Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
'This Is Ridiculous': John Hoeven Slams Navy Officials For Firing Off 'Expensive' Missiles
Forbes Breaking News
Follow
7/7/2025
At a Senate Appropriations Committee hearing last week, Sen. John Hoeven (R-ND) questioned Chief of Naval Operations James Kilby about the cost of firing missiles.
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
Senator Hovind.
00:03
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Admiral Kilby, for the attack on Qatar yesterday, 14 missiles by Iran.
00:11
Were they shot down by Qatar? Were they shot down by our forces?
00:16
And by what systems? To the extent you can cover any of that in non-confidential, would you go to that?
00:21
I can get you specific, sir, but I believe the Patriot system was the most effective U.S. system in support of that.
00:28
Whether or not there was any Qatar defensive measures taken that were excessive, I'll have to get back to you on that.
00:35
So primarily it was our Patriot batteries?
00:37
Sure.
00:38
At UD there that they fired on?
00:40
Okay. For all three of you, starting with you, Mr. Secretary, do you think that the United States needs to keep its lead in ISR technology,
00:48
or can we just tell the Air Force and Space Force, nah, we don't need the new ISR systems, we'll just do everything with satellites?
00:58
Or do you think in the near-peer competition and for what's going on in Ukraine and the Middle East and everywhere else,
01:03
we actually need the new ISR technologies that will enable us to make sure that we can be there for long periods of time
01:11
with nobody known and with kinetic capabilities?
01:13
Thank you, Senator, for the question.
01:18
Yes, we need to have good counter-ISR capabilities, and I'm always someone who believes in combat and also in navies and ships.
01:27
You need redundant systems.
01:29
You need backups.
01:30
You need different forms of systems.
01:32
And so I think it's a critical thing that we need.
01:35
Admiral, your same question.
01:37
I share Secretary Phelan's belief in this.
01:40
I think multiple systems is good.
01:42
When we have a single answer, it can be engineered against.
01:46
So we need to have terrestrial systems, air and surface as well as space, sir.
01:51
General?
01:53
Yes, sir.
01:54
Our investment in that is the MQ-9, a big-wing drone, along with other ISR capabilities,
02:00
but they're vital to us in the Indo-Pacific based on their endurance and their range.
02:04
And the MQ-9 is something you would use in the Indo-Pacific from land,
02:09
which is vitally important to support naval ships and submarines, right?
02:11
Yes, sir.
02:12
Absolutely.
02:13
That is the purpose of it.
02:14
And it's not just the existing systems, MQ-9, but we need the newer high-tech systems as well, right?
02:20
That is right.
02:20
So we're always looking to improve.
02:22
Okay.
02:23
And, frankly, the Navy, you have been strong on this, and I commend you for it.
02:28
And I appreciate it.
02:29
And thank you for so stating on the record.
02:31
Based on what we're seeing in the Middle East and what we're seeing in Ukraine and Russia,
02:38
we've got to do more on drone and counter-drone, and not only here in terms of having the best
02:46
technologies that exceed any adversary, but also cost and numbers.
02:54
Talk to me about what you're doing and what we need to do to help you make sure that we're in that position.
03:01
Starting with you, Secretary.
03:03
So I'll let the Admiral give you specifics on ways we have started to lower the cost per shot
03:08
or the way to take out drones because we've definitely pivoted from using some of our more exquisite platforms.
03:15
At the end of the day, look, we have to protect the ships because if they hit the ship, that'd be a lot more expensive problem.
03:22
But this is an area we are very focused on and one we are looking at for counter-drones.
03:27
But I would let the Admiral kind of walk you through a little bit some of the things we've been doing to lower it.
03:32
Yeah, in fact, I was on the USS Cole in the Mediterranean after they had returned,
03:38
and they'd fired off all their missiles, very expensive, as well as using their cannon on the front deck and their .50 cal.
03:46
And all of those become less desirable because as you, the UAS is getting closer to your ship
03:55
as you kind of work down the chain of what's more economical, right?
03:59
Hey, sir, sir, really quickly, I agree with you completely.
04:03
We can't use our most expensive munitions, which are really capable offensively in defense,
04:09
but we found ourselves in that position when the Red Sea started.
04:12
As things developed, we started to use air wings and the ability to attract the threat to range,
04:17
to even include helicopters.
04:20
What we've done recently is Fort Strike Group, who is just on the precipice of deploying,
04:24
has a number of systems that we installed on their combatants that are not integrated in the combat system.
04:33
But they're knockoffs from the Army, which is a coyote system, or Hellfire and Longbow,
04:38
which are missile systems that should get us that range without having to use SM-2s and SM-6s.
04:43
So that's our start in that, but we are very focused on terminal defense
04:47
and being able to have those sailors have confidence in those systems
04:51
to not have to use those more expensive, preferred munitions.
04:54
And proximity to your ships is huge.
04:57
It puts you at risk, and an adversary is going to flood the zone and make you fire off all your missiles.
05:03
Yes, sir.
05:03
So this is something you have to have today, right?
05:06
Yes, sir.
05:07
And do you feel that you are on top of this today?
05:10
Just like for our bases, we're not on top of counter-drone.
05:13
They're flying these things all over our bases.
05:15
This is ridiculous.
05:16
It puts us in jeopardy.
05:18
But we need to be on that now, guys.
05:19
So do you feel like, I mean, do you have a certain comfort level?
05:23
You got it?
05:23
I don't say we have it because it is a vexing threat.
05:26
I think we're taking steps, as we've seen with the Ford Strike Group,
05:29
and we'll continue to take those steps to get on the right side of the cost curve.
05:34
Secretary or General, anything you want to add on that?
05:37
I would say the base issue and even our shipyard issues after seeing what Ukraine did to the Russians
05:45
is something we are very focused on, and it's going to take a cross-government issue
05:50
because, you know, unfortunately today, if a drone is flying over Groton Shipyard,
05:54
there is nothing we can do about it, and that needs to change.
05:57
Right.
05:58
General, anything you want to add?
06:00
No, sir.
06:00
We're working at all levels.
06:01
We're working organic counter-UAS.
06:03
We're working installations counter-UAS.
06:06
We're working some of our bigger systems, our L-MATIS,
06:09
our lightweight marine air defense integrated system, our medium-range intercept capability,
06:14
but our counter-UAS for installations is woefully behind.
06:19
Final point.
06:20
Is, you know, we're talking so much about the B-2s and rightly so,
06:25
but what you did with your submarine was absolutely incredible as well.
06:30
You guys are absolutely amazing what you do.
06:32
Thank you so much.
Recommended
5:15
|
Up next
Jerry Moran Asks Chief Of Naval Operations: What Is Being Done To Limit Fires On Ships?
Forbes Breaking News
7/9/2025
6:44
'Why Don't You Answer My Question?': Dan Sullivan & Secretary John Phelan Get Into Spat Over Navy Ships
Forbes Breaking News
7/9/2025
6:36
Joni Ernst Accuses Navy Of Counting Junior Sailors In Senior Billets To 'Inflate Our Readiness'
Forbes Breaking News
7/9/2025
4:25
Mitch McConnell Asks Navy Secretary: How Do We Bring Down Cost Of Drone Development?
Forbes Breaking News
7/7/2025
5:56
Mark Kelly Asks Military Official About Installing Nuclear Capabilities Into Navy’s Submarine Fleet
Forbes Breaking News
5/29/2025
6:39
John Hoeven Calls Nuclear Triad 'De Facto Golden Dome' During Hearing With Air Force Leadership
Forbes Breaking News
7/1/2025
5:31
John Boozman Raises Concerns Over Potential 'PLA' Leading To 'Stalled' Military Construction Efforts
Forbes Breaking News
6/17/2025
7:18
Roger Wicker Presses Military Nominee About Getting Naval Acquisitions And Ship Building 'Back On Track'
Forbes Breaking News
7/1/2025
9:34
'What The Hell Happened To The Money?': John Kennedy Discusses Major Budget Challenges
Forbes Breaking News
6/11/2025
5:35
John Barrasso Accuses Biden Of 'Weaponizing' IRS, Asks Nominee How To Restore Agency's 'Credibility'
Forbes Breaking News
6/2/2025
12:13
'Where Does The Money Come From?': John Kennedy Grills Officials About Funding Sources For Major Projects
Forbes Breaking News
6/12/2025
4:51
'Simply Unsustainable': John Kennedy Gives Blunt Take On Energy Department Budget To Secretary Chris Wright
Forbes Breaking News
5/22/2025
5:57
'What We Do Makes No Sense To Me': Navy Secretary Discusses 'Crazy' Rule With Elizabeth Warren
Forbes Breaking News
6/17/2025
7:40
'I Know It's Interesting—That's Why I Asked It': John Kennedy Shows No Mercy To Judicial Nominee
Forbes Breaking News
6/30/2025
5:32
'We Are Expending Missiles Far Faster Than We Can Produce Them:' Deb Fischer Warns Of Low Munitions
Forbes Breaking News
7/8/2025
5:28
John Boozman Questions Military Officials About How Funding Impacts Reserve And Nat. Guard ‘Readiness’
Forbes Breaking News
5/28/2025
6:36
'How Many Innocent People Has The Theocracy In Iran Killed?': John Kennedy Grills Military Officials
Forbes Breaking News
6/24/2025
6:36
John Barrasso Accuses Democrats Of 'Sabotaging The Senate' Ahead Of Potential Government Shutdown
Forbes Breaking News
5 days ago
9:07
‘What Are We Funding?’: Rick Scott Grills Admiral On Use Of Naval Shipbuilding Funds
Forbes Breaking News
4/15/2025
5:27
Rick Scott Discusses Navy Shipbuilding Targets And The Importance Of The C130 To The Marines
Forbes Breaking News
7/9/2025
5:08
John Thune Touts GOP Budget, Slams Dems For Planning To Block Bill With 'Everything They've Got'
Forbes Breaking News
6/9/2025
2:59
'What's "Impetuous" Mean?': John Kennedy Mocks Fellow Committee Member's Criticism Of Iran Attacks
Forbes Breaking News
7/7/2025
5:19
'It's Sort Of Stunning': Jim Banks Praises Trump's Election For Driving Up Military Recruitment
Forbes Breaking News
7/9/2025
2:35
'What Is That $900 Million For Specifically?': Jon Ossoff Grills Trump Official Over MilCon Budget
Forbes Breaking News
6/17/2025
7:00
'How Do We Keep People Safe?': John Hickenlooper Rips Forest Service Chief Over Firefighting Funding Cuts
Forbes Breaking News
7/11/2025