Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
Steelers Trade George Pickens to Cowboys: A Gamble?
SportsGrid
Follow
5/8/2025
Category
🥇
Sports
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
The Pittsburgh Steelers and the Dallas Cowboys agree on compensation to trade George Pickens
00:04
from the Pittsburgh Steelers to the Dallas Cowboys.
00:07
On the surface of it, it's a pretty crazy deal because it's basically, let's just call
00:11
it a third-round pick that's going to exchange hands, a couple pick swaps in between.
00:15
George Pickens is a really talented wide receiver.
00:18
But as we all know in sports, they say, well, okay, this guy's really talented.
00:22
He's young.
00:23
We'll probably get another decade if he's really good.
00:25
You got him for a third-round pick, which means two things come immediately into play,
00:29
Joe, number one, I want a new contract and I want a lot of money.
00:33
Number two, why did that organization didn't want to pay him and traded him for a third-round
00:38
pick?
00:38
Because we've watched George Pickens make sensational catches, unbelievable one-on-one catches.
00:43
The ability to be a dominant number one wide receiver is probably in his toolbox.
00:48
But the fact that he's on the move, which means, boy, he quit on the Steelers a couple times.
00:53
He didn't feel like playing some odd storylines post-game here.
00:56
The Steelers move on from Pickens.
00:58
Let's start here before the compensation and what it means for the Cowboys.
01:01
Why did the Pittsburgh Steelers, Joe, get rid of George Pickens?
01:05
Well, he's in the final year of his rookie contract.
01:10
And they basically have not, shocker, they couldn't come to any sort of agreement.
01:15
And Pittsburgh pretty much let everyone know that, yeah, we're open to trading them.
01:22
Which means, of course, whoever he gets traded to here in Dallas's situation, they're going
01:26
to have to figure out a way to be able to sign him to a long-term deal before he even steps
01:30
foot for any games, I'm sure.
01:33
That's what he'll do.
01:34
But it was all about attitude with him, not talent.
01:38
And again, if Pittsburgh could not reel him in, we're talking about a guy that on multiple
01:44
occasions quit on his team, had shouting matches with fans going after other players.
01:50
Like, he's just a loose cannon, and he's got to grow up here a little bit.
01:57
Otherwise, you're going to give a guy another contract, a very lucrative contract, and what?
02:02
He's going to, you're not going to be able to trust him to be able to stay relevant in
02:07
the game?
02:07
I, it's a tough spot here for Dallas.
02:11
But Pittsburgh, they've seen him and known better than anybody, Donnie, and they just
02:15
washed their hands with him.
02:16
That's what it tells me.
02:17
Yeah, you get DK Metcalf in town, so what was the immediate thoughts?
02:21
Like, okay, DK's on one side, and George Pickens is on the other.
02:23
Now, all of a sudden, you say you have your formidable one-two combo, and that's like the
02:28
big three in the NBA.
02:29
Hey, join three guys together to win a championship.
02:31
Maybe on its way out at this point, but it seems like right now, the big three, meaning
02:34
superstar quarterback, two dominant wide receivers, you're on your way to doing dominant things
02:38
in the NFL.
02:39
It's like, oh, you know what?
02:40
We don't know who the signal caller's going to be, and we just anticipate it's going to be Aaron
02:43
Rogers, who wants to go to the Kentucky Derby and go to Egypt and take
02:47
Ayahuasca and then show up at training camp, which is probably what's going to happen here.
02:51
But understand this, too.
02:52
Like, you had Pickens, but he was uncomfortable in his environment, which when Mike Tomlin typically
02:57
gets rid of a young wide receiver, it's really worked out in the Steelers' favor in the past.
03:02
So now they're doing it once again, saying, this kid's got all the talent in the world.
03:05
I can't get through to him anymore.
03:07
And he wants more money.
03:08
As Mike Tomlin says, right, we want volunteers, not hostages at this point.
03:12
It seems like George Pickens was more of a, I feel like a hostage.
03:14
I don't get the football, and if I don't get the football, I don't want to play football.
03:17
You get the point of that.
03:18
From the move for the Dallas Cowboys to get him, you sort of like it, though, because
03:22
I always like to say, okay, what's the compensation of third-round pick?
03:25
If it really works out for George Pickens, and he's a good wide receiver for the next
03:29
five years, no matter what we pay him, that was pretty fair compensation.
03:32
We got what we paid for.
03:34
But also understand this.
03:35
George Pickens believes Joe Ranieri.
03:37
He's the true number one wide receiver on his football team.
03:40
He's nowhere near that on the Dallas Cowboys.
03:42
And also, you do get excited at times where it's like, okay, CeeDee Lamb's like, hey,
03:46
man, great.
03:47
Got another good wide receiver coming to the team.
03:49
I was a wide receiver in the past.
03:51
Wide receivers are built differently here.
03:53
They have a lot of fun when they're winning and catching the football.
03:56
They don't have a lot of fun when they're winning and don't catch the football.
03:59
So also, if you are George Pickens, on a contract year where it's like, I want to be paid,
04:04
you're not going to have statistics like CeeDee Lamb to get paid here.
04:07
How does he move from the Steelers to the Cowboys and say, hey, I'm comfortable here.
04:11
I'm just happy to be here, even though I'm nowhere near the number one.
04:16
It's and that's going to be the interesting part.
04:19
Right.
04:19
And Pittsburgh, listen, didn't want to deal with it because it's not like Metcalf ain't
04:24
a hothead either.
04:25
Right.
04:26
So you already brought him in and Pittsburgh's like, can you imagine these two not getting
04:30
the ball and and basically going after one another?
04:33
So you get rid of Pickens and now Dallas, OK, could it be Michael Irvin and Alvin Harper
04:40
of the 90s?
04:42
And absolutely could be absolutely unbeatable, but it could also be a total disaster in the
04:48
locker room.
04:49
The question is, who's going to take this guy under his wing and try to reel him in here
04:54
emotionally because he's a train wreck and I never like guys who quit on their team.
04:59
And he did that a number of times in his first few years there in Pittsburgh.
05:03
It is crazy, too.
05:05
And I saw he has like one of the fourth worst percentages of completions per passes his
05:09
direction.
05:09
Like, what did he catch 59 last year?
05:11
But I had like 100 plus targets.
05:13
It's like, hey, we understand we're going to throw the football for you to make catches
05:15
and you do make sensational catches.
05:17
But hey, man, you got to run the one concept that wide receivers usually struggle with a
05:21
lot.
05:22
And particularly number ones are sometimes when the play isn't designed for like you, the
05:25
third option, it's up to you to run your route to take the safety out of play, to
05:29
take the cornerback out of play, to take the linebacker out of play.
05:32
And if you're not doing that, which he wasn't doing, the entire offense can break down at
05:35
that point.
05:36
Like, you truly have to be, yes, a number one wide out that gets the football, but be
05:39
a team player when you know you're the route decoy and not the front end play here.
05:44
And sometimes wide receivers are, why isn't that play coming to me at this point?
05:47
George Pickens did a lot of that in Pittsburgh.
05:49
But you see the statistics.
05:50
You see the numbers and how talented he can be.
05:52
And also understand this.
05:53
He wasn't really in a true passing offense, per se, in Pittsburgh.
05:56
It's like, hey, man, let's run five wides, get after it.
05:59
You're going to have a hundred plus catches here.
06:01
Let's see if he gets that type of action in Dallas, which again, we're betting against
06:05
it simply because CeeDee Lamb is the number one target there and rightfully so.
06:09
Let's switch teams here because this isn't about, hey, let me get on the field and play
06:13
good football.
06:13
It's about jersey numbers.
06:14
We're not asking about, you know, George Pickens, what jersey number he will be.
06:17
But how about the Cleveland Browns?
06:19
What jersey number will Shador Sanders be?
06:21
Been number two his whole life.
06:22
Didn't get drafted number two overall.
06:24
But comes in and goes, I guess I'll settle for 12.
06:27
And it's not like number two is, you know, Miles Garrett's number.
06:31
Like you have a veteran wide receiver that just joined the team here.
06:35
And it's like, okay, I'll take 12.
06:37
Are you surprised that Shador settled for number 12?
06:42
No.
06:43
I mean, again, it's at this point, nothing is guaranteed to him.
06:48
If there had been anything guaranteed to him, I can promise you he'd have made a stink
06:53
about making sure he got number two.
06:55
But at this point, you know, you got to know when to say when.
07:00
So take your number and make the team.
07:03
And then anything is possible from there.
07:05
But right now he's got, what do they call it, Donnie?
07:08
Leverage?
07:09
He's got none.
07:10
Yeah, doesn't have too much leverage as a fifth round pick.
07:12
But also, didn't stop somebody from their camp coming out to social media and saying
07:17
like, oh, so now the Browns are going to draft him fifth and do him dirty and not let
07:21
him get number two, they say, hey, we see you.
07:23
That tweet slash social media post was deleted from his camp here.
07:27
So, you know, it wasn't just like, yeah, man, I'm happy with 12.
07:30
Now they feel like not only they were wrong by the NFL, by the Cleveland Browns, now also
07:34
by the Browns not getting drafted earlier, but by him having a different number that he
07:38
should not have.
07:39
Amazing time.
07:40
You got to love to see it.
07:41
You got to love to see it.
Recommended
4:31
|
Up next
Analysis: Pickens Traded to Cowboys, Steelers' Strategy
SportsGrid
5/8/2025
3:08
Cowboys' New Dynamics with CeeDee Lamb and George Pickens
SportsGrid
5/8/2025
3:56
WR George Pickens Traded to Dallas Cowboys: Analysis
SportsGrid
5/9/2025
2:06
Recapping a Wild, Late Finish Between Cowboys & Steelers
SportsGrid
10/7/2024
0:51
George Pickens Traded to Dallas Cowboys from Steelers
SportsGrid
5/8/2025
3:46
Trade Analysis: Pickens to Cowboys, Steelers Draft Picks
SportsGrid
5/8/2025
2:30
Steelers' Potential Strategy: Trading Receiver George Pickens
SportsGrid
1/23/2025
1:12
Dallas Cowboys Draft Strategy: Wide Receivers Lead the Way
SportsGrid
4/27/2025
26:19
NFC East Odds: Eagles, Cowboys Battle for Top | Best Futures Bets
SportsGrid
8/6/2024
3:06
Analyzing Cowboys' Decision: McCarthy Out, Schottenheimer In
SportsGrid
1/30/2025
2:29
Steelers Discuss Trade for Jonnu Smith with Dolphins
SportsGrid
5/29/2025
43:54
NFL Best Bets Week 6: Previews, Predictions, Sides and Totals
SportsGrid
10/11/2024
1:03:23
NFL Teams Introduce New Head Coaches and General Managers
SportsGrid
1/28/2025
3:19
Steelers' Interest in Daniel Jones Amid Free Agent Moves
SportsGrid
2/19/2025
4:36
Dallas Cowboys Appoint Brian Schottenheimer as Head Coach
SportsGrid
1/26/2025
16:51
NFC East Analysis: Eagles and Cowboys Lead the Charge
SportsGrid
7/5/2024
3:28
Aaron Rodgers' Impending Decision and NFL Team Moves
SportsGrid
3/25/2025
2:34
George Pickens' Fresh Start with Dallas: A New Vibe
SportsGrid
5/24/2025
1:06:12
Week 11 NFL: Eagles vs. Commanders & Other Top Clashes
SportsGrid
11/15/2024
2:37
Abdul Carter Now Favored to be the Top NFL Draft Pick
SportsGrid
1/28/2025
0:20
George Pickens delivers harsh reality check: not optimistic about Steelers' offensive future
Diario As
1/12/2025
1:15
NFC East Title Odds: Eagles vs. Commanders Showdown
SportsGrid
10/23/2024
2:02
Brian Schottenheimer Hired as Dallas Cowboys Coach
SportsGrid
1/27/2025
1:37
Dallas Cowboys Secure Future with CeeDee Lamb's Major Deal
SportsGrid
8/27/2024
4:25
Aaron Rodgers Joins the Steelers: Impact & Expectations
SportsGrid
6/6/2025