Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com
Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English
Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00We can speak now to a politician for the Green Party Europe Ecology.
00:03He's also current director and spokesman of the NGO Generation Futur
00:08and member of the European Board of the Pesticide Action Network.
00:12Mr. François Villered, thanks so much for your time in joining us here on France 24.
00:16Can I start simply by asking you, these particular pesticides
00:20currently being debated by the French Parliament,
00:23what exactly are they, when were they banned and how dangerous are they?
00:26Yes, France banned all neonicotinoids back in 2018.
00:32In Europe, not all of them are banned, so that's where the problem lies.
00:37France considered that acetamiprid, for example, is dangerous for bees,
00:43all types of bees, including wild bees, which the European authorities don't share.
00:50Is that not ultimately the problem here, is that pesticides cross borders?
00:55I mean, they don't just stop along or, you know, lines of borders.
01:00And the fact is that if France bans them, but Germany doesn't, for example,
01:03it is unfair on the farmers.
01:07Yes, but, you know, when an active substance is authorised in Europe,
01:11not every country is obliged to use it.
01:14There are huge differences in terms of number of pesticides authorised.
01:17For example, France is the country in Europe where that has the largest number of chemical pesticides allowed.
01:26So, but there are differences between countries.
01:29It's like that.
01:30The problem is a problem, an economical problem, in fact,
01:34because we spotted that the price paid to beetroot growers is lower in France compared to Germany or Belgium.
01:43So, you know, you could have an increase of about 10 percent just to have the same price as the price paid in Germany,
01:52for example, and they wouldn't need any other insecticide as acetamiprid.
01:57So, you know, it's not the environment that can be, you know, harmed to have more yield.
02:04There are other means to increase the income of farmers, as you know,
02:09just aligning the price paid to French farmers compared to the Belgium or Dutch or German farmers.
02:15OK, so that answers one of the farmers' demands.
02:18But they also say that they actually wouldn't, you know,
02:21it's putting the sovereignty of French produce into danger.
02:24What do you say to that?
02:25Oh, well, you know, France is exporting about half of its sugar
02:31because we produce so much beetroots, sugar beetroots,
02:36that we export 50 percent, about 50 percent of our own production.
02:39So it's not a matter of sovereignty at all, you know.
02:43This is not a good argument.
02:46Are there other pesticides then?
02:49You say France is one of the highest use of pesticides.
02:51I mean, is there a movement here in France to examine that?
02:54I mean, surely are all pesticides bad or are some a necessary evil?
03:00Some are worse than others, clearly.
03:03And neonicotinoids are clearly very highly toxic compounds.
03:07And that's why France banned all of them back in 2018.
03:10It was not just, you know, an idea like that on the table,
03:15because there are many, many studies, scientific studies published every year.
03:20We spotted about 24 of them last two years that shows that, for example,
03:24acetaminoprid is highly toxic.
03:26There is a lack of studies also concerning the toxicity,
03:32neurotoxicity of development for the fetus in young kids.
03:37So it's a serious matter.
03:41All neonicotinoids should be banned in Europe and not, you know,
03:43the other way around France going back to the same level as the rest of the EU.
03:51Acetaminoprid is also very persistent in the environment.
03:55So we believe that it should be banned at the EU level,
03:58and we will work on that in the coming months and years.
04:02I mean, France is currently still debating the idea.
04:05Do you think it will actually go back on this?
04:10Well, the problem is that at the present time,
04:14the French government is more right-wing than before,
04:18more conservative, I would say,
04:20and not interested at all in environmental issues.
04:24And that's why he's giving it all to farmers' unions,
04:27conservative farmers' unions, and nothing from the environment.
04:30But, you know, France had a plan to reduce consumption of pesticides
04:35by 50% in 10 years.
04:38That was 15 years ago when it started.
04:40It was a total failure because, in fact,
04:44there is not a strong conviction that the practices of farmers
04:50should be modified and improved.
04:53And I think we have still a lot of work to do to change that,
04:57and also at the EU level where there is a huge usage of pesticides
05:03and it pollutes groundwater.
05:05For example, in France, the last official report showed that 25% a quarter
05:11of all water resources is polluted by pesticide residues
05:15over the legal limits, which is, you know,
05:19concerning 17 millions of people, 17 millions of consumers throughout France.
05:24Well, it can't live like that much longer.
05:27So we have to work on reducing our dependency on pesticides
05:31in French agriculture.
05:32And I would say in the rest of Europe, it measures the same thing.
05:36And I imagine you have had lots of interactions with farmers.
05:40I mean, when you see the damage that these pesticides can do,
05:43you're telling us even about the bee population that could wipe it out.
05:46I mean, it doesn't take somebody to be in the industry
05:48to see the impact that that will have on production in the longer term.
05:52But what do farmers have to say to that?
05:54Aren't they worried about the damage the pesticides are doing
05:57to their own land and future production?
06:01Well, farmers should be worried that pesticides are dangerous for themselves.
06:06And now in France, we have recognitions for the link between exposure
06:12to pesticides and a few diseases, Parkinson's disease, some cancers,
06:17and so on.
06:18So they are the first to be harmed, honestly.
06:22But the problem is that, for example, in beetroot cultivation,
06:26they want to have a very high yield, but the yield is already very high.
06:30In the last two years in France, the average yield for beetroots
06:34throughout France was about 80 tonnes per hectare,
06:37which is, wow, very big already.
06:40So they want to have 90 tonnes per hectare, but you can only have that
06:45with the own equities, but there are other means to get revenues,
06:49that is, higher prices.
06:50If you raise the price paid to farmers for beetroots by 5 euros per ton,
06:56they will have a fair earning, and there will be no need to increase the yield.
07:03So, and you won't notice it when, you know, drinking a coffee,
07:08because a little lump of sugar won't be, you know, more expensive,
07:12because it's 5 euros per ton of beetroots is really, you know,
07:17harmless at the consumer level.
07:19On that money side of things,
07:20Mr. François Villarette of the Pesticide Action Network,
07:25thank you so much for bringing us your insight on that situation.
07:28Much appreciated.