Senior Analysts' reacts to PTI protest in Islamabad

ARY NEWS

Transcript

00:00On one hand, Mohsin Aqvi says that we have failed the PTI strategy.

00:04PTI says that we have failed the government strategy.

00:07Who has failed?

00:09Pakistan.

00:11No one has succeeded. Pakistan is failing.

00:14Pakistan is being ruined as a state.

00:18Neither the government nor PTI has done a good job.

00:22Now if you want to explain this,

00:24you see, if there is no unity in the policy,

00:27and if the decisions are not being taken together,

00:29then this is what happens.

00:31A while ago, the Minister of Internal Affairs said that

00:34he is very ashamed of the citizens of Islamabad.

00:36You should have talked to PTI instead of being ashamed.

00:39If this was the case, then you should have got a place fixed.

00:42If this is their stubbornness, then some stubbornness should have ended.

00:46Or you should have been so strict that you would have let them not come

00:50according to your claim.

00:52The reality is that the PTI protest has ended without the announcement of leadership.

00:57Of course, they will wait for their leader's new decision.

01:00And will you hand over the citizens of Islamabad to the containers again?

01:04Will you close the roads?

01:06The Minister of Internal Affairs has no experience.

01:08Politically, whatever you say, he is far behind him.

01:11In administrative matters, talking to the army,

01:14being a representative of the establishment,

01:16and talking to politicians, there is a big difference.

01:20And this becomes a question mark for the entire government.

01:23If he was the commander of all these operations,

01:26then why wasn't he seen?

01:28My question is, was Mohsin Naqvi doing everything on his own accord?

01:35He must be doing it with the blessings of the Prime Minister.

01:38I have said that this is the failure of Pakistan.

01:41I have gathered everyone in it.

01:43First of all, in the government.

01:45I am saying that how many political consultations have taken place,

01:49how many times have you and I seen them,

01:51or a meeting has come in which the political leadership,

01:54which is of their unity, in which there is the People's Party,

01:57in which there is Muslim League Noon,

01:59how many meetings have they had?

02:01How many experiences does the Minister of Internal Affairs have?

02:03Don't you and we know that in 2016, Chaudhary Nisar Ali Khan,

02:05keeping in mind the experience of 2014,

02:07did not let Imran Khan come out of Bannikala.

02:09And Gandapur Sahib was seen running on the streets.

02:11And Parvez Khattak was not allowed to cross.

02:13Because he was also controlling Punjab at that time.

02:15All the police were running on his guesses and hints.

02:18So then Parvez Khattak was not allowed to come.

02:21Then Rana Sinhaullah was stopped by the Supreme Court.

02:24The Supreme Court had facilitated that Imran Khan should be allowed to come.

02:27So then he came and he left.

02:29So then this lack of experience is visible in front of you.

02:32And it is becoming a joke.

02:34It is necessary to understand this as soon as possible,

02:37that either he takes control himself,

02:39or set up a team,

02:41so that the experienced people are with Mohsin Naqvi.

02:44If Mohsin Naqvi thinks that he is successful,

02:46then I don't think that he is a big success.

02:48Very interesting.

02:49Majid Nizami Sahib, in your opinion,

02:51this Jalsa or whatever it was,

02:53this protest, has it ended?

02:55Because Rana Sahib is saying that it has ended unannounced.

02:59We have not seen any leadership of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf.

03:02Yesterday in my program, Sheikh Muqasab was saying that

03:04we are saving our MNAs to complete the numbers.

03:07But in reality, leadership as such did not come.

03:10Ali Amin Garnapur Sahib also came and went to KPK house.

03:13But will this protest continue tomorrow?

03:16Will this protest continue in the coming days?

03:18Or is this it?

03:22Thank you very much.

03:24Because in this political era,

03:26there are many things that are not in Pakistan's politics.

03:30So I think that this trend has also emerged,

03:34in which workers are leading the protest,

03:37and there is no leadership in it.

03:39The reason for this is that in recent days,

03:42especially in Tehreek-e-Insaf,

03:44we have come to see that

03:46in the point of view of leadership

03:48and in the point of view of workers,

03:50there is no conformity and there is no balance.

03:53Because of this,

03:55leadership, seeing its various compulsions,

03:58is a little on the back foot,

04:00and the workers are leading this thing.

04:02This can be positive for PTI in a way,

04:05but in national politics, this thing is harmful.

04:08Because when you are dealing with a crowd

04:11whose leadership is not in anyone's hands,

04:14then you get to see more scenes of such political tension.

04:20And today and yesterday,

04:22we saw that what happened in Islamabad,

04:25that the police had to retreat somewhere,

04:28whether it was because they maintained peace and security,

04:31or did not fire,

04:33or saved the lives of human beings.

04:35But despite all this,

04:37I think that there is a wrong tradition in politics

04:40in which there is a crowd in front of you without leadership.

04:44So I think that the elders of the state

04:47should come to an agreement

04:49by demonstrating intellectualism in this regard,

04:52because only the government can announce something.

04:56We saw that in August,

04:58such an effort was made

05:00in which Imran Khan convened the Jalsa,

05:03and some confidence building measures were taken.

05:06But after that, in the next Jalsa,

05:08we saw that everything turned upside down

05:11and went the other way.

05:13But there is still room for improvement,

05:15because the steps that are being taken by the government,

05:18I think the situation is getting worse

05:21instead of getting better.

Category

Transcript

Recommended