Bench Powers Case: The Issue Intensifies, Reports Wasim Badami

ARY NEWS

Watch Bench Powers Case: The Issue Intensifies, Reports Wasim Badami - ARY NEWS on Dailymotion

Transcript

00:00The biggest court in Pakistan is currently discussing what the case is.

00:04The case is that the 26th amendment has been approved.

00:06As a result of that, the Chief Justice has been appointed, Yaya Afridi Sahib.

00:09Vandamante Mansoor Ali Shah Sahib.

00:10The 26th amendment has been approved. As a result of that, the Ayni Bench has been formed.

00:13Not the Ayni Court, but the Ayni Bench.

00:14The Chief Justice of which is Aminuddin Khan Sahib, whom Yaya Afridi Sahib has appointed.

00:19The objection to the government is that they have done the whole system on their own to put Mansoor Ali Shah Sahib aside.

00:23But when Yaya Afridi Sahib came,

00:25there was a thought that Mansoor Ali Shah Sahib will resign.

00:28Mansoor Ali Shah Sahib's case was worse than Faisal Sahib's and it was going on.

00:33But then there was an atmosphere that both the cases are better.

00:36Now what happened was that a case was filed, a tax-related case.

00:40And it was not filed in the Ayni Bench, but in the regular bench.

00:43And Mansoor Ali Shah Sahib was listening to that case.

00:46Then it came that from that bench, one judge was removed and another judge was appointed.

00:54And this created an impression.

00:55Because this debate arose during the hearing.

00:58One lawyer said that sir, this case that you are listening to, i.e. the regular bench,

01:01you cannot listen to this.

01:03This is the case of the Ayni Bench.

01:04Now how was this case filed in the regular bench?

01:06A committee was formed.

01:07That committee decides where and what will be filed.

01:11So the case has been filed.

01:12But then it happened that it created an impression that as soon as this case is removed from here,

01:15there is no point in taking it there.

01:16Now you see what today's remarks are.

01:19Mansoor Ali Shah Sahib has given remarks.

01:21Procedure Committee.

01:22This is the committee that decides which bench will listen to which case.

01:26He said, Mansoor Ali Shah Sahib, that if the Procedure Committee takes back the ongoing cases,

01:31the case is going on in the court, and takes it back and hands it over to the other bench,

01:34then the freedom of the court is over.

01:37Mansoor Ali Shah Sahib gave more remarks.

01:39Now this is very important.

01:40He is saying this directly in reference to the government.

01:41This means that where it seems that the decision can come against the government,

01:46then the case is taken back from the bench.

01:48This means that you have started a case and you think it is coming against the government.

01:51Then they will take it from us and hand it over to the other bench, which will be in your favor.

01:54The court questioned.

01:56They asked why the case was not decided despite the court's order.

02:00When we said that the case will be decided here, in front of this bench, then why didn't it happen?

02:03So it was said that the registrar of the Supreme Court said that in reality this case was not going to be filed in front of you.

02:10This case did not come from the bench.

02:12Then why was it filed in front of you?

02:13By mistake.

02:14This case was filed in the regular bench by mistake.

02:17This case did not come from the bench.

02:18Anyway, a development has also happened that after that the registrar has been made OSD,

02:22has been sidelined.

02:23How did you make this mistake?

02:24This has also been done by the Chief Justice of Pakistan.

02:26This is also today's development.

02:28Anyway, a judge of this bench, Aqeel Abbasi, said that this was a mistake.

02:34This was going on for a long time.

02:35So how did it come to light now?

02:37He also gave remarks that with apologies, the mistake was only to include me in this bench.

02:42I had heard this case in the High Court as well.

02:44Congratulations.

02:45Now Mr. Mansoor Ali Shah asks that how did the practice and procedure committee meet on this matter?

02:52Did the committee itself call for a meeting or did you request?

02:56The registrar of the Supreme Court said that we had written a note to the committee.

03:00Mr. Mansoor Ali Shah asked that when the judicial order was present, then why was the note written?

03:04That is, he is saying that on one hand there is the order of the practice and procedure committee.

03:08But if there is our order in front, we are saying that the case will be filed in front of this bench.

03:12Because the practice and procedure committee has already filed the case.

03:14So then our order should prevail and not that of the practice and procedure committee.

03:19Anyway, moving forward, let's see.

03:21Mr. Mansoor Ali Shah gave remarks.

03:23I don't know if this is a matter of humor or a matter of sarcasm.

03:28Mr. Mansoor Ali Shah gave remarks.

03:30This case may have been left by you by mistake.

03:33That is, it was to be filed in front of them, you filed it in front of us by mistake.

03:36But it came in front of us.

03:38But it came to the bench.

03:39Now the work of the committee is over.

03:41That is, once the committee has filed a case, it has been filed.

03:44Now this case will run there.

03:45If the cases are taken back while the committee is running, then the freedom of the court will be over.

03:50Justice Mansoor Ali Shah also gave remarks.

03:52That where the decision can be made against the government, then the case is taken back from the bench.

03:57And further he said, in which I was saying that maybe it is a matter of sarcasm or humor or I don't know what it is.

04:02Mr. Mansoor Ali Shah gave remarks.

04:04This case was left by you.

04:05It came in front of us.

04:07After all, God has also designed a plan.

04:10Justice Aqeel Abbasi said, in the case of tax, which amendment was to be reviewed?

04:15Which case was taken back?

04:17He gave remarks that the documents you are presenting are in defense of additional registrar judicial.

04:23There is a long story ahead of it.

04:24And then it also happened that these judges also wrote a letter to the Chief Justice of Pakistan.

04:29In front of the open media, in front of everyone.

04:31In which he expressed his complaint and astonishment as to how the matter is happening.

04:34So the story is brief in simple words.

04:36That the matter is right in front of the Supreme Court of Pakistan.

04:40Where some judges think that it was our right to hear this case.

04:45How can this be given to another judge or another bench from us?

04:49In this regard, there is a hearing tomorrow as well.

04:51In this regard, the registrar and the Supreme Court have been released.

04:54Additional registrar.

04:55And now there will be hearings ahead.

04:57And let's see where this case goes.

05:00It seems that the matter is also heating up in the Supreme Court of Pakistan.

05:05And maybe in the future, it will take a more serious direction.

05:08It is also true that the 26th amendment.

05:10On the basis of which the whole issue has been read.

05:13The 26th amendment has also been challenged.

05:15And its case is also on.

05:16If I am not mistaken, on January 27, the case of the 26th amendment.

05:19And let's see what happens there.

05:21Zindagi Sehat Rahi.

05:22Insha Allah.

05:23See you tomorrow.

05:24Till then, Allah Hafiz.

Category

Transcript

Recommended