Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
'Men And Woman Are Different, Right?': Katie Britt Grills 23andMe CEO About Gender Identity Policy
Forbes Breaking News
Follow
6/11/2025
At today's Senate Judiciary Committee hearing, Sen. Katie Britt (R-AL) questioned interim 23andMe CEO Joseph Selsavage.
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
And the senator's question, so would you commit today to the same privacy standards that you have
00:05
demanding those of the company that purchases 23andMe? Do not sell unless they keep the same
00:12
privacy standards that you have? Yes, that is a requirement, you know, basically of any of the
00:17
two buyers and they have put that in their asset purchase agreement. Excellent. Now tell me what
00:21
all do you test for? You know, 23andMe tests for, you know, basically a significant level of,
00:29
you know, genetic traits, ancestry, and health conditions. We actually, as part of our process,
00:35
test over 600,000 variants through our testing process. Okay, so you're able to tell somebody
00:42
maybe they can, it's predictability of potential disease and other things? And while we can't
00:48
definitively say that that person will get the disease, we can highlight risk and basically
00:53
when people are at higher risk for certain diseases. And so do you test for sex?
00:59
You know, as part of our testing, we do identify if the DNA showed that the,
01:06
if the individual is male or female. And male is XY chromosome?
01:12
That is correct. And female XX? Correct.
01:15
On your database though, you go into saying that if people self-identify of another gender,
01:22
that you will attempt to give them a prognosis of the gender that they identify with versus the gender
01:31
that they test for? Senator, I'm not aware of that. Oh yeah, you do. So it says,
01:40
we understand that sex is not always binary and the words male and female may not accurately reflect an
01:46
individual's identity. We also recognize that being categorized by birth sex may be an uncomfortable
01:52
or triggering experience to some and we do not mean to delegitimize anyone's gender identity or
01:57
expression. We use your self-reported sex to customize your health and trait reports. For example, genetic
02:05
risk and what they may mean differ between men and women. So men and women are different, right? I mean,
02:12
you say that here. We just talked about the genetic testing. But then you go on to say,
02:17
if you tell us you're female, your reports will contain information that is relevant to genetic
02:21
females XX. If you tell us you're male, your reports will contain information that is relevant to genetic
02:27
males XY. Additionally, there are some sex-specific reports that are available on individual selected
02:34
profile sex, such as male hair loss or bald spot. That's because either we're not able to build out an
02:41
acceptable model for both genders or because the trait is actually sex-specific. And so,
02:49
I guess I'm wondering, did you test, like if it's a genetic female that identified to you as a male,
02:58
would you test them for male pattern baldness? Senator, you know, as you mentioned,
03:06
we actually do, the customer does report to us, you know, what they believe their sex is. And we test
03:13
against that as well as what we found in the DNA as testing as well. I think probably the DNA is what's
03:20
best for predicting actual future disease or harm or what may come good or bad for the individual.
03:29
On that note, you have about 15 million customers, is that right? That's correct. Okay. Of that, how many
03:37
are kids? How many are kids? Senator, I don't know that number. So you don't know, from what I read on
03:46
your website, obviously parents can agree to have their child's DNA tested. Is that correct? That is
03:53
correct. So you don't know, of the 15 million people, you don't know how many of those profiles
03:58
are under 18? I don't have that information with me today, but I'd be happy to take that back. Do you
04:02
have a guess? I don't have a reasonable guess, Senator. Sir, I think we have to be vigilant when
04:10
it comes to children and their DNA. We've talked today about all of the potential risks that could occur
04:17
from privacy to security risk, obviously blackmail amongst a number of things. Would you commit to
04:25
me today that in the cell you will sell no child's DNA under the age of 18, that you will delete that
04:31
account? Congressman or Senator, I will take that back and we'll review that. I think you absolutely
04:37
should. And on that note, when it comes to bankruptcy, Professor, tell me, you know, when you look at a
04:43
privacy ombudsman in this space, when you're looking at minors, children, what type of protection
04:53
is currently in place? And what do we need to be doing as Congress? And actually, I'd like to open
04:58
this up to everybody to ensure that children are protected in this space. My understanding is that
05:04
there are specific laws protecting children information. I'm not an expert on those laws,
05:09
but whatever laws exist outside of bankruptcy are enforced inside of bankruptcy as well.
05:13
Do you all have another? I'd love your thoughts. You know, for human subjects research, we have
05:18
special rules for children population, and that might be a place to look for some comparisons.
05:23
Do you have anything, Mr. Klein? Well, as a father, I can say that I think we all
05:28
struggle with how much of our children's data or how much of our children's lives to digitize. And so there's
05:34
also a degree of parental responsibility. And when it comes to health, these are very tough choices
05:38
sometimes for all of us. Absolutely. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Padilla.
05:45
Thank you. Now, colleagues, the witnesses today have explained that our bank
Recommended
0:46
|
Up next
Tesla’s Co-Founder Calls Out Elon Musk
Benzinga
yesterday
1:30
8.8 Magnitude Earthquake Strikes Off Russia's Far East, Triggers Tsunami Alerts in Japan
TIME
yesterday
0:53
Spotify Slides After Weak Results Despite Surging YTD Gains
Benzinga
yesterday
1:22
Nancy Pelosi Backs Proposal To Ban 'Congressional Stock Trading' Named After Her — 'Proud To Support It, No Matter What They Decide To Name It'
Benzinga
today
2:14
Federal Reserve Leaves Interest Rates Unchanged as Trump Demands Cuts
TIME
yesterday
1:26
Jerome Powell Asked If Trump's 'Conduct' Could Impact The Federal Reserve's Independence
Forbes Breaking News
today
8:18
Josh Hawley Goes Absolutely Nuclear On 23andMe CEO, Says He Should Be Sued Into Oblivion
Forbes Breaking News
6/11/2025
1:13
Trump: Veterans Are Sitting 'On The Sidewalk In Front Of A Fancy Hotel & The Illegals Are Coming In'
Forbes Breaking News
today
6:06
Katie Britt Slams Dems For Focusing On Kilmar Abrego Garcia: Let’s Talk About ‘An Actual Maryland Resident’
Forbes Breaking News
5/9/2025
5:45
Katie Britt Stunned To Learn How Many Cartel Gang Members Are Currently Inside The United States
Forbes Breaking News
7/3/2025
1:41
Katie Britt Reacts To Democrats Walking Out Of Senate Judiciary Hearing On Emil Bove's Nomination
Forbes Breaking News
7/17/2025
5:30
'You Seem A Bit Naive': Marsha Blackburn Confronts 23andMe CEO Over China's Threat To DNA Data
Forbes Breaking News
6/11/2025
6:38
Ashley Moody: 'We Cannot Overstate The Threat To This Nation And To People Individually'
Forbes Breaking News
6/16/2025
5:38
'So I Didn't Think I'd Ever Say This In This Room...': Dick Durbin Has Tough Grilling Of 23andMe CEO
Forbes Breaking News
6/13/2025
5:51
Katie Britt Asks Witness About Regulating Crypto While Avoiding Rules 'That Quickly Become Outdated'
Forbes Breaking News
7/10/2025
5:43
Katie Britt Questions Lori Chavez-DeRemer About 'America At Work' Initiative
Forbes Breaking News
5/23/2025
3:03
'Fix The Train': Katie Britt Gets A Laugh Out Of Senate During Bill Discussion
Forbes Breaking News
7/11/2025
5:53
Josh Hawley Questions DHS Sec. Kristi Noem About Response To Deadly Storm In St. Louis, Missouri
Forbes Breaking News
5/21/2025
5:48
'How Long Is The Backlog Right Now?': Amy Klobuchar Grills 23andMe CEO About Data Deletion Requests
Forbes Breaking News
6/12/2025
5:04
Katie Britt Tells Jerome Powell How Affordable Child Care Can Strengthen U.S. Workforce
Forbes Breaking News
7/2/2025
5:37
Katie Britt Asks NIH Dir. Jay Bhattacharya Point Blank If He Wants To Give Up On Medical Research
Forbes Breaking News
6/11/2025
6:11
Katie Britt Asks AG Pam Bondi About Removing Backlog In The Asylum Program
Forbes Breaking News
6/25/2025
6:38
''Why Are Our Kids Anxious?': RFK Jr Discusses Social Media's Effect On Young People With Katie Britt Are Our Kids Anxious_'_ RFK Jr Discusses Social Media's Effect On Young People With Katie Britt
Forbes Breaking News
5/22/2025
5:45
Katie Britt Asks Secretary Linda McMahon About Preventing Students From Being 'Trapped' In Failing Schools
Forbes Breaking News
6/4/2025
7:02
Katie Britt Praises DHS Sec. Kristi Noem For Trump Admin. Deportation Efforts_ ‘I Am Incredibly Proud’
Forbes Breaking News
5/9/2025