Skip to playerSkip to main contentSkip to footer
  • 2 days ago

Category

📚
Learning
Transcript
00:00So, my name is Corbett. I am a final year undergraduate from the department of mechanical
00:06engineering, IIT company. My question is, what is more important in life? To know what to do
00:11or to know what we must not do? I am unable to look at your face. There is something that
00:19there is a gap and also probably the light is a bit dim. Can we do something about it?
00:25I will write you in my phone slash. Yeah, better. Now you can look into your eyes.
00:40Yes, come again please. Just that one line of the question. So, my question is, what is
00:48more important in life? To know what to do or to know what not to do?
00:52See, doing or not doing, both are functions of the doer. Right? The doer is the one making
01:08the choice. The doer is the one making the choice. You are asking, do I trust the output
01:25output? Of a certain instrument, a certain gadget? And if I trust the output, you know,
01:38if the gadget says, go left, is that more important than the instruction to go right? Let's say
01:47you have an instrument with you. And the instrument, let's say it's on your dashboard, on the dashboard
01:54of your car or bike or something. It can instruct you to go left or it can instruct you to go right.
02:03It's a positioning system, LPS, life positioning system. It can tell you go left or it can tell
02:10you go right. You are asking me, what's more important? Going left or going right? What's more
02:18important? To know what to do or to know what not to do? My question is, is your LPS trustworthy first
02:28of all? Because doing or not doing, I repeat, are functions of the doer. The doer is the instrument.
02:38Is the instrument first of all reliable? Who's the one making choice within? Who's setting these
02:46options in front of you? Who's coming to you and saying, oh, these are the options if you,
02:53if you do something, these are the options in favor of not doing something? Have you gone
03:02into the inner machine? That's the job of the engineer, right? To go into the machine. If
03:08the machine is all right, it will perform rightly. If the internal fundamentals are not in place,
03:14then we do not bother too much about the output. The output we know will be wrong. And if sometimes
03:25the output appears to be correct, that's just a fluke. It cannot last long. It's not repeatable.
03:32How do most people know what to do? And you will surely be finding people around you.
03:45I'm sure you are an intelligent and observant fellow. Have you not seen people who are very
03:50sure about themselves? And you wonder from where do they gather such confidence? How do they
03:59exactly know what to do? Because they have never bothered to investigate from where is their
04:08doership arising? They have instincts. And those are all conditioned instincts.
04:18I know I needed to get into IIT. But why exactly? And very few people will have any kind of depth
04:29in their response to this question. I very well know I need to write my GRE and then fly off
04:39to the US. How do you know this? How do you know that this is the right thing to do? Very few people
04:47will know. A lot of Muslims know that all others are infidels and therefore do not deserve to be liked.
05:06A lot of Muslims know. A lot of Hindus know that their religion is the best one.
05:12And with great confidence they will say all these things. The Hindus, the Muslims, the Christians,
05:20the Buddhists.
05:24How do they know with such surety?
05:31Well, at the age of 24 I will pass out and
05:34I suppose I must have a BMW by 30. How do you know? Who told you?
05:48I think I will have just two kids.
05:52One by the time I am 30 or something. Another before I am 35.
05:57How do you know?
06:03How do you know?
06:08Let's celebrate.
06:12And if you are celebrating, nobody is going to keep quiet.
06:16It's a party.
06:17Let there be noise.
06:18Nobody should be silent in a celebration.
06:28It's a don't, right?
06:29Don't.
06:30Don't be quiet in the middle of a party or a celebration.
06:35How do you know that this is something
06:37to never be done?
06:42From where did this come to you?
06:43Do you see that we are trying to
06:48take your attention
06:50to the inner machine that generates
06:52the list of do's and don'ts?
06:56Do you see that
06:57practically everybody
07:00has that inner list of do's and don'ts?
07:05And the generator of that list
07:07is
07:09an alien
07:11one
07:12masquerading
07:14as you.
07:16Okay, that's
07:17that's a bit too complex.
07:20The generator of that list
07:21has been corrupted
07:23by alien influences.
07:29Huh?
07:31If I am born as an Indian
07:33I have an Indian list
07:35of do's and don'ts.
07:37If I am born as a Chinese
07:38I have a Chinese list.
07:39born as a
07:44North Indian male
07:45you have one list
07:49of do's and don'ts.
07:52Born as a
07:54female
07:54in the North East
07:56you will have a
07:58very different list
07:59of do's and don'ts.
08:04They are not yours.
08:05the generator
08:07itself is
08:09not
08:10authentically
08:11you.
08:13Then how can these
08:14do's and don'ts matter?
08:17And then it becomes
08:18rather
08:18bewildering
08:19and quite amusing.
08:24A lot
08:24of people
08:25spend their entire lives
08:27just following
08:29this list of do's and don'ts.
08:31They do not bother
08:32to question
08:33where these commandments
08:34are coming from.
08:38Do you understand?
08:40Huh?
08:43Now that you are an
08:44IITN
08:45how can you be a dancer?
08:47So don't be a dancer
08:48given that you are an IITN.
08:52Who
08:52who decided that
08:54exactly?
08:57Huh?
08:57I am not encouraging
09:00you to be an answer.
09:01I am just
09:01I am just
09:03pointing to the fact
09:04that
09:04there are certain
09:06things
09:06that become
09:07inconceivable
09:08and we do not
09:11ask ourselves
09:12how
09:12when
09:13did they
09:15become
09:16prohibited?
09:18What was the
09:19inner agency
09:20making the
09:22decisions?
09:26Hmm?
09:26I must
09:28have
09:29a fat
09:29job
09:30but
09:32brother
09:33you
09:34were
09:35never
09:36quite
09:36greedy.
09:38I know
09:39you.
09:41There are
09:41so many
09:42other things
09:42in life
09:43that have
09:43mattered
09:44to you.
09:46You
09:46are somebody
09:47with taste
09:48for
09:48fun
09:49enjoyment.
09:52You like
09:53hanging out
09:53with friends.
09:56Hmm?
09:56you like
09:58being with
09:58your
09:59girlfriend.
10:01You like
10:02trekking,
10:03hiking,
10:03those things.
10:06And you
10:07feel so
10:08wonderful when
10:08you are
10:09immersed
10:09in a
10:11great book.
10:14Sartre,
10:15Mopasa
10:16or Indian
10:18literature.
10:20But now
10:21that you are
10:21in IIT
10:22you feel
10:24a great
10:25pressure.
10:26I must
10:26have
10:27a fat
10:28job.
10:28From
10:28where did
10:29this
10:29commandment
10:30come to
10:30you?
10:33Who is
10:33the inner
10:34decision maker?
10:35Is that
10:36you or
10:37is that
10:38someone
10:38greatly
10:39influenced
10:40by the
10:40surroundings?
10:41things?
10:46Don't do
10:47this,
10:47don't do
10:47this.
10:48We often
10:48say,
10:48oh,
10:48there is
10:49that little
10:49voice inside
10:50us.
10:50We call
10:51it
10:51conscience.
10:54Wisdom
10:54is to
10:55realize that
10:55your conscience
10:56is all
10:57artificial,
10:58100%
10:59influenced.
11:02And that's
11:02why the
11:03so-called
11:04inner
11:05conscience
11:05is totally
11:06outer.
11:09And varies
11:10from person
11:10to person.
11:13People have
11:14done horrible
11:14deeds
11:15based on
11:16the advice
11:17of their
11:17conscience.
11:23Hitler
11:23too,
11:24in his own
11:24eyes,
11:25must have
11:25been a
11:25man of
11:26conscience.
11:34So,
11:35who is
11:35the
11:35doer?
11:39Who is
11:40the
11:40doer?
11:46What does
11:46he want
11:47to achieve
11:47through the
11:48deed?
11:51If he
11:52says do
11:52something,
11:53he has
11:53eyes on
11:54the result
11:55probably.
11:56If he
11:57says do
11:57not do
11:58something,
11:58he wants
11:59to save
12:01something
12:01probably.
12:05what is
12:06it that
12:06he wants
12:07to gain?
12:08What is
12:08it that
12:08he wants
12:09to save?
12:12From
12:12where do
12:13his thoughts
12:15and emotions
12:16arise?
12:17Because action
12:18is an
12:18instinct,
12:19right?
12:19You say,
12:20I'll act.
12:21You act
12:21because you
12:22want to
12:22change
12:22something.
12:26Desireless
12:27action
12:27is not
12:29something we
12:30know of.
12:30we act
12:32because we
12:33want something
12:33from the
12:34action,
12:35the deed.
12:36What is
12:37it that
12:37we want?
12:38How do
12:39we know
12:39that the
12:40thing that
12:41we want
12:42from the
12:42deed is
12:43indeed useful
12:43to us?
12:46It's
12:47alright to
12:48have a
12:50target.
12:51It's
12:52alright to
12:53demand something
12:53from your
12:54action.
12:55I'm acting
12:56to reach
12:57that place.
12:58I'm walking.
12:59That's the
13:00deed.
13:00I'm walking.
13:01I want to
13:02reach that
13:02point.
13:03How do
13:04I know
13:04that that
13:05point really
13:06holds something
13:07meaningful for
13:08me?
13:11Who told
13:12me that
13:13that particular
13:14point indeed
13:15has a
13:18thing of
13:18importance?
13:21These are
13:22the questions
13:22that a
13:23young intelligent
13:24man must
13:24ask himself.
13:28Otherwise,
13:28life is
13:31a short
13:31affair.
13:32You can
13:33very easily
13:34squander it
13:34away in
13:35meaningless
13:36kind of
13:37motion,
13:37random
13:38motion.
13:39Oh,
13:39Brownian motion
13:40you know
13:40of,
13:40right?
13:42Think of
13:43the molecules,
13:44think of
13:44the atoms
13:46all the
13:47time,
13:48their entire
13:48duration.
13:49motion.
13:51They are
13:52just moving,
13:53moving,
13:53moving and
13:54colliding and
13:54changing their
13:55path and
13:56moving with
13:57great velocities,
13:58don't they?
13:58if they were
14:04humans,
14:06we would
14:08really
14:09felicitate
14:11them.
14:11We will
14:11say look
14:11at,
14:12look at
14:13these
14:13little things,
14:15the molecules,
14:16they are all
14:17karmiyogis.
14:19They are
14:20constantly in
14:21action,
14:21they are
14:22constantly doing
14:23something.
14:23It's not
14:26about just
14:27doing
14:27something.
14:30It's about
14:31knowing the
14:31doer.
14:35Know why
14:36there must
14:37be movement
14:38at all.
14:39Know who
14:39you are.
14:41Know what
14:42is it that
14:43you lack.
14:44Know what
14:45is it that
14:45you need to
14:46shed.
14:48And then
14:49the deed
14:50is right.
14:53then you
14:56know the
14:57one right
14:58direction for
14:59you,
15:00unambiguously,
15:01choicelessly.
15:09Again,
15:10makes me
15:11wonder if
15:12I have been
15:12able to
15:13communicate.
15:14Am I
15:15through to
15:15you?
15:17Yes,
15:18sir.
15:18That was
15:18actually an
15:19insight for
15:19one,
15:19sir.
15:20I expected
15:20not such
15:21a deeper
15:21insights.
15:23You and
15:24each one of
15:26you on the
15:27other side
15:27of the
15:28screen are
15:29most welcome
15:29to ask for
15:31clarification or
15:32pose a
15:33counter.
15:34I welcome
15:34that.

Recommended