Tauheen e Adalat Ka Khatrah... Kya Hukoomat Supreme Court Ka Faisla Tasleem Karne Ja Rahi Hai???
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00What is the government thinking?
00:02We can see what the government is thinking
00:04but now after this decision
00:06before this you may remember that you made a law
00:08but increasingly
00:10judges
00:12former judges are saying on TV
00:14that if we don't act on the decision then it is just contempt
00:16we have to act on the decision
00:18they said give seats, we have to give seats
00:20what is your thinking?
00:22Bismillahir Rahmanir Rahim, Qasim sir
00:24thank you for having me on your show
00:26two things
00:28there was a majority order
00:30now there is a detailed order
00:32and naturally the detailed order is limited to
00:34what was said in the short order
00:36there is an expansion of it
00:38there was a minority judgement
00:40which is a minority judgement
00:42it is not operative because
00:44no judgements are not
00:46but serious questions will be raised
00:48can I say something
00:50I am just pointing something out to you
00:52when two people are dissenting
00:54it is not really a minority
00:56two judges of the Supreme Court
00:58not only
01:00disagreed with the decision
01:02but raised serious questions
01:04on the constitutionality of the majority order
01:06now review petitions are also pending
01:08from the election commission
01:10from the PMLN
01:12against the short order
01:14so now
01:16that is also pending
01:18in addition to this
01:20that is very scope limited
01:22they say that on the surface
01:24if there are major issues
01:26we feel
01:28a party that was not present there
01:30we feel that the order is in violation
01:32of articles 51-106 of the constitution
01:34they have addressed it
01:36it is in the majority order
01:38but on review petitions
01:40there is an opposite view
01:42which provides you a chance
01:44second thing is
01:46the amendment
01:48this is where I wanted to come
01:50you brought an amendment
01:52now we will try to give you
01:54a legal opinion on this
01:56that amendment
01:58will it override
02:00the decision of the Supreme Court
02:02if it is not a view of the Supreme Court
02:04then it will put contempt on your government
02:06but I think you have burnt the boats
02:08you are the Supreme Court
02:10look at the way you have arranged
02:12the practice and procedure
02:14first you used to teach us the lesson of democracy
02:16that democracy is this
02:18I want to address this
02:20but first
02:22let us close this open chapter
02:24first of all
02:26I have a letter from the Speaker
02:28wrote to the election commission
02:30and he said
02:32and I will just read out two sentences
02:34furthermore section 12 of the amended
02:36election act categorically states
02:38that the said amendments will have retrospective effect
02:40from 2017 when the election act
02:422017 was passed
02:44and a few sentences later it categorically states
02:46and this is the view of the Speaker of the National Assembly
02:48who is a custodian of the National Assembly
02:50that as the judgment of the Supreme Court was rendered
02:52based on the law prior to the enactment of the
02:54amendment, the said judgment
02:56is now incapable of implementation
02:58now this is the view of the Speaker of the National Assembly
03:00which has been sent to the election commission
03:02and furthermore
03:04it is pertinent to mention here that the above
03:06is not only my view but in fact is the consistent
03:08jurisprudence of the honourable Supreme Court as well
03:10now this is another view
03:12what is consistent jurisprudence?
03:14there cannot be retrospective legislation
03:16this is what he is saying
03:18Sir, you can say that we are going to impose tax
03:20but Mr. Kashyap, this tax
03:22has been annulled in the last 5 years
03:24I am not a lawyer
03:26but I understand
03:28that retrospective effect
03:30in certain cases there is
03:32jurisprudence in specific instances
03:34in specific instances it is not
03:36but what I want to say finally
03:38then you can go to Mr. Zain
03:40see, the election commission is a constitutional body
03:42on one hand it is the decision of the Supreme Court
03:44in the Supreme Court Trichotomy of Powers
03:46it is the judgment of the Supreme Court
03:48but at the same time
03:50it also has to follow the constitution and the law
03:52as it exists
03:54so it will have to decide based on all these things
03:56at the same time I hope that the review petitions
03:58pending on this important constitutional issue
04:00will also be judged by the Supreme Court
04:02I think they will remove you from the 63A
04:04what I mean is that they will remove you
04:06I am sure of it
04:08you can talk to Mr. Zain
04:10he will come to your practice and procedure
04:12you can talk to Mr. Zain
04:14he will come to your practice and procedure
04:16you can talk to Mr. Zain
04:18he will come to your practice and procedure
04:20you can talk to Mr. Zain
04:22he will come to your practice and procedure
04:24you can talk to Mr. Zain
04:26he will come to your practice and procedure
04:28you can talk to Mr. Zain
04:30he will come to your practice and procedure
04:32you can talk to Mr. Zain
04:34he will come to your practice and procedure
04:36you can talk to Mr. Zain
04:38he will come to your practice and procedure
04:40you can talk to Mr. Zain
04:42he will come to your practice and procedure
04:44you can talk to Mr. Zain
04:46he will come to your practice and procedure
04:48you can talk to Mr. Zain
04:50he will come to your practice and procedure
04:52you can talk to Mr. Zain
04:54he will come to your practice and procedure
04:56you can talk to Mr. Zain
04:58he will come to your practice and procedure
05:00you can talk to Mr. Zain
05:02he will come to your practice and procedure
05:04you can talk to Mr. Zain
05:06he will come to your practice and procedure
05:08you can talk to Mr. Zain
05:10he will come to your practice and procedure
05:12you can talk to Mr. Zain
05:14he will come to your practice and procedure
05:16you can talk to Mr. Zain
05:18he will come to your practice and procedure
05:20you can talk to Mr. Zain
05:22he will come to your practice and procedure
05:24you can talk to Mr. Zain
05:26he will come to your practice and procedure
05:28you can talk to Mr. Zain
05:30he will come to your practice and procedure
05:32you can talk to Mr. Zain
05:34he will come to your practice and procedure
05:36you can talk to Mr. Zain
05:38he will come to your practice and procedure
05:40you can talk to Mr. Zain
05:42he will come to your practice and procedure
05:44you can talk to Mr. Zain
05:46he will come to your practice and procedure
05:48you can talk to Mr. Zain
05:50he will come to your practice and procedure
05:52you can talk to Mr. Zain
05:54he will come to your practice and procedure
05:56you can talk to Mr. Zain
05:58he will come to your practice and procedure
06:00you can talk to Mr. Zain
06:02he will come to your practice and procedure
06:04you can talk to Mr. Zain
06:06he will come to your practice and procedure
06:08you can talk to Mr. Zain
06:10he will come to your practice and procedure
06:12you can talk to Mr. Zain
06:14he will come to your practice and procedure
06:16you can talk to Mr. Zain
06:18he will come to your practice and procedure
06:20you can talk to Mr. Zain
06:22he will come to your practice and procedure
06:24you can talk to Mr. Zain
06:26he will come to your practice and procedure
06:28you can talk to Mr. Zain
06:30he will come to your practice and procedure
06:32you can talk to Mr. Zain
06:34he will come to your practice and procedure
06:36you can talk to Mr. Zain
06:38he will come to your practice and procedure
06:40you can talk to Mr. Zain
06:42he will come to your practice and procedure
06:44you can talk to Mr. Zain
06:46he will come to your practice and procedure
06:48you can talk to Mr. Zain
06:50he will come to your practice and procedure
06:52you can talk to Mr. Zain
06:54he will come to your practice and procedure
06:56you can talk to Mr. Zain
06:58he will come to your practice and procedure
07:00you can talk to Mr. Zain
07:02he will come to your practice and procedure
07:04you can talk to Mr. Zain
07:06he will come to your practice and procedure
07:08you can talk to Mr. Zain
07:10he will come to your practice and procedure
07:12you can talk to Mr. Zain
07:14he will come to your practice and procedure
07:16you can talk to Mr. Zain
07:18he will come to your practice and procedure
07:20you can talk to Mr. Zain
07:22he will come to your practice and procedure
07:24you can talk to Mr. Zain
07:26he will come to your practice and procedure
07:28you can talk to Mr. Zain
07:30he will come to your practice and procedure
07:32you can talk to Mr. Zain
07:34he will come to your practice and procedure
07:36you can talk to Mr. Zain
07:38he will come to your practice and procedure
07:40you can talk to Mr. Zain
07:42he will come to your practice and procedure
07:44you can talk to Mr. Zain
07:46he will come to your practice and procedure
07:48you can talk to Mr. Zain
07:50he will come to your practice and procedure
07:52you can talk to Mr. Zain
07:54he will come to your practice and procedure
07:56you can talk to Mr. Zain
07:58he will come to your practice and procedure
08:00you can talk to Mr. Zain
08:02he will come to your practice and procedure
08:04you can talk to Mr. Zain
08:06he will come to your practice and procedure
08:08you can talk to Mr. Zain
08:10he will come to your practice and procedure
08:12you can talk to Mr. Zain
08:14he will come to your practice and procedure
08:16you can talk to Mr. Zain
08:18he will come to your practice and procedure
08:20you can talk to Mr. Zain
08:22he will come to your practice and procedure
08:24you can talk to Mr. Zain
08:26he will come to your practice and procedure
08:28you can talk to Mr. Zain
08:30he will come to your practice and procedure
08:32you can talk to Mr. Zain
08:34he will come to your practice and procedure
08:36you can talk to Mr. Zain
08:38he will come to your practice and procedure
08:40you can talk to Mr. Zain
08:42he will come to your practice and procedure
08:44you can talk to Mr. Zain
08:46he will come to your practice and procedure
08:48you can talk to Mr. Zain
08:50he will come to your practice and procedure