Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
'Is That An Accurate Quote?': Jon Ossoff Grills FDA Commissioner About Reported Layoffs
Forbes Breaking News
Follow
5/27/2025
During a Senate Appropriations Committee hearing on Thursday, Sen. Jon Ossoff (D-GA) spoke about reported layoffs at the FDA.
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and Dr. Macari, good to see you.
00:03
Good to see you.
00:03
Thank you for joining us.
00:05
I was pleased to see that the secretary has made the safety of infant formula a priority for the department.
00:13
Is that correct?
00:14
That's right, and the FDA will be convening the world experts on infant formula June 4th,
00:21
and we're going to be having a robust discussion because parents want infant formula options
00:26
with a better supply chain and without added sugar and seed oils.
00:30
Did you see a recent Consumer Reports study which found that of 41 tested infant formulas,
00:38
more than 30 were found to have potentially dangerous levels of lead?
00:42
Yeah, heavy metals in infant formula is something that's getting a lot of attention, as it should,
00:47
and so that is part of Operation Stork Speed to take a hard look at that,
00:51
and it is one of the priorities of our infant formula roundtable at the FDA on June 4th.
00:56
And it's the human foods division of your agency responsible for infant formula safety,
01:03
at least in large part, yes?
01:05
Yes.
01:07
Trying to make sure I understand some of the relevant personnel decisions,
01:11
given the concern that families in Georgia have about the safety of infant formula,
01:17
the safety of the food supply. James Jones, the deputy commissioner for human foods,
01:23
submitted a resignation letter February 17th, included the quotes, quote,
01:29
the indiscriminate firing of 89 staff in the human foods program is beyond short-sighted.
01:35
The foods program staff at FDA is the envy of the world in its technical, professional,
01:39
and ethical standards. It goes on, the employees fired this past weekend are the most recent hires
01:44
and generally come to federal service with the most recent education and represent the future of the agency.
01:48
They included staff with highly technical expertise in nutrition, infant formula, food safety response,
01:54
and even 10 chemical safety staff hired to review potentially unsafe ingredients in our food supply.
02:00
That was February 17th. You were asked on April 17th whether any of the personnel reductions
02:09
had included personnel responsible for food safety or infant formula safety.
02:14
You said, quote, there were no cuts to scientists or reviewers or inspectors, absolutely none.
02:20
You were asked on April 23rd on CNN and said, quote, again,
02:24
there were no cuts to scientists or inspectors.
02:27
But then just two days later, an HHS spokesperson confirmed that, in fact, scientists had been fired
02:38
and that you were scrambling to rehire them.
02:42
Is that... Did you, in fact, say on April 23rd there were no cuts to scientists or inspectors?
02:49
Just before we get into the details, is that an accurate quote?
02:51
No scientific reviewer was cut as part of the reduction in force.
02:55
But you said there were no cuts to scientists or inspectors. Didn't you say that?
02:58
My understanding was that there were no cuts to the scientific staff,
03:03
but specifically the scientific reviewers is what I was referring to.
03:06
But you said there were... I mean, I've just...
03:08
Jim Jones is an economist.
03:08
It's a very straightforward question.
03:09
You said there were no cuts to scientists or inspectors, correct?
03:12
Scientific reviewers is what I was referring to.
03:15
That's the vast majority of scientists there. Jim Jones is an economist.
03:18
And then five days before you had said there were no cuts to scientists.
03:22
You said that, right?
03:22
I was referring to scientific reviewers. There are...
03:25
But scientists had been fired, correct?
03:27
There have been a couple... There have been research scientists in some labs that have been doing some research.
03:33
Some of that research is good. Some of it is not good.
03:36
And so there have been no cuts to scientific reviewers.
03:38
And in fact, scientists who study the safety of infant formula had been fired, correct?
03:45
I'm not aware of any scientist who studies infant formula.
03:49
Well, here's the reporting in the New York Times.
03:53
It says the HHS spokesman said those employees called back had been inadvertently fired.
03:59
And the decision to rehire specialists on outbreaks of food-related illnesses
04:03
and those who study the safety of products like infant formula...
04:07
So is this reporting accurate?
04:09
Had, in fact, scientists who study outbreaks of food-related illnesses and the safety of infant formula been fired?
04:17
The reason it's not accurate, Senator, is that people were not fired.
04:21
They were scheduled for the reduction in force.
04:23
And when I...
04:24
That was before I got there.
04:25
When I got there, we did an assessment.
04:26
And so some of those individuals out of the 19,000 were restored.
04:31
Jim Jones was an economist, and he was upset about the doge cuts, so he self-doged.
04:37
I didn't...
04:38
He was not fired.
04:39
I wish he would have stayed, but he chose to leave.
04:41
Have all scientists responsible for food safety and infant formula safety been rehired or reinstated?
04:49
Look, we have not reduced in force the scientific review staff.
04:55
I know where you're going with this.
04:57
We're not allowed to let go a single person.
04:57
I'm trying to get clarity on your statement.
04:59
You said there were no cuts to scientists, and then the HHS spokesperson said,
05:05
actually, there were cuts to scientists, and now we're trying to rehire them.
05:08
I mean, so it gives the impression you're not sure about the personnel actions ongoing in your own agency,
05:14
and that's...
05:14
Again, no one was cut.
05:15
...indication from your testimony here again today.
05:17
No one was cut in the reduction of force.
05:19
They were scheduled for the reduction in the future.
05:23
And down the road, it has not happened yet.
05:25
So the people scheduled to be cut, we did a review and found some research scientists.
05:31
When I made those statements, it was very specific.
05:33
I was very clear.
05:34
We're talking about scientific reviewers, because the trains have to run on time.
05:38
And if you're concerned about backlogging labs...
05:39
My time is up, my time is up, but you were very specific.
05:42
You said there were no cuts to scientists, and then five days later, there were no cuts to scientists.
05:48
Those are your direct quotes.
05:50
There were no cuts to scientists, but there were cuts to scientists.
05:53
No, there were no cuts to scientists, because people were scheduled for the reduction in force in the future,
05:59
and the people scheduled were re-evaluated, and we restored a couple of research scientists.
06:06
And I was referring not only to them, but to...
06:08
How many?
06:09
...to the scientific reviewers.
06:11
How many scientists responsible for preventing outbreaks of food-related illnesses
06:17
and the safety of infant formula have been restored or reinstated?
06:20
There were no scientists that were in charge of preventing outbreaks that were part of...
06:26
I didn't say in charge.
06:27
But, I mean, this is the problem in government.
06:29
Somebody has a fancy-sounding name like Infant Formula Safety, and no one can ever touch them,
06:34
even if they're not doing their job.
06:36
Okay, I'll tell you what.
06:36
How about this?
06:37
It's redundant.
06:37
I'll send you, so that you can get accurate information to the committee,
06:42
I'll send you some very detailed questions about this, and you'll respond in full, yes?
06:48
Yes, just keep in mind, the agency was half its size in 2007.
06:52
We didn't have outbreaks and rampages and food outbreaks.
06:55
But we had a huge infant formula safety crisis in this country just a few years ago.
06:59
Do you recall that?
06:59
That was because of several problems, including...
07:02
So you will respond in full to the questions that I send you.
07:05
I'm always happy to respond in full to you, Senator.
07:06
Thank you so much, Dr. McCarty.
Recommended
5:33
|
Up next
'Are You Still Planning To Close That Office?': Jon Ossoff Presses Burgum About Water Safety Office
Forbes Breaking News
5/23/2025
6:12
Jon Ossoff Delivers Speech Ahead of Senate Runoff Race
Tvideo
11/9/2020
5:40
‘When Will We Have An Answer?’: Jon Ossoff Presses Chris Wright For Update On Frozen Energy Grid Grants
Forbes Breaking News
5/22/2025
5:12
'A Disservice To The Airmen': Jon Ossoff Laments Air Force's 'Neglect' Of Facilities And Systems
Forbes Breaking News
6/17/2025
5:43
‘Irreversible Damage Has Already Been Done’: Jon Ossoff Decries Funding Cuts To Biomedical Research
Forbes Breaking News
5/2/2025
6:19
Dan Sullivan Explodes At Dem Colleagues, Accuses Ex-Senator Jon Tester Of 'Screwing Veterans'
Forbes Breaking News
5/7/2025
5:41
'I Don't Want To Hear About The Biden Administration!': Jon Ossoff Gets Fed Up With Russell Vought
Forbes Breaking News
5 days ago
5:52
'Please Take Notes On This': Joni Ernst Confronts Air Force Leaders Over Delay In Key Project
Forbes Breaking News
5/28/2025
5:48
The life of Jon Ossoff
Brut America
3/25/2025
13:10
Richard Blumenthal Blocks VA Nom, Accuses VA Sec. Of Blocking Information On Layoffs, Contract Cancellations
Forbes Breaking News
5/14/2025
17:47
John Cornyn Previews Hearing On Alleged 'Conspiracy To Hide' Biden's 'Cognitive Decline'
Forbes Breaking News
6/17/2025
1:00
John Thune Asked About Senate GOP's Plan For Ed Martin After Thom Tillis Says He'll Oppose Him
Forbes Breaking News
5/7/2025
10:27
Chris Coons Presses HUD Secretary Turner On Major Proposed Cuts To Funding And Staffing
Forbes Breaking News
6/17/2025
4:59
'Why Did You Cancel The Program?: Jon Ossoff Grills Ag Sec. Rollins On Ending Georgia Food Program
Forbes Breaking News
5/6/2025
8:31
'No, You're Here To Answer My Questions': Patty Murray Does Not Let Up On Trump's FDA Commissioner
Forbes Breaking News
5/27/2025
5:35
John Barrasso Accuses Biden Of 'Weaponizing' IRS, Asks Nominee How To Restore Agency's 'Credibility'
Forbes Breaking News
6/2/2025
2:35
'What Is That $900 Million For Specifically?': Jon Ossoff Grills Trump Official Over MilCon Budget
Forbes Breaking News
6/17/2025
1:48
John Kennedy Rails Against Nationwide Injunctions During Trump Admin Vs. Biden Admin
Forbes Breaking News
5/12/2025
10:17
'These Are Your Words': Richard Blumenthal Reads Quotes From VA Sec. About Firing Staff To His Face
Forbes Breaking News
5/7/2025
4:42
Ron Johnson To Nominee After Grilling From Dems: 'Why Do You Think They're Trying To Smear You?'
Forbes Breaking News
5/5/2025
10:04
John Kennedy Is Absolutely Stunned By Energy Secretary's Claims About Last-Minute Biden-Era Loans
Forbes Breaking News
5/22/2025
5:38
Tim Scott To RFK Jr.: 'I Do Not Want Some Folks To Think That All Things Racial Are Somehow DEI'
Forbes Breaking News
5/19/2025
13:26
Josh Hawley Claims Damning Coast Guard Report Was 'Deliberately' Concealed From Congress
Forbes Breaking News
12/12/2023
4:55
'Did One Person Get Held Accountable?': Markwayne Mullin Fires Back At Dems During Hegseth Hearing
Forbes Breaking News
6/18/2025
8:39
'I Hope I'm Wrong': Chris Coons Presses Scott Bessent Over Sanctions Policy Towards Russia
Forbes Breaking News
6/13/2025