Aaeni Tarmeem Ki Zaroorat Kyun ?

ARY NEWS

10/26/2024

Transcript

00:00Faisal Chaudhary is with us in the Islambad studio.

00:04Thank you Faisal.

00:05Let's start with you.

00:06The 27th amendment is coming.

00:07There are a lot of issues in it.

00:09What are the big problems after the 26th amendment,

00:12which should be addressed?

00:14The government is saying that they will bring more clarity on this issue.

00:17The 26th amendment is a problem in itself.

00:21The problem with it is that the legislation,

00:24if it is a constitutional legislation,

00:27the aim is to reduce the issues that arise from it.

00:31With the 26th amendment,

00:33especially in our judiciary,

00:36the issues that have already been mentioned,

00:39like pending litigation,

00:42or appointment or other things,

00:45there will be more complications.

00:48The problem is that

00:51when there is a constitutional legislation,

00:54there is a broader consensus on it.

00:57Debates have to be held

00:59so that the nitty-gritties are removed.

01:02The problem is that the government

01:05sees that there is nothing in their own opinion.

01:08The order that comes from somewhere is so strict

01:12that the parliament is opened at night,

01:16debates are not held,

01:18and the opposition is broken.

01:21And then the marriages are told that

01:24we have done this,

01:27however we have done it,

01:30we are happy with it,

01:33despite being ashamed of it.

01:36This is called the Imran agreement in Urdu.

01:39The basic law of the agreement is that

01:42the agreement cannot be by force.

01:45The amendment has been brought by force.

01:48And the parliamentarians and senators

01:51who are present there,

01:54if they are rejected in such a way,

01:57like kidnapping someone,

02:00kidnapping someone's family,

02:03kidnapping someone's children,

02:06it is considered normal,

02:09which is not the case in civilized countries.

02:12That is why the amendment was brought

02:15in the 26th, 27th, and 47th.

02:18If there is no consensus...

02:21What do you mean by consensus?

02:24Your Chief Minister was present

02:27at the hearing.

02:30What do you think?

02:33Do you think that the Chief Minister,

02:36K.P.Ali Ameen, will bring a tank?

02:39He has given a point of view.

02:42His party has also given a point of view.

02:45Mr. Khan has also given a point of view.

02:48In the 26th, he was attacked

02:51on the freedom of the judiciary

02:54and on the rights of the people.

02:57If he does not come to the Oath Ceremony

03:00of the Chief Justice of Pakistan,

03:03then you will say that he did not come

03:06to the Oath Ceremony of the Chief Justice of Pakistan.

03:09I think that Mr. Ali Ameen has brought

03:12a good amendment to the PTM protest.

03:15You have a technical objection

03:18but you have a bigger objection

03:21about the way it was brought.

03:24Let me just phrase one sentence.

03:27The issue is that it is a flawed amendment

03:30that has been brought in a corrupt way.

03:33This flawed amendment has a weight

03:36because you are bringing a 27th amendment

03:39to solve many other discrepancies.

03:42Let us assume that the 27th amendment

03:45will be brought in.

03:48What do you want to correct

03:51that was left in the 26th amendment?

03:54First of all, I am listening to you

03:57about the 27th amendment.

04:00I don't know about that.

04:03We will bring as many amendments as needed

04:06until the matter is settled.

04:09By that, I mean that until the interpretation

04:12of the amendment is written

04:15through the judgement

04:18and until a judicial decision

04:21is not taken from another

04:24in a system where decisions are made

04:27on the basis of a single nap.

04:30One bench makes a decision on a single nap

04:33and the other bench makes a different decision

04:36in a short period of time.

04:39Until there is an agreement

04:42that there is a language in the amendment

04:45through which the amendment is written

04:48instead of interpreting it

04:51or until the Chief Justice of Pakistan

04:54decides which district the wheat sack

04:57cannot go to,

05:00or what the price of sugar will be,

05:03or which ward boy can be admitted

05:06in which hospital,

05:09or how much can a hospital cost,

05:12or whether the salary of a doctor

05:15from the U.S. can be this much,

05:18or whether he should return his salary,

05:21until these interpretations are made

05:24in Article 184.3.

05:27Until the Chief Justice of Pakistan

05:30is sent home through a judicial decision

05:33and is told that he did not take a salary

05:36from his son's company

05:39but he could have taken it.

05:42If he could have taken it and did not,

05:45then you would have gone.

05:48When you amend anything

05:51to create an equilibrium,

05:54you create your own externalities.

05:57No one has ever said that

06:00there will be no externality.

06:03If this was the case,

06:06there would be no scope for amendment

06:09in the constitution.

06:12When I was studying in the U.S.,

06:15I found the answer to the question

06:18of what is the genius of the constitution.

06:21After a lot of answers,

06:24I found the answer to the question

06:27of provision for change.

Aaeni Tarmeem Ki Zaroorat Kyun ?

Category

Transcript

Recommended