• last year
#PTI #intrapartyelection #KamranMurtaza #JUIF #sunniittehadcouncil #nationalassembly #sawalyehhai #mariamemon

PTI kay Intra Party Election kay bad kiya Makhsoos Nashistain PTI Ko Mil Payengi? Kamran Murtaza Analysis
Transcript
00:00 The situation is that Tariq-e-Ishaq has got its inter-party election done.
00:04 Now they will announce it on 3rd.
00:06 Do you think that they will legally have the opportunity to claim seats?
00:11 Because I know your plea, you said that Sunni Tehreek-e-Ishaq cannot get seats.
00:16 But now that they have got their election done, will they legally have the opportunity?
00:20 I will give you an example for this.
00:24 First of all, let me clarify that we did not go to the Election Commission for seats.
00:31 We were sent a notice by the Election Commission as a parliamentary party.
00:36 And we gave legal assistance in response to that.
00:39 Now when you give legal assistance, listen to an easy answer.
00:43 Suppose there is an election in Istanbul.
00:46 And in the election, there is a final date.
00:50 It is time-bounded.
00:52 The date is set for the first of March.
00:56 I come and file the paper on the first of March.
00:59 And no one else does that.
01:02 Only one person has proposed me and the other has seconded me.
01:07 I may not be related to Istanbul.
01:10 But two people from Istanbul have proposed me and seconded me.
01:13 And no one has filed the paper.
01:15 Can someone come and say that on the second of March, when this date is over,
01:20 Mr. Kamran has become unopposed.
01:23 No one has filed a paper on the first of March.
01:26 So, he has become unopposed.
01:27 So, can he be allowed to have his election done?
01:31 Is it possible?
01:33 Although I did not get a single vote.
01:35 A citizen of Istanbul proposed me and the other seconded me.
01:38 I do not know if they would come to vote or not.
01:41 So, the question is that when a path has been set by the law and it is time-bounded,
01:47 two or three things should have been considered together.
01:50 This is not a question of greed as to how it is being posed.
01:53 This is not a question of stealing something as to how it is being posed.
01:57 This is a legal proposition.
02:00 There are three provisions of the constitution.
02:02 Article 51, Article 106 and Article 224.
02:06 Keep these three provisions in mind.
02:11 There are 104 sections of the Election Act.
02:15 There is a method in this and a time cut-off date has been given.
02:22 Mr. Kamran, your argument is based on this.
02:27 When the Balochistan party was formed,
02:29 the woman was given a seat and the elections were held in 2018.
02:32 I will answer this question.
02:36 If a person commits a crime and is released,
02:42 and if he is not caught and his work is not done properly,
02:46 will the other person be allowed to do the wrong work?
02:49 When someone calls me for legal assistance,
02:52 I will share my understanding of the law in that forum.
02:57 I have no connection with the past.
03:02 I have no connection with the past.
03:07 I have only connection with the past.
03:09 I was called for legal assistance as a party.
03:13 I have to provide legal assistance.
03:16 This is not a constitutional issue.
03:20 There will be elections for the President of Pakistan.
03:25 The current election numbers will affect the election numbers of the Jamaat.
03:32 The inclusion of the Jamaat in the political system will affect the election numbers.
03:35 This is not a political and constitutional issue.
03:37 No.
03:40 This issue has been reserved.
03:43 The decision will be made in a few days.
03:46 If the decision is against our arguments,
03:51 then the claimant will get all the seats.
03:56 If the claimant does not get all the seats,
03:59 then the other parties will get the seats according to the schedule.
04:06 After the list is exhausted,
04:09 the extension will be given according to the law.
04:13 Then the house will be completed.
04:15 The optics of the house will be that the seats will be given according to the mandate of the political party.
04:27 The mandate seats will be given to the other parties.
04:31 The minorities and women who belong to that party will not get seats.
04:36 So, a certain party will not have the representation of minorities and women.
04:40 The other parties will have the representation of minorities and women.
04:43 Sir, how does this look politically?
04:45 I think I could not explain my point to you.
04:49 I am telling you that this was time-bounded.
04:53 If I do not get a single vote in Islamabad,
04:59 if there is only one proposer and one seconder,
05:02 and I am only going to file a single paper,
05:05 which has been given by the Election Commission under Section 58,
05:08 I did not get a single vote.
05:12 But I will still be elected.
05:15 So, whatever work you have to do, you have to do it under the law.
05:19 If you make a mistake,
05:22 and you have gone against the law,
05:25 and that mistake is a false mistake,
05:27 after that false mistake,
05:29 you will be sent a mandate for a certain thing,
05:33 and a mandate for a certain thing.
05:35 If all the mandates that they are giving,
05:40 if there were no papers filed against them,
05:43 they would have been unopposed.
05:45 So, this is how this case is handled.
05:49 What does the law say?
05:51 Look at the simple language of the law,
05:53 you will understand.
05:55 Sir, I want to understand.
05:57 We should give it an emotional color.
05:59 Sir, there is a political and legal aspect to this.
06:02 When the legal and political aspects merge,
06:05 then what happened in 2019 in the case of the Balochistan Nawami Party,
06:09 my understanding was that the election commission has a prerogative for interpretation,
06:15 they thought it was appropriate that representation was necessary,
06:18 so that seat was given.
06:20 So, this is the position of the election commission.
06:22 Did this happen in this case?
06:24 Was it there before?
06:26 I do not believe your understanding is correct.
06:30 Your understanding is not correct.
06:32 And the legal experts you have consulted,
06:35 I question their understanding as well.
06:37 Sir, I am quoting Ahmed Bilal Mahboob.
06:39 Let me quote him.
06:41 Listen to me.
06:43 I will answer your question.
06:46 But I think the counter argument is not very appropriate.
06:50 Take my opinion.
06:52 Then you see the plain language,
06:54 the provisions I have referred,
06:56 read it comfortably,
06:58 then you make your judgment according to that law.
07:01 If you want to solve a political issue,
07:05 if you want to go against the law,
07:07 then you can break that law.
07:09 If you say that it happened in the past,
07:11 it is discretion,
07:13 it is not discretionary,
07:15 this is very easy.
07:17 You sit alone and read it for 10-15 minutes,
07:19 and then you can think about it.
07:21 Then if it is time-bound,
07:23 you will have to look at its schedule.
07:26 If it is time-bound and no party has claimed in it,
07:30 it has filed a list for a certain date,
07:33 and then that party comes and says
07:35 that we do not even want seats.
07:37 Can that party still be given seats or not?
07:40 Look at it comfortably.
07:42 You will be clear.
07:44 It is very easy.
07:46 There is no rocket science in it.

Recommended