Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
'Ask for the impossible" Are Trump's 'wild ambitions' simply a negotiation tactic to "raise political stakes" with allies?
FRANCE 24 English
Follow
1/10/2025
Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com
Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English
Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
Let's get some analysis on this now. Richard Johnson, US politics lecturer at Queen Mary
00:05
University joins us now from London. Good to have you with us, Richard. So expecting
00:10
Wang Ma-chan to issue an unconditional discharge in the sentencing for Trump today. Just explain
00:17
to us what that means exactly.
00:19
What that means is that the state of New York has determined that it's not in the interest
00:23
of the state to incarcerate the felon. But this is not an overturning of the jury's decision.
00:32
Trump will remain a felon. Being a felon carries certain penalties. It would restrict Trump
00:40
from ever serving on a jury in the state of New York. It could restrict his access if
00:46
he wanted to buy a firearm and actually could also restrict his travel. Now, this was a
00:53
particularly curious one because Trump is not the first president to have a criminal
00:58
record. George W. Bush had a criminal record. But for a misdemeanor, he had pled guilty
01:03
to drunken driving back in the 1970s. And when Bush was elected, there was some discussion
01:08
that he was applying for waivers to gain visa free access to travel to Canada. Now, I'm
01:15
not sure how serious that ended up being, whether Canada would have looked into that.
01:19
But when you travel abroad and you get visa waivers to certain countries that are friendly
01:24
to the United States, you have to declare on that that you don't have a criminal record.
01:29
And Donald Trump, of course, would have to declare that he was a felon, which would complicate
01:36
that. So we'll have to see in practice whether that means anything. But Trump remains a felon,
01:42
even if he does get this unconditional discharge.
01:46
Yeah, Trump very much not going off scot-free here. Richard, we saw from that Supreme Court
01:52
ruling that two conservative justices sided with liberal justices to go ahead with that
02:00
sentencing from Wang Man-shan today. The fact that that happened does go some way to show
02:05
that nobody is above the law, doesn't it?
02:09
Well, yes. I mean, the Supreme Court is a court that is strongly shaped by the ideological
02:17
interpretations that the justices apply to the Constitution. And that tends to align quite
02:23
strongly with the party of the president who appointed them. But I think it isn't accurate
02:29
to say that the Supreme Court members are purely partisans in robes. That is to say that
02:35
they act purely on the basis of what the interest of the party is that appoints them.
02:40
Some might form judgments that are closer to that than others. But basically, once you're on
02:46
the Supreme Court, you're there for life. And it's extremely rare in American history for
02:54
Congress to remove a member of the court. They have to go through the impeachment process,
02:58
which would require two thirds consensus in the Senate, which would be unlikely to be found
03:02
for a particular judge on the basis of their political leaning. So in a sense, they are much
03:07
more insulated and protected from partisan punishment, say, in the way that a member of
03:14
Congress is. If they step out of line against Trump, they could lose a primary election.
03:19
Well, that isn't something that Supreme Court justices have to think about. So they do exercise
03:24
greater independence from the party that put them into office than I think sometimes people expect.
03:31
And Trump has recently claimed that Wan Malshan is trying to embarrass him. Do you think that
03:36
this is an embarrassment for Trump? How embarrassing is this for him?
03:42
Of course, it is embarrassing for, I think, anyone to have a criminal conviction,
03:49
particularly given the circumstances of this criminal conviction, which are rooted in
03:55
allegations about marital infidelity that Trump denies. But of course, that's not quite what the
04:03
jury came to believe. Whether this has larger political ramifications, I'm less sure. I don't
04:13
think that Trump supporters have shown that they are particularly moved by this in any way. Trump
04:20
claims that this is lawfare against him, that this is a stitch up, have been received quite
04:27
well by Republican voters. And so I think this is another example of how the United States is
04:34
such a strongly divided country at the moment, and that people interpret the events around them
04:41
through a partisan lens. And so Democrats will look at this and it will confirm to them that
04:47
they view judges on suited character to be president of the United States. And Republicans
04:52
will look at this and see Democratic elected prosecutors moving against a president they
04:58
didn't like in a jurisdiction that's heavily Democratic. And at the end of the day,
05:03
I think in terms of the political ramifications, it'll be a bit of a wash.
05:08
And of course, Richard, this wasn't the only case against Trump. It's the only one to have
05:12
reached a conclusion now. Tell us how unprecedented it is for Trump to now be
05:16
returning to the White House after effectively defying four criminal cases. Well, it is remarkable
05:25
how Trump has been able to navigate the legal jeopardy that he faced. Of course, running for
05:31
president did provide him with a degree of protection because at the very least, his
05:38
presidential campaigns caused the different courts to delay proceedings in some matters.
05:46
But also Trump was strongly helped by the intervention of the Supreme Court in the
05:50
summer and the Trump v. United States case, which said that the president is immune,
05:55
not just this president, any president is immune from prosecution for official acts that they
06:01
conducted as president. Now, this particular New York case is of a different character because this
06:07
refers to actions that were alleged and found to have taken place in the 2016 presidential election
06:14
before Trump was elected president. But the actions say relating to the 6th of January 2021
06:22
and so on, these pertain to when Trump was president and the Supreme Court has given him
06:27
immunity. That is quite extraordinary. Now, what I would say on the other side is, of course,
06:31
Joe Biden may be grateful for that Supreme Court case in the coming months and years, as it does
06:38
protect him from legal lawfare or actions taken against him by Republican prosecutors who may be
06:48
unhappy with the things that he did when he was president. And finally, Richard, I did want to
06:53
get your thoughts on this so-called expansionist agenda that Trump has been pushing in recent days,
06:58
talking about taking over Greenland, absorbing Canada. Tell us your thoughts on this agenda that
07:07
he's been pushing. Well, I think in many ways, this is classic Trump negotiation tactics. Trump
07:14
has known throughout his business career, this long predates his political career, that you ask
07:21
for the impossible and then you might get more than you ever bargained that you would plausibly
07:26
have gotten otherwise. And I look at the wild ambitions of Trump with respect to Greenland or
07:36
Panama or Canada, and I think few expect that any of those will become territories of the United
07:44
States. But what it has done is, A, it's headline grabbing. So it has brought attention to certain
07:53
issues that Trump cares deeply about, whether that's trade or competition in the case of China,
08:00
or competition with China in the case of the Panama Canal, or U.S. strategic defense in the
08:07
case of Greenland. And secondly, what it's done, I suppose, is it has put pressure on the respective
08:14
governments that are in charge of those territories to consider how or to raise the
08:22
political stakes against them, should they not take action in a direction closer to what Trump
08:27
wants to take. You know, Trump could have said to Denmark, I want you to increase your defense
08:32
spending. And maybe Denmark would have. But if Trump says, well, if you don't increase your
08:36
defense spending, we're going to take Greenland. Well, it's not likely that Trump would take
08:41
Greenland, but it shows to Denmark how serious, how important this issue is to Trump. And it may
08:47
cause them to move a bit more in the direction of Trump or that Trump wants to see them.
08:52
Richard Johnson, U.S. politics lecturer,
08:54
thanks so much for joining us. Really good to get your insight there.
Recommended
10:26
|
Up next
Jan 6 insurrection: Militias, far-right extremists, those advocating violence now part of mainstream
FRANCE 24 English
1/6/2025
4:57
Trump rings in Gilded Age & McKinley era, tapping into 'Manifest Destiny view of American expansion'
FRANCE 24 English
1/20/2025
27:51
'History will be kind to Biden': Environmental, industrial policies & presiding over top G7 economy
FRANCE 24 English
1/20/2025
8:30
EU already making 'contingency plans' in case Trump returns, expert says
FRANCE 24 English
3/6/2024
3:28
Haley 'positioning herself for future', warning that 'anointing Trump will lead to November defeat'
FRANCE 24 English
2/25/2024
11:21
'Polarised electorate': American voters not easily swayed to cross the aisle
FRANCE 24 English
10/30/2024
7:50
US Presidential Election: Rise of far-right extremism in the American political life
FRANCE 24 English
11/3/2020
10:40
'Political violence symptomatic of deeper polarisation, extremism within American political sphere'
FRANCE 24 English
9/16/2024
7:34
US Presidential Election will be less about policy, 'this is really an election about democracy'
FRANCE 24 English
9/3/2024
1:57
Donald Trump on immigration: "we have no country if we have no border, we need to take the drugs out"
FRANCE 24 English
10/20/2016
1:58
Donald Trump: "Aleppo is Clinton's fault... Assad is much smarter than Obama and Clinton!"
FRANCE 24 English
10/20/2016
7:53
US VP candidates have opportunity to 'introduce themselves further' to voters, 'redefine opponents'
FRANCE 24 English
10/1/2024
7:28
As tariffs loom in Trump's 2nd term, EU must 'deepen single market, have a competitiveness strategy'
FRANCE 24 English
11/8/2024
8:40
US economy 'remarkable' ahead of election, Trump's tariff proposal a 'real risk to the whole world'
FRANCE 24 English
11/1/2024
4:55
Democrats have 'fighting chance': Harris has reenergized base but must define 'what she stands for'
FRANCE 24 English
8/20/2024
14:21
Ideological sorting, class voting have profound effect on US electorate, including ethnic minorities
FRANCE 24 English
10/16/2024
6:36
'Policy inconsistencies a hallmark of Trump': How long will the 'unwieldy MAGA coalition' endure?
FRANCE 24 English
1/20/2025
4:48
'Are you kidding me?': Vance's 'carefully constructed edifice of civility comes crashing down'
FRANCE 24 English
10/2/2024
2:09
US Presidential debate: Hillary Clinton addresses Syria crisis
FRANCE 24 English
10/10/2016
17:35
Ukraine 'most significant element' of Biden's US foreign policy as he sought to 'repair alliances'
FRANCE 24 English
1/14/2025
11:00
Tale of two candidates: Harris speaks in 'cliches, bromides', Trump 'feeds into idea he's a fascist'
FRANCE 24 English
11/4/2024
0:55
US Presidential Debate: Clinton slams Trump as Putin's "puppet"
FRANCE 24 English
10/20/2016
13:34
Joe Biden withdraws candidacy and endorses Vice President Kamala Harris, 'a much stronger candidate'
FRANCE 24 English
7/21/2024
5:11
'Fealty' trumps loyalty: Conflict of interest means nothing, 'revenge, retribution' means everything
FRANCE 24 English
11/13/2024
1:08
Trump Vs. Biden: One Candidate Gains In 2024 Election Poll Of Swing State Voters; Who Is Hurt The Most By Kennedy Jr.?
Benzinga
5/23/2024