Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
Help Rebuild Al Santillo's
One Bite Pizza Reviews
Follow
7/5/2024
El Presidente | Pizza Reviews
Category
🥇
Sports
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
It's wild in there, right?
00:18
Oh my god.
00:22
Alright, so we're at Santillo's Brick Oven Pizza since 1918.
00:28
We are in Elizabeth, New Jersey.
00:33
This place, hole in the wall, frankly we've tried to go here, what, five times?
00:37
Their hours are bananas.
00:39
Like right on the thing, it says four days a week.
00:41
I called it, he knew who we were, he says, oh, you're finally here.
00:44
A bunch of people knew.
00:45
He's like, you're lucky, I was going to close up.
00:47
He's like, this guy just, he's a one man show.
00:48
Get to 64 next time.
00:49
I don't know what that means.
00:50
They're telling me to get, they're telling me to get to 64.
00:51
I have no idea what that means.
00:52
It's like we just called in.
00:53
We didn't have to menu.
00:54
64.
00:55
They go about a year.
00:56
1964 style.
00:57
Yeah.
00:58
Our standard pie.
00:59
Yeah, but it has extra olive oil and parmesan.
01:00
We just do standard cheese.
01:01
Okay.
01:02
I did get, they had some garlic bread thing.
01:03
I'm going to try that.
01:04
Great job.
01:05
Thank you.
01:06
I appreciate it.
01:07
But this guy, he's like, you're catching up to some other pizza guy.
01:08
He made me take a picture of it.
01:09
It's like, I have it on my phone.
01:10
He's like, you're catching up.
01:11
I pay attention.
01:12
I guess I'm his rival.
01:34
One bite, every nose rules, big review.
01:36
Frank, you'd like this guy.
01:37
He knew all about it.
01:38
You know what else?
01:39
I liked everybody who knows me.
01:41
They're like, no, no charge.
01:42
This guy, $35 for two pies, straight.
01:45
I love it.
01:46
One bite, everyone knows the rules.
01:48
Santillo's, he said he just won an award recently.
01:51
Cooked well.
01:53
Cooked well.
01:55
One bite, big review, Frankie.
01:56
I'm expecting big things.
01:57
I love the guy in there.
01:58
He's just like this Italian guy, one man shop.
02:01
I was ready to leave.
02:02
He's like, you're so lucky.
02:03
I love him.
02:04
One bite.
02:05
Looks pretty good.
02:12
Interesting.
02:22
Good crisp.
02:23
Very good crisp.
02:24
One bite, everyone knows the rules.
02:30
Wow.
02:33
The crust was an electric bite.
02:41
Sauce doesn't have a tongue and a tang.
02:45
It's really cooked well.
02:46
How I like it, like well done.
02:48
I didn't ask for it well done.
02:49
It was cooked perfectly.
03:02
Yeah, I got it.
03:03
I got it.
03:11
I got it.
03:13
The crust is so good.
03:15
The crust is boosting it.
03:16
I take the normal bite.
03:17
I'm like, OK, I got where it is.
03:18
And I take the crust.
03:19
I like the crust so much it's changing my mind.
03:21
I'm going to 8-3.
03:23
8-3.
03:24
Solid, solid pizza.
03:28
I think 8-3 is the right score.
03:30
I think 8-3 is the right score.
03:31
I'm proud of that score.
03:32
I stick by it.
03:32
You almost forget this guy on Camry is such a character.
03:35
Ask him if he wants to be on there.
03:37
But this guy, this guy's the real deal.
03:38
If I was just voting on him, I'd give it like a 9-9.
03:41
Like, I love the guy.
03:42
8-3, solid score.
03:44
Very good pizza.
03:45
And another big, famous one off the list,
03:47
St. Hilo's Elizabeth Jersey.
03:49
It's a reveal.
03:51
How long you been doing it, one man shop?
03:53
Here's the deal.
03:54
My grandfather started this business in 1918.
03:57
My father started over here in 1957.
04:00
I've been working here since I was old enough to stand up.
04:04
I grew up in this house.
04:06
Still living here.
04:07
I'm 62.
04:09
And what's your hourly situation?
04:10
Whenever you feel like closing, you just close?
04:12
Right now, I'm open Thursday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday,
04:15
11 to 9.
04:16
But I pretty stay faithful to those hours.
04:18
But I built the business around my life.
04:21
That's what my father said.
04:23
The business is built around our life.
04:26
So if I got to close for something,
04:28
there's not another guy in the world
04:30
that could come over here.
04:30
And do you see what I do over here with this oven?
04:33
There's not another guy in the world
04:35
right now that could come and do what I do,
04:37
put these pies in here, turn them all around,
04:40
twist them all around.
04:42
An oven's for this?
04:43
Yes.
04:44
Everything that you see here, go take a close up in there.
04:48
Everything that you see here is all done by eye.
04:52
You've got to be taught by a master.
04:55
The people that taught me were masters.
04:56
See how you look at that?
04:58
Yeah.
04:58
You've got to know by eye how it's supposed to look.
05:00
It's part of the body.
05:01
I'm glad that you stopped in.
05:03
I'm proud to tell everybody.
05:04
But I'm the last of a dying breed.
05:07
If my father was supposed to be the last,
05:10
and then I says, he got sick when he was like 57.
05:13
He couldn't work no more.
05:15
Then it's like either I'm going to take this thing,
05:17
I know how hard it was, or else this good kind of pizza
05:20
is going to be extinct.
05:21
Who else, what other pizza places
05:23
do you respect in like New York, New Jersey area?
05:27
There's this pizza, and then there's everybody else.
05:30
But who's got a good pizza?
05:32
In this league, that's hard for me to say.
05:36
I like it.
05:36
Keep it tight for your home.
05:38
I'm telling you the truth.
05:40
You could bring me anybody's pizza,
05:41
and I could tell you what they're doing wrong.
05:44
Because this was handed down father to son
05:46
for three generations by the guys that
05:48
knew what they're really doing.
05:50
You understand?
05:51
This is a craft.
05:52
This is a trade.
05:53
This is not something that you're going to grab a guy off
05:55
the street, and in five minutes, they throw the guy in front
05:58
of the oven.
05:59
I'm sure everywhere you go, you see a lot of that.
06:01
Whoever they can get, and then the boss walks around,
06:04
he's the boss.
06:05
Now, this is the real Italian way,
06:08
how it was when they came here 100 years.
06:11
Like, squeeze that.
06:12
That's why I'm here.
06:13
Love it.
06:14
Because my father says, if you can't
06:16
make a good loaf of bread, what the hell good are you?
06:19
I'm going to take this really good aged Pecorino Romano
06:23
cheese that, once you buy it, you can't use it
06:26
the way they give it to you.
06:27
You've got to buy the good stuff from Italy.
06:30
But it's only aged so long.
06:32
You've got to age it longer.
06:33
The longer you age this, they can age this up to three years.
06:37
This is, listen, I'm going to tell you something.
06:39
Turn that off for a second.
06:40
Secrets, Tracy.
06:41
I'm going to give you a line.
06:43
When the real Italians come in here,
06:45
I'm going to teach you how to say it so you feel it.
06:48
You walk in, you see this stuff that I'm making.
06:51
This is the real fucking Guinea shit.
06:53
Give it to me.
06:54
I can say that?
06:55
Yeah.
06:56
I'm a Jewish guy.
06:57
I can still say it?
06:58
No.
06:58
This is the real Guinea shit.
06:59
Give it to me.
07:00
This is the real fucking Guinea shit.
07:02
This is real fucking Guinea shit.
07:03
Give it me.
07:04
That's how you say it, baby.
07:04
All right.
07:05
I'm doing that from now on.
07:06
This is the real fucking Guinea shit.
07:08
Give it to me.
07:09
Done.
07:09
I'm doing that from fucking now on.
07:11
Everywhere I go, it's Italian.
07:12
This is the real fucking Guinea shit.
07:15
Give it to me.
07:15
All right.
07:16
I like it.
07:18
You can say it.
07:19
You got to authorize it.
07:20
All right.
07:20
You hear that?
07:21
I put your blood in this, bro.
07:23
All right.
07:23
As long as I, listen, everyone heard.
07:25
I just got blessed to say it.
07:26
Give me the fucking Guinea shit.
07:28
100% Italian and it's like he had a book all old rules
07:33
Go through the book go through the book if he could find something that was harder or longer tougher way to do it
07:39
That's the way we're gonna
07:43
Give me the fucking guinea shit
07:47
You gotta say just like this
07:49
You got the real fucking guinea shit. Give it to me. You got the real fucking shit. Give it to me
07:59
You don't believe this shit when I was 13 years old you see that bread
08:03
Yeah, I used to put a hundred and sixty three loaves of bread in that oven
08:07
It was insane
08:08
And you know what?
08:09
My father taught me and then he left me here by myself to practice and try
08:14
Practice and try and if I screwed it up, I had to make it over explain it to the customer
08:19
That's that's how you get the real deal. I forget the fucking guinea shit
08:23
I was taught all the old Italian ways. No, what like little tiny shopkeeper. It was great
08:27
He went to it. You went to sit tires. You went this in Tanney's you went to Kalamazoo
08:32
It was wonderful when you went and saw what a happy Italian people if you know, it's like gave us like a little thrill
08:37
What do you think the New Haven pizza been there like Sally's Pepe is modern
08:41
I only want to have was Pepe's and I'm gonna tell you he makes a good pie
08:47
But I got issues with it was like a disgust with you off the record. I
08:52
Mean everyone has their opinions Sally's I like more than Pepe
08:57
Sally's I think you'd like Sally Sally's is more like all I could tell you is I never had Sally's but I said one of
09:03
My intelligences up there and I got two videos I could show you
09:09
Of a guy that worked for my dad doing so knows that went up there and investigated
09:15
That's what we do. We're Italians. We do our own dirty work. Oh
09:20
I love it. How's that one? Perfect. Well, you know these guys all these guys talk about pizza
09:27
I don't even know is anything about well, I don't know. I know about eating
09:31
That's pretty good for like a first time. I can't complain you got the job done. So this is like
09:38
That's kind of hot to be eaten. But you know, it's good. It's like all right electric golf, right?
09:44
You want me to give you a demonstration now when I clean the oven this is like the most ancient thing you see over here
09:51
I
09:53
Figured out a way to do all this
09:55
Well, my father taught me this you see this this right here
09:59
There's old pair of pants tied onto the stick, but I have people here
10:04
I don't know how many times I tried to teach them how to do this and they can't do it go like this
10:13
I
10:15
Must be like in good shape
10:19
Listen
10:20
This is like all the guys I had that work for me. They don't the gym rats
10:24
They used to love this because this is like, you know a workout for like a lot. Oh, yeah
10:31
It's like a nice worker. Well, you ever want to come down here for a couple of lessons?
10:36
I'd recommend it because
10:38
When you go out then I know I know like this guy's got intelligence
10:43
That you've seen from me a couple of pointers that you got to be looking for. Well, you're yeah, you're already a ton today
10:49
I appreciate it. Listen, I live and breathe this stuff. I appreciate it. You can tell it'll come through. I'm glad we came
10:55
Thank you very much
10:57
And anytime you want to come back, you let me know. I'll work something out for you.
11:01
Alright, I appreciate it man. That was great.
Recommended
3:35
|
Up next
Barstool Pizza Review - Jimmy's Apizza (Milford, CT) presented by Rhoback
One Bite Pizza Reviews
yesterday
6:37
Barstool Pizza Review - Nicky's Place (East Haven, CT)
One Bite Pizza Reviews
2 days ago
6:42
Barstool Pizza Review - Blue Square Pizza (Hopkinton, MA) presented by Netflix
One Bite Pizza Reviews
3 days ago
2:42
Barstool Pizza Review - Casa Bella (Hampden, MA)
One Bite Pizza Reviews
4 days ago
3:41
Barstool Pizza Review - Aurora's Pizzeria (Chicopee, MA) presented by Netflix
One Bite Pizza Reviews
7/2/2025
4:19
Barstool Pizza Review - Kim's Uncle Pizza (Westmont, IL) presented by BODYARMOR
One Bite Pizza Reviews
7/1/2025
3:11
Barstool Pizza Review - Fox's on Wolf (Mokena, IL) presented by Kraken
One Bite Pizza Reviews
6/30/2025
12:57
Barstool Pizza Review - Pizza Di Farfalla (New Lenox, IL)
One Bite Pizza Reviews
6/26/2025
1:52
Barstool Pizza Review - Chicago's Pizza (Chicago, IL) presented by Rhoback
One Bite Pizza Reviews
6/26/2025
3:03
Barstool Pizza Review - Dino's Italian Pizza (Chicago, IL)
One Bite Pizza Reviews
6/23/2025
2:54
Barstool Pizza Review - La Pizza Nostra (Miami, FL) presented by Kraken
One Bite Pizza Reviews
6/19/2025
5:57
Barstool Pizza Review - Mamale Cafe (Bay Harbor Islands, FL)
One Bite Pizza Reviews
6/18/2025
3:15
Barstool Pizza Review - Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza (Miami, FL) presented by Rhoback
One Bite Pizza Reviews
6/17/2025
10:34
Barstool Pizza Review - Marc's Artisanal Pizzeria (Miami Beach, FL)
One Bite Pizza Reviews
6/16/2025
2:34
Barstool Pizza Review - Petralunga (North Bay Village, FL)
One Bite Pizza Reviews
6/12/2025
2:39
Barstool Pizza Review - Bar Bucce (Miami, FL)
One Bite Pizza Reviews
6/10/2025
2:32
Barstool Pizza Review - Flour Pizzeria & Cafe (Los Angeles, CA)
One Bite Pizza Reviews
6/9/2025
3:08
Barstool Pizza Review - Acre Pizza (Sebastopol, CA)
One Bite Pizza Reviews
6/5/2025
3:45
Barstool Pizza Review - Lambretta Pizzeria (Toronto, ON)
One Bite Pizza Reviews
6/4/2025
3:13
Barstool Pizza Review - Mac’s Pizza (Toronto, ON)
One Bite Pizza Reviews
6/3/2025
6:05
Barstool Pizza Review - Terrazza (Toronto, ON)
One Bite Pizza Reviews
6/2/2025
6:35
Barstool Pizza Review - Pizzeria Rustico (Boston, MA) Bonus Re-Review
One Bite Pizza Reviews
5/29/2025
2:13
Barstool Pizza Review - Braintree Brewhouse (Braintree, MA)
One Bite Pizza Reviews
5/28/2025
4:15
Barstool Pizza Review - Mike & Lenny's Bar Pizza (Walpole, MA)
One Bite Pizza Reviews
5/28/2025
4:09
Barstool Pizza Review - Laced Pizza & Pub (Foxborough, MA) presented by Kraken
One Bite Pizza Reviews
5/24/2025