Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
Trump tries to appeal to Arab and Muslim voters
FRANCE 24 English
Follow
10/31/2024
Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com
Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English
Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
Kamala Harris snapped back at Donald Trump this Thursday over what she called his very
00:04
offensive remarks about women.
00:06
Returning reproductive rights to the fore, the rivals take their knife-edge White House
00:10
race to Western battleground states, both holding rallies in Nevada this Thursday.
00:16
One of the seven swing states that will decide the fate of the United States presidency.
00:20
Harris will have the support of the pop star J-Lo, aka Jennifer Lopez.
00:25
Trump has a rally planned, as well as a media op with the far-right polemicist Tucker Carlson.
00:29
Four million Muslims live in the United States.
00:35
Their votes could well prove decisive in some of these swing states.
00:38
There is a big issue on their minds.
00:41
The fate of their fellow Muslims in the Gaza Strip.
00:44
The United States bankrolls Israel's military with $3.3 billion each year and has given
00:50
an additional $8 billion in recent weeks.
00:56
In the 2020 US election, she voted Democrat.
01:00
But Samra, a Muslim of Yemeni origin, says she will be voting for Donald Trump next week,
01:05
accusing the Biden administration of not doing enough to end the conflict in Gaza.
01:11
With Trump's history of anti-Muslim rhetoric, Samra describes her decision as a sacrifice.
01:17
But she says it's one she's willing to take in the hopes that Trump will halt the violence
01:20
in the Middle East.
01:23
By voting for Donald Trump, I recognize what comes with a Donald Trump presidency.
01:27
I'm willing to live in a state where there's, you know, fear at home, where there's more
01:33
stringent immigration policies, where there's, you know, detrimental rhetoric.
01:38
That's a sacrifice I'm willing to make as an Arab and a Muslim in America, in order
01:42
for us to save lives in Gaza.
01:45
And she's not the only one in the Muslim community to have changed her mind about the Democrats.
01:51
Inia, who lives in Detroit, also says she will not be voting for Harris.
01:56
Why would I vote for her? I voted for her and Biden four years ago. Now I feel guilty.
02:03
Never again I'm voting for... Probably Democrats are pro-war. This is the history of Democrats.
02:09
They like war. I'm not voting for Democrats anymore, for sure.
02:14
Others in the community say they will vote for Harris in the hopes of keeping Trump out
02:17
of office.
02:19
I do believe that Donald Trump, the way things are going, we will end up with a dictator
02:25
in office. It'll be a scary world for Muslims. It'll be a scary world for, you know, women.
02:34
In 2017, Trump sparked outrage amongst the Muslim community when he imposed a travel
02:38
ban from several Muslim-majority countries.
02:42
According to plans drawn up by his top immigration adviser, Trump may re-impose the ban if he
02:47
becomes president.
02:49
This comes at a time when he seems to be trying to appeal to Arab-American and Muslim voters,
02:54
inviting several Muslim leaders on stage with him at a campaign rally last week.
03:00
Let's begin, Ian Reifowitz, Distinguished Professor at SUNY Empire State University
03:04
in New York. Thank you, sir, for being with us. I hope you are well. How important is
03:09
the Muslim vote in this election?
03:11
Well, it's going to be such a close election that any community is important. Muslim Americans
03:18
represent approximately 1-2 percent of the population, but they do play a large role,
03:24
or a larger role, in Michigan, where they are disproportionately concentrated. We did
03:29
see a Muslim mayor of a relatively small city, Hamimchak, come out in favor of Trump. So
03:36
their vote does matter.
03:38
Numerically, it's not a huge community. For example, if you want to talk about the sides—and
03:45
I hate to use those words of what's going on in the Middle East—but the Jewish American
03:48
community is about 3 percent of the population. And there's a real question about whether
03:54
you're going to see some erosion there. Polling doesn't suggest you're going to see much of
03:58
an erosion there over, for example, let's say, Kamala Harris being seen as too supportive
04:05
or not condemning strongly enough some of the more extreme campus protests against Israel.
04:12
In some ways, Harris is sort of caught between a rock and a hard place on this issue.
04:16
Indeed. If you examine the intentions of both parties, there seems to be very little difference
04:22
in how they view the situation with Israel, both of saying Israel has the right to defend
04:26
itself, but clearly more indication from the Democrats that they would like to see what
04:31
is happening stop.
04:33
Right. Well, Donald Trump said recently that his main policy would be to, quote,
04:37
let Israel finish the job, which doesn't sound like he would put any constraints at all on
04:45
Israel. There's been tremendous constraints put on Israel by the Biden administration,
04:53
but behind the scenes they have certainly tried to get Netanyahu, the prime minister of Israel,
04:58
to take fewer extreme measures. And you could argue that a Trump White House would give
05:07
a green light to Netanyahu to do even more damage, to operate with less constraints and
05:14
less restraint when it comes to Gaza. Your report earlier, a few minutes ago, gave people some hope.
05:20
I do think it would have an impact on the election, as well as more importantly on the
05:27
lives of people in the Middle East, if there was some kind of truce announced between Israel and
05:32
Hezbollah and possibly one including Hamas before the election. We've got five days to go.
05:38
There is always the opportunity for an October surprise. Well, today's the last day of October,
05:43
and that would certainly be a big surprise that would help Paris.
05:46
Indeed. We look and wait for that then, Ian. In terms of the way the world is looking at this,
05:51
though, they look and hear the Biden administration saying to Netanyahu to be careful, to not kill
05:59
civilians, to stop the violence. And in a sense, the Biden administration has taught the talk. But
06:05
clearly it's had very little impact on Netanyahu, very little impact on Israel,
06:10
because funding has been increased in recent weeks, an additional $8 billion given to Israel
06:16
to help its military carry out what is happening on the ground right now. In terms of how Muslims
06:24
are looking at this, though, one can only imagine that they feel they've got no friend in either
06:28
party. Yes, I mean, you can certainly understand that. There was a push a few weeks ago where the
06:36
Israeli government was told by the Biden administration, listen, you've got to get
06:40
more aid into Gaza or else. And apparently that worked and more aid did flow into Gaza.
06:48
So it's a question of better or worse, even if the better option may not be seen as the best
06:55
option for Muslim Americans. They are in a very difficult situation. They are watching people that
07:03
they care about suffer. Certainly Jewish Americans have seen that as well in Israel. It's not an easy
07:10
decision, certainly for anybody. But one can look at the statement by Trump that he would let Israel
07:17
finish the job. And I think if there's some daylight between the Biden-Harris and Trump
07:24
approaches, I think it's that. Ian, what about other minorities in this election? Is there any other
07:31
particular minority that you feel might have a say, might have an important voice? I suppose all
07:36
voices are important, but you know what I'm getting at, is there one area we should be looking for?
07:40
Right. Numerically speaking, Indian Americans have been a democratic group. They might come out even
07:45
more strongly given that Kamala Harris does come from an Indian background. Her mother was an
07:51
Indian immigrant to the United States. They are very important. Certainly the largest groups among
07:56
non-white Americans are black and Latino Americans. There has been questions as to whether Harris will
08:03
do as well as Biden did. Some polls, including a very well-publicized New York Times poll, showed
08:08
her running behind Biden. However, more recently, an ABC News poll has showed her, even with black
08:14
and Latino men who were seen as a particularly likely group to run, to support her less than
08:20
they did Biden, they're actually supporting her more than they did Biden. From this ABC News poll,
08:25
Harris is running plus 74 among black men compared to plus 60 for Biden, and Harris is running plus
08:33
27 among Latino men compared to plus 23 for Biden. So I think you've got evidence in both directions.
08:39
At the end of the day, with an election that appears to be this close, every group matters,
08:44
but I think we've tried to cover in the last couple of minutes some of the most important ones.
08:48
Ian Reifowitz, as always, pleasure to have you here on France 24 and hear your very well-researched
08:53
and well-thought-out opinions. And based on research, of course, we must add Professor
08:58
Ian Reifowitz, Distinguished Professor at SUNY Empire State University. Thank you for joining
09:02
us here on France 24. Great to see you, sir. We'll keep you across all developments on the
09:07
US presidential election campaign between now and November the 5th. That's next Tuesday and beyond.
Recommended
1:10
|
Up next
John F. Kennedy Assassination 16mm Original - Driver shooting at Kennedy!
Jelani Trent
9/7/2015
1:55
Arab-Americans flock to Trump in US presidential election
FRANCE 24 English
11/7/2024
8:12
Middle East policy: how do Harris and Trump compare
FRANCE 24 English
9/23/2024
7:19
Harris and Trump focus on closing messages with rallies in Georgia, Nevada, Arizona
FRANCE 24 English
10/24/2024
8:19
Democrats, Republicans battle over election rules in Harris-Trump face off
FRANCE 24 English
9/26/2024
7:22
Harris media blitz aimed at connecting with younger white voters, Trump supporters, expert says
FRANCE 24 English
10/9/2024
2:04
US presidential election : Harris and Trump court hispanic voters
FRANCE 24 English
10/23/2024
0:42
Trump Woos Muslim Voters, Says He's 'Building The Biggest And Broadest' Peace Coalition: 'Kamala And Her Warmonger Cabinet Will Invade The Middle East'
Benzinga
11/5/2024
8:47
Trump and Harris make final pushes in key battleground states
FRANCE 24 English
10/21/2024
8:50
Harris and Trump in final push ahead of Tuesday vote
FRANCE 24 English
11/4/2024
7:33
Harris and Trump offer worlds-apart contrasts on top issues in presidential race
FRANCE 24 English
10/27/2024
16:26
Trump may try to leave a legacy of peacemaking in Middle East, but risks being manipulated: analyst
FRANCE 24 English
11/7/2024
6:59
Immigration a key issue in US presidential campaign
FRANCE 24 English
9/18/2024
1:35
Trump hurls a string of insults at Harris including 'lazy,' a racist trope against Black people
FRANCE 24 English
10/23/2024
2:09
Trump praises Al Sharaa, presses Syria leader on Israel ties after lifting sanctions
FRANCE 24 English
5/14/2025
1:16
Trump and Harris to debate on ABC; Trump says he wants two more
FRANCE 24 English
8/9/2024
2:01
Harris slams Trump for hypocrisy on abortion as US starts voting
FRANCE 24 English
9/22/2024
1:46
'Republicans for Harris': some former Trump staff calling to vote against him
FRANCE 24 English
8/21/2024
5:57
54% of Israelis would prefer Donald Trump to become the Americain president rather than Kamala Harris
FRANCE 24 English
10/23/2024
7:13
Europe concerned about a potential Trump victory
FRANCE 24 English
9/25/2024
2:18
'Palestinians expressing anger at Trump & at the PA leadership for a lack of direction'
i24NEWS (English)
12/15/2017
2:39
US embassy in Israel: Watch Donald Trump''s speech
FRANCE 24 English
5/14/2018
6:50
New York Times polls sees Trump ahead in three Sun Belt states
FRANCE 24 English
9/24/2024
1:56
Dutch election winner Geert Wilders: An anti-Islam firebrand known as the Dutch Donald Trump
FRANCE 24 English
11/23/2023
2:00
Americans in London react to Trump US Election victory
National World - LocalTV
11/6/2024