#PTI #intrapartyelection #KamranMurtaza #JUIF #sunniittehadcouncil #nationalassembly #sawalyehhai #mariamemon
PTI kay Intra Party Election kay bad kiya Makhsoos Nashistain PTI Ko Mil Payengi? Kamran Murtaza Analysis
PTI kay Intra Party Election kay bad kiya Makhsoos Nashistain PTI Ko Mil Payengi? Kamran Murtaza Analysis
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00 The situation is that Tariq-e-Ishaq has got its inter-party election done.
00:04 Now they will announce it on 3rd.
00:06 Do you think that they will legally have the opportunity to claim seats?
00:11 Because I know your plea, you said that Sunni Tehreek-e-Ishaq cannot get seats.
00:16 But now that they have got their election done, will they legally have the opportunity?
00:20 I will give you an example for this.
00:24 First of all, let me clarify that we did not go to the Election Commission for seats.
00:31 We were sent a notice by the Election Commission as a parliamentary party.
00:36 And we gave legal assistance in response to that.
00:39 Now when you give legal assistance, listen to an easy answer.
00:43 Suppose there is an election in Istanbul.
00:46 And in the election, there is a final date.
00:50 It is time-bounded.
00:52 The date is set for the first of March.
00:56 I come and file the paper on the first of March.
00:59 And no one else does that.
01:02 Only one person has proposed me and the other has seconded me.
01:07 I may not be related to Istanbul.
01:10 But two people from Istanbul have proposed me and seconded me.
01:13 And no one has filed the paper.
01:15 Can someone come and say that on the second of March, when this date is over,
01:20 Mr. Kamran has become unopposed.
01:23 No one has filed a paper on the first of March.
01:26 So, he has become unopposed.
01:27 So, can he be allowed to have his election done?
01:31 Is it possible?
01:33 Although I did not get a single vote.
01:35 A citizen of Istanbul proposed me and the other seconded me.
01:38 I do not know if they would come to vote or not.
01:41 So, the question is that when a path has been set by the law and it is time-bounded,
01:47 two or three things should have been considered together.
01:50 This is not a question of greed as to how it is being posed.
01:53 This is not a question of stealing something as to how it is being posed.
01:57 This is a legal proposition.
02:00 There are three provisions of the constitution.
02:02 Article 51, Article 106 and Article 224.
02:06 Keep these three provisions in mind.
02:11 There are 104 sections of the Election Act.
02:15 There is a method in this and a time cut-off date has been given.
02:22 Mr. Kamran, your argument is based on this.
02:27 When the Balochistan party was formed,
02:29 the woman was given a seat and the elections were held in 2018.
02:32 I will answer this question.
02:36 If a person commits a crime and is released,
02:42 and if he is not caught and his work is not done properly,
02:46 will the other person be allowed to do the wrong work?
02:49 When someone calls me for legal assistance,
02:52 I will share my understanding of the law in that forum.
02:57 I have no connection with the past.
03:02 I have no connection with the past.
03:07 I have only connection with the past.
03:09 I was called for legal assistance as a party.
03:13 I have to provide legal assistance.
03:16 This is not a constitutional issue.
03:20 There will be elections for the President of Pakistan.
03:25 The current election numbers will affect the election numbers of the Jamaat.
03:32 The inclusion of the Jamaat in the political system will affect the election numbers.
03:35 This is not a political and constitutional issue.
03:37 No.
03:40 This issue has been reserved.
03:43 The decision will be made in a few days.
03:46 If the decision is against our arguments,
03:51 then the claimant will get all the seats.
03:56 If the claimant does not get all the seats,
03:59 then the other parties will get the seats according to the schedule.
04:06 After the list is exhausted,
04:09 the extension will be given according to the law.
04:13 Then the house will be completed.
04:15 The optics of the house will be that the seats will be given according to the mandate of the political party.
04:27 The mandate seats will be given to the other parties.
04:31 The minorities and women who belong to that party will not get seats.
04:36 So, a certain party will not have the representation of minorities and women.
04:40 The other parties will have the representation of minorities and women.
04:43 Sir, how does this look politically?
04:45 I think I could not explain my point to you.
04:49 I am telling you that this was time-bounded.
04:53 If I do not get a single vote in Islamabad,
04:59 if there is only one proposer and one seconder,
05:02 and I am only going to file a single paper,
05:05 which has been given by the Election Commission under Section 58,
05:08 I did not get a single vote.
05:12 But I will still be elected.
05:15 So, whatever work you have to do, you have to do it under the law.
05:19 If you make a mistake,
05:22 and you have gone against the law,
05:25 and that mistake is a false mistake,
05:27 after that false mistake,
05:29 you will be sent a mandate for a certain thing,
05:33 and a mandate for a certain thing.
05:35 If all the mandates that they are giving,
05:40 if there were no papers filed against them,
05:43 they would have been unopposed.
05:45 So, this is how this case is handled.
05:49 What does the law say?
05:51 Look at the simple language of the law,
05:53 you will understand.
05:55 Sir, I want to understand.
05:57 We should give it an emotional color.
05:59 Sir, there is a political and legal aspect to this.
06:02 When the legal and political aspects merge,
06:05 then what happened in 2019 in the case of the Balochistan Nawami Party,
06:09 my understanding was that the election commission has a prerogative for interpretation,
06:15 they thought it was appropriate that representation was necessary,
06:18 so that seat was given.
06:20 So, this is the position of the election commission.
06:22 Did this happen in this case?
06:24 Was it there before?
06:26 I do not believe your understanding is correct.
06:30 Your understanding is not correct.
06:32 And the legal experts you have consulted,
06:35 I question their understanding as well.
06:37 Sir, I am quoting Ahmed Bilal Mahboob.
06:39 Let me quote him.
06:41 Listen to me.
06:43 I will answer your question.
06:46 But I think the counter argument is not very appropriate.
06:50 Take my opinion.
06:52 Then you see the plain language,
06:54 the provisions I have referred,
06:56 read it comfortably,
06:58 then you make your judgment according to that law.
07:01 If you want to solve a political issue,
07:05 if you want to go against the law,
07:07 then you can break that law.
07:09 If you say that it happened in the past,
07:11 it is discretion,
07:13 it is not discretionary,
07:15 this is very easy.
07:17 You sit alone and read it for 10-15 minutes,
07:19 and then you can think about it.
07:21 Then if it is time-bound,
07:23 you will have to look at its schedule.
07:26 If it is time-bound and no party has claimed in it,
07:30 it has filed a list for a certain date,
07:33 and then that party comes and says
07:35 that we do not even want seats.
07:37 Can that party still be given seats or not?
07:40 Look at it comfortably.
07:42 You will be clear.
07:44 It is very easy.
07:46 There is no rocket science in it.