Justice Mansoor Ali Shah Say Bat Karnay Ki Koshishen? Govt Apne Maqsad Mein Qamiyab Hogi?

2 months ago

#Khabar #JusticeMansoorAliShah #PMLNGovt #PMShehbazSharif #QaziFaezIsa

Follow the ARY News channel on WhatsApp: https://bit.ly/46e5HzY

Subscribe to our channel and press the bell icon for latest news updates: http://bit.ly/3e0SwKP

ARY News is a leading Pakistani news channel that promises to bring you factual and timely international stories and stories about Pakistan, sports, entertainment, and business, amid others.

Official Facebook: https://www.fb.com/arynewsasia

Official Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/arynewsofficial

Official Instagram: https://instagram.com/arynewstv

Website: https://arynews.tv

Watch ARY NEWS LIVE: http://live.arynews.tv

Listen Live: http://live.arynews.tv/audio

Listen Top of the hour Headlines, Bulletins & Programs: https://soundcloud.com/arynewsofficial
#ARYNews

ARY News Official YouTube Channel.
For more videos, subscribe to our channel and for suggestions please use the comment section.

Transcript

00:00Noor Alam has said that my party did not ask me to take back the matter of the larger bench.

00:11Because there were rumours that the party might ask him to take back the money.

00:16Secondly, he is saying that there is no age limit in this.

00:23Do you think that Noor Alam's bill will have a retrospective effect?

00:40You should read Noor Alam's bill which is increasing in the number of judges.

00:45It is very interesting.

00:48In that, the retrospective appeal, as you can tell better,

00:52the bench that makes the decision first listens to the retrospective appeal.

00:56Now, in this amendment, a bigger bench will listen to the retrospective appeal.

01:00And it is also being said that it will be applied in the past.

01:03So, what can be the purpose of this?

01:05What can be the purpose?

01:07A special session has been decided.

01:11We have to see whether it will have an effect or not.

01:16But apparently, it will have some purpose.

01:19So, Noor Alam is suddenly saying that it is an order of the day.

01:24And there is an increase in the number of judges.

01:28So, now the government is playing technically, in other words.

01:32Can we say this, Mr. Asnath?

01:34You can also add that the government is going to support an amendment of the JUI.

01:43A while ago, Senator Fnan was saying that the rest of the members of the PTI,

01:47who have not written PTI in their nomination papers or in their signatures,

01:53we can request them.

01:55Look, it is the judgment of the Supreme Court.

01:57According to the judgment of the Supreme Court, they should declare PTI.

02:01As I said, there is a confrontation.

02:04On one hand, there is a policy of keratin and stick.

02:06On the other hand, there is an attempt to negotiate with Mansoor Ali Shah.

02:10Who wants to negotiate?

02:12The government wants to negotiate. Who else wants to negotiate?

02:14Has anyone reached out to Mr. Asnath?

02:16Look, you are telling us that efforts are being made.

02:19And there is only one apprehension of the government.

02:21That is the case of the Election Tribunal.

02:23As Mr. Asif has also said,

02:26it is being said that when the Chief Justices will be changed in October,

02:30the government will also leave.

02:32So, at the moment, the government has an apprehension.

02:34That is the case of the Election Tribunal.

02:36According to the Election Rigging, a Constitutional Petition is pending in the Supreme Court.

02:40Although, I don't think that Mr. Mansoor Ali Shah will be an agenda-driven Chief Justice.

02:44His focus will be on judicial reform.

02:46And this government is in a confrontation mode at the moment.

02:49This was the case in the era of Umar Atta Bandyal.

02:51But he is a future Chief Justice.

02:53He is a future Chief Justice.

02:55And there are four Chief Justices in the future.

02:57They are creating an atmosphere.

02:59I think that this will be a backfire for them.

03:01And this will be a huge loss for them.

03:03Because it seems that a Constitutional Amendment will not be possible.

03:07And there is no doubt about it.

03:09It is a huge advantage for the government.

03:11They will think that Chief Justice Qazi Faisal,

03:14in many cases,

03:16endorsed their point of view.

03:19Judges interpret the law according to their point of view.

03:23Yes, but the perception is very clear.

03:25Perception is sometimes greater than reality.

03:27Reality can be something else.

03:29Now, I will reiterate Senator Afnan's point.

03:33He says that according to the PTI Memorandum,

03:35they have only three seats.

03:38And they cannot vote based on the party policy.

03:41According to the party policy,

03:43these three seats will not be included

03:45if a Constitutional Amendment is introduced.

03:47So, if they are convinced in the two-thirds majority,

03:50can they also be included?

03:52There are eight such parties in the Parliament,

03:56which are still independent.

03:58So, the government may have a view on them.

04:01Let me tell you about the party position in the National Assembly.

04:07There are 213 government members.

04:09224 are needed for the two-thirds majority.

04:13Now, if the JUI supports this,

04:15or if the government and the JUI

04:16work together to introduce a Constitutional Amendment,

04:18then the JUI has eight members in the National Assembly.

04:20So, the government needs three members in the National Assembly.

04:23And the independent members?

04:25The government will try to include them.

04:27The government has all the resources.

04:29Now, it will be introduced next week.

04:32Are there any attempts to reach out to these members on the back channel?

04:36The government is saying that they have the strength.

04:39They can introduce a Constitutional Amendment.

04:41But the strength is not complete.

04:44It is not complete.

04:45It is not complete because the JUI will not fully support it.

04:50Even though they are introducing a Constitutional Amendment,

04:52the JUI has its members.

04:53Noor Alam Khan.

04:54And if the government supports it,

04:56Noor Alam Khan has said that the party has not asked him to withdraw the amendment.

05:02This means that the party supports it.

05:04Then there is a statement from Maulana Sahib,

05:06in which he has said that there will be a 12-year dispute.

05:08The solution will not be so soon.

05:10Maulana Sahib has met Shujaat Sahib today.

05:12And the media attack that he did was also a very mild media attack.

05:17It was not a matter of discrimination,

05:19not even in the context of the government.

05:21Maulana Sahib is a minister and a politician.

05:23He has made many exemplary decisions in the past.

05:26He can make any decision.

05:28He is the representative of the country.

05:30You have created an illusion that he can make any decision.

05:32Mr. Hassan, in the coming days,

05:34will we see the shape of the Supreme Court changing?

05:39Right now, there is a lot of confrontation.

05:43There is no clear picture in this.

05:45On the one hand, it is being said that Chief Justice Qazi Faiz does not want to take an extension.

05:49He will retire on 25th October.

05:51I think that the focus of the government is that

05:54Chief Justice Mansoor Ali Shah,

05:56as it has been in the past,

05:58when a Chief Justice comes,

06:00an attempt is made to talk to him informally.

06:02Talk about some sensitive issues.

06:04Justice Qazi Faiz is the guarantee of this system.

06:08As long as he is there, this system will continue.

06:10If you look at the case of Election Tribunal,

06:12he has been suspended in the Supreme Court.

06:14He has got three seats in recounting.

06:18This is the decision of January 13th.

06:20So, there are issues with the arrival of Justice Mansoor Ali Shah.

06:23If he is resolved,

06:25This is the fear of the government.

06:27This is not a guarantee.

06:28This apprehension has been removed.

06:30So, I think that Justice Mansoor Ali Shah will be the Chief Justice.

06:32But one thing is that there is a division in the government.

06:36Should Justice Qazi Faiz be given an extension?

06:38No, a Chief Justice for three years.

06:40In the case of PTI,

06:42I am also a supporter of the government.

06:44But there are many other things

06:46on which they did not listen to the government.

06:49For example, the case of lease in Margalla.

06:51They said that thousands of acres of land cannot be given.

06:55Similarly, the case of Chief Justice in Lahore.

06:58The death penalty of President Musharraf has been appealed.

07:00So, these are the things.

07:02So, to give the impression that

07:04any judge is above the law in any way

07:06and is looking at the other side,

07:08that would be definitely wrong.

07:10But Mr. Hassanat Malik, thank you very much.

07:12Mr. Azhar Farooq, thank you very much for joining me in the program.

Justice Mansoor Ali Shah Say Bat Karnay Ki Koshishen? Govt Apne Maqsad Mein Qamiyab Hogi?

Category

Transcript

Recommended