Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
Mike Levin Asks Energy Sec. Chris Wright About Cost-Benefit Of Different Types Of Energy Generation
Forbes Breaking News
Follow
5/21/2025
During a House Appropriations Committee hearing earlier this month, Rep. Mike Levin (D-CA) questioned Energy Secretary Chris Wright about cost-benefit analysis of energy generation types.
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
You're recognized to close.
00:01
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
00:02
And since everybody's inviting you, Mr. Secretary,
00:04
I have to invite you to the great state of California
00:06
and to come out and see the San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station.
00:09
Look forward to working with you on that.
00:11
I wanted to ask about something that my friend from Indiana,
00:16
Congressman Mervan, brought up, which is the hydrogen hubs.
00:19
And specifically, I wanted to make sure that you had received a bipartisan letter
00:25
that we had sent on April the 7th about our hub in California called Arches.
00:32
It's a great project to boost energy security.
00:35
Obviously, we want to decarbonize things that are, you know, very tough to do,
00:41
like steel and shipping and trucking, great American innovation in a more resilient future.
00:48
I would love to get any input that you might have.
00:51
I know you said that, you know, you're reviewing all these things.
00:55
I know you've got a lot of incoming, but we would be very grateful to have a reply
00:59
to that bipartisan letter that we sent about a month ago
01:02
and just get a sense of, you know, your thoughts on the hubs and specifically on Arches.
01:09
Yes, and again, I'm very cautious about giving answers when I don't really have an answer.
01:16
You know, I've assembled a team and a process that's not political,
01:21
that's not focused on buzzwords.
01:23
It's just a business, technology, business, and end market overview of projects.
01:29
You know, we want, if we're going to invest a lot of money,
01:31
we want something at the other end that's going to go forward,
01:34
that's going to have customers and offtakers and move on with it.
01:38
You mentioned that the hydrogen hub there particularly focused on decarbonization,
01:42
and that's, you know, greenhouse gas emissions in the United States on a per capita basis
01:47
are lower than any year since I was born.
01:50
So we have had market forces driving decarbonization.
01:54
Wealthier countries in general move to less carbon-intensive energy systems,
01:58
and I think this is a positive, and I think you'll see a continuation of that trend.
02:03
And so things on decarbonization is more about what's the cost?
02:07
What's the dollar per avoided ton of CO2-equivalent emission?
02:13
And if that dollar per ton is low and market forces, buyers of those products or users of that
02:21
will pay that cost to drive that process, that's great.
02:26
That's technology at work and customers coming into a marketplace to drive things forward.
02:30
So that's basically the criterion.
02:32
Is the technology viable?
02:34
What does the engineering show?
02:35
What does it look like the end cost might be?
02:37
Is there a marketplace of people willing to pay that cost?
02:41
That's the, you know, we're letting kind of the marketplace of businesses and people
02:46
to decide what's viable and not what's viable, not what we like or what we don't like.
02:51
It's just sort of an objective business and technological evaluation.
02:55
When do you anticipate we might get a reply?
02:57
This summer.
02:58
This summer.
02:58
I wish it was faster.
03:00
You know, in the hundred days, you know, one of the things that slowed me down is getting
03:04
people, getting qualified business professionals inside of the house and then develop a independent
03:10
thing that every project will go through the same thing and we'll get results out.
03:15
But that is now rolling.
03:17
People are in there.
03:18
And so it's, you know, I wish it had been last month.
03:21
But to me, it's more important to get sort of the right answers because we've got a limited
03:25
amount of resources, right?
03:26
We want to get the greatest bang for the buck for every resource, you know, we deploy.
03:31
I share your desire to get the greatest bang for the buck.
03:33
I guess I want to unpack or understand a little bit about how you evaluate the cost benefit
03:39
of different types of electricity generation.
03:42
So before you talked about geothermal being something that was intriguing to you.
03:48
I don't want to mischaracterize what you said.
03:50
But, you know, relatively low cost and high benefit.
03:54
We've talked a lot about nuclear.
03:56
Of course, nuclear has a very high levelized cost of energy, new nuclear compared to certain
04:00
other sources, but also has, you know, significant benefits, too.
04:04
We've got to fix the back end of the fuel cycle, as I will repeatedly say.
04:09
Yes.
04:09
Can you speak to, you know, how you evaluate other sources of electricity?
04:14
You know, we talked a bit about solar.
04:16
I'd love to get your thoughts on, you know, I want to figure out how we can best work with
04:20
you is what I'm trying to say.
04:22
Yes.
04:22
Yeah.
04:23
So, again, great question as were your previous ones.
04:25
So there it's, I think the key thing on electricity, electricity is complicated.
04:29
So it's more difficult than other things because everything fits into a big complicated system.
04:34
And what matters is the system cost.
04:38
Like you use the term levelized cost of electricity.
04:41
And I have been for years, you know, a virulent critic of that term.
04:46
Good to know.
04:47
Because it treats electricity as if it's like your gas tank.
04:50
You put a little bit in and you take a little bit out and you put a little bit.
04:53
It's just not how electricity works.
04:54
At every moment in time, you have to balance supply and demand.
04:59
So the most critical design for an electricity grid is at peak demand.
05:05
You've got to supply electricity at peak demand or people die.
05:08
Texas lost over 200 people by not meeting electricity at peak demand.
05:12
They died in our country.
05:13
Think of how we'd feel with 250 additional murders.
05:17
And so on inauguration day here in PJM, 65 million people, 13 states, 4 a.m. was peak demand
05:25
for PJM this year.
05:26
And at that time, we got 44 percent of the electricity from gas, 22 percent from coal, 22 percent from
05:34
nuclear, 6 percent from hydro, 4 percent from oil.
05:38
That tells you the grid was very tight, 2 percent from wind and 0 percent from solar.
05:44
So when someone tells me solar, you know, when it produces electricity and you divide by all
05:47
the costs, it's cheap.
05:49
Well, it's it's what what is it doing when the sun is shining and it's giving electricity?
05:54
It just means all the other kit has to reduce its output because all that other kit has
05:58
to be there at 4 a.m.
06:00
on January 21 or in this case, thousands of people would have died, would have frozen to
06:04
death.
06:05
So to me, it's about the system cost.
06:07
I'm I'm over time, but I would like to invite you to California because there may be some
06:11
people with a different point of view and it would be good to hear your interactions
06:15
with them.
06:16
Would you commit to that?
06:17
Oh, absolutely.
06:18
I love nothing.
06:20
I love nothing more to get.
06:21
And in fact, I will be in the Bay Area very end of May visiting Slack, Lawrence Livermore
06:29
and Lawrence Berkeley Labs.
06:31
Yeah.
06:32
And I'll be I'll be there for several days.
06:34
I'm biased towards Southern California.
06:36
So we got to invite you.
06:36
I think I'm briefly going to be at the Reagan Library in Southern California as well, like
06:41
at the end of that trip to California.
06:43
But yes, passionate about this and I love to engage with people that have different
06:47
perspectives as me on energy.
06:49
That's how I learn.
06:50
Appreciate it.
06:51
I'll yield back over time.
06:52
Thank you, Congressman.
Recommended
6:45
|
Up next
Susie Lee Asks Energy Secretary Chris Wright About Potential Expansion Of Geothermal Projects
Forbes Breaking News
5/9/2025
6:42
Mike Simpson Asks Energy Secretary Chris Wright About The Future Of U.S. Nuclear Development
Forbes Breaking News
5/9/2025
5:26
GOP Lawmaker Asks Energy Secretary Chris Wright About Using Solar Power To Meet Energy Demands
Forbes Breaking News
6/17/2025
5:29
'You Stand By That Statement, Correct?': AOC Questions Energy Secretary Chris Wright About Energy Prices
Forbes Breaking News
6/10/2025
5:14
'That's Your Testimony?': Rob Menendez Asks Secretary Chris Wright If 'All-The-Above' Energy Plan Lowers Costs
Forbes Breaking News
6/11/2025
4:36
Craig Goldman Asks Secretary Chris Wright To Honor A Commitment To A Texas University To Build A Nuclear Project
Forbes Breaking News
6/17/2025
6:41
Energy Secretary Chris Wright Touts 'Golden Era Of American Energy Dominance'
Forbes Breaking News
6/10/2025
5:02
Frank Pallone Confronts Energy Secretary Chris Wright About Failure To Answer Congressional Requests
Forbes Breaking News
6/11/2025
5:41
Bill Hagerty Asks Energy Sec. Chris Wright About Efforts In Advancing Nuclear Production
Forbes Breaking News
5/23/2025
5:13
'I Never Ask Incorrect Questions': Diana DeGette Grills Secretary Wright On Cuts To Office Of Nuclear Energy
Forbes Breaking News
6/11/2025
8:16
Frank Mrvan Presses Energy Sec. About Criteria For Judging Projects Undergoing Department Reviews
Forbes Breaking News
5/20/2025
6:00
Michael Guest Asks Energy Sec. About DoE’s Plans To Meet Energy Needs Of International AI Race
Forbes Breaking News
5/8/2025
2:15:10
Energy Secretary Chris Wright Testifies Before House Appropriations Committee About Proposed Budget
Forbes Breaking News
5/7/2025
5:44
‘I Knew You Were Going to Say That’: Debbie Wasserman Schultz Confronts Energy Sec. Over Withheld DoE Funds
Forbes Breaking News
5/8/2025
5:40
‘When Will We Have An Answer?’: Jon Ossoff Presses Chris Wright For Update On Frozen Energy Grid Grants
Forbes Breaking News
5/22/2025
1:43:36
Energy Secretary Chris Wright Testifies Before The Senate Appropriations Committee
Forbes Breaking News
5/21/2025
6:18
‘Why Are We Doing All This?’: John Kennedy Presses Wright On DoE’s ‘Nearly $100 Billion’ Spent On Loans
Forbes Breaking News
5/22/2025
5:45
'Were You Personally Involved?': Mike Levin Grills Top Trump Officials Over Shock DOGE Cuts
Forbes Breaking News
5/22/2025
6:42
‘Shouldn’t Be A Difficult Exercise’: Rosa DeLauro Confronts Energy Sec. On DoE’s Oversight Noncompliance
Forbes Breaking News
5/9/2025
7:08
Michael Cloud Asks Energy Sec. About Speeding Up Permitting Process Amid Competition With China
Forbes Breaking News
5/21/2025
6:36
Katie Britt Asks Energy Sec. Chris Wright About Plans To ‘Win’ Nuclear Energy Race Against China
Forbes Breaking News
5/23/2025
4:51
'Simply Unsustainable': John Kennedy Gives Blunt Take On Energy Department Budget To Secretary Chris Wright
Forbes Breaking News
5/22/2025
7:39
Mike Lee Questions Energy Nom About Critical Materials Landscape And Strengthening Supply Chains
Forbes Breaking News
5/6/2025
5:23
Things Get Heated When RFK Jr., Bonnie Watson Coleman Clash About Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program
Forbes Breaking News
5/14/2025
5:17
Mike Lee Presses Energy Nom About Nuclear And Natural Gas: ‘How Important Do You Think Innovations Are?’
Forbes Breaking News
4/14/2025