it claims that Buddhism
08:29
actually is indigenously Chinese and Tibetan Buddhism is an offshoot of Chinese Buddhism
08:36
which really is a mockery of history. So it is very important for us in India to understand
08:44
our historical links with Tibet, our cultural links with Tibet and of course the fact that
08:51
when Tibet was attacked by China in 1950-51, the people of Tibet looked to India for help
09:01
and then eight nine years later in 1959 when Chinese forces carried out a very brutal repression
09:10
of the uprising in Tibet then the Dalai Lama and thousands of Tibetans fled to India and they took
09:17
refuge in India and China has never forgiven us for giving shelter to the Dalai Lama. You
09:24
mentioned about the 1962 war that came just three years after India gave shelter to the Dalai Lama.
09:32
So China wanted to slap India in the face for this action of hostility or perceived hostility to China
09:43
and that China has never forgotten and China continuously now not only sees the Dalai Lama
09:52
both as a splittist and occasionally as a terrorist and also keeps claiming Indian territory. So we
09:58
have to formulate our Tibet policy very very carefully keeping in mind both the interests
10:03
of our large neighbour which looks to India for help for spiritual inspiration and guidance
10:08
but also for our own national security. Thank you Dilip sir. One has had the opportunity to
10:17
visit four or five places in India where there are Tibetan settlements like
10:26
Pathankot, Dalhousie, McLeodganj, Dehradun. There is a place called Amdo Tibetan
10:39
it's an eatery. Amdo is a very significant word and in all four of these places in the early 70s
10:52
when I had the opportunity of going and visiting these places it was
11:00
also for the pleasure of eating chow chow and momos and thukpa, Tibetan dishes which
11:08
you get in the eateries. One met about five at least veterans of the China-Tibet war.
11:22
You know that very fierce confrontation which they had and a couple of them showed photographs
11:32
a very young version of themselves with a revolver or a weapon photograph.
11:45
They shared briefly some of the experiences when one asked them.
11:53
In Delhi also one has had the opportunity of interacting with
12:01
their officials of the government in exile. Otherwise I think the most common news that
12:10
one hears about them is of still being exploited in so many ways of so many of the monks committing
12:21
suicide of the PLA. The PLA is even trying to now incorporate them in their army and
12:36
the way they are being exploited within China in all kinds of
12:42
forms. It is sad but it is a fact. What all other you will say is the most
12:58
outstanding or highlighted points about your book?
13:03
I got into the writing of this book essentially because I felt that in the discourse that
13:12
we are having in India or we have in India on India-China relations with the focus being on
13:20
what we call the India-China border dispute. We ignore the most important factor which is Tibet.
13:31
Most books that I have read written either by Indians or by foreigners
13:36
on India-China relations focus on what they call the India-China border dispute
13:42
and in this they scrutinise with a very fine tooth comb India's claims.
13:49
They pick loopholes in those claims and they say India's claim is weak. Therefore,
13:56
China's claim is correct and they accept China's claim as Q.E.D. Confusion reached.
14:04
They do not examine China's claim. So, I started looking at China's claim
14:10
and then I found that there is after all there is Tibet in between and the Chinese army
14:18
historically has crossed the Himalayas only once and that was in 1793 when the emperor
14:24
Qianlong, who was a Manchu emperor, he had sent an army at the invitation of the Tibetans
14:30
because Tibet was being continuously raided by the Gurkha rulers of Nepal. So, the Tibetans got
14:39
very disturbed and they asked the Qianlong emperor, who was also a Buddhist and a patron of
14:43
Tibetan Buddhism, to send an army. So, he sent a Manchu army led by Fukan Khan who came down
14:50
from Beijing, crossed Lhasa, came down, crossed the Himalayas and then threatened Kathmandu.
14:56
This was in 1793 and then the ruler of Nepal accepted the terms. He also accepted the terms.
15:08
A peace treaty was signed and he withdrew. That was one occasion. That's the first occasion when
15:14
a Chinese army had crossed the Himalayas and entered not India but Nepal. The second location
15:20
was in 1910 when the governor of Sichuan province, a person called Cao Erfang. Cao Erfang
15:27
was a very brutal governor of Sichuan and he had been appointed by the Manchu emperor in the dying
15:33
days of the Manchu dynasty, Manchu rule in China and he invaded Lhasa, butchered a lot of people
15:43
there and then his troops also crossed into Arunachal Pradesh. Now, this disturbed the British
15:52
and they decided that they would need to draw up the border between India and Tibet and of course
15:59
subsequently Cao Erfang, the Manchu dynasty was overthrown. There was Chinese revolution.
16:06
The Manchu dynasty was overthrown and Cao Erfang was killed by the people
16:13
and the 13th Dalai Lama declared independence in 1913. When he declared independence,
16:21
the British decided that the border between Tibet and India, at least the northeast, must be defined
16:26
and they called the representative from Tibet and the representative from China. China at that time
16:31
was in civil war. So, they picked up one of the two governments in China, recognized it one two
16:36
weeks before the conference started, called them over to India and this was the Shimla conference
16:42
and the outcome of it was a tripartite agreement which decided the McMahon line. The Chinese did
16:50
not get the significance of the Shimla agreement. The British of course followed a very very very
17:00
dubious kind of policy where they called the Tibetan representative to India, had him sign
17:06
the agreement as a high contracting party but the agreement also says that Tibet is under the
17:11
sovereignty of China and this was part of the agreement and this is where the title of my book
17:17
comes, The Imperial Games in Tibet because the status of Tibet was decided by Britain and Russia.
17:28
Britain and Russia were fighting for supremacy in Central Asia right across from Iran to the
17:36
northeast of Asia and Britain was trying to ensure that Russia did not come anywhere close to the
17:43
British Empire in India. So, in 1907 they came to an agreement by the Manchu rulers of China
17:53
but the Manchu dynasty had subsequently become very weak. You know in the 18th century
17:58
the Manchu China, the Chinese empire under the Manchu or the Qing dynasty was a very powerful
18:04
and a very rich dynasty, probably the richest country in the world at that time in the 18th
18:08
century but in the 19th century it had become very weak because Europeans were taking away
18:14
concessions on the pacific ocean side, the Russians were eating away into the north. So,
18:20
Britain and Russia decided that it was best to keep Tibet as a buffer not between Britain and
18:29
China but between Britain or the British Empire in India and the Russian Empire and both felt that
18:35
keeping Tibet under the Chinese empire was perhaps the best thing to do. The Tibetans also did not
18:42
quite mind being under Chinese suzerainty at that time because the Manchu rulers were also
18:49
followers of Tibetan Buddhism. They respected Dalai Lama, they kept him and they honoured him.
18:55
The fifth Dalai Lama in fact in the 17th century had gone down to Peking and the Chinese emperor,
19:07
the Manchu emperor had welcomed him, built a palace in his honour and asked him to help them
19:13
organise the administration of the Manchu empire. They also devised the Manchu script
19:20
and helped the Manchus develop scriptures or Buddhist texts in the Manchu language. So,
19:26
the Manchu emperors greatly revered the Tibetan rulers. So, Tibet did not quite mind being
19:32
under the overall suzerainty of China because they did not interfere in day-to-day affairs in Tibet
19:38
but the situation changed under Chow Ar Fung. When Chow Ar Fung became governor of Sichuan province,
19:45
he was for some reason extremely brutal and he came in and he started
19:49
trying to plunder Lhasa and that is when the differences became very acute between
19:57
Tibet and China. Even in 1951 when China invaded Tibet, some Tibetans felt that perhaps
20:06
the communist China would not be brutal, they would also be like the Manchu rulers,
20:12
they would respect Chinese autonomy and in fact if you remember in May 1951, there was an agreement
20:18
signed between Tibet and China which is called the 17 point agreement under which China agreed
20:24
to respect Tibetan autonomy, agreed to respect the institution of Dalai Lama, the Tibetan Buddhism
20:32
and the internal autonomy of China but they could not respect their own commitments and very soon
20:40
they started repressing the people, carrying out cultural genocide. You talked about the repression,
20:47
the Tibetans estimate that nearly a million people have been killed in Tibet, there have
20:52
been periodic uprisings and right now there are boarding schools being set up where all Tibetan
20:59
children are taken into colonial style boarding schools where they are only taught Chinese language,
21:05
taken away from their families, from their parents. So, that is the kind of repression
21:10
that is taking place now. Earlier, trying to convert them to becoming. This is the
21:19
harnification of Tibet and earlier Tibetans could come across through Nepal into India
21:28
till about 2007-2008 but lately their numbers have come down to a trickle because China has
21:34
is fencing the border in Nepal as you must have seen and it is also building border villages
21:41
to keep an eye on Tibetans trying to cross the border. So, Tibet is becoming, has become a prison
21:49
where Tibetans are not allowed to come out, not allowed to meet their families, relatives
21:56
and Tibetans outside are not allowed to visit Tibet.
22:02
There are, you mentioned villages, there are about 800 I think villages that they have
22:11
which are strewn across the, along the line of actual control or the India-Tibet border which is
22:20
referred to as the disputed Sino-Indian border but the India-Tibet border. It's very alarming
22:31
although very recently in the last day or two there seems to have been some stepping down,
22:41
I'll believe it only if it happens on the ground, from what they did in 2020 which amounted to
22:48
the second aggression by China. The first aggression was in 1962. 2020, May and June
22:56
were easily what could be, you know, termed as a second aggression and much of what they
23:07
grabbed then, it is reported that they're going to de-escalate and, you know, try and
23:18
get back to the pre-May 2020 status. There's a book by Major K. C. Johre. I wonder if you
23:28
read that. It was actually about pre and post 1962. He was 94 when he wrote it about five years ago.
23:41
He was from the Indian Frontier Administrative Service in the post-independence days and had,
23:53
was actually posted in Tibet. He mentioned something about, you know, a lot of documents,
24:05
a lot of, you know, records not being, you know, with us. Is that so?
24:17
What you're trying to bring out is that China often wins when they, you know, refer to history
24:26
of that period, you know, pre and post-independence,
24:30
of which we don't seem to have any records. Well, nor do the Chinese. The first thing to
24:39
examine is what is China's claim to Tibet? Now, China claims that Tibet is a part of China.
24:47
The question is when did Tibet become a part of China?
24:53
Chinese historians themselves do not agree on when Tibet became a part of China. Some say it
24:59
became a part of China under the Manchus, which means 18th century. Some say no, it became a part
25:05
of China under the Mongols, that is the Yuan dynasty, which means the 13th century. So,
25:11
you go back five centuries. Some say it became a part of China under the Tang dynasty, which means
25:16
you go back to about the 9th century CE or 8th century CE. Now, the Chinese claim that it has
25:27
been a part of China since ancient times. Now, what does ancient times mean? Nobody knows. Now,
25:35
China claims that Tibetan language is a part of what they call the Sino-Tibetan family.
25:41
Now, Tibetan is nowhere, is nothing like Chinese. It's a completely different family of languages.
25:47
It is closest to a family of languages you can call the Tibeto-Burman,
25:52
Tibeto-Burmese family. People who speak Sikkimese and Bhutanese can understand Tibetan because they
25:59
have been traditionally very close languages. So, it is nothing like Chinese and the Tibetan
26:05
script was developed by Tibetan monks who came down to India, Tibetan pundits who came down to
26:11
India and they prepared the script on the basis of the late Brahmi script of the Gupta period.
26:19
So, the script, if you look at the script, anybody who knows Devanagari script today
26:23
or any Indian, North Indian script can easily see Kaka Gaga written there. It's that similar.
26:31
The Tibetan religion, although Chinese claim that it has come from China, the fact is that if you
26:36
look at all their textbooks, all the 300 volumes are translations of texts from India. In fact,
26:43
today the teachings of the Buddha are best compiled in Tibetan because in India,
26:49
a lot of the books were destroyed. And in fact, when Nalanda University was set on fire,
26:54
a lot of the books were rescued by monks, both Tibetan and Indian, who took them to Tibet.
27:05
And in the 20th century, early 20th century, there was an Indian Mahapundit called
27:10
Sankrityan, Rahul Sankrityan, who traveled to Tibet and he collected many of these
27:16
manuscripts and brought them to India. And these manuscripts are lying in Patna museum today.
27:22
So, these manuscripts have been rescued from Tibet and when the Tibetan monasteries were destroyed,
27:27
a lot of the manuscripts were destroyed by the Chinese army.
27:33
Now, China did not know anything about the border of Tibet and India. It was only after their army
27:44
came into Tibet in 1951, their army moved into Lhasa in October 1951. And thereafter,
27:51
they slowly spread themselves to the borders of Tibet and they were shown by whichever Tibetans
27:59
were prepared to collaborate with them, they were showed the frontier of where Tibet ended
28:04
and where India started, which is how one of the first maps that the Chinese published
28:10
of Tibet was I think in 1957 or 59. There was no map before that.
28:17
And of course, Aksai Chin, they took because the traditional route between
28:23
Xinjiang and Tibet was through Ladakh. But since Ladakh was under Indian control,
28:31
they made a new road across Aksai Chin, which was a very unnatural road. And this road was
28:39
built by the Chinese with Russian help because the Russians were very close in Xinjiang at that
28:44
time. So, their engineers came down and helped the Chinese build this road. And the first reports of
28:50
the construction of this road through Aksai Chin came actually in some British newspapers
28:54
through Russian sources in 1952. So, the Chinese slowly came in, they understood the terrain
29:05
and then by the late 1950s, they started asserting and defining their claim lines.
29:13
But to date, they do not really draw a clear line of what they claim.
29:18
They say that it is an imperial legacy. Of course, it is an imperial legacy.
29:25
But Chinese control over Tibet is also an imperial legacy.
29:29
You know, since 2020, we have had about 24 meetings, I think, co-commander level meetings.
29:43
And it is now, like I said, I will believe it only when it happens on the ground. Whatever
29:50
has been reported in the last couple of days of a bit of de-escalation and, you know,
29:58
reverting back to a pre-May 2020 status. While on the one hand, they are doing that,
30:06
on the other hand, they are arming themselves very heavily with all indications of, you know,
30:17
actually preparing for a war. A war which, ironically, they do not want to fight by
30:26
firefights. But because in 1967, in some skirmishes that we had in Sikkim,
30:34
at which time we, you know, the difference was that in 62, we had an ancient rifle.
30:41
In 67, we had a modern self-loading rifle, which we lost. In 67, they lost over 400.
30:52
And it is after that, that they expressed very hard that let us not fire at each other.
30:57
So, they are very, very shy about, you know, actual close quarter combat,
31:06
in which, you know, with firearms. However, what do you see as
31:15
the Tibet's future, which so far, I'm afraid, seems very bleak?
31:26
Well, Tibet's future, yes, it certainly looks quite bleak, because China has become an extremely
31:33
powerful country. It is the world's second largest economy. Militarily, it's extremely strong,
31:39
and it is also extremely aggressive. So, it is not willing to negotiate. You're talking about
31:46
the border talks that have been taking place between India and China. Now, all that we have
31:51
agreed upon in these 30 years of talks is to maintain peace and tranquility. They have not
31:58
made any further progress than that. And even that tranquility is difficult to maintain, because we
32:02
lost 20 of our people in Galwan the other day. Although the result of it was that of the Chinese
32:10
lost, it was reported as 43, then they lost, I think, 100, at least, if not more.
32:17
Okay. So, we are looking at the Tibetan people who have a government in exile, but no country
32:26
in the world recognizes that government as a government in exile. Now, the United States
32:32
has made some very small beginnings by passing an act, the Tibet Support Act, or Resolve Tibet Act,
32:39
in which they have recognized certain rights of the Tibetans. It's a very small beginning.
32:45
India has so far not changed its policy on Tibet, recognizing that Tibet is a part of China. So,
32:53
the Tibetans have a very uphill struggle, but the geopolitical situation can change.
33:00
And when it changes, there will be an opportunity. The real resistance of the people of Tibet
33:07
comes from the resilience and the resistance of the people of Tibet inside Tibet, because they,
33:13
despite being under a very brutal regime, they have been holding on to their faith
33:19
in their culture, in their religion, in their nation. And it is this that is the real hope
33:28
of the people of Tibet. The very fact that China is still so sensitive about opening up Tibet
33:36
shows that it has not yet won the hearts and minds of the people of Tibet.
33:40
So, while it can claim that Tibet has been a part of China since ancient times,
33:45
fact is that the Tibetans today do not recognize themselves as being Chinese,
33:51
which is why China has to hold on to Tibet through brute force.
33:59
Mr. Dilip Sinha, thank you very much for some very important facts about Tibet,
34:09
which you come out with. And I look forward to reviewing your book. It deserves to be read by
34:19
all in India who have anything to do with our borders, from the politicians
34:30
and all of us who deal with security. Thank you very much.
34:35
All the best.
Recommended
24:16
|
Up next
Ambassador Dilip Sinha (retd.) speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on the turmoil in Bangladesh and its impact on India | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
12/15/2024
26:00
General MM Naravane (Retd.), former Indian Army Chief, speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on his new book ‘The Cantonment Conspiracy’ | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
7/1/2025
30:51
Ashok Sajjanhar, former Indian ambassador speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on Quad and its future | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
9/24/2024
36:50
Indian Ambassador Abhay Kumar speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on How Nalanda changed the world | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
4/12/2025
34:18
Lt Gen RS Sujlana (Retd.), former Commandant, Indian Military Academy, speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on his latest book, Peasants to Warriors: A Travelogue of Sikh Soldiering | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
yesterday
29:43
Lt. Gen. Kamal Davar (Retd), former Founder DG, Defence Intelligence Agency and President, Delhi Forum for Strategic Studies speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on political turmoil in Pakistan, Af-Pak hostilities and impact on India | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
2/10/2025
30:23
Dr. Udai Bhanu Singh, former Senior Research Associate, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies & Analyses speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on changes in Myanmar affecting India | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
1/21/2025
31:03
Dr Aman Hingorani, Senior Advocate, speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on his book Unravelling the Kashmir knot: Past, Present and Future | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
7/22/2024
36:13
Tenzin Lekshay, Spokesperson & Additional Secretary (International Relations), Central Tibetan Administration, speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on the Dalai Lama's assertion on reincarnation and its implications| SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
7/9/2025
13:26
Lt Gen Kamal Davar (Retd.) speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on how the world media viewed India’s Op Sindoor | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
5/20/2025
34:38
Maj Gen Rajan Kochhar (retd.) speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on India's defence budget | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
2/4/2025
27:43
Lt Gen Kamal Davar (Retd.) former DG, Defence Intelligence Agency & President, Delhi Forum for Strategic Studies speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on Israel-Iran war’s impact on India | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
6/27/2025
30:26
Maj Gen Rajiv Narayanan (Retd.) former ADG, Military Operations & Visiting Fellow, Centre for Land Warfare Studies, New Delhi speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on India’s Op Sindoor and what it achieved | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
5/19/2025
21:18
Lt Gen A.K. Bhatt (retd), DG, Indian Space Association speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on new space-age opportunities for India's armed forces | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
11/22/2024
26:43
Lt Gen Rajan Bakshi (retd.), former GOC-in-C Central Command, Indian Army speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on the continuing border standoff with China | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
9/22/2024
32:33
Maj Gen Jagatbir Singh (Retd.), Distinguished Fellow, United Service Institute of India and Editor, Salute speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on implications of US initiating peace talks with Russia | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
2/27/2025
35:35
Desh Kapoor, Atlanta, US-based geopolitical observer and analyst, speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on India wrought devastation on Pakistani military infrastructure during Op Sindoor | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
6/10/2025
29:43
Lt Gen Kamal Davar (Retd.), former founder Director General of Defence Intelligence Agency and President of Delhi Forum for Strategic Studies, speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on future of India-Bangladesh relations | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
3/1/2025
30:28
Maj Gen Mrinal Suman (retd.), military analyst, speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on the current situation in Jammu & Kashmir | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
5/13/2024
29:11
Maj Gen Sudhir Vombatkere (Retd.), strategic affairs commentator, speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on applying India's ancient military wisdom to address its security challenges | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
2/13/2025
30:08
Aparna Rawal, security researcher and analyst, speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on changing Af-Psk dynamics as Afghan Taliban warms up to India | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
1/27/2025
34:11
Dr. Harinder Sekhon, Distinguished Fellow, CUTS International and former Intelligence Analyst, National Security Council Secretariat, speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on the need to review India-US relations | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
6/22/2025
5:10
Thailand Vs Combodia Military, Airforce & Navy Comparison | Details of Warheads Will Shock You
Oneindia
3 days ago
3:51
CHILLING FOOTAGE: Al-Qassam Fighters DESTROY Israeli Positions With Mortars & RPGs | IDF Backtracks?
Oneindia
3 days ago
3:01
Hamas BLAMES Trump & Netanyahu for Sabotaging Gaza Ceasefire |Trump LIED to Send U.S Troops In Gaza?
Oneindia
3 days ago