Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
'Opportunity to really learn from disaster and start rebuilding better into a more resilient future'
FRANCE 24 English
Follow
1/13/2025
Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com
Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English
Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en
Category
đź—ž
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
First, firefighters from Canada and from Mexico are being deployed to Los Angeles as the devastating
00:17
California wildfires rage for a seventh day. The governor of California, Gavin Newsom,
00:24
says this could be the worst natural disaster in American history. In all, 24 people are
00:30
confirmed to have lost their lives and over 100,000 residents have been forced to evacuate.
00:37
Many of those have lost their homes. Today, the largest fire in Palisades remains less
00:44
than 15% contained, but some of the evacuees are nonetheless keen to return and see the
00:51
destruction with their own eyes. Solange Mougin has this report.
00:59
The fires may have come and gone, burning much of everything in their wake in this neighbourhood
01:04
of the Pacific Palisades, but that doesn't mean the danger's passed. With the National
01:09
Guard blocking roads and a curfew in place from sunrise to sunset, many residents have
01:14
nonetheless lined up, trying to get back into their homes, either to quickly grab beloved
01:20
items or more necessities, or to simply see with their own eyes where their homes once
01:25
stood.
01:26
To collect my dad's ashes, which we had to leave behind, as well as my grandma's ashes,
01:31
which we also had to leave behind.
01:33
It's gotten exponentially harder to get in, rightfully so, because of the looting. I did
01:38
get in two days ago when the market burned down and I had to turn around because of the
01:42
smoke and you couldn't get visibility and it's like you were in a ball of fire.
01:46
Not only do blazes continue unchecked in the Los Angeles area, but there are also added
01:51
risks of something firefighters call spotting, or new blazes caused by blowing embers. The
01:57
Weather Service has issued several red flag warnings of strong winds, with the greatest
02:02
risk coming on Tuesday. And then there are the dangers of broken gas lines, contaminated
02:07
ash, as well as unstable structures. Finally, there's also the very real risk of looting.
02:13
For residents, it is a long and difficult wait.
02:16
I'd be frustrated, but the truth is, is that anybody who understands even the slightest
02:22
bit about fires knows that all it needs is a good wind and things can turn bad quickly.
02:27
So I know they're doing that for everyone's safety. It doesn't make us want our belongings
02:35
out of there any less.
02:37
With some 100,000 people still under evacuation orders, many residents are not only grieving
02:42
their lost homes and communities, but they're also anxiously waiting it out, hoping for
02:47
an end soon to the blazes.
02:50
Well, as Californians reeling then from the fires, experts around the world are starting
02:56
to ask how we can better prepare ourselves for more fires in the future as the climate
03:02
emergency worsens. One of those experts is Alexander Held from the Resilience Program
03:09
at the European Forest Institute. He joins us live on the program now. Thanks for making
03:14
the time good to speak to you.
03:16
My pleasure.
03:17
Look, when we zoom out from those scenes in California, what lessons do you as an expert
03:25
draw in terms of fire management?
03:29
Well, with all the tragedy and catastrophe that we're observing, the fact is that a lot
03:37
of experts from the fire community and from the fire science community have predicted
03:42
some of those situations. And now we have the opportunity to really learn from the disaster
03:48
and start rebuilding reconstruction better into a more resilient future. So let's use
03:54
this disaster as good as we can.
03:56
Indeed. And when it comes to thinking about climate change, of course, the top priority
04:01
or one of the top priorities is mitigation, how we cut down on greenhouse gases, for example.
04:07
But given that experts like yourself say that the planet may well pass that 1.5 degrees
04:15
Celsius threshold in the coming years, the other question becomes then how it is that
04:20
we humans adapt, how we build resilience within the cities we live in to prepare ourselves
04:27
for more events like this in the future. Just tell us a bit about what steps practically
04:31
you think should be taken.
04:33
Well, the first prerequisite is, of course, as you mentioned, stopping the greenhouse
04:37
emissions and then in preparing a resilient situation, a more resilient situation when
04:43
it comes to wildfire and urban population. It's clear we have the ingredients for fires,
04:48
topography, weather and fuel, and we can't influence topography and change the weather.
04:53
So the only tool we have is addressing the conditions, the characteristics of the vegetation
04:59
that is fuel for a fire. And that can be mitigated and modified to a situation where
05:06
we will still have fires, but acceptable fires and manageable fires.
05:10
Look, and when we talk about reconstruction in Los Angeles in particular, how do you think
05:18
homes and communities there should be rebuilt now, keeping in mind that, of course, there
05:23
could be more fires on this scale to come?
05:28
Okay, there are a lot of programs out there and concepts in America and around the world,
05:32
fire wise concepts, fire smart concepts, building construction guidelines, etc. In terms of
05:39
how is your house prepared, how is your property prepared, how is your garden prepared, how
05:44
are the roads, access for firefighters, exit for evacuations and all that. So this is a
05:50
unique chance now of rebuilding into a better future. But one of the crucial points is that
05:56
the society has to accept in the future, we have to manage our landscape and we have
06:03
to live with fire and not like you tried in the past, living without fire and resulting
06:09
in an overgrown landscape that then goes up in flames in these severe conditions. So this
06:14
is the first step to take in terms of building awareness for the society that there is no
06:20
future without fire. You decide what fire and how do you like your smoke.
06:26
Look, and that is a stark image that you paint for us that these fires are going to happen
06:31
sort of come what may. And that makes me think about somewhere like California, that is one
06:36
of the wealthiest states in the United States, which is one of the wealthiest countries in
06:41
the world. Sort of what does that tell us when we zoom out even more about what needs
06:48
to be done now to support those developing countries that clearly don't have the resources
06:53
of somewhere like California, but could well face devastating fires linked to climate change
06:59
in the future?
07:00
Well, we see in California, as in other places that are highly developed, that in situations
07:06
like this, the best fire service in the world cannot do much. So the lesson to draw from
07:12
countries that are in a developing stage, or like where I'm in Germany, in a state where
07:17
fires are becoming more frequent, is that we start from the start engaging in an interdisciplinary
07:23
approach to managing fires, not only firefighting, not only suppression, but accepting that fire
07:29
will play a role in the future. It will be there if you like it or not. And if you accept
07:34
this, then you need foresters, urban planners, special planning, tourism, environment, education,
07:40
all on one table to develop objectives for the future that everybody can subscribe to.
07:47
But the prerequisite is accept that there will be fire and there will be smoke. And
07:52
we have to find a way that we can live with that in these conditions. And it is possible.
07:57
And look, just a final question for you then, is it possible in the future that areas like
08:03
Pacific Palisades that have been so devastated now, could be simply uninhabitable as a result
08:10
of fire risk?
08:12
I think we as a human race are very adaptable. And we have examples from other hot and dry
08:18
places in the world where if you manage sustainably and resilient, then you can live in these
08:24
conditions and there's no reason to give up. It should rather encourage us to really mitigate
08:32
climate change and provide for a living environment where we can live in balance with our environment.
08:39
Alexander Hell talking to us there from the Resilience Programme at the European Forests
08:43
Institute. Thanks very much indeed.
08:46
Thank you very much.
08:47
Well, for those who are directly caught up in the fires in Los Angeles, there are more
08:53
immediate questions to answer now. Among them, will my insurance cover the rebuilding of
08:59
my home? Delano D'Souza has this report.
09:04
In this Los Angeles neighbourhood ravaged by wildfires, a resident returns to inspect
09:09
the damage. Jesus Hernandez finds his home has been completely destroyed.
09:14
Again, you would be met with the living room, which is literally right here in this area.
09:20
As Jesus inspects what little remains, worry starts to mount.
09:27
Hopefully the insurance can pay for most of it. If not, then we're going to have to
09:35
stay with friends or someone.
09:37
Many residents in Southern California remain anxious as insurance companies have suspended
09:42
or limited their coverage in the past two years. In the affluent neighbourhood of Pacific
09:47
Palisades, thousands of contracts have been cancelled. This couple struggled but eventually
09:53
found an insurance policy days before last week's fire broke out.
09:57
I wonder how many other people weren't able to get that policy at the 11th hour because
10:00
you worked very hard to get it.
10:02
Between recurring wildfires, flooding and the risk of an earthquake, California remains
10:07
costly for insurance firms eager to leave the state.
10:11
Authorities have now forbidden companies from cancelling policies for the next year.
10:16
So right now, my immediate goal is to make sure that we get the claims paid, the claims
10:21
paid as quick as possible and that we get people on the road to recovery as quickly as
10:26
we can.
10:27
While experts estimate the damage and economic loss could cost between $135 billion to $150
10:34
billion, insurance companies could wind up paying nearly $20 billion.
10:42
Well, let's look a little now at the political fallout from the wildfires in California.
10:47
Our foreign editor, Ketavan Ghorjasthani, with me now.
10:50
And look, Ketavan, Donald Trump will be taking office a week today and the incoming
10:56
president is already pointing fingers, isn't he?
10:59
Absolutely. In the past few days, he's been attacking the Democratic leadership of the
11:04
state of California, especially the governor, Gavin Newsom, who's been a longtime foe of
11:10
the elected president.
11:12
And mostly it has been about mismanagement of water resources.
11:18
Trump accusing Gavin Newsom of being incompetent, but also more specifically, for
11:25
example, not signing a water restoration declaration.
11:29
This has been looked into by U.S.
11:32
reporters and apparently there is no such document that Gavin Newsom could not have
11:37
signed. What Donald Trump seems to be referring to is a sort of spat that he had with
11:42
Gavin Newsom back in 2020, so during his first term at a time when there were wildfires
11:49
in California and Donald Trump had sought to divert some water from the northern part
11:56
of California through a presidential memorandum to bring it down to some of the
12:01
farmlands further south, something that Gavin Newsom could not block as a governor,
12:07
but opposed publicly, saying that it was bad environmentally, especially for some
12:13
species that were close to extinction.
12:16
It was in the end the California attorney general that blocked that move by Donald
12:21
Trump. But even if that is true, that this water was not brought from the north to the
12:27
south, experts say that it would have had little bearing on what is happening right now
12:31
in California, that this is not about a lack of water because they point to the
12:37
reservoirs in and around Los Angeles as saying that they're all pretty much at normal
12:43
average levels for this time of the year, except one, which is a reservoir in the
12:49
area of the Pacific Palisades that has been hit hard.
12:53
This one was closed down for maintenance and that is why it was empty.
12:58
So nothing about managing the water there.
13:02
The only thing that Gavin Newsom agrees with Donald Trump on is this question about
13:08
why some fire hydrants were empty and were dry.
13:12
And for that, he has launched an investigation.
13:15
They're looking into that.
13:16
Another person that's been attacked by Donald Trump also is the mayor of Los Angeles,
13:21
Karen Bass. She's been attacked for supposedly cutting the funding to the fire
13:28
department of the city of Los Angeles by about 17 million dollars.
13:33
That is a little bit misleading because, yes, that budget has been cut.
13:38
But the city council also, parallel to this, added 53 million in pay raises, added 58
13:46
million in new kits for the firefighters.
13:49
So in the end, technically, the budget grew by 7 percent, not reduced.
13:55
And a lot of experts also say that there's not really been an impact on the fire
14:00
department's ability to fight the fire.
14:02
It's just simply that the fire was too big.
14:05
Look, and the fires are still raging, Ketavan, but there are already conversations now
14:10
turning to recovery and reconstruction.
14:12
And on that as well, the political blame game from Donald Trump is turning towards the
14:18
White House. Yes, the FEMA, the Federal Emergency Management Agency, already saying
14:24
that they've had about 24,000 people applying for federal assistance.
14:31
And Donald Trump coming out recently saying that Joe Biden had left, quote, no money in
14:38
FEMA. Now, it is true that the FEMA funding or that that fund has been depleted over the
14:45
past year because of the multiplication of natural disasters.
14:50
But Joe Biden signed a bill back in December to replenish that fund, putting in 29
14:58
billion dollars into that fund.
15:00
So the current balance of FEMA is actually 27 billion dollars.
15:05
Now, you might say this is likely not going to be enough in order to cover all the
15:10
disaster recovery that will come from these wildfires, but also possible other natural
15:16
disasters coming up.
15:17
But it is not no money.
15:20
But this blame game about FEMA and the role of FEMA has been something that Donald Trump
15:25
has used. We saw it back in the fall during Hurricane Helene, where he accused
15:30
Joe Biden of using the FEMA funds to help illegal immigrants instead of helping those
15:36
harder hit areas.
15:38
This is something that has also been debunked.
15:41
But Donald Trump has made FEMA a target.
15:45
We've seen that in the past.
15:47
The question now is what he's going to do when he gets into office.
15:50
He has said that broadly he wants to cut the budget of federal agencies.
15:55
He hasn't spoken specifically about FEMA.
15:58
But given that FEMA has been a target over and over again, there is some worry among
16:03
people who work in and with FEMA that that could be one of those areas where he would
16:09
cut a budget. And when you see what is happening right now in California and what we've
16:13
seen in the past few months in the United States from wildfires to hurricanes, FEMA is
16:19
an essential organization in the United States when it comes to that disaster recovery.
16:24
Ketavan Ghorjasdhani, for the moment, thanks very much.
16:27
Indeed.
Recommended
6:51
|
Up next
Natural element of ecosystem: L.A. fires 'so intense, violent, brutal that recovering's problematic'
FRANCE 24 English
1/18/2025
8:18
Firefighters up against climate change and dry, gusty weather conditions 'made to spread fire'
FRANCE 24 English
1/24/2025
11:50
'Whole range of factors: environmental, human and societal, contributing to worsening of disasters'
FRANCE 24 English
7/11/2025
9:54
'Mayotte abandoned years ago': Island felt 'forgotten, neglected' during drought & migration crisis
FRANCE 24 English
12/20/2024
6:22
Trump's 'war' on science and environmental policy will 'delay inevitable transition and cost lives'
FRANCE 24 English
5/5/2025
5:51
Protecting our oceans: 'Int'l community and private sector need to be challenged'
FRANCE 24 English
6/10/2025
6:57
Mayotte powerless in face of climate change: 'There's a huge inequality and injustice issue here'
FRANCE 24 English
12/17/2024
9:15
Climate change disrupting species’ habitats and altering both productivity and seasonality
FRANCE 24 English
6/12/2025
10:47
'Destructive industries destroying water and land which the wildlife depend on, which we depend on'
FRANCE 24 English
12/3/2024
8:37
As US abandons green policy, environmentally-engaged countries may exhibit more leadership globally
FRANCE 24 English
1/21/2025
9:13
'Collective problem needing a collective solution: Global warming is projected to increase well beyond 2 degrees'
FRANCE 24 English
6/20/2025
4:23
Mayotte 'totally devastated': 'There will be long-term consequences on the island'
FRANCE 24 English
12/17/2024
4:28
Planet's future in balance: World must unite, 'bring forth radical action' to reverse warming trend
FRANCE 24 English
11/8/2023
5:44
Following years of conflict, large-scale disaster in Derna 'goes beyond abilities of Libyan govt'
FRANCE 24 English
9/11/2024
47:30
Storm of the century? Hurricane Irma leaves massive destruction across the Caribbean
FRANCE 24 English
9/7/2017
9:01
USAID $40bn budget frozen: Int'l aid by UN agencies, NGO's, public/private sector severely impacted
FRANCE 24 English
2/4/2025
5:33
UN food, refugee agencies face massive cuts following demise of USAID and billions in funding losses
FRANCE 24 English
4/30/2025
9:34
Mayotte: France must raise 'standard of infrastructure, public services' in densely-populated island
FRANCE 24 English
12/20/2024
4:48
'Are you kidding me?': Vance's 'carefully constructed edifice of civility comes crashing down'
FRANCE 24 English
10/2/2024
7:11
COP29: In absence of world's biggest polluters, 'more underrepresented nations have a bigger voice'
FRANCE 24 English
11/15/2024
5:51
In the wake of the quake's devastation, Morocco's 'local civil society is really coming together'
FRANCE 24 English
9/12/2023
6:21
Climate Change: Top scientists finalizing UN report amid extreme weather worldwide
FRANCE 24 English
7/28/2021
10:05
Gone 'in the blink of an eye': Aid for Libya 'won't heal psychological trauma, wounds lasting a lifetime'
FRANCE 24 English
9/14/2023
13:07
Science at a crossroads: Europe positions Itself as the gateway to global research
FRANCE 24 English
5/5/2025
3:06
'Unwanted visit: You can hardly welcome the US VP with open arms' amid Trump's threats of annexation
FRANCE 24 English
3/28/2025