Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
Maj Gen Rajan Kochhar (retd.) speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on India's defence budget | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
Follow
2/4/2025
Maj Gen Rajan Kochhar (retd.) speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on India's defence budget | SAM Conversation
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
Welcome to SRAM Conversation, a program of South Asia Monitor.
00:12
Our subject today is allocation for defence in the 2025 budget announced yesterday by
00:23
the Finance Minister, Ms. Nirmala Sitharaman.
00:28
At every budget, there is a lot of expectation about how much the allocation for defence
00:38
is going to be, but it appears that over all these years, there is not much of a difference
00:45
in the pattern.
00:46
If the allocation this time is Rs. 6,81,210.27 crore, it amounts to about a 4.65% increase
01:01
in capital allocation, a 9.29% increase in pensions, and a 10.47% increase in expenditure
01:15
on civil.
01:18
This is not really a jump at all.
01:21
It's not an increase at all, because inflation takes care of, you know, inflation negates,
01:29
it neutralizes such an increase.
01:31
The aim of the army for 24 was technology absorption, and for this year, it is the year
01:42
of defence reforms, very, very urgently required reforms.
01:48
In modernization, we need field guns for the artillery, 68% of them are vintage, 22% of
02:02
them are current, and just 8% of them are state of art.
02:10
In technology, we need to focus on artificial intelligence, quantum computing, machine learning,
02:19
robotics, hypersonic, cyber, and space capabilities.
02:24
Development organization output is not enough.
02:30
We need the private sector and academia, replacement of aging equipment is another area we need
02:38
to address very urgently.
02:45
In particular, there are equipments like the Vajra K-9 self-propelled gun, the ATAGS howitzer,
02:55
the futuristic infantry combat vehicle, the government public sector output is not enough.
03:04
The private industry must be tapped.
03:07
And today, the private industry has acquired quite a capability to produce the kind of
03:19
equipment that we need.
03:22
And the border roads, ever since 2007-2008, when then Prime Minister Manmohan Singh was
03:41
very worried about how much progress China had made and how little progress we had made,
03:52
and he promised a fast-track development package for Arunachal Pradesh.
03:58
Since then, we've built about 100 roads, bridges, and tunnels, 75 of which were inaugurated
04:09
by the Defense Minister quite recently.
04:14
But they need much more than the 6,500 crore.
04:21
They need about 10,000 crore because there's still more to be made.
04:27
There are more bridges, roads, and tunnels that are required not only in the border that
04:36
we have with the Chinese, the Line of Actual Control, but with Pakistan and also in the
04:41
island territories.
04:44
Without delving any more, I will request VG General Rajan Kocha, it's a pleasure to have
04:53
you with us.
04:54
Please update us on whatever needs to be done.
04:58
Good evening, sir, and Jai Hind to all your viewers.
05:08
And at the outset, I wish to thank you for inviting me over for this very important discussion,
05:15
especially within 24 hours of the presentation of the defense or the union budget.
05:23
As a nation, we all are concerned for the security of the country.
05:29
And that is why this budget is allocated to the Ministry of Defense on a yearly basis.
05:38
Only the government is aware of the threat of perceptions which we have today.
05:42
And to negate these threats, we have to learn the capabilities.
05:49
You have rightly said that the budget over the years has not given us as far as the defense
05:58
is concerned, much to cheer about.
06:01
The reason is that we have a large percentage of vintage equipment in the armed forces,
06:09
a small percentage of state of art.
06:12
So if you have to graduate from vintage to state of art, what is our roadmap?
06:20
How many years we want this state of art of 8 to 10% to remain where it is and progress
06:29
to at least 25%?
06:35
Have our budget planners taken this roadmap into account?
06:41
Because if you take this roadmap into account, and if you visualize that you will take around
06:52
5 to 10 years to reach this statistics of 25%, then unfortunately, this kind of a budget
07:01
does not give you much to cheer about.
07:05
The reason is, let us analyze first the capital part of the budget.
07:14
Now this capital budget last year was 6.21 lakh crores at the time of the budgetary estimate.
07:28
When the revised estimates came, it became 6.41 lakh crores.
07:36
So let us take the benchmarking on the comparison, not from the budget estimate with the government
07:44
is trying to tell us, but from the revised estimates, that is 6.41 lakh crores.
07:52
And if we compare this budget of 6.41 to 6.81, we see only an overall increase of 6%.
08:07
Now looking at the capital budget, we had 1.72 lakh crores given to us.
08:13
It is now 1.8 lakh crores.
08:16
It's only an increase of 8,000 crores.
08:20
So I just want to bring home the point, do we in our country, in our nation, think that
08:31
we are not going to fight a war?
08:35
Because in case you have a thinking that the nation is prepared to fight a war, then
08:43
the necessary budgetary allocation is to be given to modernize our army, considering the
08:52
adversaries, strengths and capabilities.
08:58
So this increase as rightly brought up by you is just around 4.65% and if you relate
09:09
it to the revised estimate, it will be even less than 4%.
09:15
Taking the 4% as the figure, the inflation today is 5%.
09:26
So that implies that you are back to the same level and I'm not taking yet into account
09:34
the depreciation of the Indian rupee, which is 4.85% since the last year.
09:43
So if you combine 5% with the 4.8, you would be left approximately with a figure of 10%
09:54
and you have increase of only 4%.
09:57
So that implies there is some fault line here in the allocation of the capital acquisition
10:07
budget.
10:08
One more important area, last year we have underspent 12,500 crores.
10:19
Do you not think it is criminal when money is given to you and you are not able to spend
10:26
that money?
10:27
Who is to be held accountable for this?
10:31
12,500 crores we have returned back to the government.
10:39
So it brings us to another point that are our procedures very bureaucratic or cumbersome
10:52
that we are not able to spend the money?
10:56
And if this be so, what are we doing to improve these procedures?
11:02
Of course, we have the defence acquisition procedure 2020, we have the defence acquisition
11:08
councils meeting regularly, but the bureaucracy is the one who is creating the major obstacles.
11:16
I often get to interact with young scientists, young entrepreneurs, startups who are not
11:26
able to push their way through into the government bureaucracy.
11:30
So possibly through your program, this message must go loud and clear that we need to simplify
11:40
our procedures and get the best equipment in the least possible time.
11:47
The next important aspect is a modernization plan has already been given and you also alluded
11:57
in your opening narrative.
12:00
Now this modernization plan, will we be able to get all this within this allocation of
12:10
the budget?
12:11
We are so far planning, for your information, a procurement of 12 Sukhoi aircrafts.
12:26
26 Sukhoi's and one more Scorpene.
12:31
Sir, 12 Sukhoi's have been opened.
12:35
The latest.
12:36
The latest.
12:37
Okay, now this 26 Sukhoi's, even if you plan to get, you will not be able to get in the
12:43
next one year because of the budgetary allocation, then 240 aero engines of the Sukhoi have also
12:52
been contracted.
12:53
Yes.
12:55
Yes.
12:56
Then you have the Reaper drones, 31,000 crores worth of investment from the USA in 31 MQ-9
13:06
Sky as well as Sea Reaper drones.
13:12
So if you take into account this, all these major acquisitions, what we are trying to
13:19
do, it leaves very little space.
13:25
No, you know, it's alarming because I go back to, I cannot but help mentioning here that
13:36
General B.C. Joshi, God bless his soul and General Shankar Roy Choudhury, General B.C.
13:42
Joshi took over in 93, General Shankar Roy Choudhury took over in 95, it's over 30 years.
13:53
These two chiefs, while serving, they had said, look, we are not getting enough and
14:00
it's a pity that we have to return because whatever you return gets adjusted, means the
14:08
next year that much is less because it is adjusted against the new budget.
14:14
Absolutely.
14:15
Absolutely.
14:16
And we see that even now, we are returning 20 or 30 crores, whatever it's, you know,
14:27
and that means that the procedure of the acquisition, it's often been said, you know, it's been
14:37
revised.
14:38
But like you mentioned, you know, interacted with some entrepreneurs, so have I.
14:47
And that's been their lament.
14:52
You mentioned about the private sector.
14:56
I would just like to elaborate on this particular aspect because this is extremely important
15:03
because if we are looking at Aat Nirbhara Bharat, we have to focus more on the private
15:12
sector and less on the government sector.
15:16
Today, 75% of the budget has been earmarked for domestic procurements.
15:24
That implies that out of 180 crores, 75, which is a figure of around 130 lakh crores is going
15:47
to be spent for the domestic sector.
15:50
Now, this 130 lakh crores, you have made a policy that only 25% of this will be allocated
16:01
to the private sector and 75% to the public sector, that is the defence PSUs and the ordnance
16:11
factories.
16:12
Last year's statistics are quite a revelation, which say that when you gave the private sector
16:20
25%, they produced 75% of your export targets, means 75% of your exports were through the
16:32
private sector and 25% through the public sector in spite of giving them 75% of the
16:41
budget.
16:43
So, the question here is, and it's quite relevant in our context, because we have a large number
16:50
of companies coming into the private sector now, and especially with the FDIs of being
16:57
increased from 49% to 74%, so the strategic partnerships are also coming into play.
17:06
The OFBs are also, the OEMs are also aligning with the private sector today.
17:14
So the question is that, do we not have a case in point in increasing this allocation
17:21
to 50%?
17:22
Because if we do that, you will see a quantum jump in our exports.
17:30
We have pegged the target 2025 as 35,000 crores of export, we are only trying to complete
17:40
this target by exporting BrahMos and Akash.
17:47
What about the other defence systems with the private sectors getting involved with?
17:52
So, it's extremely important here, certain defence reforms are required.
17:59
And when the Chief or the Raksha Mantri says that the year 2025 will be the year of defence
18:09
reforms, I wish to see this as one of the defence reforms.
18:18
The theatreization is a part of the defence reforms of 2025, where three new theatres
18:27
are coming up.
18:30
The cyber and space are also going to see defence reforms in 2025.
18:37
Yes, our main adversary, number one adversary, China has been very, very, very active in
18:44
this.
18:46
Absolutely.
18:47
So, I would like to reiterate this point that let's involve the private sector because
18:56
one of the days when Nehru's thought was that defence is a strategic sector, then we cannot
19:06
give it to the private sector, we have to give it now because that's...
19:11
Certainly not.
19:12
Today we have a private sector which has the capability, it has shown the capability.
19:19
In some of the naval equipments that you see, it's there, a huge system like an aircraft
19:27
carrier, even there, there are Indian entrepreneurs, Indian companies, which have participated
19:35
and produced.
19:36
Look at the United States, in the United States, the aircrafts, the aircraft carriers,
19:47
the submarines are all manufactured by the private sector and that is how the United
19:54
States is one of the topmost superpower in the world and China is closely following it
20:02
because China also follows a similar policy.
20:07
So, it is high time that dependence on HAL, because over a period of time, the Air Chief
20:15
is also making a statement that I'm not getting the aircrafts, Tejas Mark 1 and Mark 1 Alpha
20:23
are not coming through in the requisite numbers with the Air Force 1s, there is a deficiency
20:31
of 12 squadrons of the Air Force today.
20:36
And the Air Force Chief has gone on record, he's gone on record very recently.
20:41
Yes, absolutely.
20:42
He has made a very critical observation about the slow delivery of combat aircraft to the
20:54
Air Force.
20:56
So, if we look at these statements, because after all, the Air Force Chief will not make
21:03
such a public statement unless it was necessary, unless it was to make the government realize
21:10
that it is high time we start looking at these things and if we are going to rely on Aat
21:19
Nirmal Bharat, I don't think the Air Force will be able to get these 12 squadrons in
21:24
the next 20 years.
21:25
So, there is now a requirement and you must have your plan ready to equip your Air Force
21:34
with either F-35s or Sukhois 57, because right now the debate is on whether India would like
21:43
to invest in F-35 or the Sukhois and more so when you have to make up the shortfalls
21:52
of your squadrons.
21:53
But the second most important aspect is, which possibly we haven't discussed in much media
22:01
is our air defence system.
22:05
The air defence here, I think needs a more deliberate focus, especially when we see the
22:15
Iron Dome like system in Israel and now President Trump also made a statement that USA also
22:27
needs an Iron Dome kind of air defence system.
22:31
If USA can feel the pinch of its existing air defence system in spite of Petrods and
22:42
Tharts and all that, I think that India is very largely affected and I am given to understand
22:52
that Akash Teer, that is the new air defence acquisition which is going to control all
23:02
air defence assets in the country today.
23:05
We have the Sukhoi Russian system also coming, we have the Prithvi missiles, we have the
23:15
Akash and we have the Barak-8 LR SAMs and we have the S-400 with us.
23:24
So we have a plethora of air defence system, but we require a system which is going to
23:30
be automated, which is going to be sensor based and which will launch the right kind
23:39
of air defence missile depending upon the threat.
23:44
And that is why this Akash Veer is coming through.
23:47
I am given to understand that 455 of these systems are on the anvil, 107 have been delivered,
23:56
105 are going to be delivered in March 2025 and the balance in March 2027.
24:02
So let's hope this goes through and for this budget is required.
24:08
And so far, I would like to see a commitment from the government to state that the budget
24:19
has been catered for, for the next two years for the acquisition of the Akash Veer air
24:28
defence missile system.
24:30
And one more important aspect is we would also like to be confident that this Akash
24:40
Veer is going to deliver.
24:42
So possibly the integration of the Army Air Defence Corps and the Indian Air Force has
24:50
to be done in a very, very closely coordinated manner because both of them will be actively
24:58
involved in the air defence of the nation.
25:00
So this is one important aspect I wanted to bring out in our talk today because over the
25:08
years we have been relying on Strelas, Tungushkas, Shilkas, L-60s, L-70s.
25:21
The days of all these weapon systems are over now because we have to have long range vectors.
25:30
We have to engage the targets in excess of 2,000 kilometres.
25:35
We cannot think of 50, 60, 70 kilometres now.
25:39
So considering that the enemy is also working on this technology, I would like to highlight
25:48
some areas of technology like artificial intelligence, quantum computing, machine learning, hypersonics
25:58
and robotics because these are the five technologies which need to be assimilated into the defence
26:06
forces and the budgetary allocation is actually affecting the amalgamation of these technologies
26:14
into our systems.
26:15
Today 2024 was declared as the year of the absorption of technologies by the Army Chief.
26:26
Technology absorption.
26:27
I would like the Army Chief to bring it out that in 2024 what all technologies and to
26:47
which extent have been absorbed into the Indian Army because if that was your year where you
26:53
had to focus on absorption of technology, let us see how far have we reached there and
27:05
it will be an eye-opener because once this information actually comes out, it will be
27:12
an eye-opener for us to see that how much of distance we have yet to cover and that
27:20
is why when we compare with China, when we compare with our adversaries because China
27:27
is the main adversary today, for your information sir, China has an increase of 17% last year
27:36
towards defence budget.
27:39
Pakistan has 17.5% increase of budget.
27:49
So these two countries are equally bothered as we are bothered to improve our posture
28:01
of defence.
28:02
Are we only going to be a defensive posture or do we have any offensive element also built
28:12
into our strategy or our doctrines?
28:15
That is extremely important because…
28:20
You see the irony is that we do not, we have tremendous capability which we have only displayed
28:28
like, you know, once in 2016 in the form of those surgical strikes and once a little later
28:39
in 2019 Malakot strike.
28:43
We have tremendous capability but I think we need much more of political will to…
28:54
because we cannot take for granted that China is armed itself very heavily throughout, you
29:06
know, line of control, it's created about I think 600 odd villages, it's doing so much
29:16
on the ground and we cannot afford to be, you know, we cannot afford to be found wanting
29:25
if there is a push comes to shove and there is a confrontation and you cannot at all,
29:34
you know, say that there will not be so.
29:37
Absolutely right and the infrastructure to talk about China, since you raised the issue
29:46
of the border areas, the infrastructure or the border roads organization, I feel would
29:54
be disappointed with this budget because from 6500 crores you have just reached around 7100
30:00
odd crores.
30:02
So we were expecting a much more increase, as a matter of fact in my article I had suggested
30:11
or I was hoping that at least the border roads will get 10,000 crores because see, China's
30:20
activities on the LAC we are not able to control.
30:26
China's infrastructure development is going at such a fast pace that I don't think…
30:34
And they began much earlier than us.
30:36
Yeah.
30:37
They began much earlier than us.
30:38
So in case we have to match our own infrastructure on the borders with China, there needs to
30:46
be absolutely a fast track process and for that fast track process you must, you need
30:56
money and if that money is not going to be there and if, for information sir, I was just
31:05
very interested in the statistics I saw today, out of the 1 rupee which the government spends,
31:14
it spends 8 paisa on defence.
31:20
That means that after every 1 rupee of our expenditure, only 8 paisa is spent on defence.
31:28
So it clearly tells you that this sector is not getting its due what it should get.
31:36
No, no, it is not, it is not.
31:39
Therefore we need to keep on reiterating these aspects till the cows come home to bring out
31:48
the fact that the national security of a country is extremely important.
31:55
Today if there is a war, the consequences of war can be disastrous in case the nation
32:05
is not strong enough.
32:10
So for the nation I mean the armed forces.
32:15
So you have to strengthen your armed forces.
32:18
Schemes like Agnivir should be shown the back door because today our armed forces strength
32:31
has been reduced from 13 lakhs to 11 lakhs.
32:36
The border management has increased.
32:39
Bangladesh border, we are seeing deployment now happening.
32:47
China border is eyeball to eyeball.
32:51
Line of control is eyeball to eyeball.
32:55
Why do you think the revenue expenditure is going up, sir?
32:57
Why do you think revenue expenditure is going up?
33:01
It is going up because the troops have to be maintained on the borders and are increasing
33:06
by the day and that is why the revenue expenditure is almost 46% of the budget.
33:16
People say that revenue expenditure should be reduced.
33:18
How can we reduce?
33:21
Because the threats are there, the cost of fuel, the cost of ammunition, the cost of
33:28
aircrafts like today have increased, the cost of convoy movements, feeding the troops in
33:37
the high altitude areas.
33:40
So we have to look into this entire thing in a holistic manner and I think it's high
33:46
time this from 1.9% of the GDP and if you remove the pensions, it becomes 1.48% of the
33:56
GDP.
33:57
This 1.48% definitely should go up to 2% if not 2.5% and gradually over a period of five
34:07
years, we must get a 3% share of the GDP because unless we are going to do that, unfortunately,
34:13
we are going to remain where we are.
34:18
Jailkocha, thank you very much.
34:22
You've given us a lot but I'm afraid for a shortage of time, we have to finish here.
34:31
Thank you very much and all the best.
34:34
Thanks a lot, sir.
34:35
It was a pleasure to be on the show, sir.
34:37
Jai Hind.
Recommended
21:18
|
Up next
Lt Gen A.K. Bhatt (retd), DG, Indian Space Association speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on new space-age opportunities for India's armed forces | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
11/22/2024
26:43
Lt Gen Rajan Bakshi (retd.), former GOC-in-C Central Command, Indian Army speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on the continuing border standoff with China | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
9/22/2024
29:43
Lt. Gen. Kamal Davar (Retd), former Founder DG, Defence Intelligence Agency and President, Delhi Forum for Strategic Studies speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on political turmoil in Pakistan, Af-Pak hostilities and impact on India | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
2/10/2025
29:11
Maj Gen Sudhir Vombatkere (Retd.), strategic affairs commentator, speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on applying India's ancient military wisdom to address its security challenges | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
2/13/2025
30:28
Maj Gen Mrinal Suman (retd.), military analyst, speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on the current situation in Jammu & Kashmir | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
5/13/2024
30:51
Ashok Sajjanhar, former Indian ambassador speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on Quad and its future | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
9/24/2024
30:23
Dr. Udai Bhanu Singh, former Senior Research Associate, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies & Analyses speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on changes in Myanmar affecting India | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
1/21/2025
28:38
Col Rajinder Singh Kushwaha (retd.), formerly of Bihar Regiment that lost 20 soldiers at Galwan in 2020, speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on why China cannot be trusted | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
10/16/2024
32:33
Maj Gen Jagatbir Singh (Retd.), Distinguished Fellow, United Service Institute of India and Editor, Salute speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on implications of US initiating peace talks with Russia | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
2/27/2025
31:03
Dr Aman Hingorani, Senior Advocate, speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on his book Unravelling the Kashmir knot: Past, Present and Future | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
7/22/2024
24:16
Ambassador Dilip Sinha (retd.) speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on the turmoil in Bangladesh and its impact on India | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
12/15/2024
30:08
Aparna Rawal, security researcher and analyst, speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on changing Af-Psk dynamics as Afghan Taliban warms up to India | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
1/27/2025
34:38
Former Indian Ambassador Dilip Sinha speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) on his recent book “Imperial Games in Tibet: The Struggle for Statehood and Sovereignty”| SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
10/24/2024
3:17
Mayank Chhaya speaks about Mahatma Gandhi and his concept of trusteeship | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
10/3/2024
3:02
Kangana Ranaut SLAMS Rahul Gandhi: Accuses Him of Trying to DESTROY India Over SEBI Allegations
Oneindia
8/12/2024
27:12
India’s best known TV anchor and political commentator Rajdeep Sardesai speaks with Mayank Chhaya | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
12/27/2024
32:01
'Nehru Should've Never Made V.K. Krishna Menon the Defence Minister': Jairam Ramesh on his New Book
The Wire
12/16/2019
2:22
Congress drawing sadistic pleasure from India-China conflict: BJP leader Sambit Patra
Aaj Tak
7/1/2020
1:39
Rafale deal controversy II Arun Jaitley slams Rahul Gandhi in Lok Sabha
Hindustan Live
1/2/2019
1:51
ವಿರೋಧ ಪಕ್ಷಗಳ ಒಕ್ಕೂಟವಾದ ಇಂಡಿಯಾ ಒಗ್ಗಟ್ಟಿನಿಂದ ಹೋರಾಡುವ ಅಗತ್ಯವಿದೆ!
Oneindia Kannada
9/18/2023
5:14
Modi Turning India Soldiers into Labourers': Rahul Gandhi Blasts Narendra Modi Over Agniveer Scheme
Oneindia
5/28/2024
35:13
Vikram Jit Singh, journalist and author of Flowers on a Kargil Cliff that narrates powerful human stories of love and loss in the 1999 Kargil War, speaks with Col Anil Bhat (retd.) | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
12/15/2024
2:39
Her Name is Cat | show | 1998| S1 | Official Trailer
JustWatch
today
1:09
Banquet Busters | show | 1948| S4 | Official Trailer
JustWatch
today
26:00
General MM Naravane (Retd.), former Indian Army Chief, speaks with Col Anil Bhat (Retd.) on his new book ‘The Cantonment Conspiracy’ | SAM Conversation
South Asia Monitor
today