How Will a Minority Government Carry Out Majority Legislation? Expert Analysis

ARY NEWS

#supremecourt #legislation #constitutionalamendments #nationalassembly   How Will a Minority Government Carry Out Majority Legislation? Expert Analysis

Transcript

00:00The government, which is a minority government, how will it legislate?

00:06Secondly, why are the letters not clear enough?

00:09Why is it not clear in front of us?

00:12And this seems to be a very secretive legislation, which we can call an unseen package.

00:17Secondly, yesterday the government held a meeting of the National Assembly and Senate.

00:21So now, what is this number game?

00:23How will they get the numbers?

00:25This is a big question here.

00:27And in order to upset the judicial setup, which is a grand legislation,

00:31are all the Jamaats, especially if we talk about Maulana Fazl-ur-Rehman,

00:36because he matters a lot in this situation,

00:38are they supporting the government or not?

00:41Because when Noor Alam Khan was asked,

00:43that Maulana Sahib is on board,

00:45he used to say, no, this is my private bill.

00:49And the other members of Maulana Sahib's Jamaat say,

00:52yes, we have not yet considered this much.

00:55So what does Maulana Sahib say on this?

00:57But now we are understanding from Maulana Fazl-ur-Rehman's conversation

01:01that he is not supporting the increase of the tenure of the judge,

01:08the increase of the tenure of the Chief Justice.

01:10But he is talking about a committee, a package.

01:13And he says, the way the Army Chief's speech is held,

01:17if that method is adopted, then they can think again.

01:21So first of all, let's see what Maulana Sahib is saying,

01:25what does he think, should there be an extension or not?

01:51Maulana Sahib's suggestion has been heard,

02:11but very interestingly, when he was asked a question,

02:15that will you vote on this bill, or the government that is thinking,

02:19the reforms that it is bringing,

02:21he says that the reforms that we are proposing,

02:24if they come, then we will think about it.

02:28Let's listen to Maulana Sahib.

02:31So the JUI will not vote on this bill?

02:36Maulana Sahib says that the reforms that we are proposing,

02:39if they come, then we will think about it.

02:43Now, the picture that was not clear,

02:45is now becoming clear to us,

02:47that Rana Sanaullah Sahib is also endorsing what Maulana Sahib said,

02:52that we still have a doubt whether the JUI is with us or not.

02:56So Rana Sanaullah has taken a step forward and said that

02:59if you look at what Maulana Sahib is saying,

03:02then he is closer to what we are proposing.

03:05Let's listen to Rana Sanaullah.

03:08To increase the number of JUI's,

03:10we will have to make a constitutional amendment,

03:12that is an act, that will be legal.

03:15So Maulana Sahib has given a long speech after this,

03:21if you look at it,

03:24his position is not that of PTI or Sunni Tehreek.

03:29He is closer to our position.

03:34Now, before Noon League,

03:36if we want to know how much truth is in Rana Sanaullah's words,

03:40that he is saying that if you look at what we are proposing,

03:44Maulana Sahib is actually proposing the same reforms.

03:47So what is he saying, the Noon League,

03:49regarding the judicial set-up, let's look at it.

03:53The amendment can be made in the parliament.

03:55The Supreme Court Chief Justice's appointment can also be formalized.

03:59Their age can also be limited.

04:01The formula given on seniority can also be done.

04:04By the way, there are many countries where this seniority principle is not there.

04:08The principle is, the best judge.

04:10In the world, it happens that you have never said that

04:13the senior companions should be made CEOs.

04:16The best person is given a chance.

04:20The age should be put on success.

04:23Until you become an old man, we will not let you succeed.

04:30Let's move on to the next panel.

04:33Haider Naqvi Senior Advisor is with us.

04:35Hassan Ayub has joined us.

04:37Thank you so much, Hassan.

04:38Haider, you too.

04:39And our beloved Chaudhary Ghulam Hussain is also with us.

04:42So, with your permission, I will start with Mr. Chaudhary.

04:46Mr. Chaudhary, tell us, is this picture clear?

04:49What Mr. Maulana is talking about is actually the proposal of the Noon League.

04:54The claim of which is being made by Rana Sanaullah.

04:56So, will this be legalized now?

05:00Or, it is being said that he was not on one page earlier.

05:04Will he cast a vote or not?

05:06So, has he come to one page after this statement?

05:10It was not seen on this.

05:12He is just saying that seniority should not be the only basis

05:17for appointment of a Chief Justice.

05:20But, he does not agree with the rest of the things.

05:25Now, they are bringing the constitutional amendment

05:28or they are making the law.

05:31But, I think that the issue is that

05:34they have kept the week as a holiday,

05:36they have kept the Sunday as a holiday.

05:38Which doomsday is coming

05:40which you are moving very fast to avoid?

05:45Then, there is the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, on Monday.

05:51If you had kept it on Tuesday,

05:53what would have happened?

05:55I do not understand.

05:56But, we will see.

05:58We do not want to attack the intentions.

06:01Tomorrow, we will see what they present

06:03and what all things they want to do.

06:06So, if this is the policy

06:08that some judges who have given their independent opinion

06:11on some matters,

06:13they want to spoil it

06:15and some judges who are like-minded with them,

06:20they want to oblige them.

06:23So, we will see this by tomorrow evening.

06:26Let's not preach.

06:28But, there are a lot of tests.

06:30Will this bill come in tomorrow's session or not?

06:33Will others give time or not?

06:35Will all the issues be taken into consideration or not?

06:38We will have to see.

Category

Transcript

Recommended