Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
Report on 2022 coup plot in Brazil 'very methodical, detailed and loaded with evidence'
FRANCE 24 English
Follow
11/28/2024
Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com
Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English
Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
Let's bring in Anthony Pereira, Director of the Kimberly Green Latin American and Caribbean Centre
00:05
at Florida International University. Thank you so much Anthony for being on the programme
00:10
with us this evening. We heard some of the details in that report.
00:14
When it comes to this case, just how strong is the case against Jair Bolsonaro?
00:21
Well I think this is going to wake a lot of people up, the fact that this report is so detailed
00:26
and so thorough. I mean if the allegations are true, it indicates a level of planning,
00:32
it's a level of intentionality way beyond what we've heard about before. I mean some of this
00:36
has been out in the public domain before. I think it's unlikely that prosecutors wouldn't
00:44
make some charges based on this report, whether it'll be all 37 people named in the report or
00:50
just some of them, whether it'll be for all of the alleged incidents or just some of them,
00:56
is up to the prosecutors. But I think it's a quite a serious and thorough report and so
01:01
it's going to raise a lot of questions in Brazilian politics that are going to be pursued
01:07
I think over the next few months. And is time on Bolsonaro's side here?
01:11
When is the Attorney General expected to respond to this particular case?
01:17
Well the commentaries I've read don't expect anything to happen until 2025.
01:21
You know Brazilian politics are kind of dormant between in December, January, until after
01:26
Carnival. But something is likely to happen in 2025. I think one question that has been raised
01:33
is whether the Trump administration, which will be inaugurated on the 20th of January,
01:38
whether the Trump administration will weigh in in any way on this. I think Bolsonaro is hoping
01:44
that these charges will go away as they did for Donald Trump with the Jack Smith investigation.
01:49
But I think the circumstances in Brazil are very different. And another question I would raise is
01:54
what does this mean for the opposition? Are center-right politicians going to distance
01:59
themselves from Bolsonaro because of these allegations and what could become a criminal
02:05
prosecution? Or are they going to unite around Bolsonaro and echo his claim that these are
02:13
unsustainable charges, that nothing like this ever happened, and that he's just going to continue
02:19
to deny what's in the report?
02:22
Well on that first point, some say Bolsonaro is expected to play his Trump card, so to speak. But
02:29
what kind of support might he actually receive from Donald Trump when he comes back to office
02:34
in January? What kind of an impact could that have?
02:37
I mean, there may be some sort of U.S. pressure. I think the question of pressure, though,
02:42
it could generate a backlash in which people in Brazil say, look, this is a sovereign decision,
02:48
this is a legal case that's involving domestic courts in Brazil, and it doesn't really enter
02:55
the realm of foreign relations and foreign policy. And so there might be resistance to any pressure
03:01
on the U.S. side. We saw with Elon Musk's conflict with the Brazilian Supreme Court,
03:06
there was an attempt in the U.S. Congress to pressure Brazil on that, and it didn't really
03:11
get very far. In the end, Elon Musk ended up agreeing to pay the fines that were imposed by
03:16
the Supreme Court. And I think it's going to be limited what can be done, but there may be some
03:23
mobilization of public opinion, at the very least, in the U.S. on the side of Bolsonaro
03:29
within the Republican Party and possibly in Congress.
03:32
And when you talk about that kind of pressure, are we talking as well about
03:36
sanctions, other punitive financial measures that could be imposed by the U.S. to ramp up
03:42
that pressure on Brazilian authorities? Possibly. What was proposed in the case
03:47
of Musk was denying visas to members of the Brazilian Supreme Court that were part of the
03:52
decision to fine X. So there could be something like that. I mean, I think another question that's
03:59
raised is, you know, how secure is Brazilian democracy? Because the report, it has some
04:05
comical aspects to it. I'm not saying that an attempted coup is comedic by any means,
04:11
but I think some Brazilians are thinking, you know, how secure is our democracy if a few people
04:16
around the president could contemplate not having a peaceful transition of power and
04:22
get this far in planning it, if the allegations are true? But yeah, on the U.S. side, I think
04:28
it's likely, you know, if there is anything, it's likely to come from Congress, and it's
04:32
likely to be similar to the measures that we saw that were directed at the Supreme Court
04:39
in defense of Elon Musk in the recent conflict between X and the Supreme Court.
04:45
And supporters of Bolsonaro, he himself as well, claims that he's been persecuted. He's
04:50
described all of this as a witch hunt. What kind of resonance is all of this having with the general
04:57
public, though? I think there was a pretty strong condemnation at the time of the attacks on the
05:03
Planalto on January 8th, 2023, both in Brazilian public opinion and the Brazilian political
05:09
establishment, that that attempt went too far. And there's evidence in this report that that
05:16
attack on the Planalto was linked to this attempted coup. And so I think it'll be,
05:23
there are some politicians on the right who are already distancing themselves somewhat from
05:28
Bolsonaro and saying that, you know, this goes too far. I think we shouldn't forget as well
05:34
that there is an alleged member of the group who's plea bargained, Lieutenant Colonel Mauro Cidi,
05:41
and he's cooperating with the federal police. So these are not just allegations that come from the
05:47
police investigation and sort of monitoring of social media and sort of secondhand reports.
05:55
There is somebody who's testifying, who's plea bargained, and testifying as having participated
05:59
in some of these activities, who is on the side of whoever will prosecute the case.
06:06
So the evidence is pretty strong. And this is just one case. There are multiple investigations
06:12
that have been launched in Brazil over suspected plots against Lula and his administration.
06:19
How serious do you think all of this is for Bolsonaro? Could he ultimately one day be put
06:25
behind bars, do you think? It could happen, I think. I mean, the decision to imprison a former
06:31
president is pretty serious. Bolsonaro is 69. So I think if this were to happen after he's 70,
06:38
there may be a, even if we're convicted, there might be an argument that he shouldn't go to
06:43
prison given his age. So, you know, and I think there is a, there could be an appearance of
06:49
making a martyr out of someone like Bolsonaro. But I think, you know, Bolsonaro has on his
06:58
on his side the fact that the coup was not successful. So the prosecutors would have to
07:03
prove that something was attempted that wasn't actually realized. And so he has the advantage
07:08
of saying, well, look, nothing ever happened in the end. But I think people reading the report
07:14
might change their mind about the effectiveness of that argument, because there's a lot of
07:18
documentation there, including, for example, of how members of the group allegedly monitored the
07:24
whereabouts of Alexandre do Moraes, the Supreme Court justice. They knew where he was in the middle
07:30
of December. They knew that he had traveled to Sao Paulo. They knew that he was in his residence.
07:33
They knew when he was going back to Brasilia. So there was a lot of use of government apparatus to,
07:41
allegedly, to engage in this activity and to plan this coup. And so I think if people
07:49
read the report, they might be somewhat less convinced by this idea, well, since nothing
07:55
happened, nothing could have been behind. There was nothing, there's no evidence, you know, there's
08:00
nothing there. There's no fire where you see that smoke. But I think, as I say,
08:07
the report is very sort of methodical, very detailed, and very loaded with evidence.
08:14
Anthony, how popular is Bolsonaro currently in Brazil? And is there an argument that all of this
08:20
might actually boost his political support? It could. Some people say that, you know, Alexandre
08:26
do Moraes, the Supreme Court justice, is sort of public enemy number one for the base of the
08:31
Bolsonaristas. They will see this as more judicial overreach, more evidence that Alexandre do Moraes
08:38
is sort of waging a campaign against Bolsonaro. He's weaponizing the justice system, as was also
08:46
alleged here in the United States, with some of the cases against Donald Trump. So it could just
08:52
harden and polarize public opinion. But as I said, if you look at the public opinion and the political
08:58
reaction to the January 8th, 2023 attacks on the Planalto, that was quite different from the United
09:04
States, where a majority of Republicans didn't condemn what happened at the Capitol. In Brazil,
09:11
there was a much wider, broader condemnation of what happened on January 8th, 2023. And to the
09:18
extent that the prosecutors will draw a link between what happened there, the depredation of
09:24
those buildings, the destruction, the vandalism, and what appeared to be happening, what's alleged
09:28
to have been happening in December of 2022, with this attempt to prevent the peaceful transition
09:35
of power, I think a majority in Brazil may well end up condemning both the January 8th,
09:43
2023 acts and this alleged plot to prevent a peaceful inauguration of the new president.
09:52
Antony, thank you so much for all of that. We'll have to leave it there for now. That's Antony
09:55
Pereira joining us there from the Florida International University. That is it from us
10:00
for now. Do stay with us though. Up next, it's Ion Africa.
Recommended
1:10
|
Up next
John F. Kennedy Assassination 16mm Original - Driver shooting at Kennedy!
Jelani Trent
9/7/2015
4:21
Riots in Brasilia: 'I don't think that we have seen the last episodes of Bolsonarism in Brazil'
FRANCE 24 English
1/11/2023
8:36
Brazil's electorate remains 'divided': Will Bolsonaro trial 'bleed into 2026 presidential election'?
FRANCE 24 English
2/19/2025
5:47
MAGA global shakedown: Facing tariffs, sanctions, Lula now stands 'good chance of getting reelected'
FRANCE 24 English
8/1/2025
2:39
Undocumented, Brazil's 'invisible' citizens fight for their rights
FRANCE 24 English
4/14/2022
7:43
Maduro's hold on power 'unprecedented': 'Cruelty' of Venezuela's govt 'a shock to the world over'
FRANCE 24 English
9/9/2024
3:51
Lula Accuses U.S Of Staging ‘Brazil Coup’ | SLAMS Trump’s 50% Tariff Threat As Economic Blackmail
Oneindia
6 days ago
3:20
Why could Brazil's democracy be under threat? | The Economist
The Economist
2/27/2019
3:33
Brazil election: "The election of Bolsonaro is based on fake news, on myths"
FRANCE 24 English
10/29/2018
1:07
Brazil's capital Brasilia on alert for more street protests
euronews (in English)
1/12/2023
7:28
'Chances of conviction quite high': Trump's defense team 'going for a hung jury'
FRANCE 24 English
5/28/2024
4:12
'Tribal politics: If Trump can claim victory to MAGA base domestically that's all that matters'
FRANCE 24 English
7/10/2025
2:19
Brazil: Evidence points to the existence of six cells to carry out the military coup
teleSUR English
11/27/2024
1:00
Watch: The clean-up begins in Brazil’s capital
euronews (in English)
1/9/2023
1:00
Federal Police Raid The Home Of Former Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro
Forbes Breaking News
7/18/2025
1:16
Brazil's Lula insists Trump 'not elected sheriff of the world'
AFP English
2/23/2025
1:40
Brazilian women take to the streets in protest of far right candidate Bolsonaro
FRANCE 24 English
9/30/2018
1:46
Brazil's Supreme Court orders house arrest of ex-President Jair Bolsonaro amid coup plot allegations
euronews (in English)
5 days ago
10:40
'Political violence symptomatic of deeper polarisation, extremism within American political sphere'
FRANCE 24 English
9/16/2024
1:06
Brazil general prosecutor charges Bolsonaro for alleged coup plot
The Star
2/19/2025
9:52
'Naive attempt at total peace: Colombians pin blame on Petro's feckless policies on security, peace'
FRANCE 24 English
6/10/2025
1:00
Brazil divided: Lula supporters jubilant as Bolsonaro fans question election result
euronews (in English)
11/2/2022
1:00
LONELY BOY SNORTING CRYSTAL METH
Amandaphillips
11/28/2017
9:10
Trump and Putin to hold talks in Alaska next Friday
FRANCE 24 English
yesterday
1:11
Nagasaki survivors say 'never again'
FRANCE 24 English
yesterday