Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
Amid unprecedented conflict, Israel must 'empower govt of Lebanon, people of Iran' to achieve peace
FRANCE 24 English
Follow
10/3/2024
Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com
Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English
Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en
Category
đ
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
And let's get a bit more on this now. I'm joined as well live by Nomi Bar-Yacob.
00:05
She is an Associate Fellow at Chatham House. Good to speak to you on the
00:08
programme today. Thanks for your time. Thank you Nadia for having me on your
00:12
show. Look, first of all I'd like to ask you a similar question to what I asked
00:16
Iris Mackler there in Jerusalem. Netanyahu has been very clear a response
00:20
to those Iranian attacks will come. How big a retaliation do you think we're
00:26
talking about here and is it imminent? I think we're talking both very very
00:32
serious in nature and scope of the retaliation. They've been talking about
00:36
the oil refineries and they've been talking about potentially hitting the
00:42
nuclear sites. And you've seen one of the frontrunners to succeed Netanyahu, a
00:47
former Prime Minister, Naftali Bennett, announcing that this is the time to
00:52
strike. And he's a very powerful figure in politics even though he's not in the
00:57
Knesset, the Israeli Parliament at the moment. But there is definitely a mood to
01:03
strike and to strike hard. And I think the question is, and when, I mean there is
01:08
a push to try to do it imminently. But we have to remember this is also the
01:13
Jewish New Year and people see this as a potential time to celebrate. It's a
01:20
year since the 7th of October disaster in terms of Israel. It's the
01:27
greatest disaster that this country has faced. So killing Nasrallah and many
01:34
Iranian Revolutionary Guards is considered in Israel a success. And
01:40
Netanyahu for sure has been wanting to, the Israeli Prime Minister, to target the
01:45
Iranian nuclear sites. And part of the defence that was targeted in April is
01:51
response to Iran's 13th of April coordinated attack with its proxies on
01:57
Israel. Do you agree with what we were just hearing from our correspondent in
02:01
Jerusalem, that if this is to be a major wave of attacks on Iran, if for example
02:08
the nuclear sites are targeted, that Israel could not act alone, it would need
02:13
the support of allies like the United States? Yes, absolutely. I think Israel
02:18
cannot go alone without informing the United States, Israel's greatest ally, and
02:27
various other states, because this is, as I stated earlier, it's a large operation
02:33
in nature and scope. How does the fact that Hezbollah in Lebanon has been so
02:41
seriously weakened now after this string of attacks, culminating of course in the
02:46
killing of Hassan Nasrallah, impacted Israel's calculus now? Has that emboldened
02:53
Israel, do you think, in terms of what we're seeing with Iran? Yes, absolutely. I
02:57
think the fact that, I mean, the killing of Hassan Nasrallah and other, you know,
03:04
Hezbollah leaders as well as taking a large bulk of Hezbollah's military
03:10
arsenal out has been in the planning for 20 years, and so as a plan to hit
03:16
Iran, the question was always whether this was necessary and whether, and if
03:23
it was necessary, then the question, it was deemed necessary, the question
03:26
therefore is when. And there was definitely a consensus in Israel, not
03:31
only the government, which is a very extreme government, but it's also
03:35
supported by the left, the killing of Nasrallah and the killing of all the
03:42
IRGC, the Iranian Revolutionary Guards commanders, was part, there was
03:48
definitely a consensus in Israeli society that that was the right move at
03:54
the right time. The problem is that there isn't an exit strategy, and if the exit
03:59
strategy is meant to be, how do you move from that, taking out a threat, a direct
04:04
threat to Israel, to peace, then you need to empower the government of Lebanon and
04:08
you need to empower the people of Iran, meaning not the Ayatollahs and not the
04:16
supreme leader. So the question is, is this really going to bring peace? And
04:20
that is the big question. And it could go very much the other way. So it's not
04:26
clear at all. But yes, we're at a very, very, very critical juncture at the
04:30
moment, with a direct conflict between Israel and Iran at an unprecedented
04:36
level, given that the attack by Iran yesterday was at least double the number
04:40
of ballistic missiles than the 13th of October, sorry.
04:45
Yeah, and I'd like to ask you a bit about the the ground campaign in
04:49
Lebanon. It does seem that incursion has now begun. Look, Israel has said, this is
04:55
going to be limited, it's targeting Hezbollah operatives only, it doesn't
04:59
want to move deep into Lebanon. And I wonder how plausible you think that is,
05:03
because history tells us that previous Israeli campaigns in Lebanon that were
05:08
supposed to be short, ended up lasting years.
05:11
Yes, exactly. I think that and we also saw in Gaza, where they have said that
05:15
this is just a surgical incursion into Rafa, and then it's lasted months on end.
05:23
And this is just a temporary sort of measure just to take out, you know, one or
05:27
two leaders and one, you know, and a serious amount of ammunition, but in a
05:32
particular spot, that is the danger. At the moment, the army and the government
05:37
is stating that this is going to be a short time, but by short, they mean
05:40
weeks. I mean, we're not talking days. And as you correctly stated, once you go
05:45
in, it's very difficult to come out. It's very difficult, because the question is
05:50
who is going to fill the vacuum. So say they take out much of the Hezbollah
05:56
military arsenal between the Israeli border and the Litani River, it's not
06:01
evident that the Lebanese army and the Lebanese government are going to be able
06:06
to govern that area independently. So you know, previously Israel had the South
06:14
Lebanese army as its own proxy, which was an absolute disaster. So it's very clear
06:19
that Israel should not have any kind of role in in governing and supporting any
06:28
body that will. The question really is, is Resolution United Nations Security
06:33
Council Resolution 1701 going to be implemented? Will there be a stronger
06:37
mandate for the forces there for UNIFIL? It's not clear because they can't do
06:45
their job at the UN. They're meant to keep the peace between the Litani River
06:50
and the Israeli border. But without without the support of the parties, they
06:56
can't. And that is a big question. They're not peacemakers, they're
06:59
peacekeepers. And so far, they haven't been able to do their job because there
07:04
hasn't been that ability. If Hezbollah is indeed weakened, who is going to fill
07:10
that vacuum?
07:11
Just a final question for you. The United States, of course, just weeks away
07:16
from this crucial presidential election. We're hearing today as well,
07:19
apparently that the UN Secretary General has been barred from entering Israel
07:23
because of him failing to unequivocally condemn Iran following those strikes. I
07:29
just wonder your thoughts, lastly, on what room is left now for diplomacy?
07:35
Well, the UN isn't a trusted body, unfortunately, in Israel. So this last
07:39
move, which is shocking and shameful of barring the United Nations Secretary
07:45
General from entering Israel, and they said terrible, the statement of the
07:51
Israeli foreign minister said that he supported the rapes and supported the
07:55
actions of Hamas on the 7th of October last year, which clearly isn't the case.
08:01
But he failed to condemn the attack. And there has been a problem in terms of
08:07
and as you said at the outset, instead of going towards diplomacy and using
08:11
diplomatic means to resolve this, they are using military means. And the
08:15
question, the problem with military means is it cannot be the endgame. The
08:19
endgame is never military. So the question is, what comes next afterwards?
08:24
So yes, barring the UN Secretary General is quite typical of this current
08:30
government.
08:31
It's been really good to get your thoughts. Thank you so much. That's Naomi
08:34
Barr-Yakov talking to us there. She is from Chatham House. Thank you.
08:39
Thank you, Nadia.
Recommended
4:20
|
Up next
Lebanon in a 'humanitarian crisis': The demand for aid and assistance is 'enormous'
FRANCE 24 English
10/3/2024
8:22
'Voices of reason gaining strength: Most Israelis and Palestinians want an end to this madness'
FRANCE 24 English
8/29/2024
10:38
Next phase requires 'building trust & accepting this war should come to an end'
FRANCE 24 English
1/30/2025
7:49
'End the wars everywhere': Peace in Lebanon requires 'Palestinian state, normalisation for Israel'
FRANCE 24 English
11/29/2024
5:43
'Lebanese political class completely helpless in face of militia Hezbollah'
FRANCE 24 English
9/23/2024
10:44
'Lebanon in the hands of Nabih Berri now, he can save the country or he can let the country sink'
FRANCE 24 English
10/2/2024
15:47
'It's time for this war to end, we have to stop doing this to each other'
FRANCE 24 English
1/30/2025
7:49
'Less impetus to end war in Gaza: The war is functional to destruction of Palestinian people'
FRANCE 24 English
12/4/2024
16:35
'Israel's options 'limited': They've 'failed' to destroy Hamas, 'unlikely' to destroy Hezbollah
FRANCE 24 English
9/27/2024
7:42
Dismissing de-escalation calls, is Netanyahu 'fusing nat'l security with personal, legal interests'?
FRANCE 24 English
9/20/2024
8:25
US, Israel 'worlds apart': Blinken-Abbas meeting marks 'beginning of very long process'
FRANCE 24 English
1/11/2024
3:54
'No strategic political endgame in sight' as Israel seeks to extinguish Irans' 'ring of fire'
FRANCE 24 English
10/8/2024
3:38
'Must look at full picture': Netanyahu warns ceasefire is temporary, Israel retains right to fight
FRANCE 24 English
1/18/2025
6:16
'Objective of destroying Hamas': 'Not a way to bring Israeli-Palestinian conflict to a peaceful end'
FRANCE 24 English
1/15/2024
9:23
'Hezbollah problem too big to solve': In Middle East 'we don't solve problems, we try & gain time'
FRANCE 24 English
9/26/2024
1:00
LONELY BOY SNORTING CRYSTAL METH
Amandaphillips
11/28/2017
1:10
John F. Kennedy Assassination 16mm Original - Driver shooting at Kennedy!
Jelani Trent
9/7/2015
14:19
French senator 'appalled': EU deal with Trump counter to what 'EU should be standing for'
FRANCE 24 English
yesterday
4:40
Starmer to press Trump on Gaza, trade in Scotland talks
FRANCE 24 English
yesterday
8:51
'It's an engineered starvation campaign against civilians, women and children in the Gaza Strip'
FRANCE 24 English
yesterday
5:33
Thailand-Cambodia border crisis traces roots 'to pre-colonial Southeast Asia"
FRANCE 24 English
4 days ago
12:29
Taipei holds air raid drill to prepare for Chinese attack
FRANCE 24 English
7/17/2025
1:46
Syrian Bedouin fighters mount new offensive in Sweida against Druze fighters despite truce
FRANCE 24 English
7/17/2025
6:06
Trump lashes out at MAGA base as Epstein row escalates
FRANCE 24 English
7/17/2025
5:57
Israeli strike hits Gaza church, killing 3 and wounding priest who was close to Pope Francis
FRANCE 24 English
7/17/2025