Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
Incoming Trump administration may go 'as far as war' with Iran, expert says
FRANCE 24 English
Follow
1/19/2025
Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com
Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English
Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
Well, joining me to discuss this Eberhard Kinley, Research Director at CNRS.
00:05
Thank you so much for taking the time to speak to us today on the program.
00:09
Thank you for having me.
00:11
So the ceasefire deal that's been struck is rather similar to the one proposed by Biden
00:16
back in May, but it's only taking place now.
00:18
So would you say Trump was the catalyst for this outcome?
00:22
Yes, to an extent, I suppose.
00:26
He certainly wanted to have some good news for himself before his inauguration.
00:31
And I suppose it's largely to do with his prestige, his sense of prestige, and of course,
00:38
his ability to put perhaps additional pressure temporarily on Netanyahu, who was not extremely
00:46
impressed by the pressures, the very limited pressure exercised by Biden.
00:52
Now that we're cautiously optimistic about things moving on in the region, what kind
00:58
of impact do you think Trump will have on the Middle East?
01:01
Would you say that his approach will be more or less in the same direction as Joe Biden's?
01:07
It's very difficult to say at that stage, because we all know that President Trump or
01:11
future President Trump, he will only be inaugurated tomorrow, that he is volatile, that he is
01:17
not always extremely consistent, as we have seen in other issues like the Bitcoin issue.
01:23
Now, this being said, there are a few, I think if we go back in history, there are a few
01:29
sort of guiding lines that help us to understand where he might be going within, of course,
01:35
these parameters of volatility.
01:37
I suppose he is still very much wedded to his old ideas, the ones like the Abraham Accords
01:45
and the Trump plan in 2020.
01:50
So I think if we go back to his first mandate, we will see what is in store for the Middle East.
02:01
It's more or less in the same vein as what you said, but under the first Trump administration,
02:05
the US recognised Israel's sovereignty over the Golan Heights.
02:09
He also recognised Jerusalem as the capital and closed the PLO office in Washington as well.
02:14
Are we likely to see this sort of hardline approach continue then?
02:20
I suppose this is the most likely option.
02:23
Again, we don't quite know.
02:25
But if some pressure was exercised or exerted on Netanyahu this time round, that does not
02:31
mean that the American plans and the Trump plans for the Middle East are, say, hostile
02:39
to what the current Israeli government considers as its interest.
02:44
So indeed, I think deals in the Israeli-Palestinian affairs that will be proposed or suggested
02:52
will be much more in the Israeli interest than in the Palestinian interest.
02:59
Now let's talk a bit about Trump's ties with the Israeli government, because we've heard
03:04
reports that his son-in-law, Jared Kushner, has doubled his stake in a financial firm
03:09
that stands to gain from financing illegal Israeli settlements in the Palestinian territory.
03:14
I wonder what you make of this.
03:16
Well, I suppose this is sadly true.
03:22
So there may be a conflict of interest.
03:25
But I suppose even without such a conflict of interest, what we know about Trump, what
03:32
we know about his earlier policies, indicates that any deal that will be suggested or proposed
03:38
will be far less in the Palestinian interest than in the Israeli interest, or at least
03:43
in the interest as formulated by the current Israeli government.
03:46
So I think the conflict of interest issue is one of them, but certainly not the major
03:51
one.
03:52
By and large, people who voted for Trump, by and large the people around him, are certainly
03:57
much closer to the current Israeli government than to the Palestinian administration or,
04:03
of course, to Hamas.
04:05
And how do you think the U.S. support for annexation impact Israel's relations with
04:11
its Arab neighbors, particularly those involved in the Abraham Accords?
04:17
This is difficult to say, because, well, last time around, of course, these proposals, they
04:26
did not go through for the obvious reason that Trump is no longer president.
04:30
Now, we remember also that in the old days, Saudi Arabia was, well, not divided, but it
04:36
was sort of not entirely opposed to these ideas.
04:40
And I suppose the Saudi government at the time would have accepted a deal that favors
04:48
Israeli interest.
04:49
Today, this may be different.
04:51
However, we should also see that the Gulf states, they do not have that much sort of
04:56
leeway or that much of leverage on the United States.
04:59
So it may well be that a new President Trump will try to impose or will try to impose a
05:06
solution that may even contradict the interests of some of its allies.
05:12
And going forward, do you expect Trump to prioritize a long-term solution for Gaza,
05:18
or will his focus remain on supporting Israel's security efforts?
05:25
Trump and long-term solutions seem to be a contradiction in terms.
05:30
We already mentioned his, say, volatility and his tendency to change his opinion.
05:39
Now, I don't think that Trump is at this particular moment thinking about a long-term solution.
05:46
He is thinking about a short-term solution, which will help his inauguration, which will
05:51
help him in the early days of his new mandate.
05:55
I do not think that he is in a position at the moment to envisage anything in the longer
06:02
term.
06:03
Now, also the people around him, we'll have to see who will sort of wield more influence
06:09
in this Trump administration, people like, for instance, the new or the probably new
06:14
Ambassador Huckabee to Jerusalem, or Waltz, the national security advisor.
06:23
There are people who are certainly more able and more willing to think about long-term
06:29
solutions than others.
06:31
So I think this is really, the jury is out.
06:34
However, if there is a long-term solution, or if Trump sort of continues to push his
06:42
agenda, the one that he pushed some four years ago, we will see a long-term solution
06:49
that is in the favor of the current Israeli government in its majority, however fragile
06:53
it is.
06:54
It will be one that will possibly go to annexation and maybe the expulsion of Palestinians from
07:02
Gaza, maybe from the West Bank.
07:04
This is certainly a possibility.
07:06
There is a possibility also that we will move, if reason prevails in Washington, that we
07:11
will move to some sort of two-state solution, something, however, that will be not two states
07:17
as we imagined them normally, but one state, Israel, and a statelet, which would be Palestine,
07:25
as envisaged under the first Trump plan.
07:27
Now, there is also possibly the, well, what I would call the latest Blinken plan, a solution
07:36
that he sketched out a few days ago at the Atlantic Council, which would involve the
07:41
Palestinian Authority, which would involve non-Hamas representatives from Gaza, which
07:49
would involve international forces from Arab countries and abroad, either, as well in a
07:55
sort of transitory government and in a transitory security force.
08:01
However, I think, well, however difficult this would be to put in place, it's not something
08:06
that is likely to win the favors of Trump.
08:09
So I suppose the sort of less favorable options for the Palestinians are more likely.
08:17
And just lastly, if you will, how would you characterize Trump's strategy vis-a-vis Iran?
08:23
Are we likely to see a continuation of the maximum pressure approach we saw during his
08:28
first administration?
08:30
Again, with the caveats earlier made, we are not sure.
08:34
Still, this is very likely.
08:36
Now, Trump in general, so far we have seen, is not somebody who would like to go to war.
08:43
I think his instincts, his ideas is to put pressure through economic pressure, blockades,
08:52
sanctions, and so on and so forth.
08:54
I think this is the general approach.
08:56
And that's, I suppose, what he meant if all hell would might break loose in the Middle
09:00
East, that he would resort to these sort of issues, to these sort of techniques.
09:04
However, with Iran, I think there may be an exception, and indeed maximum pressure may
09:10
go as far as war.
09:12
Eberhard Kindler from CNRS, thank you so much for taking the time to speak to us on France
09:17
24 today.
Recommended
2:25
|
Up next
Trump says US personnel moved as Iran nuclear talks stall
FRANCE 24 English
6/12/2025
2:05
US warns against Iran retaliation as Trump raises 'regime change'
FRANCE 24 English
6/23/2025
2:23
Trump outburst 'will be very disconcerting for Israelis'
FRANCE 24 English
5 days ago
14:51
'We are engaged in a brutal war that has to be ended as soon as possible'
FRANCE 24 English
10/6/2024
4:26
US presidential debate: 'Bombast and lies' from Trump
FRANCE 24 English
6/28/2024
10:35
Second phase of ceasefire depends on Trump administration, expert says
FRANCE 24 English
2/1/2025
5:42
MAGA split forms over US involvement in Iran
FRANCE 24 English
6/18/2025
1:46
Row between Trump and Zelensky erupts at White House
FRANCE 24 English
3/1/2025
5:22
EU leaders seek ‘clarity’, ‘rational assessment’ of Trump administration
FRANCE 24 English
2/17/2025
6:11
Trump and Middle East threatens to overshadow NATO summit
FRANCE 24 English
5 days ago
6:34
Harris and Trump to clash as America awaits next twist
FRANCE 24 English
9/10/2024
2:46
A look at Trump's controversial nominations for cabinet
FRANCE 24 English
1/18/2025
2:11
'Heaviest bombardment Tehran has seen since staart of war'
FRANCE 24 English
6 days ago
4:50
Trump sends military force to LA: 'Extraordinary' move from White House
FRANCE 24 English
6/8/2025
2:28
Iranians struggling to make ends meet
FRANCE 24 English
12/16/2024
12:10
'Dangerously simplistic' view of int'l relations: Trump 'unfit' to handle global threats, challenges
FRANCE 24 English
11/8/2024
3:36
'This would bring to an end two and a half months of political uncertainty'
FRANCE 24 English
9/21/2024
1:37
US Secret Service director resigns after Trump assassination bid
FRANCE 24 English
7/24/2024
1:39
Trump holds first campaign event since an apparent assassination attempt
FRANCE 24 English
9/18/2024
1:22
'If I had five minutes'... What a former French military chief would tell Trump
FRANCE 24 English
3/2/2025
3:16
Harris says in first interview US ready to turn page on Trump
FRANCE 24 English
8/30/2024
8:22
Trump’s plan to shutdown USAID would lead to rise in conflict and insecurity, expert says
FRANCE 24 English
2/7/2025
1:42
'We are going to be looking about what this legacy has left for France"
FRANCE 24 English
9/9/2024
0:15
MR1
Go Go Video
1/9/2022
0:22
thththth
Go Go Video
9/20/2020