Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
Trump's Gaza reconstruction plan completely 'unworkable, illegal and dangerous for region'
FRANCE 24 English
Follow
2/12/2025
Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com
Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English
Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en
Category
đ
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
Our top story. Today a group of negotiators from Hamas have arrived in Cairo for truce
00:17
talks even as the ceasefire with Israel appears increasingly precarious. The Palestinian group
00:23
said its visit is aimed at ending what it called the current crisis. Yesterday the Israeli
00:29
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu echoed a warning from the US President Donald Trump
00:34
saying the war in Gaza would resume if Hamas did not release Israeli hostages by this Saturday.
00:41
The Israeli military has also begun calling up reservists in preparation for a possible
00:47
return of the fighting. Well let's start by listening to Netanyahu himself speaking last
00:53
night. If Hamas does not return our hostages by Saturday at noon, the ceasefire will end
01:00
and the Israeli defence forces will return to intense fighting until Hamas is finally
01:05
defeated. Well no surprise then that there is a significant fear in Gaza at the prospect
01:12
of a resumption of Israeli airstrikes. Fifteen months of war there have killed over 40,000
01:19
civilians and some 90% of the population has been displaced. Here's the view from Rafa
01:24
earlier on today. From the moment we heard this news our hearts sank. The whole country
01:31
was shaken. We'd barely started believing that a truce would happen and that a solution
01:36
was on the way, God willing. We're calling on Hamas and we're calling on Israel. We asked
01:41
them to reach an agreement and put an end to this situation. The people are suffering.
01:45
The people are the victims. Israel must release the prisoners and abide by the agreements
01:51
and Hamas must also adhere to the agreements for the sake of the people. The people are
01:55
completely exhausted. There is no country in the world that is protecting us. Well there
02:01
is concern too in Israel about the possible resumption of the war, particularly among
02:06
the families of hostages who remain in Gaza. It's a shock. We're trying to analyse it,
02:14
we're trying to think what are the possibilities. We want to believe that both sides and the
02:22
mediators can sit down and solve this issue. I hope the ultimatum we heard from Trump will
02:32
speed the negotiation and make all stages come quickly. We saw what's going on, hostages
02:42
just come back, but what we saw on Saturday says that we can't wait so long for all of
02:51
them. Donald Trump has not only demanded the hostages be released by this weekend, he's
02:57
also called on Jordan and Egypt to take in Palestinians on a large scale so the United
03:03
States can quote, take over Gaza and begin a giant redevelopment of the enclave. Human
03:09
rights groups say such forced displacement from Gaza would amount to ethnic cleansing
03:15
and both Amman and Cairo have strongly opposed the idea. Well to discuss the challenges then
03:22
for Jordan and for Egypt and how they may now try to work with a Donald Trump White
03:28
House, I'm pleased to welcome to the programme Neil Quilliam. He's a Senior Middle East Research
03:34
Fellow at Chatham House. Hello to you and thanks for joining us. You're welcome, thank
03:39
you for having me. Look, I'd like to talk about Jordan first of all. King Abdullah met
03:44
with Trump yesterday at the White House. Now, Abdullah did not publicly discuss Trump's
03:50
resettlement plan, but he did say he would take in a number of Palestinian children who
03:55
need medical treatment. Let's just hear first of all a little of the exchange between the
04:00
two leaders. I think one of the things that we can do right away is take 2,000 children
04:09
that are either cancer children or in a very ill state to Jordan as quickly as possible
04:15
and then wait for, I think, the Egyptians to present their plan on how we can work with
04:19
the President to work on the Gaza challenges. I want to tell you, excuse me, just please.
04:29
I didn't know that, what you just said, 2,000 children with cancer or other problems. And
04:35
that's really a beautiful gesture. And Mr Quilliam, how do you think King Abdullah handled
04:42
those remarks to the press alongside Donald Trump? I mean, I think he dealt with them
04:47
very adeptly, very diplomatically. I mean, you can see from his language, from his body
04:54
language as well, that he's been put in a very uncomfortable position. So he was stretching,
05:00
he was doing his utmost to charm the President and also offer a very small piecemeal kind
05:09
of solution. And that's taking on 2,000 children suffering from cancer or other illnesses.
05:16
I mean, that's probably as far as he can go. So he reached out, he's offered the utmost,
05:22
but he was placed in a really difficult position. Well, you say that's probably as far as King
05:27
Abdullah is able to go. Just spell out for us why that is. I mean, he can't take Palestinians
05:35
from Gaza. I mean, one, he would be complicit in population transfer, he'll be playing a
05:43
role in part of that. Two, I mean, how does that actually happen? I mean, there are the
05:49
physical and logistical dimensions behind that. And three, demographically, I mean, what is he
05:54
going to take 1 million from Gaza or 500,000 Palestinians? I mean, we know that it's illegal.
06:01
We know there's a tantamount to ethnic cleansing. So he can't be complicit in that. And
06:06
certainly, his own country, I mean, has already 1.4 million Palestinian refugees, has
06:12
something in the region of 1.2 million Syrian refugees and hosts of other refugees. So it
06:18
would place a tremendous burden on the country. But also, he knows that if they came, they
06:25
wouldn't be going back. They're not coming as refugees as such. They would remain there
06:31
and have a permanent presence. Neither Egypt nor Jordan is in a position to take that many
06:38
Palestinians and certainly wouldn't want to.
06:42
I suppose one of the big challenges, though, for Jordan is the amount of money it does get from
06:46
the United States, money that Trump has suggested the United States could simply cut. I
06:51
mean, in 2023, Jordan was the fourth highest recipient of American aid. Do you think that
06:59
money could be cut? And what impact would there be if so?
07:04
I mean, it's difficult to know whether it would be could be cut. I mean, Trump also said
07:09
yesterday that they can rise above cutting that aid. And that aid is released
07:16
in five-year cycles. So they're mid-cycle at the moment. But that doesn't mean that Trump
07:21
couldn't put it on, I guess, on a kind of a permanent hold or a strong pause. I mean, that
07:29
$1.4 billion a year cut would be tremendously difficult for Jordan. I mean, they are largely
07:37
dependent on external support and external aid. So it would really compromise the Jordanian
07:45
economy and the security. So it would put the country at considerable risk. But Jordan's
07:54
stability, I think, not to overplay it, but Jordan's stability would be at risk. But that in
08:01
itself is a security risk for Israel. So it doesn't make sense to cut that aid, even if it's
08:10
concerned for the security of Israel or the security of the region. But we can see from
08:17
Trump, his policies don't always make absolute sense. But the question is, does he really have
08:24
the will to push ahead with this? Or is there enough kind of heft in the system to mitigate
08:30
and to push against it and to advise otherwise?
08:33
Well, let's turn our attention then to Egypt, because there are reports today,
08:39
unconfirmed reports, I should say, but there is reporting that the Egyptian leader, Sisi,
08:46
won't actually meet Trump at all if Trump keeps this demand on the table that Egypt, like Jordan,
08:52
take in hundreds of thousands, if not over a million Palestinians. What do you think
08:58
Egypt's strategy now is? Because like Jordan, it's very dependent on financial support
09:03
from the United States.
09:05
I think the ball almost sits in Egypt's court. And words are coming out of Egypt that they do
09:14
want to work towards a reconstruction plan. And you heard King Abdullah yesterday say that the
09:22
Egyptians, the Jordanians, are going to be meeting with Mohammed bin Salman, the crown prince of
09:26
Saudi Arabia, soon to sort of hammer out an alternative. And I think that that is the only
09:32
option. And in a way, you know, one hopes in a benevolent sense that Trump's rhetoric, that his
09:39
very strong position is intended to sort of throw down the gauntlet and get the Arab states to come
09:45
together and come up with a plan that has a political and economic and a reconstruction
09:50
dimension to it. I think that's the only thing they can really do to sort of push back or at
09:57
least persuade Trump that his plan is just completely unworkable. It's dangerous for the
10:02
region. And, you know, it's completely illegal, too. I suppose the question is for Donald Trump,
10:07
does he care, actually, whether a plan is illegal? And does he care if he puts more people
10:13
in the Middle East in danger? The answer to that might be no. But then how do you operationalise
10:20
that? I mean, what does it actually mean to move 2 million people? I mean, who's going to do the
10:25
moving? How is that going to happen? I mean, that in itself, is the US going to put boots on the
10:31
ground to make that happen? Or are they just going to sort of say to Israel, do whatever you want,
10:35
but I can't see how that can possibly happen, whether he likes it or not, or whether he wishes
10:42
it or not. How do you actually operationalise such an ill-thought-out plan? That's going to be
10:50
like a fly in the ointment for him, or at least something that's going to make this idea hopefully
10:55
just disappear. And look, if we zoom out a little bit here, what role do you think other big Middle
11:03
East powers, other allies of the United States, like Saudi Arabia, may play in the weeks ahead,
11:09
as we try to think about how these Arab countries navigate this relationship with Donald Trump?
11:15
I mean, I think it's about the Arab states coming together, working together. You know,
11:20
there is a clear common cause. And I think you can see the leaders cooperating and coordinating
11:27
on this piece. And I think that is going to be what they're going to have to do. And this is
11:31
why and how they're going to have to come up with an alternative plan. But at the moment,
11:36
what you have are Arab leaders coming together and really pulling together, and clearly Arab
11:40
populations behind that. So in a way, there are divisions, but there is a kind of a clear sense
11:49
of unity on this one issue that pulls everybody together. It's really kind of galvanising leaders
11:56
and obviously highly sensitising the region. Neil Quilliam, good to talk to you. Thanks very much
12:03
indeed. Now staying with this story, halfway around the world in Bangkok, five Thai farmers
12:14
who were freed last week in the latest swap between Israel and Hamas are adjusting to their
12:22
new lives back home in Thailand. Now among them is Wachara Sioun. France24's Oliver Farry has his story.
12:32
Days after returning home, Wachara Sioun joins his community in prayer in northern Thailand.
12:39
He spent almost 500 days in captivity in Gaza after being abducted on October 7, 2023
12:46
from the kibbutz in southern Israel, where he worked tending avocados and potatoes.
12:50
Wachara says he was aware of the risks before heading to Israel, but felt he had little choice
12:56
but to go. When I first went, it was exciting, but there was also fear because I knew the country was
13:03
at war. Still, I had to go. I wanted my family to have a better life, and I wanted my daughter to
13:08
get an education. On the morning of October 7, he awoke to text alerts on his phone. When he left
13:16
his room, he was surrounded by Hamas gunmen. While in captivity, he survived on cheese, tomatoes and
13:22
cucumbers, though supplies of food and water were not always available. Finally, in late January,
13:28
he and two fellow Thai captives got the good news they'd be free. They told us there would be a
13:34
ceasefire. That time, I believed it. I even saw them firing guns in the air in celebration.
13:44
Now he wants to make up for lost time and spend it with his family, whom he hadn't seen in nearly
13:50
five years. I want to help my father and take my daughter to visit different places because I
13:58
haven't been with her for so long. My parents are getting older and can't do much anymore.
14:04
I want to be the one to take care of them, to make their lives easier because they've
14:09
struggled for so long. A total of 41 Thai labourers were killed in the October 7 attacks
14:17
and 30 kidnapped. Thailand's foreign ministry believes one Thai national is still in captivity
14:23
in Gaza.
Recommended
1:10
|
Up next
John F. Kennedy Assassination 16mm Original - Driver shooting at Kennedy!
Jelani Trent
9/7/2015
10:51
Israel-Hamas war: Prominent Palestinian human rights activists join FRANCE 24
FRANCE 24 English
3/19/2025
11:17
Trump has int'l connections: Europe, Arab Gulf will work with US to achieve peace, reconstruct Gaza
FRANCE 24 English
1/21/2025
4:36
'It has to be done, this war has to end': Israel-Hamas 'bad deal better than no deal'
FRANCE 24 English
1/15/2025
8:22
'Voices of reason gaining strength: Most Israelis and Palestinians want an end to this madness'
FRANCE 24 English
8/29/2024
7:49
'Less impetus to end war in Gaza: The war is functional to destruction of Palestinian people'
FRANCE 24 English
12/4/2024
8:55
Following 15 months of war in Gaza, civilians have 'wounds that are not visible to the naked eye'
FRANCE 24 English
1/22/2025
7:58
'Evidence couldn't be clearer': Hamas, allies committed 'hundreds' of war crimes in attack on Israel
FRANCE 24 English
7/18/2024
10:38
Next phase requires 'building trust & accepting this war should come to an end'
FRANCE 24 English
1/30/2025
16:35
'Israel's options 'limited': They've 'failed' to destroy Hamas, 'unlikely' to destroy Hezbollah
FRANCE 24 English
9/27/2024
9:23
'Hezbollah problem too big to solve': In Middle East 'we don't solve problems, we try & gain time'
FRANCE 24 English
9/26/2024
15:47
'It's time for this war to end, we have to stop doing this to each other'
FRANCE 24 English
1/30/2025
7:42
Dismissing de-escalation calls, is Netanyahu 'fusing nat'l security with personal, legal interests'?
FRANCE 24 English
9/20/2024
6:57
Israel can only defeat Hamas ideology by 'presenting alternative ideology that is more attractive'
FRANCE 24 English
10/27/2023
3:38
'Must look at full picture': Netanyahu warns ceasefire is temporary, Israel retains right to fight
FRANCE 24 English
1/18/2025
11:42
'Bleak reality' in Rafah: Gazans flee in 'absolute fear & terror' amid strikes from air, land & sea
FRANCE 24 English
5/16/2024
7:25
Amb Paoli: 'In diplomacy, you never give up' so we must support all efforts to elect a new president
FRANCE 24 English
11/28/2024
3:54
'No strategic political endgame in sight' as Israel seeks to extinguish Irans' 'ring of fire'
FRANCE 24 English
10/8/2024
0:15
MR1
Go Go Video
1/9/2022
0:22
thththth
Go Go Video
9/20/2020
0:19
GJGJGJ
Go Go Video
1/14/2019
9:54
'We have to do more with less' - international development challenges after USAID cuts
FRANCE 24 English
yesterday
10:34
Stocamine, Alsace: 'Toxicity of chemical waste will not disappear, nobody knows how to deal with it'
FRANCE 24 English
yesterday
2:09
Soaring temperatures prompt stay-home warnings across Europe
FRANCE 24 English
2 days ago
2:52
Iranians flee to Turkey to seek safety amid Israeli strikes
FRANCE 24 English
2 days ago