Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
'In Terms Of Opt Out...': Elena Kagan Presses Attorney Making Case Against LGBTQ Books In Schools
Forbes Breaking News
Follow
4/22/2025
Justice Elena Kagan questions attorneys during Oral Arguments for Mahmoud v. Taylor, a case involving LGBTQ+ books in schools.
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
for students who disagree. Mr. Baxter, I guess I'm interested in what the nature of the rule
00:04
you're asking for is. I mean, when you started, it was about, you know, matters pertaining to sex.
00:13
But as you've answered some of these questions, you've basically said, well,
00:17
you know, my clients have religious principles that conflict with what is being taught.
00:23
And does it go that far? In other words, you know, does it matter what the subject matter is? Does
00:30
it matter what the age of the child is? Does it matter what the nature of the instruction is?
00:36
If so, how does it matter? Or in the end, is what you're saying when a religious person
00:42
confronts anything in a classroom that conflicts with her religious beliefs or her parents that
00:51
that the parents can then demand an opt out? It's really the latter, Your Honor. And that's
00:56
exactly what Montgomery County allowed in its own religious diversity guidelines. Anything that
01:00
violated a student's or imposed a substantial burden in their language on a student's religious or
01:05
parents' religious beliefs, they had the right to opt out. So this is a rule that applies as well
01:10
to a 16-year-old in biology class saying, you know, I don't, you know, the parents say,
01:18
I don't want my child to be there for the classes on evolution or on other biological matters which
01:26
conflict with my religion. It would apply just as well to that. We know that those don't happen
01:30
very often because country... But it would if there were. Certainly. And schools have, there are laws,
01:35
for example, in states that allow students to opt out of dissection because they don't want to
01:39
participate in that. And there are schools that allow, there are schools across the country,
01:42
Hawaii, which has a school district about the same size as Montgomery County... And if that's the,
01:46
so that's a pretty broad rule. If that's the, let me ask what the next step of that is. Suppose there
01:53
are things that, you know, students opt out of, and then, you know, the parents think, it's just not really
02:01
fair that my student, that my kid has to leave the classroom or has to put on, you know, head phones or,
02:09
you know, has to otherwise be made to feel isolated. So the next challenge is really the class can't do
02:18
this either. Would, what would your position be on that? Well, no student, your honor, has the right
02:24
to tell the school what to teach or to tell other students what they have to learn. You would clearly
02:28
run into problems in that situation. But to the extent that this is a rule about people being able to
02:34
access public education in a sort of equal manner, the parent might say, my child is not being able
02:42
to access education in that equal manner because, you know, he's made to leave the classroom or he's
02:49
made to, you know, do something else that isolates him from the class. I mean, certainly that's an
02:55
argument that we've often heard with respect to prayer and that people have accepted with respect to
03:01
prayer, accepted with respect to prayer, that it's kind of like not a sufficient answer to just say,
03:06
don't worry, the prayer can go on. You don't have to be part of it. So I'm just wondering whether
03:12
that's the next step here. No, your honor, I don't think so because the, of course, under the
03:16
establishment clause, there are different rules, but under the free exercise clause, we think that
03:20
the, on strict scrutiny, those parents would, would always lose if they're trying to direct the school
03:25
what to teach or tell other students what they must teach. Okay, but you are suggesting, okay, so that's a,
03:30
that's a straightforward answer. I appreciate that. But just to go back, and this was also a
03:37
straightforward answer, which I appreciate, but in terms of opt out, you're basically saying opt out
03:43
for anything. It's, it's really the parents that get to decide, you know, assuming that their beliefs
03:48
are sincere, right? It's really the parent that gets to decide. Doesn't matter the kid's age, doesn't
03:54
matter sex, not sex. Doesn't, doesn't really matter this whole idea, I suppose, of pressure or
04:01
coercion. You know, if like just looking at a book would be in conflict with religious principles,
04:10
that would be enough. Well, and I would just to be clear, under Yoder, the court left open what would
04:15
happen if there were kids who objected. But we know that these things, you know, schools around the
04:19
country already have these very broad opt out policies across the curriculum in Hawaii for anything
04:23
controversial, in Arizona for anything that parents find deemed harmful. And we just don't find these
04:28
kinds of cases or these kinds of burdens where parents are bringing extreme examples. You know,
04:34
parents with kids really don't have a lot of time to be suing the school board and they're looking for
04:37
the original. Sorry.
Recommended
3:50
|
Up next
Elena Kagan Presses Attorney About Where To ‘Draw Lines’ In LGBTQ+ Book Bans Case
Forbes Breaking News
4/23/2025
4:55
'Please Answer My Question': Sonia Sotomayor Grills Lawyer On 'Coercion' In Case Of LGBTQ Books In Schools
Forbes Breaking News
4/22/2025
2:41
'I'm Not Understanding Why It's Not Feasible': Brett Kavanaugh Grills Lawyer In LGBTQ Books In School Case
Forbes Breaking News
4/22/2025
4:49
'I Guess I Am A Bit Mystified': Brett Kavanaugh Grills Lawyers In Case Involving LGBTQ+ Books In Schools
Forbes Breaking News
4/22/2025
2:27:33
Supreme Court Hears Oral Arguments In Case About LGBTQ Books In Schools
Forbes Breaking News
4/22/2025
2:16
'What Are The Ages Of The Children?': Justice Samuel Alito Grills Lawyer In Case Of LGBTQ+ Books In Schools
Forbes Breaking News
4/22/2025
1:27
Chief Justice Roberts Questions Lawyers About 'Opt-Outs' During Hearing On LGBTQ Books In Schools
Forbes Breaking News
4/22/2025
2:23
'What If A Teacher Was Transgender And The Student... Didn't Want To Use The Pronouns...': Amy Coney Barrett
Forbes Breaking News
4/22/2025
7:33
Amy Coney Barrett Presses Attorney About ‘Burden’ LGBTQ+ Books In Schools Place On Children
Forbes Breaking News
4/23/2025
1:28
Clarence Thomas Grills Lawyer During Oral Arguments On Potential Bans Of LGBTQ+ Books In Schools
Forbes Breaking News
4/22/2025
10:39
Ketanji Brown Jackson Does Not Hold Back Grilling Attorney About The Use Of LGBTQ+ Books In Elementary Schools
Forbes Breaking News
4/22/2025
4:10
'I Went To Second Grade Too...': Neil Gorsuch Questions Lawyers About Teaching LGBTQ+ Books In Schools
Forbes Breaking News
4/23/2025
7:52
Samuel Alito Presses Attorney About ‘Coercion’ During LGBTQ+ Book Bans Case Arguments
Forbes Breaking News
4/23/2025
1:33
'Are They Actually Being Taught Out Of The Books?': Clarence Thomas Grills Lawyers In LGBTQ+ Books Case
Forbes Breaking News
4/22/2025
1:53
Sonia Sotomayor Presses Attorney About Books With Interracial Couples In LGBTQ+ Book Ban Case
Forbes Breaking News
4/22/2025
1:07:23
Justice Elena Kagan Discusses Supreme Court Ethics Following Reports On Clarence Thomas, Harlan Crow
Forbes Breaking News
9/22/2023
1:50
'Can I Finish?': Tensions Mount As Samuel Alito Questions Lawyer About 'Uncle Bobby's Wedding'
Forbes Breaking News
4/22/2025
2:04
John Roberts Presses Attorney About The Relevance Of Student Age In LGBTQ+ Book Banning Case
Forbes Breaking News
4/23/2025
1:43
Elena Kagan Slams Attorney During California Emissions Rule Case: ‘You Didn’t Put On Much Evidence’
Forbes Breaking News
4/23/2025
2:52
Sonia Sotomayor Slams Attorney Who Claims Parents Do Not Sue Schools: ‘I Have A Whole List Of Cases’
Forbes Breaking News
4/23/2025
3:43
Elena Kagan Shows Absolutely No Mercy To Trump's Lawyer In Birthright Citizenship Case
Forbes Breaking News
5/15/2025
5:57
'You Resisted Justice Kagan': Amy Coney Barrett Grills Trump Lawyer At Birthright Citizenship Case
Forbes Breaking News
5/15/2025
4:59
Parents Should Have Option for Kids to Skip LGBTQ+ Readings in School, Lawyer Says
TMZ
4/27/2025
0:46
‘A Great Ruling’: Trump Responds To SCOTUS Ruling On Parents Rights Over LGBTQ+ Books In School
Forbes Breaking News
6/27/2025
3:34
Suzanne Bonamici Asks Her GOP Colleagues To ‘Stop Picking On Trans And LGBTQ Students’
Forbes Breaking News
4/15/2025