Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
Menendez Brothers Speak Out as Parole Hearing Nears | TMZ Live
TMZ
Follow
4/7/2025
Erik and Lyle Menendez say they finally have something to look forward to as they inch closer to a possible release from prison, and they're revealing how they've evolved during their 35 years behind bars.
Category
✨
People
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
to the Menendez brothers who have a big week ahead
00:03
because their re-sentencing hearing
00:06
will happen on a schedule for Friday.
00:08
Now, the bigger date I think for them
00:12
is what the governor has already laid in motion,
00:14
which is they go before the parole board in June.
00:18
So I guess re-sentencing, the best they could hope for
00:22
is that the judge says that he's gonna change his sentence.
00:28
No, it's not.
00:30
On Friday.
00:30
No, that is what is on the table right now,
00:34
which is if the judge changes the sentence
00:36
and eliminates life without parole,
00:39
then it goes to the parole board,
00:41
but it's already at the parole board,
00:43
so it seems irrelevant, right?
00:44
Because the parole board's already hearing it
00:47
based on what the governor asked them to do.
00:48
So regardless of what happens on Friday,
00:51
here's why I said no.
00:54
There's something else that their lawyer,
00:56
Mark Garagos, is gonna ask for.
00:57
He is not just gonna ask for re-sentencing.
01:00
He is going to ask that the judge change the conviction
01:06
from murder to manslaughter,
01:10
because it's based on this whole imperfect self-defense
01:13
that was available in the first trial but not the second,
01:17
and he's gonna say, change it to manslaughter.
01:20
If that happens, they're instantly freed
01:22
because they've served more than three times the max.
01:25
So that's why this hearing really matters,
01:29
not really because of the re-sentencing,
01:32
which everybody's making a big deal about
01:33
because it's already at the parole board,
01:35
but if Garagos gets his way, they could be out on Friday.
01:40
I don't know that that's gonna happen,
01:41
but that's what he's gunning for.
01:42
Mark Garagos is the person to talk to,
01:45
and you and Mark Garagos spoke with Eric and Lyle Menendez.
01:50
They were in prison.
01:50
You had a prison interview with them,
01:53
which is the subject of our documentary
01:55
that is premiering tonight on Fox,
01:58
the Menendez brothers, the prison interview.
02:00
It is really remarkable.
02:02
Now, if they get to the parole board, the hearing,
02:06
you're gonna hear them in this documentary
02:08
talking about the things that the parole board cares about,
02:10
that they're looking very closely at.
02:12
What have they done as far as rehabilitation?
02:16
Rehabilitation and safety to the community,
02:19
those are the two factors that the parole board looks at,
02:23
and I think when you hear them on this special tonight,
02:26
I think you get to decide whether or not,
02:28
one, have they been rehabilitated,
02:30
and you can be the judge.
02:31
Do you feel like they are a danger to society?
02:36
Listen to what they said to Harvey and to Mark
02:39
about their life in prison and how it's changed
02:43
with all of this attention
02:47
and the possibility of getting out of prison.
02:49
Hope for the future is really kind of a new thing for us.
02:53
I think Eric would probably agree with that.
02:55
It's not something that we spend a lot of time on.
02:59
I'm striving to be a better person every day,
03:01
and I want to be a person that my family can be proud of.
03:03
The 360-degree evaluation of where they are,
03:07
where they've been, and where they're going to be
03:09
is incredible.
03:11
Their entire life, they've been spoiled.
03:12
They've been coddled, and they've always got what they want,
03:14
and this is just something they want.
03:15
They wanna get out of prison?
03:18
Who have evolved into?
03:23
Who I've seen Lyle evolve into?
03:29
I'm beginning to like myself, be proud of myself,
03:32
and find it okay to like myself.
03:35
You never know how long you'll be blessed
03:36
to be on the earth, so we don't just sit around
03:38
waiting for something.
03:40
They have done a lot of good things in prison,
03:43
but I cannot fathom the fact that they should get out.
03:47
They should not be released from prison,
03:49
and I know, Harvey, we go back and forth on this so much,
03:53
but I can't, I do not wanna be living in California
03:55
and knowing that they're out.
03:56
I just don't understand it.
03:57
Courtney, I mean, look, polls have been done.
03:59
This is a very polarizing issue.
04:02
Split down the middle.
04:05
You don't really feel like there's a danger
04:07
of them being out, right?
04:08
I mean, if your position is,
04:10
I don't think they should get out
04:11
because of how heinous the crime was, that's one thing,
04:16
but there's certainly, I hear nothing in them
04:18
that makes me go like, all right, if these guys get out,
04:21
they're a danger to society.
04:22
That's why I don't see it.
04:23
They're great liars.
04:24
We saw them on the stand lie over and over again.
04:26
It was 40 years ago, Courtney.
04:27
I don't care.
04:28
They can still do it.
04:29
Well, no, no, no, no, but that makes a difference.
04:30
No, actually.
04:31
How?
04:32
How does it?
04:33
Well, no, no, no, but hold on.
04:34
On the stand, they actually copped to the lies.
04:36
They had lied before, and when they were cross-examined,
04:40
they copped to it.
04:41
Their defense was they were sexually abused by their dad,
04:44
but they copped to all those lies in those trials.
04:48
There's a misconception about that.
04:50
I think the bigger thing right now is,
04:52
and the shocking thing to me is Governor Newsom,
04:56
that he has taken the reins of this case,
04:59
and he's gonna run for president in 2028.
05:02
This is such a divisive issue,
05:04
yet knowing that, he's asked the parole board
05:08
to review the case.
05:09
If the parole board comes back with a clean bill of health
05:13
saying they're rehabilitated and they're not a danger,
05:16
he's gonna release them because why would he start it?
05:18
Why would he start the wheels in motion
05:20
if he's not gonna do it?
05:21
And I agree with you, and you didn't understand
05:24
how they're gonna keep the anonymity
05:27
of the victims in the last story.
05:28
I don't understand how in the world Governor Newsom
05:32
is taking the reins, as you said, on this,
05:35
and seeming like he would let them out.
05:38
I think-
05:39
If he's gonna run for president.
05:40
All I can say is, I think this-
05:41
It doesn't add up.
05:42
It doesn't add up politically,
05:44
but I think there's something that-
05:44
Well, that's all there is when you run for president.
05:46
I don't know.
05:47
I think there's something that moved him.
05:50
I totally agree, and I could even see that,
05:53
but it doesn't add up with him then running for president.
05:55
It doesn't add up for that.
05:56
Absolutely not.
05:58
Shanice, Houston, Texas.
06:00
I think the main thing to just consider
06:02
with this whole situation is there are the brother's safety
06:07
if they are released, and also how they're gonna be able
06:10
to take the opposition and the backlash
06:11
that they will receive, and very harshly, might I add,
06:14
because of the heinous crime that was committed.
06:17
You're absolutely right.
06:18
That's the reality.
06:19
That is gonna happen, but they're committed,
06:20
especially Eric.
06:22
I did this interview.
06:23
He was so committed to working on childhood trauma issues.
06:27
So we will see.
Recommended
2:35
|
Up next
Menendez Brothers Sentencing Changed to 50 Years to Life, Parole Board's Next | TMZ Live
TMZ
5/18/2025
1:43
Menendez Brothers Sentencing Changed to 50 Years to Life, Parole Board's Next | TMZ TV
TMZ
5/18/2025
3:44
L.A. D.A. Says Menendez Bros Missed Chance to Come Clean
TMZ
4/14/2025
6:31
Menendez Brothers Star Witnesses for Resentencing Hearing Are Prison Employees | TMZ Live
TMZ
11/14/2024
1:26
Menendez Brothers Attorney Mark Geragos Speaks After Sentence Change
TMZ
5/18/2025
2:04
Menendez Brothers Should Remain In Prison, Reporter From First Trial Says
TMZ
10/17/2024
9:55
Erik and Lyle Menendez Talk About Being Attacked in Prison on '2 Angry Men' Podcast | TMZ Live
TMZ
2/20/2025
2:18
Resentencing Brings Menendez Brothers One Step Closer to Freedom
TIME
5/14/2025
1:05
L.A. prosecutor urges Menendez brothers to 'come clean' for release
Bangkok Post Group
3/12/2025
1:35
Menendez brothers have sentence reduced, now eligible for parole
The Star
5/15/2025
2:33
Menendez Brothers Resentencing Decision to be Announced by End of the Week | THR News Video
The Hollywood Reporter
10/23/2024
4:29
Menendez Brothers' Lawyer Thinks Recall of Sentence Is 'Easiest Solution'
TMZ
10/4/2024
2:12
Could Menendez Brothers Be Released From Prison Appeal Process Explained
US Weekly
9/27/2024
5:23
Feds See Uptick in Calls From Diddy Accusers Since His Arrest | TMZ Live
TMZ
10/2/2024
0:28
Menendez Family Feeling 'Confident' Prior to Hearing
TMZ
11/25/2024
2:06
Pennsylvania Residents Concerned About Inmates Being Released from Nearby Prison
Tribune Broadcasting
5/30/2018
2:07
Netflix Series Put Menendez Brothers Back in Spotlight Behind Bars | TMZ TV
TMZ
2/21/2025
7:10
Diddy Received Standing Ovation From Other Inmates After Verdict, Lawyer Says | TMZ Live
TMZ
4 days ago
0:45
Menendez Family Lawyer Teases 'Developments' at Hearing
TMZ
11/25/2024
6:35
Gov. Newsom Launches 'Risk Assessment' on Menendez Brothers | TMZ Live
TMZ
2/26/2025
4:14
Kim Kardashian Says It's Time the Menendez Brothers Are Released From Prison
DHLTV
10/7/2024
2:33
The Menendez Brothers | movie | 2024 | Official Trailer
JustWatch
9/28/2024
4:51
Menendez Brothers Won't Be Home For Holidays, Resentencing Hearing Delayed | TMZ Live
TMZ
11/25/2024
1:37
Know Why The Prosecutors Alleged Sean Diddy Combs Of Violating Prison Rules
LehrenDotCom
11/19/2024
12:02
10 Creepiest Lyle and Erik Menendez Interview Moments
WatchMojo
10/3/2024