Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
Moscow sees one of Ukraine's largest drone attacks as fighting rages in Kursk and eastern Ukraine
FRANCE 24 English
Follow
8/21/2024
Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com
Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English
Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
In other news, Ukraine launched the largest drone attack of the Russian capital overnight.
00:04
According to Russian authorities, 11 drones were destroyed over Moscow.
00:08
In total, 45 Ukrainian drones were reportedly downed across Russian territory.
00:14
The latest attacks come as the incursion into Kursk continues.
00:18
This Wednesday, the deputy head of Russia's Security Council says negotiations with Ukraine
00:23
are off the table.
00:25
For more, we can bring in Samuel Rahmani, Associate Fellow at the Royal United Services
00:29
Institute.
00:30
Thank you very much for joining us here on France 24.
00:33
Now, when Ukraine started this incursion into Kursk, one was under the impression that Kyiv
00:39
was doing this to get an upper hand in any negotiations.
00:42
But now with Moscow saying talks are off the table, where does it leave Ukraine?
00:47
Well, the Russians are playing a double game with the talks.
00:50
Obviously, you see hardliners like Dmitry Medvedev consistently brand the Ukrainian
00:55
government as an illegitimate regime that cannot be engaged in dialogue with.
00:59
But you also see other Russian officials in the past, like Dmitry Peshkov and even Vladimir
01:04
Putin, as recently as June 14th, talk about the prospect of talks.
01:07
I don't think we should take a single isolated statement for Dmitry Medvedev as a sign that
01:12
negotiations are impossible.
01:13
I think that Ukraine, if it can make more gains in Kursk, is probably increasing the
01:17
likelihood of future diplomacy.
01:19
How do Ukraine's NATO allies view this incursion?
01:25
Well, I think that it caught some NATO allies by surprise and probably some others less
01:28
by surprise.
01:29
I think that there was obviously some coordination with the United States on this, at least coming
01:34
from the statements from John Kirby.
01:36
But the Germans, for example, were somewhat left in the dark.
01:39
But even though the Germans may not have been consulted on very readily, they're also not
01:43
objecting to the use of their weaponry on Russian soil.
01:47
And it's very possible that when Ukraine was going to NATO countries and asking them
01:50
for permission to use their weapons inside Russia, they were talking about it in the
01:54
context of some kind of territorial incursion.
01:57
So even if they didn't know about Kursk specifically, they probably knew that Ukraine was going to
02:01
try to do some kind of a strike into Russia at some point.
02:04
But Samuel, I have a question.
02:05
I thought the weapons were allowed to be used for defensive purposes.
02:09
But is it considered defensive purposes if the weapons are being used on Russian territory?
02:15
Well, I think it can definitely be considered to be defensive.
02:17
It depends on how you define defensive.
02:19
And that might be defined very differently by Kiev and other NATO allies.
02:23
If you're talking about trying to derail the Russian war machine and firing drones on what
02:27
funds it, which is oil refineries, perfectly legitimate.
02:30
Of taking drones on metallurgy factories would be perfectly legitimate.
02:36
And Russia's occupying territory inside Ukraine with heavy fortifications that are hard to
02:40
trespass.
02:41
So deliberate your own territory.
02:44
The only way forward might be to do a land swap deal.
02:46
And Ukraine can frame that as defensive also.
02:49
And Russia's also striking across the border in Sumy, which is right across the border
02:53
from Kursk.
02:54
One could assume that Ukraine launched this incursion into Kursk before the winter sets
03:02
in, but also before the presidential election in the United States.
03:07
We don't know what's going to happen there.
03:08
Yes, Kamala Harris is up in certain polls.
03:12
But one never knows, right?
03:14
Is there much of an appetite for this conflict to continue much longer and be settled just
03:19
on the battlefield?
03:21
Well, I think that there probably is a concern in Ukraine, obviously, about what a Trump
03:26
presidency would mean.
03:27
And the planning for this would have likely occurred long before August the 6th.
03:31
So it probably was at a time when Trump was leading Joe Biden on average by about 5% in
03:35
the polls.
03:36
And he was talking about ending the war on day one.
03:40
So I think that this offensive may have been done with that in mind.
03:42
But regardless of who is president, there will very likely be some kind of a division
03:48
between Republicans in Congress and whoever's in the White House, even if Harris is there.
03:51
And the Ukrainians need to show that this war is winnable to get more American support.
03:56
And that's why they're doing this offensive, too.
03:58
Because I think over the past 18 months, when we saw the failed Ukrainian counteroffensive,
04:02
when we saw Russia make incremental gains in Donetsk, in places like Bakhmut and Chez
04:07
The feeling in Washington, amongst many, was that the war was not winnable.
04:10
And now Ukraine has changed that paradigm potentially.
04:14
It seems to have changed the paradigm for now.
04:16
I want to talk about something that's going to happen on Friday.
04:20
We're going to have the Indian prime minister who's going to be going to Kyiv.
04:23
His first visit, Narendra Modi's first visit to Ukraine since the conflict broke out.
04:28
The first visit by an Indian leader to the country in some decades.
04:31
Clearly, Modi will have to walk a very fine, tricky line, because on one hand, New Delhi
04:39
doesn't want to alienate Moscow.
04:43
I mean, Modi was just in Russia last month, hugging Vladimir Putin.
04:48
And he also doesn't want to leave Kyiv out in the cold.
04:53
What can we expect from that visit?
04:56
Well, I agree with you.
04:57
India has definitely got a very delicate line to thread.
05:00
Obviously, India views Russia as one of its historical, all-weather, trustworthy partners.
05:06
We've been in times when the United States has supported Pakistan, and China has been
05:10
aggressive towards it.
05:11
So it definitely does not want to do anything to blow its relationship with Russia.
05:15
What I think Modi will try to do when he visits Kyiv will be, number one, try to assuage
05:20
Ukrainian concerns about India's enabling of sanctions violations.
05:24
There's a lot of concerns in Kyiv, for example, right now about how European oil is simply
05:28
being refined in India, and that Russian oil may be being refined in India and then being
05:31
sold to Europe.
05:32
And then the second thing would be to show that it is a contributor to a broader peace
05:36
settlement and is a potential leader in terms of a global south peace solution that might
05:41
be different from the solutions that China has proposed, which Ukraine sees as giving
05:45
up too much territory, or South Africa and Africa has proposed, which have been criticized
05:49
in a similar fashion.
05:51
Yeah, New Delhi actually says that he will, Modi will be looking to discuss a resolution
05:57
to the conflict.
05:58
One wonders if that's going to be a diplomatic resolution, a negotiated resolution, given
06:02
that Moscow says it's not willing to talk.
06:04
We'll see how things span out.
06:06
Samuel, thank you very much for that.
06:07
Samuel Rahmani joining us today.
Recommended
1:28
|
Up next
Putin accuses Ukraine of a ‘large-scale provocation’ as troops cross into Russia's Kursk region
FRANCE 24 English
8/8/2024
3:16
Ukraine denies involvement in Moscow strike, predicts more attacks
FRANCE 24 English
5/30/2023
3:07
BIG Breaking : Did U.S Help Zelensky In Moscow Blitz? 'Ukraine Received U.S Intel Despite...' |
Oneindia
3/11/2025
1:28
Fears of escalation grow in Ukraine's second largest city after Russian strikes
FRANCE 24 English
10/11/2022
2:31
Russian column purportedly ambushed in surprise Ukrainian incursion in Kursk region
FRANCE 24 English
8/9/2024
3:30
Ukraine’s BIGGEST Moscow Drone Blitz Timed to Sabotage OSCE Head’s Visit? Russia’s Explosive Claim
Oneindia
3/11/2025
4:26
Putin accuses West of stoking global war to destroy Russia in state-of-the-nation address
FRANCE 24 English
2/21/2023
1:19
Russia targets Ukraine with mass drone attacks
FRANCE 24 English
3/26/2025
1:30
Evacuations continue in Ukrainian city of Pokrovsk as Russia attacks Donetsk region
FRANCE 24 English
8/20/2024
0:15
MR1
Go Go Video
1/9/2022
0:22
thththth
Go Go Video
9/20/2020
0:19
GJGJGJ
Go Go Video
1/14/2019
1:10
John F. Kennedy Assassination 16mm Original - Driver shooting at Kennedy!
Jelani Trent
9/7/2015
9:54
'We have to do more with less' - international development challenges after USAID cuts
FRANCE 24 English
today
10:34
Stocamine, Alsace: 'Toxicity of chemical waste will not disappear, nobody knows how to deal with it'
FRANCE 24 English
today
2:09
Soaring temperatures prompt stay-home warnings across Europe
FRANCE 24 English
yesterday
2:52
Iranians flee to Turkey to seek safety amid Israeli strikes
FRANCE 24 English
yesterday
1:48
Bulgarians protest government's plan to adopt the euro
FRANCE 24 English
yesterday
5:13
Major heatwaves sweep Southern and Western Europe
FRANCE 24 English
yesterday
1:33
At least 71 killed in Israel's attack on Tehran's Evin prison
FRANCE 24 English
yesterday
1:29
France bans smoking in parks, beaches and bus stops
FRANCE 24 English
yesterday
1:39
Irish rap group Kneecap perform controversial Glastonbury set
FRANCE 24 English
yesterday
1:47
Tens of thousands defy Orban's ban to march in Budapest Pride
FRANCE 24 English
yesterday
2:05
US senators debate Trump's controversial spending bill
FRANCE 24 English
yesterday
17:41
Trump business for security deal 'effectively rewards Rwanda for invading, occupying, looting Congo'
FRANCE 24 English
2 days ago