Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
NY doctor risks extradition to Louisiana in abortion pill case
FRANCE 24 English
Follow
3/6/2025
Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com
Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English
Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
This is apropos. Well, since returning to office, Donald Trump and his administration
00:06
have taken a number of actions aimed at restricting access to abortion, both within the U.S. and
00:12
internationally, including pardoning anti-abortion protesters convicted of violating a law that
00:19
protects abortion clinics and their patients, and freezing foreign aid, the U.S. being the
00:25
single biggest donor to the United Nations Sexual and Reproductive Health Agency. Our
00:30
New York correspondent Jessica LeMessurier reports on the case of one doctor who could
00:36
face criminal prosecution for sending abortion pills out of state.
00:42
A doctor here in New York has found herself at the center of a legal battle over women's
00:47
reproductive rights in the United States. Dr. Margaret Carpenter is facing legal challenges
00:52
in two states where abortion is almost entirely banned. A Texas judge has fined her over
00:57
$100,000 for sending abortion pills to someone in the state. And in Louisiana, the attorney
01:02
general has signed an extradition request for Dr. Carpenter after she was indicted for
01:07
prescribing an abortion pill to a teenager there. Take a listen.
01:12
She's not a provider. She's a drug dealer. She didn't provide care to anybody.
01:16
While New York's Governor Kathy Hochul was quick to respond to that, she says she won't
01:20
comply with the extradition request.
01:23
When the attorney general of Louisiana calls this doctor a drug dealer, I want all Americans
01:30
to know exactly what that means. As a result of the Trump administration stacking the Supreme
01:36
Court, overturning Roe v. Wade, which gave us protections that we took for granted for
01:42
almost 50 years, that now doctors who are trained to protect the lives of women and
01:47
give them the options and choices that they have as a right are now being called drug
01:52
dealers, this fight is going to continue.
01:55
This appears to be the first time that a state has criminally charged a doctor in another
02:00
state for prescribing abortion drugs. New York and several other Democratic-led states
02:06
have passed so-called shield laws to protect doctors who provide abortion pills to patients
02:11
in other states. This case is an early test of conservative states' power to prosecute
02:17
doctors outside their borders and stop abortion medication from reaching their residents.
02:23
The Abortion Coalition for Telemedicine, which was co-founded by Dr. Carpenter, says that
02:27
threats against doctors jeopardize women's access to reproductive health care and should
02:32
alarm everyone.
02:34
Jessica LeMessurier reporting there from New York.
02:37
Well, for more, we're joined now by Julie FK, co-founder of the Abortion Coalition for
02:41
Telemedicine. Thank you so much for being with us this evening, Julie, on the programme
02:46
here. As I say, you co-founded the organisation that Dr. Carpenter represents. How did you
02:51
find yourselves at the centre of this firestorm?
02:55
Well, the Abortion Coalition for Telemedicine, or ACT, is the only national reproductive
03:03
rights organisation that stands up for telemedicine from licensed practitioners in all 50 states.
03:09
So we were built and designed to protect access to telemedicine for all patients, no matter
03:15
what zip code or their ability to pay.
03:19
And talk to us a little bit more about Dr. Carpenter. Does she risk arrest, essentially,
03:24
if she travels out of state? What is the current situation for the doctor?
03:31
You know, abortion providers in America are a unique bunch of physicians who are really
03:38
mission driven. They recognise that reproductive health care is essential, and so they are
03:42
dedicated to making sure that women and pregnant people get access to that.
03:47
The SHIELD laws create a safe way for licensed practitioners to give certified medications
03:54
to patients anywhere and will not turn them over to anti-abortion politicians who bring
04:00
lawsuits. So right now, Dr. Carpenter has had the strong support of Governor Hochul
04:06
in New York State, and we expect that other governors will similarly stand up for Dr.
04:11
Carpenter's right to perform safe, legal and licensed care without risk of criminalisation.
04:18
And Julie, what wider consequences could this case have, and do you expect that there will
04:23
be others?
04:28
We would not be surprised to see increased attacks on access to Mifepristone, which is
04:33
the key medication that is used for safe abortion care globally. We expect that the anti-abortion
04:41
forces who have for decades been trying to reduce women's access to abortion and to medication
04:47
abortion will continue that. And when you go after a doctor, whether it's Dr. Carpenter
04:52
or one of the many, many other doctors who are providing safe access to telemedicine
04:57
abortion, you're really undermining the ability of tens of thousands of women to get access
05:02
to safe care and to make the decisions that they need that are best for their families.
05:08
And right now in the United States, one fifth of all abortions are done by telemedicine,
05:13
and it's the fastest growing method of abortion in the United States. So it has really brought
05:18
the attention of anti-abortion officials who want to make abortion unavailable nationwide
05:25
in the United States.
05:26
And you and your organisation, you're determined not to back down on this. What happens next
05:31
for you?
05:33
Well, what happens next in these cases depends on whether these state officials continue
05:41
these cases. Seventy percent of Americans want access to abortion under the Roe framework
05:48
that was taken away by the Supreme Court. So, you know, there may be a kind of stranglehood
05:53
on the legal enforcement in these states, but it doesn't represent popular opinion.
06:00
And we're going to keep fighting for the rights of women to make decisions about whether when
06:04
and whom and with whom to have children or not as a fundamental human right and as one
06:09
that many, many states are standing behind for everybody throughout the nation.
06:14
Donald Trump, he's moved separately to drop a high profile case, this one in Idaho. It's
06:19
a long running legal battle over the right to emergency abortion services there. So what
06:24
kind of signal does this send about how Donald Trump plans to interpret federal law going
06:29
forward, laws that are designed essentially to protect urgent care when they come up against
06:36
individual states, individual abortion bans?
06:44
What we've seen through the Trump administration's dropping of a lawsuit out of Idaho, as well
06:50
as other state and federal actions towards removing lifesaving medical care for miscarriage
06:56
management, for post abortion care, for pregnancy complications, is that they are devaluing
07:01
women's lives. They are really playing Russian roulette with anybody who goes into a hospital
07:07
seeking unbiased and best quality medical care to deal with pregnancy complications,
07:13
with miscarriage or a whole range of conditions. And it's really appalling to see that they
07:19
would start trying to take away the right to somebody's life and health and future fertility
07:24
simply because of an anti-abortion agenda.
07:27
Yeah. And speaking of that agenda, as you see it, Donald Trump is so far avoided questions
07:32
about whether he'd veto a national ban on abortion. Are you concerned that that is actually
07:37
where the U.S. is moving?
07:43
This is the president that brought us an ultra conservative Supreme Court that had one goal
07:48
and that was to overturn Roe versus Wade, and they've done that. And they took away
07:52
a lot of constitutional rights in doing that, rights that have been established for 50 years
07:57
and rights to abortion care that were also very similar to the rights of LGBTQ people
08:03
to have marriage, of interracial marriage. So he has really taken a big whack at our
08:09
constitutional rights. And I don't trust that that won't happen again. Unless we really
08:14
start standing up and protecting our reproductive freedoms, the right to access contraception,
08:21
IVF, emergency contraception, abortion and safe maternal care for everybody, then we're
08:27
going to lose those rights. It's really important that Americans really keep their eye on the
08:33
goal of expanding and restoring abortion rights in this country for everyone.
08:38
And Julie, those rights, they obviously differ depending on which state you're in. Vastly,
08:44
you mentioned those shield laws earlier. New York is one of the Democrat led states that
08:48
has specific legislation protecting doctors who provide abortion pills to women in other
08:54
states. But how does that actually work in practice, legally speaking? How is that protection
08:59
offered to them?
09:03
So eight states have passed telemedicine abortion shield laws. Some are led by Democratic governors.
09:09
Some are led by Republican governors. And it really is a step forward to say that if
09:14
a licensed practitioner is using telemedicine within that state, within that shield state,
09:20
that it doesn't matter where the patient is. The abortion is taking place within the state
09:25
and they will protect that doctor's, that licensed practitioner's right to provide safe
09:30
care regardless of the patient location. We talk about it as the modern day house call,
09:36
that the doctor is treating patients regardless of where they are. And it really has been
09:42
tremendously successful in serving women in areas that are under resourced because there
09:48
just aren't clinics. But even in places, Boston, Chicago, major cities where women choose telemedicine
09:55
because they can have the exact same medications, taking them in the safety and comfort of their
09:59
own home without having to travel, without having the costs and expense and having to
10:04
go past clinic harassers and others. So there are a lot of benefits and we want to make
10:09
sure that every woman gets to make the decision about what method of abortion is right for
10:13
her.
10:14
And Donald Trump's decisions and his actions, they're not just having repercussions for
10:19
women in the U.S. Talk to us a little bit about the impact that the decision to freeze
10:24
foreign aid has had on reproductive health services around the world, particularly for
10:30
the most vulnerable women.
10:35
The denial of funding from the Trump administration has had devastating effects in many different
10:41
parts of the world. Access to contraception is a key part of women's health. We already
10:47
weren't funding much access to abortion services, but even medical trials, all sorts of pregnancy
10:54
care, there are so many ways that reproductive health care needs support. And to all of a
11:00
sudden cut off that support, we're really putting women's lives in danger. And I think
11:05
the thing to remember is that when we look at how we provide care, even in the U.S.,
11:10
we have one of the worst maternal mortality rates in the world and we have the ability
11:14
to do much better. And we need to, we need to stop playing politics with women's lives.
11:18
Julie, we'll have to leave it there for now. We do really appreciate you joining us on
11:23
the programme this evening. That's Julie FK, co-founder of the Abortion Coalition for
11:27
Telemedicine. Thank you so much for being with us. Well, that is it from us for now.
Recommended
1:10
|
Up next
John F. Kennedy Assassination 16mm Original - Driver shooting at Kennedy!
Jelani Trent
9/7/2015
1:49
Liberal US states stockpile abortion pills after ruling
FRANCE 24 English
4/11/2023
5:02
'Women in crisis will have their lives put at risk' as Florida abortion ban takes effect
FRANCE 24 English
5/1/2024
8:46
US women cross Mexico border to seek abortions after states ban procedure
FRANCE 24 English
10/30/2024
1:10
US Supreme Court hears challenges on Texas abortion law
euronews (in English)
11/2/2021
3:04
Abortion Ruling Anniversary: Kamala Harris and Democrats Target Donald Trump | Oneindia News
Oneindia
6/25/2024
0:55
Supreme Court rules in favor of abortion rights activists in Texas
Mashable
6/30/2016
1:22
The day US Supreme Court reversed Roe v. Wade, ending constitutional right to abortion
FRANCE 24 English
3/5/2024
3:07
Poland abortion ruling: protest movement grows across country
FRANCE 24 English
10/27/2020
1:00
Support For Legal Abortion
Stringr
6/28/2023
1:00
Abortion rights defenders gather outside US Supreme Court and in New York
euronews (in English)
6/26/2022
2:53
Women protest in Mexico City in defense of abortion rights
The Manila Times
9/29/2024
1:21
Abortion Pills are Now Permanently Available via Mail
Women-Life
2/27/2022
8:37
Abortion a key issue for voters ahead of US election
FRANCE 24 English
9/10/2024
1:09
US Supreme Court moving to overturn key abortion rights law, says leaked report
euronews (in English)
5/3/2022
1:35
In narrow ruling, US Supreme Court allows emergency abortions in Idaho
FRANCE 24 English
6/28/2024
1:24
Thousands call for protection of abortion rights at US Women's March
FRANCE 24 English
11/3/2024
2:18
Supreme Court Strikes Down Restrictive Lousiana Abortion Law In 5-4 Decision
Newsweek
6/29/2020
17:56
US abortion rights under threat: The spectre of a post-Roe America
FRANCE 24 English
5/19/2022
1:49
Everything to Know About Abortion Pills
Cosmopolitan USA
2/28/2023
3:56
Andrea Prudente: Malta abortion refusal threatens woman's life, say doctors
euronews (in English)
6/23/2022
1:32
Abortions in the US
Brut America
3/25/2025
0:33
Supreme Court Upholds Emergency Abortions in Idaho, Overturning Near-Total Ban
Benzinga
6/28/2024
0:29
South Carolina's 6-week Abortion Ban
Benzinga
8/25/2023
0:35
Pope Francis urges peace in Sudan
The Manila Times
4/17/2023