VP SARA IMPEACHMENT: Mga reaksyon sa pag-archive ng senado sa impeachment complaint vs. VP Sara | 24 Oras - video Dailymotion

GMA Integrated News

Sa pag-archive ng Senado sa impeachment complaint laban kay Vice President Sara Duterte, binatikos ng ilang senador ang Kamara na siyang naghain ng reklamong tinawag na unconstitutional ng Supreme Court.   Si House Speaker Martin Romualdez, kinuwestyon ang aniya'y pagmamadali ng Senado sa pag-archive ng impeachment case ni VP Duterte, lalo't hinihintay pa ang desisyon ng Korte Suprema sa apela ng Kamara.   Para kay constitutional framer Atty. Christian Monsod, itinuturing nang dismissed ang reklamo, pero giit ng ibang legal experts, maaari pa itong buhayin.   Pinuri ng kampo ni VP Duterte ang desisyon ng Senado at iginiit na dapat itong igalang. Tiniyak nilang handa pa rin sila sakaling may panibagong kaso.   24 Oras is GMA Network’s flagship newscast, anchored by Mel Tiangco, Vicky Morales and Emil Sumangil. It airs on GMA-7 Mondays to Fridays at 6:30 PM (PHL Time) and on weekends at 5:30 PM. For more videos from 24 Oras, visit http://www.gmanews.tv/24oras.   #GMAIntegratedNews #GMANetwork #KapusoStream  Breaking news and stories from the Philippines and abroad: GMA Integrated News Portal: http://www.gmanews.tv Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/gmanews TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@gmanews Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/gmanews Instagram: http://www.instagram.com/gmanews  GMA Network Kapuso programs on GMA Pinoy TV: https://gmapinoytv.com/subscribe

Transcript

00:00Impeachment Complaint

00:30Inayos na ng Senado ang wording ng musyon para sa pag-archive ng impeachment complaint laban kay Vice President Sara Duterte

00:48nang subukan pa ni Senate Minority Leader Tito Soto na pigilan ang butuhan.

00:53Nag-motion siyang ipagpaliban muna ang desisyon habang may nakabin-bin pang motion for reconsideration sa Supreme Court.

01:02Pero tinanggihan ito ng nakararaming Senador kaya natuloy ang butuhan.

01:06My God have mercy on your decision.

01:09I move to transfer the articles of impeachment to the archives. I so move Mr. President.

01:15Ang resulta, 19-4 pabor sa pag-archive ng impeachment complaint.

01:20Kami lang sa pumabor sa Senate President Jesus Codero, mga Duterte allies sa Senadora Amy Marcos,

01:27Senador Bato de la Rosa, Bongo at Robin Padilla, pati ang miyembro ng minoriya na si Senador Migs Zubiri.

01:34Let history, Mr. President, record that in this moment, we chose the Constitution.

01:40We chose the rule of law by defending the integrity of the Supreme Court

01:44and maintaining the system of checks and balances under our Republican system of government.

01:49To the House of Representatives, I say, do not allow yourselves to be used for the blind hatred and ambition of a few

01:56who did things haphazardly, gravely abused their discretion, and violated due process rights under the Constitution.

02:05The Senate is not your playground.

02:06Kesa, inaatupag ninyong palitan ang pinili ng taong bayan, binoto at minahal.

02:15Bakit din nyo nalang palitan ang tao, kayo naman lang ang pumili?

02:23Ayaw paawat ng iba sa kaka-flex.

02:27Ano kaya kung yung speaker nyo nalang ang paltan nyo?

02:31Naging tagabantay na lamang sila nang humihiyaw na dambuhalang sanggol.

02:39Ginawa ng bonjing na armas ang impeachment.

02:44Bumoto man pabor sa pag-archive ng impeachment complaint, may hamon si Senador Erwin Tulfo sa Bise.

02:50Ang boto kong ito ay hindi para iabswelto si VP Sara Duterte.

02:57Kung tunay po na walang kasalanan si VP Duterte, dapat siya mismo ang manguna sa pagbubukas ng lahat ng dokumento,

03:08paggamit ng budget, at mga hakbangin niya bilang pangalawang pangulo at kalihim ng DepEd.

03:15Walang dahilan para umiwas kung malinis po ang konsensya.

03:23Ang apat naman na hindi po mabor sa mosyon,

03:27sina Senate Minority Leader Tito Soto,

03:29at kasamahan sa minorya na si Senadora Riza Ontiveros,

03:33pati ang mga miyembro ng mayorya na sina Senador Kiko Pangilinan at Bam Aquino.

03:37Anything that will make it easier for a public officer to evade accountability should be opposed.

03:46Madismiss man natin ngayon o ma-archive ang articles of impeachment,

03:52mas mahirap i-dismiss o i-archive ang daing ng mga tao sa pananagutan at katarungan.

04:01Ang boto na no ay hindi nangangahulugan na hindi natin nire-respeto ang pasya o kapangyarihan ng Korte Suprema.

04:14Lalo-lalo na't hindi pa ito pinal.

04:17Hintayin lang ang final decision.

04:21Kaya katakataka kung bakit kailangan magkaroon ng archiving.

04:32Nag-upstay naman si Senador Panfilo Lacson dahil gusto raw niyang hintayin ang final ruling ng Supreme Court.

04:39In-archive ng Senado ang reklamo alinsunod sa ruling ng Korte Suprema

04:43na null and void ang impeachment complaint sa simula pa lamang

04:47dahil labag ito sa one-year bar rule at may mga hindi nasunod ang kamera sa proseso.

04:53Ano nga ba ang ibig sabihin kapag sinabing na-archive ang articles of impeachment

04:57ayon sa ilang Senador para itong itinabi na pwedeng ilabas o buhayin muli.

05:03Pero para sa ilan, misto lang patay na ang impeachment.

05:07I know for a fact, once it is archived, it is dead.

05:11Yes, it's dead but it's not really buried.

05:14But yes, it's dead.

05:16In effect, because it's in the archive,

05:19but sabi nga ni Justice Ascuna pwede na mahugutin pa ulit kung magbago ang Korte Suprema.

05:25Pag in-archive, kahit hindi pa patay, napakahirap ilabas sa archives.

05:31Kailangan pa mag-majority vote.

05:33Pag sinabi ng Korte Suprema, we are reconsidering the decision,

05:38eh di po buhayin ulit. Napakasimple naman nun eh.

05:40Para sa GMA Integrated News, Sandra Aguinaldo nakatutok 24 oras.

05:47Kinwestyon ni House Speaker Martin Romualdez

05:49sa kanya'y pagmamadali ng Senado sa pag-archive ng impeachment case

05:53ni Vice President Sara Duterte.

05:55Lalot, hinihintay pa ang desisyon ng Korte Suprema sa apelan ng Kamara.

05:59Sinagot din niya ang mga batikos na ibinato sa kanya

06:02at sa Kamara ng mga Senador.

06:04Nakatutok si Tina Pangaliban Perez.

06:05Sa ginawang pag-archive ng Senado sa impeachment,

06:12sabi ni House Speaker Martin Romualdez,

06:14inilibing daw ng Senado ang Articles of Impeachment

06:17laban kay Vice President Sara Duterte.

06:20Sabi ni Romualdez,

06:21hindi daw ang paghahain ng impeachment ang minadali,

06:25kundi ang paglilibing nito.

06:27Yan daw ay kahit pa hindi pa pinal ang desisyon ng Korte Suprema

06:31na nagsabing unconstitutional ang Articles of Impeachment.

06:35Sabi ni Romualdez,

06:37aktibo pa ang kaso

06:38at hiningan pa ng Korte ang mga respondent ng kanilang tugon

06:42sa motion for reconsideration na inihain ng Kamara.

06:46Pero pagpuna ni Romualdez,

06:48binaturaw sila ng mga personal na pag-atake at akusasyon

06:52at pangmamaliit sa kanilang constitutional duty

06:55para palabasin paglalaro lang ito sa kapangyarihan.

06:59Hindi lang daw ito unfair,

07:00kundi mapanganib din

07:02dahil pinahihina nito ang tiwala ng publiko

07:04sa checks and balances sa isang demokrasya.

07:08Sabi kasi ng ilang Senador,

07:10pamumuliti ka at pagkontra lang kay Duterte ang impeachment,

07:13puntong pinalagan din ang iba pang kongresista.

07:17The family name is just accidental.

07:22Alam po natin yan

07:23at kailangan po as public officers,

07:25we need to make ourselves accountable.

07:29Kung pinayagan lamang po kami ng Senado

07:32na mailatag yung mga ebidensya sa impeachment trial

07:36at wala po kaming napatunayan,

07:39siguro po pwede po nating masabi

07:41na ito'y pamumuliti ka lamang.

07:43Justice! Justice! Justice for the people!

07:49Ang pag-archive ng Senado sa impeachment complaint,

07:52sinalubong ng mga protesta ngayong araw.

07:55Boom!

07:56Binatikos din ang ilang mamabatas

07:58ang ginawang ito ng Senado.

08:00Bakit sila nagmamadali?

08:03Hindi po ibig sabihin

08:04dahil immediately executory,

08:05final na.

08:07Kasi nga,

08:08meron pang motion for reconsideration.

08:10Nakakahiya ang desisyon ng Senado.

08:12They chose to surrender their independence

08:14and willfully abandon their constitutional mandate.

08:17Today, the Senate decided to become a Duterte Senate.

08:21These Senators will go down

08:23in our Philippine history

08:24as cowards, no?

08:26Mga senaduwag.

08:28Matapos ang aksyon ng Senado sa impeachment,

08:31handa na ba ang Kamara na mag-move on

08:33at hintayin na lang ang February 2026

08:36para maghain ulit ang impeachment complaint

08:39laban sa Bise?

08:39Antayin po muna natin ang resulta ng MR.

08:45Para sa amin,

08:46hindi pa po tapos yung laban.

08:48Para sa GMA Integrated News,

08:50Tina Panganiban Perez,

08:52nakatutok 24 oras.

08:55Kahit na-archive na sa Senado

08:57ang impeachment complaint,

08:59sabi ng kampo ni Vice President Sara Duterte,

09:01masyado pang maaga

09:03para masabing patay na ito.

09:05Kaya handa raw sila

09:06sa anumang kahinat na nito.

09:07Nakatutok si Marisol Abduramas.

09:13With 19 affirmative votes,

09:164 negative votes,

09:181 abstention.

09:20In the matter of the impeachment trial

09:22of Vice President Sara Zimmerman Duterte

09:25to the archives,

09:27the same is hereby approved.

09:30Hindi raw inaasahan ang kampo

09:32ni Vice President Sara Duterte

09:33ang desisyon ng Senado

09:35na i-archive o isang tabi munang

09:37Articles of Impeachment

09:38laban sa Vice.

09:39Pinuri ang mga pahayag

09:40ng mga senador sa sesyon kahapon.

09:42Pero kahit naka-archive na,

09:44sinabi ng tagapagsalita

09:45ng defense team ng Vice

09:46na hindi pa rin daw

09:48masasabing patay na

09:49ang impeachment.

09:50I think it's too early to say

09:51kasi nga may MR pa

09:52and we don't want to preempt

09:54the decision of the Supreme Court

09:56on the motion for reconsideration.

09:59Ano man daw

10:00ang kahinat na ng Articles of Impeachment,

10:02handa raw ang defense team ng Vice.

10:03I'm really not so familiar

10:05doon sa mismong rules ng Senate.

10:07So, pero narinig nga natin kanina yan

10:09na posible namang mabuhay.

10:11Sa atin naman,

10:12we're ready for any eventuality.

10:13I-dinekla na ng Supreme Courts

10:15na unconstitutional

10:16ang inihay impeachment's complaint.

10:18Ngayon,

10:18nakatutok daw ang kampo

10:19ng Vice sa paghahanda

10:21ng komento

10:22na hinihin ang Korte Suprema

10:23para sa motion for reconsideration

10:25na inihain ng Kamara.

10:27Para sa GMA Integrated News,

10:29Marisol Abdurrahman,

10:32nakatutok 24 oras.

10:36May tuturing na raw

10:37na dismissed

10:38ang impeachment complaint sa Vice

10:40nang i-archive ito ng Senado

10:43kung pagbabasihan

10:44ang desisyon ng Korte Suprema

10:46ayon sa isa sa constitutional framers.

10:49Pero ang tingin naman

10:50ng iba pang law expert,

10:52pwede pa iyang buhayin

10:54sa pamagitan ng tamang mosyon na

10:57nakatutok si Mark Salazar.

10:59Thank you once again.

11:03Ngayong in-archive na ng Senado

11:05ang impeachment complaint,

11:06ano ang mangyayari

11:07kung katigan ng Korte Suprema

11:09ang motion for reconsideration

11:11at payagan ng paglilitis

11:13kay Vice President Sara Duterte?

11:15Tinanong namin ang mga eksperto

11:17sa constitutional law.

11:18The Senate can always retrieve

11:21the articles from the archives.

11:24It is without prejudice

11:26to bringing it back

11:28if necessary.

11:30Natutunog siya ng deep sleep siya ngayon

11:32sa Senado hanggang buhayin siya

11:34ng isang tama na mosyon.

11:37Pero may ibang punto

11:38si Attorney Christian Monsod,

11:40isa sa mga framers

11:41ng 1987 Constitution.

11:44Tinukoy niya ang mismong desisyon

11:46ng Korte Suprema

11:47kung saan,

11:48nang i-archive ng camera

11:50ang tatlong naunang impeachment complaint,

11:52itinuring ito ng Korte

11:53na dismissed.

11:54Sabi ng Supreme Court,

11:57pag in-archive,

11:59it amounts to a dismissal.

12:03Well, I don't know what they say.

12:05But if you follow the Supreme Court decision,

12:08the Supreme Court said

12:09that when it was archived,

12:11it amounted to a dismissal

12:14of the charges.

12:16At kung paninindigan naman

12:17ng Korte Suprema

12:18ang desisyon nitong

12:19unconstitutional ng impeachment complaint

12:22laban sa Vice,

12:23bukang refining po

12:24ang susunod na mangyayari

12:25sa House of Representatives.

12:27Whatever is the ruling,

12:28the final ruling of the court,

12:30I would say

12:32we should abide by it

12:33because that is part of the law,

12:35the land,

12:36and that is our system.

12:38Kung ano man na magiging pasya

12:40ng Supreme Court,

12:41may mga kwestiyon sa tila

12:43butas umano sa desisyon.

12:45Una,

12:46paano daw nasabi ng Korte Suprema

12:48na nalabag ang one-year ban

12:50nang iakyat ng Kamara

12:51sa Senado

12:52ang fourth impeachment complaint

12:54matapos nilang i-archive

12:56ang tatlong naunang complaints.

12:57Malinaw kasi na

13:00inunang desisyonan ng House

13:02yung fourth complaint

13:05bago pa nila

13:07dinesisyonan naman

13:09yung tatlo pa

13:10na complaint.

13:14Paano yun maging

13:15bar dun sa

13:16pang-apat na complaint?

13:18Nauna nga

13:18inaksyonan ng House

13:20through a plenary vote

13:23yung

13:24pang-apat na complaint.

13:26So yung logic

13:27medyo

13:28questionable na.

13:31Isa pang tanong,

13:32maituturing bang

13:33initiated

13:34ang tatlong naunang

13:35complaint

13:36kahit hindi ito

13:37na-refer sa isang

13:38House committee?

13:40Sabi ni Retired

13:41Associate Justice

13:42Adolf Ascuna,

13:43binago ng kasalukuyang

13:44Supreme Court

13:45ang naunang

13:46interpretasyon

13:47na initiated

13:48o nasimula

13:49ng isang impeachment

13:50proceeding

13:51kung ito ay

13:51na-refer na

13:52sa isang komite.

13:53The interpretation

13:54we gave in

13:55Francisco

13:56versus

13:57House

13:58is the one

13:59that was

13:59modified

14:01in the present

14:02case

14:03because in the

14:04present case

14:04the Supreme Court

14:06said that

14:06the three

14:08complaints

14:08were initiated

14:09even if they

14:10were not

14:11referred to

14:11the committee

14:12because they

14:13were archived

14:14and later on

14:16with the

14:17lapse of the

14:1719 congress

14:18they were

14:19terminated

14:20and dismissed.

14:21Sa ibang

14:22parte

14:23ng

14:23SC

14:23decision

14:24hinahanapan

14:25din

14:25ng due

14:26process

14:26ang

14:26Kamara

14:27dahil

14:27hindi

14:28raw

14:28pinasagot

14:29muna

14:29si Vice

14:30President

14:30Sarah

14:31bago

14:31inakyat

14:31sa Senado

14:32ang

14:32complaint.

14:34Isa

14:34raw

14:34itong

14:34bagong

14:35kondisyon

14:35ayon

14:36kay

14:36Munsud.

14:37Kung

14:52anuman

14:52daw

14:52ang

14:52desisyon

14:53ng

14:53Korte

14:53mahalagang

14:54natalaka

14:55ito

14:55ng

14:55komprehensibo

14:56at

14:57naipaliwanag

14:58ng gusto

14:58sa

14:58publiko.

15:00Hindi

15:00nagsagawa

15:00ang

15:00Supreme

15:01Court

15:01ng

15:01oral

15:02arguments.

15:02Sana

15:03may

15:03wrong

15:04oral

15:04argument

15:05dito

15:05sa

15:05MR

15:06upang

15:07mapaliwanag

15:08sa

15:08ating

15:08mga

15:09kababayan

15:10kung

15:11ano

15:11talaga

15:12ang

15:13dahilan

15:14na

15:15hindi

15:15pwede

15:16itong

15:17kasalukuyang

15:19articles

15:19at

15:20ito

15:20ay

15:21medyo

15:22pumasok

15:22dun sa

15:23one-year

15:23ban.

15:24Bakit?

15:25Bakit

15:25na ban yan

15:26na hindi

15:27naman

15:27refer

15:27sa

15:28committee?

15:28Bigyan

15:29ng

15:29pagkakataon

15:30ng

15:30House

15:30to

15:32hear

15:32their

15:32side

15:33in an

15:33oral

15:33argument

15:34kung

15:34bakit

15:35hindi

15:35pa

15:36initiated

15:36dito

15:37by

15:38the

15:38time

15:38they

15:39adopted

15:39their

15:40own

15:41complaint

15:41hindi

15:42pa

15:42initiated

15:42itong

15:44tatlo.

15:44Para

15:45sa

15:45GMA

15:46Integrated

15:46News,

15:47Mark

15:48Salazar

15:48nakatutok

15:5024

15:50oras.

15:52Mismong

15:53si Vice

15:53President

15:54Sara

15:54Duterte

15:55naman

15:55na nagsabing

15:55tuloy

15:56ang paghahanda

15:57ng

15:57kanyang

15:57kampo

15:58sakaling

15:58may

15:59mga

15:59impeachment

16:00case

16:00pang

16:00isang

16:01pa

16:01sa

16:01kanya

16:01sa

16:02inaharap.

16:02Pero

16:03ang

16:03disisyon

16:03ng

16:03Senado

16:03sa huling

16:04impeachment

16:05case

16:05na

16:05tinalakay

16:06nito,

16:07kailangan

16:07anyang

16:07irespeto.

16:09Nakatutok

16:09si

16:09Jandy

16:10Esteban

16:11ng

16:11GMA

16:11Regional

16:12TV.

16:17Emil,

16:18kailangang

16:18respetuhin

16:19ang

16:19disisyon

16:20ng

16:20Senado.

16:20Yan

16:21ang

16:21pahayag

16:21ni

16:22Vice

16:22President

16:22Sara

16:23Duterte

16:23matapos

16:24i-archive

16:25ng

16:25Senado

16:26ang

16:26articles

16:26of

16:26impeachment

16:27laban

16:27sa

16:28kanya.

16:28Matapos

16:33dumalo

16:33sa

16:33Misa

16:34ng

16:34Pasasalamat

16:35para

16:35sa

16:35Kadayawan

16:35Festival

16:36Celebration

16:36ng

16:37Davao

16:37City,

16:38humarap

16:38sa

16:38media

16:38si

16:38Vice

16:39President

16:39Sara

16:40Duterte.

16:41Sabi

16:41niya

16:41tungkol

16:41sa

16:42pa

16:42siya

16:42na

16:42Senado

16:42na

16:42i-archive

16:43ang

16:43impeachment

16:44complaint

16:44laban

16:44sa

16:44kanya.

16:45Kinahangla

16:46na to

16:46respetuhin

16:47ang

16:48role

16:48sa

16:49to

16:49ang

16:50Senate

16:50of

16:50the

16:51Philippines

16:51din

16:52sa

16:52to

16:53ang

16:53nasun

16:53o

16:53sa

16:54to

16:54ang

16:54demokrasya.

16:55So kung

16:55mauna

16:56ang

16:56desisyon

16:57sa

16:58majority

16:58sa

16:59members

16:59of

17:00the

17:00Senate

17:01everyone

17:01must

17:02follow

17:02and

17:03respect

17:03that

17:05decision

17:05of

17:05the

17:06Senate.

17:06Pero

17:07magpapatuloyan

17:07niya

17:08ang

17:08kanilang

17:08paghahanda.

17:09Kinahanglan

17:09panghandaman

17:10ang

17:10tanan

17:11na

17:11posibleng

17:12maitabo.

17:12So

17:13possibly

17:13wala

17:14takibalo

17:142026,

17:152027,

17:162028

17:17na

17:18ay

17:18mga

17:18magfile

17:20na

17:20impeachment.

17:22That

17:22will be

17:23another

17:23opportunity

17:25to answer.

17:27Nakipagkita rin

17:28si VP

17:28Duterte

17:29sa kanyang

17:29legal team

17:30at sa

17:30petitioners

17:31na nagsulong

17:31sa dismissal

17:32ng impeachment

17:33sa isang

17:34Thanksgiving

17:34celebration.

17:35Ayon sa

17:36Facebook

17:36post

17:36ni Davao

17:37City

17:37Counselor

17:37Atty.

17:38Luna

17:38Acosta

17:38na isa

17:39sa mga

17:39petitioner,

17:40kailangan

17:41pa nila

17:41maghahain

17:41ng

17:42komento

17:42sa

17:42motion

17:43for

17:43reconsideration

17:44na

17:44inihain

17:44ng

17:45House

17:45of

17:45Representatives.

17:46Anya,

17:47kumpiyansa

17:47sila

17:47sa kanilang

17:48legal

17:48arguments.

17:49Sinagot

17:49rin

17:50ni

17:50Duterte

17:50ang

17:51sinabi

17:51ni

17:51Palace

17:51Officer

17:52Attorney

17:52Claire

17:52Castro

17:53na meron

17:54silang

17:54impormasyon

17:54na pumunta

17:55umano

17:55ang

17:56visa

17:56ng

17:56Kuwait

17:56ng

17:57walang

17:57travel

17:57authority.

17:58Dapat

17:59dilita

17:59mag-propagate

18:02o

18:02misinformation

18:03and

18:04fake news

18:05and

18:06there's

18:07no

18:07truth

18:07at all

18:08na

18:09niya

18:10to

18:10cooperate

18:11without

18:11a

18:12travel

18:12authority.

18:18Emil,

18:19matapos

18:20ang

18:20misa

18:20na

18:20pasasalamat

18:21ay

18:21dinaluhan

18:22naman

18:22ni

18:22Vice

18:22President

18:23Sara

18:23ang

18:24pagtitipon

18:25ng mga

18:25barangay

18:25officials

18:26sa Davao

18:26City

18:27dito

18:27sa Result

18:28Park.

18:28Emil.

18:29Maraming

18:30salamat

18:30John D.

18:31Esteban

18:31ng GMA

18:32Regional TV.

VP SARA IMPEACHMENT: Mga reaksyon sa pag-archive ng senado sa impeachment complaint vs. VP Sara | 24 Oras

Category

Transcript

Recommended