The Scotsman Bulletin Wednesday April 17 2024 #HateCrime #Misogyny

The Scotsman

Scotsman deputy editor Alan Young speak to political correspondent David Bol about the Hate Crime law

Transcript

00:00 Hello and welcome to the Scotsman's Daily Bulletin for Wednesday. I'm Alan Young. I

00:14 am Deputy Editor of the Scotsman. I'm joined today by our Deputy Political Editor, David

00:19 Wald, to talk through some of the main stories. Hi, David.

00:23 Morning, Alan. How you doing?

00:25 Good. Let's have a look at the front page first off. And we lead today on the story

00:32 that Hamza Yousaf really can't get away from. We lead on his comments around the forthcoming

00:42 law around misogyny and his admission that trans women would be protected by it. This

00:51 is all tied in to the row over the Hate Crime Act, which we also feature on the front page

00:59 where women, if you remember, were not included and it has only added to the controversy.

01:06 We'll get into that with David in a minute. Also pictured on the front page there are

01:11 the Scots in the Team GB swimming squad ahead of the Paris Olympics. And we also feature

01:19 the news of a new manager for Aberdeen that they have announced at last. But David, there's

01:26 going to be a bit of drama in the Scottish Parliament today. I think we should start

01:31 by saying that this bid by the Tories to repeal the Hate Crime Act is going absolutely nowhere.

01:41 There's no chance that that's going to be voted through. And it's essentially a piece

01:45 of political theatre. But it will still be quite interesting to see if any SNP MPs rebel.

01:52 Yeah, that's right. I mean, like you said, it's not going to be repealed. Most of the

01:58 MSPs in Hollywood support this bill. And there's also problems if it was to be repealed because

02:03 it's consolidated some of the other sort of hate crime legislation. But it is a bit of

02:08 political theatre from the Tories. That's exactly what it is. They have an allocation

02:13 of time in Hollywood, and they've decided to bring this debate to really shine a light

02:17 on what they say is a really bad piece of legislation. It'll be interesting to see even

02:22 if some of the SNP and MSPs don't vote in favour of repealing it, there might be some

02:27 sort of words said or some concerns raised sort of internally of the SNP that could pose

02:33 quite a problem for Hamza Yousafzai Authority. We've obviously been in recess for a couple

02:37 of weeks. So there's not been a forum at Hollywood to sort of talk a lot of this out since it

02:41 launched on the 1st of April. So it's really the first big chance for a big, quiet, over-the-top

02:48 probably debate about it in Hollywood.

02:50 Indeed, and apologies for saying MPs there. I think I've caused you to do the same. So

02:56 of course MSPs in the Scottish Parliament. So talk us through the misogyny law, which

03:02 is what we lead on today. It's all wrapped up together, isn't it?

03:06 Yeah, it's basically the same people shouting about the same concerns on this, because the

03:11 Hate Crime Act, there's been so many different problems pointed out by critics, but one of

03:17 the original problems, other than the free speech and the other things we've discussed

03:21 it in great length, is the fact that the sex characteristic was left out of that as an

03:27 aggravator. There's one for age, disability, transgender and other sort of characteristics,

03:34 but not sex, because a review found that that needed its own law to tackle misogyny. So

03:41 it's basically seen this piece of legislation, the Hate Crime Act, isn't enough to sort of

03:46 embed that problem. So we'll do that. But that hasn't come forward yet. There are sort

03:52 of initial plans. So the Misogyny Act was kind of seen as quieting some of the criticism

04:02 that sex was not included in that. But yesterday, Hamza Yousaf was asked about whether trans

04:07 women would be included in that. And I don't think particularly surprisingly, he said that

04:12 they would, basically saying that they can face misogyny, trans women, and it's basically

04:18 that perception of the offender. But it's obviously lit a lot of this controversy again,

04:24 and upset from people who essentially don't believe that trans women are women and deserve

04:30 that same protection.

04:32 And just more widely on the Hate Crime Act, then. So there was a lot of noise about it.

04:38 We're two weeks in now, but we've got updated stats yesterday on how many reports are actually

04:44 coming in to Police Scotland.

04:45 Yeah, I mean, we had a huge surge in the first week, there were thousands, and we kind of

04:51 expected that to be the case. This week, we've seen the second week, it's dropped by 75%.

04:57 It's almost fallen off a cliff. There was obviously a lot of initial interest, whether

05:00 there was a lot of vexatious complaints in the first week that people just weren't bothering

05:05 with. But it does just show that that initial rush has kind of depleted a little bit. But

05:10 the concerns haven't really gone away. And hence why we're going to see this debate at

05:14 Holyrood today.

05:15 Indeed, indeed. What time does it kick off?

05:18 This afternoon, it's about half past two-ish, I think.

05:21 Right. Thanks very much, David. We'll of course be covering that at scottsman.com throughout

05:27 the day and in tomorrow's paper. If you're on the site, please do subscribe if you can,

05:32 then you will not miss a thing. And if you're out and about today, please do pick up a copy

05:37 of the paper from me and from David. Bye for now.

05:39 [Music]

05:46 you

Category

Transcript

Recommended