Skip to playerSkip to main contentSkip to footer
  • 2 days ago
During Tuesday's debate on the Senate floor, Sen. John Kennedy (R-LA) introduced an amendment regarding teacher deductibles.
Transcript
00:00is not agreed to. The point of order is sustained and the amendment fails.
00:05Mr. President, I call up amendment number 2775 on behalf of Senator Kennedy and
00:11ask that it be reported by number. The clerk will report.
00:15Senator from South Dakota, Mr. Thune, proposes an amendment number 2775 for Mr. Kennedy to
00:22amendment number 2360. Mr. President, Senator from Louisiana. Mr. President, as you know,
00:34as we all know, many of our teachers in America come out of pocket to pay for school supplies.
00:46In 2002, what, 23 years ago, we allowed teachers to deduct $250 when they come out of pocket.
01:01My amendment would raise that deduction from $250 to $600. Teachers right now spend an average
01:13of $650 out of their own pocket. So we would allow them to deduct that instead of the amount
01:20we set in 2002. And I ask a favorable consideration, Mr. President, of my amendment. This will just
01:33let teachers break even for coming out of pocket.
01:36Mr. President.
01:38Senator from Oregon.
01:41I wouldn't have much dispute of subsidizing the out-of-pocket expenses of our public school
01:47teachers. When I was a child, my dad, the mechanic, said, son, because we're so fortunate to live
01:54in America, if you go through the doors of that public school and you study hard, you can
01:58do just about anything. Although I'm certainly a lifetime fan of public education. But in addition
02:06to expanding this for public school teachers, it has a new policy of expanding it to homeschool
02:11teachers. Well, that's quite a new policy to put into a reconciliation bill that really should
02:17be in the education committee and debated and bring people to bear. I'm not immediately struck
02:23that that's a great idea. But certainly, as a new policy, it should go through committee. And for that reason,
02:32I think I'll do a point of order on this particular amendment.
02:38Mr. President, I raise a point of order that the amendment violates Section 4106 of the Fiscal
02:45Year 2018 Budget Resolution, House Con Res 71 of the 150th Congress, known as the Senate Pay-As-You-Go
02:56Go. Point of order.
03:02Mr. President.
03:03The senator from Louisiana.
03:04Do I have any time left, Mr. President?
03:08No.
03:09Mr. President, pursuant to Section 904 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, and on behalf of all of the teachers in
03:20America, and the waiver provisions of applicable budget resolutions, I move on behalf of all of the teachers in
03:29America to waive all applicable sections of that act and applicable budget resolutions for purposes of the
03:37pending amendment. And once again, on behalf of our teachers, I ask for the yays and nays.
03:43Is there a sufficient second? There appears to be. The clerk will call the roll.
03:52Ms. Alsobrooks. Ms. Baldwin.
04:08Mr. Banks.
04:12Mr. Barrasso.
04:17Mr. Bennett.
04:23This is Blackburn.
04:37Mr. Blumenthal.
04:41Mr. Blumenthal.
04:48Ms. Blunt Rochester.
04:50Mr. Booker.
04:52Mr. Bozeman.
04:56Mrs. Britt.
04:57Mr. Bud.
05:01Yes.
05:22Ms. Cantwell.
05:52Ms. Capito, Mr. Cassidy, Ms. Collins, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons.
06:22Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons.
06:52Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Coons, Mr. Co
07:22Mrs. Fisher, Mr. Gallego, Mrs. Gillibrand, Mr. Graham, Mr. Grassley, Mr. Hagerty, Ms.
07:44Hassan, Mr. Hawley, Mr. Heinrich, Mr. Hickenlooper, Ms. Hirono, Mr. Hoven, Mr. Husted,
08:06Mrs. Hyde-Smith, Mr. Johnson, Mr. Justice,
08:36Mr. Cain, Mr. Kelly, Mr. Kennedy, Mr. Kim, Mr. King, Ms. Klobuchar, Mr. Lankford,
08:49Mr. Lee, Mr. Lujan, Ms. Lummis, Mr. Markey, Mr. Markey,
09:05Mr. Marshall, Mr. McConnell, Mr. McCormick, Mr. Merkley,
09:25Mr. Murray, Mrs. Moody, Mr. Moran, Mr. Moreno, Mr. Mullen,
09:30Ms. Murkowski, Mr. Murphy, Mrs. Murray, Mr. Ossoff, Mr. Padilla,
09:36Mr. Paul, Mr. Peters, Mr. Reed, Mr. Ricketts, Mr. Risch, Ms. Rosen, Mr. Rounds,
09:59Mr. Sanders, Mr. Schott, Mr. Schott, Mr. Schiff, Mr. Schmitt, Mr. Schmitt,
10:22Mr. Schumer, Mr. Schott, Mr. Schott of Florida, Mr.
10:39Schott, Mr. Schott, Mr. Schott of South Carolina,
10:41Mrs. Shaheen, Mr. Sheehy, Ms. Slotkin, Ms. Smith, Mr. Sullivan, Mr. Thune, Mr. Tillis,
11:08Mr. Tuberville, Mr. Van Hollen, Mr. Warner, Mr. Warnock, Ms. Warren, Mr. Welch, Mr. Whitehouse,
11:15Mr. Wicker, Mr. Wyden, Mr. Young.
11:38Mr. Whitehouse, Mr. ClevelandCR support
11:40Mr. Tienel, Mr. immoral at the dusk
11:44Mr. Snyel, Mr. Jamesville, Mr. Adam
11:49Mr.illy, Mr.� Gray with his friend
11:53Mr. Will��, Mr. Bongyia, Mr. Thibyl, Mr. K.
12:06Senators voting in the affirmative, Banks, Barrasso, Blackburn, Bud, Cassidy, Collins,
12:19Cornyn, Kramer, Curtis, Danes, Ernst, Fisher, Graham, Hoven, Husted, Hydesmith, Johnson,
12:28Kennedy, Lankford, Lee, McCormick, Moody, Moreno, Mullen, Hall, Ricketts, Rounds, Scott of
12:38Florida, Sheehy, Thune, Tillis, Tuberville, Wicker.
12:47Mr. Cotton, Aye.
12:51Mr. Bozeman, Aye.
13:09Senators voting in the negative.
13:12Also Brooks, Baldwin, Bennett, Blunt Rochester, Booker, Durbin, Gallego, Gillibrand,
13:21Hassan, Heinrich, Hickenlooper, Hirono, Kelly, Kim, Klobuchar, Merkley, Murray,
13:30Ossoff, Padilla, Peters, Reed, Rosen, Sanders, Schiff, Schumer, Slotkin, Smith,
13:40Warren, Welch, Wyden.
13:45Mr. Kane, No.
14:00Ms. Lummis, Ms. Lummis, No.
14:04Mr. Warnock, Mr. Warnock, No.
14:23Mr. Warnock, No.
14:26Mr. Warnock, No.
14:33Mr. Murphy, Mr. Murphy, No.
14:38Mr. Lujan, Mr. Lujan, No.
14:42Mr. Scott, Mr. Scott of South Carolina, Aye.
14:46Aye.
15:04Miss Lummis.
15:05Miss Lummis.
15:08Aye.
15:08Mrs. Capito.
15:09Mrs. Capito.
15:12Aye.
15:14Mrs. Brett.
15:14Mrs. Brett.
15:15Aye.
15:16Mr.
15:22Mr. Schmidt.
15:23Mr. Schmidt.
15:25Aye.
15:31Mr. King.
15:32Mr. King.
15:33Aye.
15:42Ms. Cortez Masto.
15:43Ms. Cortez Masto.
15:45No.
15:45Aye.
15:46Mr. Hagerty.
15:47Mr. Hagerty.
15:48Mr. Hagerty.
15:49Aye.
15:50Mr. Hagerty.
15:51Aye.
15:52Ms. Cantwell.
15:53Ms. Cantwell.
15:54No.
15:55Mr. Young.
15:55Mr. Young.
15:56Aye.
15:57Mr. Young.
15:58Mr. Young.
16:04Mr. Young.
16:05Mr. Young.
16:05Aye.
16:19Mr. Krapo.
16:20Mr. Krapo.
16:20Aye.
16:20Mr. Risch.
16:21Mr. Risch, Mr. Risch, aye.
16:51Mrs. Shaheen, Mrs. Shaheen, no.
17:10Mr. Whitehouse, Mr. Whitehouse, no.
17:18Mr. Blumenthal, no.
17:24Mr. Van Hollen, no.
17:35Mr. Fetterman, Mr. Fetterman, no.
17:48Mr. Kearns, Mr. Brown, no.
17:54Mr. Brown, no.
17:57Mr. Brown, no.
18:14Mr. Koons. Mr. Koons, no. Mr. Markey, Mr. Markey, no. Mr. Warner, Mr. Warner, no. Mr. Schatz,
18:33Mr. Schatz, no. Mr. Hawley, Mr. Hawley, aye.
19:03Mr. McConnell, Mr. McConnell, aye.
19:33Mr. Marshall, Mr. Marshall, aye.
19:45Mr. Grassley, Mr. Grassley, aye.
20:15Mr. Cruz, Mr. Cruz, aye.
20:40Ms. Murkowski, Ms. Murkowski, aye.
21:05Mr. Justice, Mr. Justice, aye.
21:25Mr. Justice, aye.
21:26Mr. Justice, aye.
21:27Mr. Justice, aye.
21:28Mr. Justice, aye.
21:29Mr. Justice, aye.
21:30Mr. Justice, aye.
21:31Mr. Justice, aye.
21:32Mr. Justice, aye.
21:33Mr. Justice, aye.
21:34Mr. Justice, aye.
21:35Mr. Justice, aye.
21:36Mr. Justice, aye.
21:37Mr. Justice, aye.
21:38Mr. Justice, aye.
21:39Mr. Justice, aye.
21:40Mr. Justice, aye.
21:41Mr. Justice, aye.
21:42Mr. Justice, aye.
21:43Mr. Justice, aye.
21:44Mr. Justice, aye.
21:45Mr. Justice, aye.
21:46Mr. Justice, aye.
21:47Mr. Justice, aye.
21:48Mr. Justice, aye.
21:49Mr. Justice, aye.
21:50Mr. Justice, aye.
21:51Mr. Justice, aye.
21:52Mr. Justice, aye.
23:25Mr. Sullivan, Mr. Sullivan, aye.
26:59Mr. Moran.
27:15Aye.
27:17Aye.

Recommended