Speaker National Assembly and Punjab Assembly send letters to Election Commission | Expert Analysis - video Dailymotion

ARY NEWS

#nationalassembly #punjabassembly #malikahmedkhan #ayazsadiq #electioncommission #supremecourt #khawarghumman #chaudhryghulamhussain #haidernaqvi #hassanayub   Speaker National Assembly and Punjab Assembly send letters to Election Commission | Expert Analysis

Transcript

00:00Mr. Sobhani, I think that the election commission was waiting for these letters.

00:07Mr. Chaudhary, your analysis is very unique.

00:15But it is true that the decisions of the election commission in the past are now painful for them.

00:27They accepted the Supreme Court's decision and appealed to the Supreme Court for guidance.

00:35Now that the Supreme Court has made a decision and the law has been amended,

00:43the law has been amended.

00:46Mr. Sobhani, thank you very much for your time.

00:49Mr. Hassan, you have already said that a petition is coming.

00:52It has come from the PMLN in front of the election commission.

00:56Now these two letters have also come in front.

00:58This question is being raised on it.

01:00If the law passed by the National Assembly was a precedent, then it should have been implemented a long time ago.

01:09A constitutional amendment is coming.

01:11You have seen the drama that took place in the city council in reference to the constitutional amendment.

01:14After that, Mr. Maulana said yesterday that we completely reject this petition.

01:21Now it is hot in the city council that the designated seats will go back to the status

01:28on which they were before the Supreme Court's decision.

01:32This means that the PTI was going to meet, it will meet the PDM communities again.

01:38Yes, Hassan, what is your information?

01:41Look, first of all, I would like to clarify a little.

01:44Maybe you wanted to say something.

01:47This is not a law passed by the National Assembly.

01:50This is basically Pakistan's Election Act 2017, which is a law of the present time.

01:57So basically, under Election Act 2017, this petition was passed.

02:02Mr. Hassan Ayub, you are very intelligent.

02:06We are completely in favor of your intelligence.

02:08I did not want to say anything wrong.

02:10I wanted to tell you that after the decision,

02:14Obviously, who has to pass the law?

02:16The National Assembly has to pass it.

02:18Even the Senate does it.

02:20Sir, it was initiated by the National Assembly.

02:23When the President is there, he assents it.

02:25When the President assents it, then the law is made.

02:27What are we talking about?

02:28Read the letter and tell me.

02:30Read the letter and tell me.

02:32Have you read the National Assembly letter?

02:33Read the letter and tell me.

02:34I am clarifying for you.

02:35Read it.

02:36Read it.

02:37No matter what the letter says, if the law is passed by the National Assembly and not the Senate, then the law will be made.

02:41Hassan Ayub, what kind of debate is this?

02:43Everyone knows that the National Assembly initiated it.

02:46There is nothing wrong in that.

02:51I was trying to tell you.

02:54The Speaker of the National Assembly says that these special sessions are the right of the National Assembly.

03:03The National Assembly is incomplete.

03:05So, the law that we have passed has been initiated by the Speaker of the National Assembly.

03:10Everyone knows this.

03:12The law is passed by the Senate and the President also assents it.

03:19I don't think we should waste time on such auxiliary things.

03:27Please go ahead, Mr. Hassan.

03:29Now, this is the matter that when the election act was amended on Bundelkhand, it was retrospective.

03:37Now, the problem is that it is also said that whatever amendment is being made, no court decision can affect it.

03:46Now, this is the law of the day.

03:48This is the law of the day.

03:50Now, when this is the law of the day, then the Election Commission has to act according to the law.

03:57The Supreme Court judges have also taken a step to act according to the law.

04:01So, the decision of the Election Commission is being discussed.

04:04Now, they have to focus on this.

04:06Their legal department also has to focus on this.

04:08And then, eventually, they will have to decide.

04:11But, really, it has become a little difficult for the Election Commission.

04:15But, is the law superior or the order of the Supreme Court?

04:21So, according to me, the law is above and the order of the Supreme Court will be below it.

04:28So, this is your opinion.

04:30Mr. Nagvi, obviously, there is a fight going on, a confrontation between the institutions.

04:36I don't think there is any doubt on this.

04:39Everyone is commenting on this.

04:41The decision is before the Election Commission of Pakistan on July 12.

04:46After that, on August 7, the law is passed.

04:51On August 8, the President of the country signs it.

04:55For Mr. Hassan Ayub's satisfaction, on August 9, this act is notified in the Gazette of Pakistan.

05:03It becomes the law of Pakistan.

05:06And the parliament passes it and the President of Pakistan signs it.

05:12After that, it becomes a part of the Gazette.

05:14Now, the question is being raised here.

05:18You, the Election Commission, have been sitting on one thing for so long.

05:23You have to follow any law on one thing.

05:25If you want to follow the decision of the Supreme Court, then follow it.

05:28If you want to follow the law of the National Assembly, Parliament or the Gazette of Pakistan, then follow it.

05:36Why are you hanging in the middle?

05:38Look, the matter did not end on August 9 when it came to the Gazette of Pakistan.

05:43Or when the decision of the Supreme Court came, the matter did not end after that.

05:47So, what is the law doing?

05:48The law is making you go round and round.

05:50And the party that gets the hand, makes it round and you are going round and round.

05:54Let's talk on the basis of logic.

05:56Wherever institutions are formed in the world, the offices of the institutions work according to their job description.

06:03That this is your job description and you have to follow it.

06:06Now, there is a big objection that why did the Speaker of the National Assembly and the Speaker of the Punjab Assembly write the letter?

06:11The Speaker of the National Assembly and the Speaker of the Punjab Assembly will demand that Iwan be completed.

06:16They did not write that these sessions should be given to our Jamaat.

06:20They said that these sessions should be decided as soon as possible under the law that has been passed.

06:26So, there is no objection at all that all these things are due to following the job description of every official.

06:34The Speaker is also following his job description.

06:37We are sitting in this show, our management is also following his job description.

06:43Job descriptions are being followed all over the world.

06:45So, let's put this aside.

06:47Now, let's see what is happening.

06:49You said a very good thing that this confrontation is going on.

06:52This will not end now.

06:53Now, this confrontation will end on a big stage.

06:57Now, what will that big stage be?

06:58The nation should wait for it.

06:59May Allah do good.

07:00May Allah save Pakistan from a big stage.

07:03No, it will not be about Pakistan.

07:05It will be about these governments and opposition.

07:08Obviously, when governments are in the front and back, the loss of the country and the state of Pakistan is obvious.

07:15Then we will not object to the government.

07:17We will not object to the government.

Speaker National Assembly and Punjab Assembly send letters to Election Commission | Expert Analysis

Category

Transcript

Recommended