Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
'And so it goes': Macron attempts to re-center govt, albeit 'in a fairly hamfisted, very clumsy way'
FRANCE 24 English
Follow
12/6/2024
Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com
Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English
Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
I'm going to begin the program here in France where President Emmanuel Macron is continuing
00:11
his hunt for a new Prime Minister today.
00:13
He's set to hold talks with leaders from his own centrist bloc as well as the Socialist
00:18
Party and the right-wing Republicans.
00:21
Finding Michel Barnier's replacement is a task that the French President said Thursday
00:25
would be completed in the coming days.
00:27
In a defiant televised address, Macron roared out stepping down, despite growing calls from
00:32
opposition leaders for him to do so, blaming the fall of Barnier's government on quote
00:37
anti-Republican politicians.
00:39
Emily Boyle has more on that speech.
00:45
In his first allocution since the fall of his government on Wednesday, Macron announced
00:49
he would be naming a Prime Minister in the next few days.
00:55
In the next few days I will appoint a Prime Minister.
00:58
I will instruct him to form a government of general interest representing all the political
01:02
forces of a government that can participate in it, or at least undertake not to censor
01:07
it.
01:08
Michel Barnier was forced to hand in his resignation and that of his government after the motion
01:12
of no confidence passed by 331 votes.
01:16
Barnier had been in the role three months, the shortest tenure of any Prime Minister
01:20
in modern French history.
01:22
The President, who looked significantly weaker after the motion of no confidence, came out
01:27
defiant.
01:28
He assured his critics he would not be stepping down.
01:32
The mandate that you democratically gave me is a mandate of five years and I will remain
01:38
in office until the end of that term.
01:41
Macron lashed out at what he called an anti-Republican front which was not working in the interests
01:46
of the French people.
01:48
I will never assume the irresponsibility of others, especially of members of Parliament
01:53
who choose to bring down France's budget and government only a few days before the Christmas
01:58
holidays.
01:59
Macron now faces a difficult task to come up with a Prime Minister capable of leading
02:04
a minority government in a Parliament where no party holds a majority.
02:09
The President said that the first priority for this new Prime Minister will be to come
02:13
up with a budget in January.
02:15
For the time being, the 2024 budget will roll over to next year.
02:19
We're going to talk more about the political turmoil here in France and speak to Paul Smith
02:26
who is an Associate Professor in French and Francophone Studies at the University of Nottingham.
02:31
Great to have you Paul.
02:32
So Macron has hinted a little bit at taking responsibility for what's happened but he's
02:36
mostly blamed the fall of Michel Barnier's government on this so-called anti-Republican
02:41
front.
02:43
Is that really the case?
02:44
Should Macron be taking more blame here?
02:47
I think he's assuming, as he said, he takes blame for the original mistake or what he
02:53
said last night was that people hadn't understood his dissolution back in June.
02:58
I'm not sure I understand it still to this day.
03:02
Why would the French have to understand his thought behind that?
03:05
But I think that that's really his attempt to re-centre in a fairly ham-fisted way, I
03:13
have to say, a very clumsy way, trying to re-centre the government and open negotiations
03:19
with the centre-left.
03:21
Whether they respond positively or not, we'll see this morning when their leaders go to
03:25
meet with Macron at the Elysee.
03:27
But I actually thought the speech itself, the tenor of the speech, was not a good one
03:31
and was quite glad it only lasted 10 minutes because he just felt that he was going to
03:35
keep digging a hole for himself.
03:38
Macron also very much ruled out the idea of him stepping down despite the mounting
03:44
pressure on him to do so.
03:46
He says he's going to stay on until 2027.
03:49
Do you think he should step down?
03:50
No, I don't.
03:52
I don't see any reason constitutionally for that to happen and that would just create,
03:55
if he did step down, it would create an even bigger crisis.
03:59
There are only two parties in France that would be ready for a presidential election
04:03
and that would be La France Insoumise and the National Rally.
04:07
The other parties are absolutely not prepared and that really would be, he talked about
04:12
this anti-Republican front, meaning La France Insoumise on one side and the National Rally
04:17
on the other, that would absolutely be handing things over to them, the prospect of a presidential
04:24
election at this point, irrespective of what the opinion polls are telling us, would be
04:29
absolutely catastrophic for France.
04:31
And Paul, you mentioned there that Macron is going to be continuing talks with political
04:35
leaders today.
04:37
It's aimed at forging an agreement on finding some sort of new prime minister to take over
04:42
from Barnier.
04:43
How do you think the talks will go?
04:45
Will they be able to find a consensus?
04:48
It's really very difficult because you've got to find, first of all, you have to find
04:52
a candidate that can reach across the divide.
04:54
That's the really big problem at the moment.
04:57
There are one or two names that have been circulating, but it's very difficult to see
05:01
somebody, let's say on the centre-right, who could reach across to the left.
05:05
There might be some centre-left candidates who might be willing to reach across to the
05:10
right.
05:11
One, I suppose, encouraging thing is that Laurent Wauquiez, the leader of Les Républicains
05:16
in the National Assembly, has said that he will not, his group will not censure another
05:21
government.
05:22
They're kind of, they're using this whole idea of the motion of no confidence as a kind
05:25
of a bar, if you like, a benchmark.
05:30
But at the moment, the speech last night was not really meant, I don't think, to placate
05:38
the centre-left.
05:39
So it's very difficult to see exactly who would be the kind of, people have used the
05:43
idea of the National Union government sort of sitting in the middle of French politics.
05:47
It's difficult to see at this moment in time who would lead that.
05:50
So there are no names, you know, there have been some names that have been floating around,
05:55
but do you have any names that you would think perhaps could take over?
06:00
Yeah, the defence minister, Sébastien Le Corneuil, has been mentioned, but the problem
06:04
there is that he's being mentioned because he has the favour of the National Rally.
06:09
Well, the problem with governing with the kind of tacit agreement of the National Rally
06:15
of Le Pen and company is that, you know, it's like Aesop's fable of the scorpion and the
06:20
frog.
06:21
The scorpion in the end will sting the frog and drown with the frog when you cross the
06:24
river because that's in its nature.
06:26
It needs to be somebody who is much more in the centre and has a reputation, who has
06:32
a good reputation with the parties of the left who might reach out and bring on board,
06:38
if it's at all possible, the socialists or at least, I mean, as Emily said and as Macron
06:46
himself said, at least parties that won't automatically push the censure button, because
06:51
otherwise we just get into a continual kind of spiral of governments appointed and then,
06:57
you know, votes of no confidence and so it goes.
07:02
And away from the candidates that could possibly take over from Barnier, Macron also in that
07:07
speech yesterday mentioned this special law that will be tabled to Parliament this month,
07:12
that in order to allow public services to continue without a working budget.
07:19
Give us a sense of what kind of impact you think this new law will have.
07:23
Well, this new law will indeed, will simply sort of tide France over.
07:29
In fact, it's possible for Parliament, once there is a government in place, it's possible
07:35
to, first of all, to have this special law that will tide us over, will tide the French
07:41
over.
07:42
But then actually Parliament has until June to put in place a permanent budget for 2025.
07:47
I mean, it's not a, you know, these, although these things have never happened or haven't
07:50
happened in the recent past, the French system is prepared for it.
07:54
So there'll be a special law which can be as temporary or as long lasting as it needs
07:59
to be to cover the period.
08:01
And then come the new year, come January and afterwards, then a new bill could be brought
08:08
by a new government and that would kind of set things up.
08:11
So although we're carrying forward the tax criteria, the pensions criteria that we had
08:17
for 2024, and some people will win, some people will lose.
08:21
And because, you know, there are aspects of what the Barnier government have put in place
08:25
that are going to help French agriculture, those things aren't going to come into place.
08:30
Nevertheless, they can do.
08:31
It's not the end of the story with regard to a budget, but at least it tides France
08:37
over for the time being.
08:38
Paul, it's always a pleasure talking to you.
08:40
Thanks so much for giving us your insight there.
08:42
That's Paul Smith, who is an associate professor in French and Francophone studies at the University
08:47
of Nottingham.
08:48
Thanks so much.
Recommended
1:10
|
Up next
John F. Kennedy Assassination 16mm Original - Driver shooting at Kennedy!
Jelani Trent
9/7/2015
14:28
'Search for a Goldilocks govt in a parliament of bears': Will Macron find 'new way through' impasse?
FRANCE 24 English
12/5/2024
6:16
French PM set to survive no confidence vote
FRANCE 24 English
2/5/2025
12:39
'Twilight' of his presidency: 'Macron has painted himself into a corner from which he can't escape'
FRANCE 24 English
12/2/2024
5:00
'Macron responsible for bad economic situation': Snap elections 'created chaos in financial markets'
FRANCE 24 English
12/10/2024
25:40
'European vacuum': Franco-German alliance in trouble at a 'critical moment for Europe and France'
FRANCE 24 English
12/5/2024
14:00
Does LR risk getting swallowed up by centre or losing themselves, clinging ever closer to far right?
FRANCE 24 English
12/19/2024
9:18
EU in uncharted territory: Neither France nor Germany 'able to provide the leadership Europe needs'
FRANCE 24 English
12/5/2024
5:57
No-confidence vote 'putting France in a very difficult position for political reasons'
FRANCE 24 English
12/4/2024
8:28
Barnier govt on chopping block: 'Very surprising alliance between left-wing coalition and far right'
FRANCE 24 English
12/4/2024
7:24
'High-tension politics': As Barnier pushes ahead with high-stakes budget, 'will govt stand or fall'?
FRANCE 24 English
12/2/2024
25:50
Macron names PM, "lurches towards right" with "twin focus" on reducing budget, "courting far-right"
FRANCE 24 English
9/5/2024
8:21
'Worrying & concerning': Left coalition largely ignored as Macron 'caters to interests' of far-right
FRANCE 24 English
9/20/2024
4:00
'Institutions in crisis': Macron's 'tacit alliance with far right a preview' of the lead-up to 2027
FRANCE 24 English
9/17/2024
9:56
Macron 'alone in his castle': Center, left parties were all 'elected together as Republican Front'
FRANCE 24 English
8/28/2024
6:23
Macron gives far-right 'best of both worlds': Role of kingmaker who's 'not accountable for anything'
FRANCE 24 English
9/6/2024
8:35
'Extremely volatile': Far-right 'king-maker' as Macron sidelines election victor 'republican front'
FRANCE 24 English
9/6/2024
10:46
Politics is always divisive: In a democracy, 'you must be divisive otherwise you're selling nothing'
FRANCE 24 English
7/8/2024
5:07
In spirit of letting 'democracy play out', is Macron 'obliged' to consider PM from NFP leftist bloc?
FRANCE 24 English
8/27/2024
6:56
'Macron can't continue to play Master of Time, he's actually now coming across as a procrastinator'
FRANCE 24 English
8/23/2024
7:20
Republican front sidelined: Barnier govt 'can only exist with implicit support of far-right Le Pen'
FRANCE 24 English
9/20/2024
5:44
Is France heading toward 'powder-keg situation'? PM to face 'significant political, social problems'
FRANCE 24 English
9/2/2024
11:35
Does Macron seek to exploit 'divides' within NFP to 'impose his politics on National Assembly'?
FRANCE 24 English
9/2/2024
5:03
Polski, Deputy Mayor of Paris: NFP 'elected for change, we need to send a strong message of change'
FRANCE 24 English
7/9/2024
4:12
Far right's 'shadow everywhere': 'French PM's only hope is to keep far right happy and on-board'
FRANCE 24 English
10/1/2024