Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
'Very real' risk of ceasefire 'unravelling', expert says
FRANCE 24 English
Follow
2/1/2025
Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com
Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English
Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
More on the developments so far. Let's speak now with Oliver McTernan, the co-founder and
00:05
director of Forward Thinking, a charity that works on conflict resolution and mediation in
00:10
the Middle East. Thank you so much for joining us. Now, we've now had four prisoner exchanges
00:17
taking place. How do you see the developments so far? How fragile is this ceasefire and the
00:23
situation? Well, I think both of your correspondents have captured, first of all,
00:31
the high emotion. And I think in a very fragile situation, charged with emotion,
00:38
it doesn't look promising. I feel the whole procedure is so drawn out that it's full of risks.
00:47
When we see scenes like today on both sides and in Gaza, I fear the risk of this unravelling is
00:55
very, very real. So, you're already seeing risks, huge risks there, but negotiations
01:04
on the next phase are set to begin next week very soon. Who do you expect? Who can we expect
01:13
will take part in terms of mediating those talks? Well, I would imagine it will be the
01:20
Qataris assisted by the Egyptians that would be responsible. I think the role, as I understood it,
01:28
the role of the Americans is to guarantee what is agreed upon. Now, I think the big problem with
01:37
this whole system in the last 15 months has been that it's been carried out in the glare of public
01:46
opinion and comment. And that must make it extremely difficult for the negotiators. Prime
01:53
Minister Netanyahu is constantly making comments and constantly, if I may add, repeating his first
02:01
goal in this war, which he clearly stated was to see the total demise of Hamas alongside then
02:08
the release of the hostages. And for me, if he continues this, he's still continuing two goals
02:17
that are just incompatible. So, I'm still worried about his intentions. I'm still worried what's
02:25
going to happen to the 2.3 million people in Gaza? Are they going to be forced out of their
02:31
place because of the inhumane conditions now that they're expected to live in? All of these
02:38
issues are not being addressed. There's no political horizon to these negotiations.
02:43
It's simply transactional. A number of people released for a number of hostages released.
02:50
There's no vision of where this is going to take us and what will the future be. So,
02:55
the risk of the cycle of violence continuing, I think, is very, very real.
03:00
Indeed, several Middle East diplomats have already voiced opposition to potential forced
03:08
displacement of Gaza, of Palestinians in Gaza. Donald Trump suggested that 2 million of them
03:16
could be taken in by neighboring countries. What could we see going forward?
03:23
Well, I think on a political level, it's just not acceptable. I can't see present Jordan or
03:32
even Egypt being able to accommodate such a large number of Palestinian refugees. But I think what
03:41
it would be disastrous for the future if they are forced what I would call involuntary migration
03:48
because of the circumstances in Gaza. My worry is that it will be presented as a humanitarian option.
03:56
People will say, look, we've let you back into the north. We've let you back down into Rafa.
04:02
You see it's unlivable with the humanitarian option is to provide you sort of subsistence
04:09
in another country. So, a ship will come in or Egypt will be pressurized to open the Sinai.
04:17
I think this is disastrous. It'll be just a continuation of the cycle of violence.
04:22
We are not solving the problem. At the end of the day, no one is addressing the root cause
04:29
of what we've been witnessing over the past 15 months. And that's simply the ongoing occupation
04:35
of the Palestinian territories, Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem, and the failure to
04:40
acknowledge and accept the Palestinian state until we have the political courage, I think,
04:46
to do that at the international level, then what we're witnessing today will be repeated and repeated.
04:53
Now, you have been looking at the situation for decades in the Middle East.
04:59
Is the two-state solution now a faraway dream, do you think?
05:03
Well, for me, I think it is the only realistic option. I think to talk about a one-state in light
05:12
of what's happened and in light of the high emotion and mistrust that your correspondents
05:18
captured earlier on, I think it is just a pipe dream to say that you can have a one-state. I think
05:25
how two states evolve, whether they evolve into a federation and whatever in the future,
05:32
or indeed one state, is a matter for the people themselves to decide. But I think what we need now
05:38
is to restore a sense of international order to act on the Declaration of 1948. What's given
05:46
Israel legitimacy should also give a Palestinian sovereign independent state legitimacy.
05:53
Then as two states, it is up to them to work out the future and what sort of
05:59
political structure they think would be workable.
06:03
To that end, how do you view the political situation in both
06:08
the Palestinian Authority and in Israel?
06:14
I wish I could give you a short answer to that. I think it is really distressing,
06:22
first of all, to see the disunity that is still in the Palestinian political front,
06:29
that the split between Hamas, Fatah and other factions, I think is regrettable.
06:36
What's needed is a determination now, in light of this horror that they've endured as a people,
06:43
a determination to get a unified approach and a unified government.
06:49
I think on the Israeli side, it's equally split. There is profound differences. When I visit the
06:55
Knesset, I'm very aware of the profound differences in the political vision,
07:02
but what's holding them together now is the united trauma of what happened on October 7th.
07:08
People are holding on because they feel that's the right thing to do in these circumstances.
07:16
But on both sides, there needs to be a lot of discussion, a lot of trying to discover
07:26
what is in the best interest of each country and each people, and a fear that lots of the
07:32
actions being taken and supported by America and other countries, a lot are very short-sighted,
07:41
immediate solutions that will bring long-term problems.
07:46
Now, US President Donald Trump is set to meet the Israeli Prime Minister next week.
07:51
What role might he play in the next stages now that he has taken office?
07:57
Well, my hope would be that Trump will pressurize Netanyahu to make this ceasefire permanent
08:05
and to get some political horizon, a vision of where we go from here. We cannot see a repetition
08:13
of this. I look on Trump as the first American president to not wear the dress of principles.
08:23
He is frank in what he sees as his priority, and what he sees as his priority in foreign policy
08:32
and in the Middle East is the domestic interests of America. And those domestic interests were once
08:39
summed up to me by a CIA analyst who said it's economic. And I think being transactional, what
08:47
he will try to do is to find an economic solution for the region that will benefit first and foremost
08:57
American domestic interests. To do this, I hope the Saudis will stand firm on their commitment
09:05
that they will only normalize if they see the establishment of a Palestinian state.
09:10
So, if Trump, I think, goes down this road, then I'm hopeful. If he thinks that he can
09:18
deport the Palestinians, all of these issues, I think he is going to just add to the problems
09:25
that we've been witnessing over the past 75 years.
09:29
Oliver MacTernan, Director of Forward Thinking, thank you so much for your insight.
Recommended
1:10
|
Up next
John F. Kennedy Assassination 16mm Original - Driver shooting at Kennedy!
Jelani Trent
9/7/2015
4:27
'This is clearly a gamble and many think it's too risky'
FRANCE 24 English
6/10/2024
3:28
'Conflicting pieces of information coming in at the moment'
FRANCE 24 English
9/15/2024
3:52
'People aren't safe anywhere, anytime'
FRANCE 24 English
5/26/2023
7:48
'This is going to be a tough slog for the Ukrainians'
FRANCE 24 English
6/12/2023
6:49
Palestinians 'happy' and 'terrified' as ceasefire due to take effect
FRANCE 24 English
1/18/2025
6:36
'Deep concern' over released hostages' health
FRANCE 24 English
2/1/2025
14:51
'We are engaged in a brutal war that has to be ended as soon as possible'
FRANCE 24 English
10/6/2024
2:23
Sudan ceasefire to expire
FRANCE 24 English
4/27/2023
3:57
'We do appear to be nearing the end of a long period of uncertainty'
FRANCE 24 English
9/21/2024
2:13
Grenfell Tower fire a 'culmination of decades of failure': UK inquiry
FRANCE 24 English
9/4/2024
10:35
Second phase of ceasefire depends on Trump administration, expert says
FRANCE 24 English
2/1/2025
2:18
‘Blocked on both sides’: Transnistria residents fear for future
FRANCE 24 English
3/8/2024
4:37
'Neither side is doing all it can yet'
FRANCE 24 English
9/23/2024
2:30
'We got to this point partly because of misinformation widely spread across social media'
FRANCE 24 English
8/3/2024
1:51
'There are a number of hostages that have lost their lives'
FRANCE 24 English
1/27/2025
2:05
'There's no way to flee': Tehran residents brace for more strikes
FRANCE 24 English
6/17/2025
4:03
Sudan's RSF open to talks on immediate ceasefire with army
FRANCE 24 English
1/3/2024
3:29
‘There’ll be nothing left’: Pokrovsk residents flee Russian advance
FRANCE 24 English
9/23/2024
2:50
'Everyone seems to have a personal story of suffering and loss'
FRANCE 24 English
12/18/2024
12:39
Perspective
FRANCE 24 English
2/10/2025
7:28
Entre Nous
FRANCE 24 English
4/8/2025
2:04
‘Critical situation’: On patrol with French forces in Lebanon
FRANCE 24 English
9/23/2024
5:20
'We are really seeing a mounting death toll among children'
FRANCE 24 English
9/29/2024
7:39
'Too risky'? Ukraine says West should permit long-range attacks in Russia
FRANCE 24 English
9/3/2024