Ikaapat na impeachment complaint ng HOR laban kay VP Duterte, idineklarang unconstitutional ng Supreme Court | 24 Oras Weekend - video Dailymotion

GMA Integrated News

24 Oras Weekend is GMA Network’s flagship newscast, anchored by Ivan Mayrina and Pia Arcangel. It airs on GMA-7, Saturdays and Sundays at 5:30 PM (PHL Time). For more videos from 24 Oras Weekend, visit http://www.gmanews.tv/24orasweekend.  #GMAIntegratedNews #KapusoStream  Breaking news and stories from the Philippines and abroad: GMA Integrated News Portal: http://www.gmanews.tv Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/gmanews TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@gmanews Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/gmanews Instagram: http://www.instagram.com/gmanews  GMA Network Kapuso programs on GMA Pinoy TV: https://gmapinoytv.com/subscribe

Transcript

00:00Tignin na ilang retiradong maestrado ng Korte Suprema,

00:04taliwas sa umiiral na patakaran ang desisyon ng Korte Suprema

00:07kagnoy sa impeachment complaint labang kay Vice President Sara Duterte.

00:11Hindi raw maaring basta ipatupad na lamang ng Korte Suprema

00:14ang anilay mga bagong patakaran.

00:18Nakatutok si Joseph Moro.

00:22Ang pagdismiss daw ng House of Representatives

00:25sa tatlong naon ng impeachment complaint

00:27at ang dahilan kung bakit pawal na ang pag-ahain

00:30ng ikaapat na impeachment complaint na nasa Senado ngayon

00:33laban kay Vice President Sara Duterte.

00:36Sa desisyon ng Korte noong biyernes na isinulat

00:39ni Supreme Court Associate Justice Marvick Lohnen,

00:42magsisimula ang one-year bar mula sa inisiyasyon

00:45o pagsisimula ng isang impeachment complaint

00:48kung hindi inaksyonan o kapag dinismiss

00:51o kaya ibagyang naaksyonan o partially acted upon.

00:54December 2024 may inihahing tatlong impeachment complaint

00:58pero in-archive ito ng Kamara

01:00at pinaburan ang ikaapat na complaint

01:03na siyang pinagbotohan ng mayorya

01:05at iniakyat sa Senado.

01:07Sabi ng Korte Suprema,

01:09binigyang prioridad dapat ng Kamara

01:11ang mga naunang reklamo.

01:12Ang pagdidismiss daw sa mga ito

01:15pabor sa ikaapat na complaint

01:17ay nag-trigger o nagpagana sa one-year bar

01:20sa separate concurring opinion

01:22ni Associate Justice Rodil Salameda

01:24ang hindi raw pag-aksyon ng Kamara

01:26sa tatlong naon ng complaint

01:28ay nagsalbah kay Duterte

01:30para hindi na sumagot sa mga aligasyon

01:32laban sa kanya.

01:34Dagdag pa ng Korte,

01:35nilabag ng Kamara ang karapatan ng vice

01:37para sa due process

01:39dahil sa isinubit na yung sagot ng Kamara

01:41kinumpirma nitong

01:42hindi raw nabigyan ang pagkakataon

01:45ng vice na marinig

01:46tungkol sa mga ebidensya

01:48laban sa kanya.

01:50Sabi ng Kamara,

01:50hindi na ito kailangan

01:51sa ilalim ng konstitusyon.

01:53Sabi ng Korte,

01:54ang pagkiling sa ikaapat na complaint

01:56at paglabag sa karapatan ni Duterte

01:58grave abuse of discretion

02:00o pag-abuso sa kapangyarihan ng Kamara

02:03kaya void of initio o walang visa

02:06mula sa simula pa lamang

02:07ang articles of impeachment

02:09na nasa Senado.

02:11Hindi raw ito magagamit

02:12ng Senado sa impeachment.

02:14Pero sabi rin ng Korte,

02:16hindi nila inaabswelto si Duterte

02:17sa mga aligasyon.

02:19Ang unamang desisyon daw

02:20ay makakamit lamang

02:21sa pamamagitan

02:22ng isa pang impeachment process

02:24na didinggin at lahatulan ng Senado.

02:27Pero para kay dating Supreme Court

02:28Associate Justice Adolf Azcuna,

02:31tila nagbigay ng bagong depenisyon

02:33ng Korte kung kailan

02:34nagsisimula ang isang impeachment case

02:36na taliwas

02:37sa umiiral ngayong patakaran.

02:40Sa ngayon kasi,

02:41batay sa desisyon ng Korte

02:42sa Francisco Jr.

02:43versus House of Representatives

02:45noong 2003,

02:46itinuturing na initiated

02:48ang isang impeachment complaint

02:49kapag nailagay na ito

02:51sa order of business

02:52ng Kamara

02:52at ni-refer sa komite.

02:54Pero sa bagoan niyang depenisyon,

02:56batay sa desisyon

02:57ng Korte Suprema,

02:59maituturing na rin

03:00na nasimulaan

03:01ang isang impeachment complaint

03:02kapag hindi ito

03:03na-refer sa komite,

03:04dinismiss

03:05o inarchive

03:06tulad ng nangyari

03:07sa tatlong naon

03:08ng reklamo.

03:10Apelan ni Escu

03:10na sa Korte Suprema

03:11ituring na valid

03:13o may visa

03:13ang mga aksyon

03:14na nakaayon

03:15sa dating depenisyon

03:16sa ilalim

03:17ng Doctrine of Operative Facts

03:19at gamitin na lamang

03:20ang bagong depenisyon

03:21sa mga susunod na kaso.

03:23Ganito rin ang pananaw

03:24ng retired Supreme Court

03:26Associate Justice

03:26Antonio Carpio.

03:28Ang ginagawa ng Supreme Court

03:29riniretroact nila

03:31to this case.

03:33The House,

03:34the people

03:35did not know

03:35that there was

03:36this requirement

03:37because there was

03:37no requirement like this.

03:39You cannot make it

03:40retroactive.

03:41It should be prospective.

03:43You know,

03:43Doctrine of Operative Fact.

03:45If there is a new requirement,

03:47you cannot say,

03:48oye, bakit hindi mo

03:49sinunod ito?

03:50E paano mo

03:51isunod?

03:52Wala nga yun.

03:53It did not exist

03:54at the time.

03:55Wala rin daw pagdinig

03:56na hinihingi

03:57ang unang depenisyon

03:58sa mga impeachment complaint

03:59na pinagbotohan

04:00ng mayorya.

04:01Ang sabi niya

04:02ng Supreme Court,

04:03it should be,

04:04it cannot be

04:05an ex-party hearing.

04:07It has to be

04:08an actual hearing.

04:09That will require time.

04:11Para kay dating

04:12Supreme Court,

04:13Associate Justice

04:14Antonio Carpio,

04:15maaaring umapela

04:16ang Kamara

04:16sa Korte Suprema

04:17para maitama

04:19ang mga umunoy

04:19pagkakamaling ito.

04:21I think

04:22out of

04:23courtesy naman

04:24to the Supreme Court,

04:25itay nila yung

04:26motion for reconsideration.

04:28Let's give

04:28the Supreme Court

04:29an opportunity

04:30to correct itself.

04:32So,

04:33kahit na unanimous sila,

04:35we can point out na,

04:37first of all,

04:38meron namang approval.

04:40Maaaring nalabag din daw

04:41ang karapatan

04:42ng Kamara.

04:43That's normally

04:44the case, no?

04:45Dapat may oral argument.

04:47In this case,

04:48there are two petitions

04:50sa Supreme Court,

04:51kay VP Sara

04:52at saka kay

04:53Atternator yun.

04:54The House

04:55was never made

04:56to comment.

04:57Kasi pag

04:57you were not heard

04:58through a comment,

05:00through an answer,

05:01walang due process yun eh.

05:02Ito,

05:03walang order

05:04for the House

05:05to comment.

05:06Para kay retired

05:07Chief Justice Artemio,

05:08panganiban,

05:09respetuhin daw

05:10ang desisyon

05:10ng Korte Suprema

05:11pabor man

05:12ang publiko

05:12dito o hindi.

05:14Pero maaari

05:14para umapela

05:15o humingi

05:16ng klarifikasyon

05:17ang Kamara.

05:18Kung siya lamang daw

05:19sa halip na tila,

05:20magmadali

05:20maglabas ng desisyon,

05:22dapat daw nag-issue

05:23muna ng status

05:23ko order

05:24ang Korte

05:25o huwag munang

05:26dinggin ang Senado

05:26ang impeachment complaint

05:27habang may dinidinig

05:29na petisyon.

05:30Sana rin daw

05:30nagsagawa ng oral arguments

05:32para rito bago

05:33nagkabotohan.

05:34Para sa GMA Integrated News,

05:36Joseph Morong,

05:37Nakatutok 24 Oras.

Ikaapat na impeachment complaint ng HOR laban kay VP Duterte, idineklarang unconstitutional ng Supreme Court | 24 Oras Weekend

Category

Transcript

Recommended