Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
Legal War Brewing Between Federal & State Prosecutors | TMZ Live
TMZ
Follow
12/20/2024
In the Luigi Mangione case, federal and state prosecutors may soon be at odds...
Category
✨
People
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
There is a dogfight going on in New York City, not with dogs, but with prosecutors.
00:06
There is a, from all we can see, there is something going on in the Luigi Mangione case,
00:13
specifically whether the feds are trying to bigfoot the state of New York
00:21
and take the case from the state so that the feds can do it first.
00:26
Right, because he's now been charged. Yesterday he was in federal court to face the charges that
00:32
the feds have now hit him with. He had already been charged by New York State for murder and
00:40
that was the case that, in fact, a lot of people involved in the case, including his attorney,
00:46
thought he was going to be going into court tomorrow.
00:48
Everybody did.
00:48
Yesterday.
00:49
They end up, there was a camera there that the judge approved.
00:53
They were, the stage was set in New York court for Luigi to show up and face the judge
01:01
and everybody thought that was going to happen. And when he was flown from Pennsylvania,
01:05
he was taken to a federal facility by the FBI, which escorted him along with the NYPD.
01:11
He is currently, right now, being held at Brooklyn MDC, the same place we've been talking about.
01:17
A federal facility.
01:19
The same place where Diddy is. And it is interesting that, although, look,
01:28
just from the outside looking in, right, as a bystander, this seems like a New York case.
01:35
The murder that was, Brian Thompson's murder, happened on the streets of New York. That's
01:40
in dispute.
01:42
It is absolutely a New York case. But New York is not saying it's also not a fed case. The feds
01:47
have their own laws. It's a different sovereign. And you could prosecute both.
01:52
The question is, who goes first? So there is a federal law here under which he would be
01:59
prosecuted. And there is a state law under which. So it's not unusual that both would.
02:05
But the train was on the tracks and going down the tracks on the state side. And the feds have
02:12
now in a federal detention center and that the feds
02:16
arraigned him yesterday. It feels like there's something going on here.
02:20
Well, I mean, look, at the end of the day, the feds are going to be able to trump the state if
02:23
they want to. But it is an odd case to bring as a federal crime. I understand that there are
02:28
federal elements to it and they could do it. We saw this, of course, Harvey, in the case against
02:33
Rodney King, the officers who beat Rodney King.
02:34
I was just thinking of that.
02:36
First tried as a state case.
02:37
They were found not guilty. And then they've tried them in the federal system for civil
02:40
rights violations and two of them got convicted.
02:43
That's right. But typically this happens in Syriatim, where one will try them and then if
02:46
they're you know, the state will go after them. And if doesn't get a conviction, the feds will.
02:50
But here they're fighting for territory.
02:52
Well, you got to remember, there is a difference. And the difference is
02:55
that if he's convicted on the state court, the most he can get is a life in prison.
03:00
On the federal side, he can get the death penalty.
03:03
So the stakes are much higher for him on the federal side.
03:05
We should say we've just laid out all those things. Definitely.
03:09
Like you said, feels like a dog fight.
03:12
On the record, the feds have said that Manhattan D.A. will get first crack at this.
03:19
I know there was a there was a yeah, a window that said
03:22
currently we think as it stands right now, currently Manhattan will go first.
03:28
Well, currently, they also thought that he was going to be in state court and he wasn't.
03:38
Yeah.
Recommended
0:58
|
Up next
Supporters For Luigi Mangione Gather Outside Of Federal Court Ahead Of His Hearing
Forbes Breaking News
4/25/2025
10:16
Luigi Mangione's Alleged Diary Entries Show Months of Murder Planning | TMZ Live
TMZ
12/19/2024
4:38
Luigi Mangione’s Mom Reportedly Spoke to the FBI Right Before His Arrest | TMZ Live
TMZ
12/26/2024
1:16
US prosecutors to seek death penalty for Luigi Mangione
The Star
4/2/2025
3:46
Luigi Mangione Officially Charged with Murder of Brian Thompson | TMZ Live
TMZ
12/10/2024
1:00
Chicago Justice | show | 2017 | Official Trailer
JustWatch
2/1/2023
0:30
Federal Prosecutors Charge Luigi Mangione With Murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson
Benzinga
12/20/2024
5:47
Luigi Mangione's Grandmother Left Huge Inheritance, Arrest Could Cut Him Off | TMZ Live
TMZ
12/13/2024
2:29
Menendez Brothers' Family Lawyer Bryan Freedman Rips New D.A. Nathan Hochman
TMZ
12/16/2024
4:04
Diddy Hit With New Criminal Charges, Feds File New Superseding Indictment | TMZ Live
TMZ
4/4/2025
1:13
Luigi Mangione Court Appearance Has People Flocking From Across U.S.
TMZ
2/21/2025
1:14
Justice | movie | 2017 | Official Trailer
JustWatch
1/31/2023
0:39
DOJ Pursues Death Penalty For Luigi Mangione Over Murder Of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson
Benzinga
4/2/2025
2:48
NYC Mayor Eric Adams Speaks After Trump DOJ Orders Prosecutors to Drop Charges Against Him
TIME
2/11/2025
2:20
Luigi Mangione's Manifesto Could Shake Up Terror Charge, Defense Attorney Says
TMZ
6/5/2025
0:39
Georgia Prosecutors Reject Trump’s Immunity Claim, Urge Case to Proceed
Benzinga
12/19/2024
0:59
Lawyer says ‘no evidence’ links gun found on Luigi Mangione to CEO shooting
The Independent
12/11/2024
1:10
Diddy Case Prosecutors Arrive at Courthouse Ahead of Trial Proceedings
TMZ
5/18/2025
6:10
Menendez Brothers Get New Judge In Resentencing Case | TMZ Live
TMZ
10/29/2024
0:38
Chelsea Manning Responds To Death Penalty Sought By Luigi Mangione's Prosecutors
Forbes Breaking News
4/25/2025
2:23
Meadows fights to move Georgia election interference case
23ABC News
8/31/2023
0:32
Luigi Mangione struggles against police on way in to extradition hearing
The Independent
12/10/2024
3:46
Lindsay Hubbard and West Wilson Share Insight On Summer House Season 10
US Weekly
today
1:50
Inside Rick Moranis’ Quiet Life Away from Hollywood After Wife’s Death
US Weekly
today
1:16
Amanda Bynes Says She's Going on Ozempic, Hopes to Lose Over 40 Lbs
US Weekly
today