Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: DEAR JASSI [Toronto Intl Film Festival 2023 - Toronto, Ontario - Remote] - Part I
Fest Track
Follow
10/1/2023
Director Tarsem Singh talks to Fest Track about thematics, narrative license and visual texture in regards to his new dramatic film: "Dear Jassi" playing the Platform section at the Toronto International Film Festival in Toronto, Ontario.
Category
🎥
Short film
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
[MUSIC PLAYING]
00:03
Making a film is such a big undertaking, you know?
00:29
And this one seems even more so.
00:32
Even though you've done the big movies,
00:34
this is a big movie in all of its themes
00:37
and all these things.
00:38
Can you talk about that?
00:39
Because the psychological places people need to go in this
00:42
is really very intense.
00:44
Have you seen the movie?
00:45
Yes.
00:46
Wow.
00:47
OK.
00:48
Yes, it's hard to describe.
00:49
When you tell people "Romeo and Juliet,"
00:51
I think there was a friend, Mark Romanek, who looked at it.
00:55
And he just said--
00:55
I said, it's "Romeo and Juliet."
00:56
He just said, no, you need to get a little bit more license.
00:59
When you pull the rug, he said, it's incredibly disturbing.
01:02
And he-- this was when he saw an earlier cut.
01:05
Then I put the mystic saying the words to do the setup.
01:08
So hopefully the film does it for you.
01:10
Because he just said, no, it can't be "Romeo and Juliet"
01:12
because in that one, they die from a misunderstanding
01:15
of pills and that information.
01:18
I wasn't ready for a machete attack and a gang rape
01:21
and a blah blah.
01:21
And I went, OK.
01:22
So he said, you don't want the audience to hate you for not
01:26
giving them a heads up.
01:28
Then the problem is I overboarded and tried
01:30
to set it up too much up front.
01:32
And I realized the clock was out of the bag so early
01:35
that you didn't.
01:35
I said, no, I'm going to go with the Groucho Marx thing, which
01:39
is you make audience fall in love with it.
01:41
I mean, his take was you let the audience outgrass you,
01:44
and then you double cross them.
01:45
So you tell them it's going to get dark.
01:47
And then you kind of like show you how they fell in love.
01:49
You believe the situation.
01:50
OK, I'm not going to do anything.
01:52
And then you do that.
01:53
And then you come back to cathartic again.
01:56
So I kind of went for that particular circle.
01:58
And it took only tweaking because there was no coverage.
02:01
Blanc asked me one particular time, do you have a close up?
02:04
I said, there is no close up.
02:05
I shot everything.
02:06
That's why there is no editor.
02:07
I edited it in 48 hours.
02:09
It was done.
02:09
It's just medium shots.
02:11
I looked at the performances.
02:12
And I just said when I shot it, I used the cliche of it's--
02:17
imagine, Hanukkah wrote a script.
02:19
And Shirin Nishad, not even like Asfar Ali,
02:22
like Shirin Nishad directed it.
02:24
So it's very tabloid shot.
02:26
But what's happening inside the flame is not tabloid.
02:29
It's naturalistic.
02:30
So the two schools don't mix, Hanukkah and Shirin Nishad.
02:34
Then I just said, no, I'm going to put that together.
02:36
And the structure will be that.
02:40
I want to stay here with you for a--
02:44
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
02:46
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
03:10
Yeah, it's funny.
03:10
You bring up Mark.
03:12
Because I talked to Mark both when "One Hour Photo" came out.
03:14
But then he and I talked many years later again about it
03:17
after Robin had died.
03:18
And it was interesting because what you were talking about,
03:21
it's sort of like lulling people in and pulling out the rug,
03:23
but giving them enough room to form their own perceptions.
03:28
He used the great word.
03:29
He said, like he said, I think the word always people use
03:31
is license.
03:32
But did you have a license to go there?
03:34
And then I overbought the license
03:36
by putting some of the darkness up front.
03:38
And I just thought, like, no, I don't
03:40
want you to think you know where it's going.
03:42
I want to tell you in research that this is what you see.
03:44
And also, you have to remember, my friends
03:46
had heard nothing about it.
03:47
Mark and everybody thinking, oh, you made a little--
03:49
it's a Bollywood Hollywood.
03:50
And he came in, and he was like--
03:52
he said, I can't fucking breathe.
03:53
You need to set this up.
03:54
And I just said, OK, but people who will see it in the thing,
03:56
it'll say, dear Jesse, hopefully they
03:58
would have seen a trailer.
03:59
They would know it's Robin Juliet, and it'll go there.
04:01
So now it's playing much better, thanks to notes from, I think,
04:05
Mark, phenomenal, from Fincher, and from best ones,
04:12
I would say, but really poignant ones.
04:13
One from Fincher's wife, Sian.
04:16
She was articulate about it.
04:17
And also from Bennett Miller.
04:19
I just-- I've never done it before,
04:21
because these guys--
04:22
I've had these guys for friends, and they always
04:24
show each other rough cuts and talk on how to tweak.
04:26
Whenever they showed me a rough cut, I'd be like, great.
04:28
I just thought they want me as an audience.
04:30
And when I showed them, they just looked and said, no,
04:33
you need to ding, ding.
04:34
And I'm like, oh, so that's what you wanted from me?
04:36
I wish I'd given it to you earlier.
04:38
Unfortunately, the kind of films that make us so visual,
04:41
in the beginning, that whatever is not working,
04:43
I go, I'm going to solve that visually.
04:44
Is this going to be allowed?
04:45
That's why you're not feeling it,
04:46
because I'm going to do x, y, z.
04:47
In this one, there's nothing I could do.
04:49
That was it.
04:50
The movie is very visual, but not fantastical.
04:54
And I've never done that.
04:55
When I went with that, I just said,
04:57
what I intend to show, you can see.
04:59
So if it's not working, tell me.
05:01
And I couldn't have shown it to a better group of five people.
05:04
So they just dinged at me with that, and I went like,
05:07
oh my god, they solved every problem
05:09
that I thought I was having.
05:10
They told me what the problems were,
05:12
but Sian told me a particular solution, and that happened.
05:16
[VIDEO PLAYBACK]
05:16
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
05:18
, [NON-ENGLISH SPEECH] [NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
05:46
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
05:58
- Now, you were talking about naturalism.
06:00
Sometimes that's the hardest thing to direct,
06:01
because organically, you have to find that.
06:04
And between your two lead actors,
06:05
I mean, one who really hadn't acted before,
06:07
you have to sort of balance that with an organic sort
06:10
of nature of, OK, here's where the camera is, per se,
06:13
I would think.
06:14
Can you talk about finding the right direction in this style?
06:17
- It's quite difficult. That's why the brief that I gave
06:20
to them was that I don't want actors.
06:22
I said, I will look for the person who's poignantly right.
06:25
What I did in the fall was to look
06:26
for that girl who had the language barrier, who had XYZ.
06:29
In this particular one, I said, I don't want an actor.
06:31
And they just said, oh.
06:32
And when I told the producer, I mean, there's no music,
06:34
but there is no background music.
06:36
And I think the writer's thing was, so how will you know when
06:38
it's scary?
06:39
And their emotional part, I said, acting, hopefully.
06:43
And so I just didn't want any background music.
06:45
So it became all the more important
06:46
that the people that I cast were--
06:51
the genuine article.
06:52
So when they showed me all the actors, it never worked.
06:55
Then when I saw this Kabaddi player, they said,
06:56
but he can't act.
06:57
He's done nothing.
06:58
I said, it's OK.
06:59
Now we treat him like basically a child.
07:02
And he was so smart that-- but I did
07:05
create exactly the same environment
07:07
that I did for the fall.
07:08
But the first time they meet, the first scene is shot first.
07:11
The second scene is shot second.
07:12
Third scene-- so basically, I built their relationship
07:15
on that.
07:16
But somewhere when about 70% of it was done, he got it.
07:19
And then I could help production a bit
07:21
by shooting certain scenes out of sequence.
07:23
But until that particular point, I just said, you can't.
07:26
The guy is a sportsman.
07:28
He's coming.
07:29
He's doing everything I'm asking him.
07:30
Let's make his life comfortable.
07:33
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
07:35
I can't live without you.
07:37
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
07:39
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
07:41
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
07:42
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
07:43
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
07:46
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
07:49
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
07:52
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
07:55
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
07:57
But on the reverse with Jessie, you have to show her just
08:00
longing, but also her understanding of the world,
08:03
per se, and yet not understanding the world.
08:06
I had that good language barrier,
08:08
which the real girl did, too, that her English was
08:10
much better than the Punjabi's, very broken.
08:13
So you kind of give the other person a lot more benefit
08:15
of the doubt.
08:16
The problem was that even all the other actors
08:18
and all that they gave me, they were all actors.
08:20
And it was horrible.
08:22
So it couldn't work.
08:23
So in these particular time when I would get it,
08:25
I said, only one thing you have to do
08:26
is keep him away from actors.
08:27
And keep him away from-- because he's
08:29
coming from a different school.
08:30
And I'll get that naturalism out of him.
08:32
They should learn from him.
08:33
But the thing is, in the last scene, which is quite intense,
08:36
those people are incredible theater actors,
08:39
because there is nobody inside.
08:41
They're just on the phone doing a play in front.
08:43
I rehearsed it on location about 18, about 23 times.
08:48
And we shot one take, because I didn't want the mystic
08:52
to hear what's happening.
08:53
I said, he will never go in the zone.
08:55
He'll never give me that shot to tell me somebody and walk away.
08:58
And that's exactly what happened,
09:00
because I brought him over yesterday.
09:01
And for the first time, he saw the film.
09:03
He was supposed to go outside the theater and sing.
09:06
He saw that film.
09:07
He just didn't get up from his seat.
09:08
He just said, I can't.
09:09
And I said, OK, OK, send everybody home.
09:11
So I knew that's what would happen.
09:12
So those people are theater actors.
09:15
So it worked.
09:16
But I wanted them nowhere near the people
09:18
who were doing this stuff that was being made up
09:21
and moving along.
09:23
[NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]
09:24
But that's why the dichotomy of the shots,
09:46
like the last shot, which I want to give away,
09:48
the last shot with her and the way
09:50
that looks with the pan, and then going to them
09:53
and the singing and the way that book ends it.
09:56
I mean, obviously, it's--
09:57
[INTERPOSING VOICES]
09:58
--shot that, I was gutted.
09:59
I walked away.
10:01
And I just-- this thing, one of my friends said,
10:03
I think I've shot the best shot I've ever shot.
10:05
And the guy said, oh, is it incomplicated?
10:07
I said, it's a pan, actually.
10:11
It's a pan.
10:12
But I just thought it was--
10:13
the sun had to come up at the right time.
10:15
These guys, I told them, whatever happens,
10:17
this mistake, we'll get one chance at him.
10:19
Because when I asked him, can you do this?
10:20
I've seen you sometimes do this.
10:22
And his answer was, if it feels right.
10:25
So I had no idea what he's going to do.
10:27
I told him, OK, when you go, just walk off to the road,
10:29
go wherever you want.
10:30
He said, OK.
10:31
So when we did the thing, I knew we had one take.
10:33
But when the pan happened, the sun came up behind him.
10:36
It takes seven minutes to come out from behind the tree.
10:38
It's an 18-minute shot.
10:39
I cut out the last six minutes because I
10:41
thought on the big screen, you could see him till the very end.
10:44
But you can't.
10:45
Once he goes to the right, people--
10:47
but it needed that thing to decompress.
10:49
So I left the length of that shot,
10:51
because people are quite like Mark.
10:53
They were like, what did you just do?
10:55
When I showed it to him, there were no titles.
10:56
He was just thinking, I didn't know when to stop
10:58
and if I should stop.
10:59
And I just said, OK, I had to tweak
11:00
where the titles go to allow you enough time to decompress.
11:03
I tried taking out that section.
11:05
And it was like, hey, it would turn into a Gasparnoay film,
11:09
which is just when you hit it, bang, you go, OK, out,
11:12
finished.
11:12
And I didn't want to end there.
11:14
I think people needed a breather.
11:16
So I left that length in exaggeratedly.
11:19
[MUSIC PLAYING]
11:22
[MUSIC PLAYING]
11:26
[MUSIC PLAYING]
11:30
[MUSIC PLAYING]
11:34
[MUSIC PLAYING]
11:38
[MUSIC PLAYING]
11:41
(upbeat music)
11:44
[MUSIC PLAYING]
Recommended
13:33
|
Up next
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: DEAR JASSI [Toronto Intl Film Festival 2023 - Toronto, Ontario - Remote] - Part II
Fest Track
9/30/2023
13:24
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: LIMBO [Toronto Intl Film Festival 2023 - Toronto, Ontario - Remote] - Part II
Fest Track
9/14/2023
8:34
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: MR. K [Toronto Intl Film Festival 2024 - Toronto, Ontario] - Part I
Fest Track
12/3/2024
11:15
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: MR. K [Toronto Intl Film Festival 2024 - Toronto, Ontario] - Part II
Fest Track
12/3/2024
13:07
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: UNRULY [Toronto International Film Festival 2022] - Part I
Fest Track
9/22/2022
10:36
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: UNRULY [Toronto International Film Festival 2022] - Part II
Fest Track
9/22/2022
10:35
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: MEDUSA [Toronto International Film Festival 2021 - Virtual] - Part III
Fest Track
3/28/2022
11:38
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: MEDUSA [Toronto International Film Festival 2021 - Virtual] - Part II
Fest Track
3/28/2022
6:27
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: PROJECT WOLF HUNTING [Toronto International Film Festival 2022] - Part II
Fest Track
11/14/2022
8:12
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: PROJECT WOLF HUNTING [Toronto International Film Festival 2022] - Part I
Fest Track
11/14/2022
2:43
Fest Track On Sirk TV: TORONTO INTL FILM FESTIVAL MIX 2022 (Quick Look) [Toronto,Ontario]
Fest Track
11/14/2022
8:35
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: SUJO [Sundance Film Festival 2024] - Part I
Fest Track
2/7/2024
8:17
Fest Track On Sirk TV: BOMBAY ROSE [IFFAM 2019] - Part II
Fest Track
6/14/2021
8:12
Fest Track On Sirk TV: WET SEASON [IFFAM 2019] - Part I
Fest Track
6/14/2021
7:41
Fest Track On Sirk TV: BOMBAY ROSE [IFFAM 2019] - Part I
Fest Track
6/14/2021
11:38
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: MONTE VERITA [Locarno Film Festival 2021 - Virtual] - Part III
Fest Track
6/28/2022
12:43
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: MOSTRO [Locarno Film Festival 2021 - Virtual] - Part II
Fest Track
6/27/2022
13:59
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: MONTE VERITA [Locarno Film Festival 2021 - Virtual] - Part I
Fest Track
6/28/2022
14:09
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: ULTRASOUND [Tribeca Film Festival 2021- Virtual] - Part I
Fest Track
6/22/2021
12:15
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: I COMETE - A CORSICAN SUMMER [International Film Festival Rotterdam 2021 - Virtual]
Fest Track
2/14/2021
14:31
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: HUNTERS ON A WHITE FIELD [Tribeca Film Festival 2024] - Part II
Fest Track
6/27/2024
12:48
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: THE MOOGAI [Sundance Film Festival 2024] - Part II
Fest Track
2/8/2024
5:00
Fest Track On Sirk TV: DANCE WITH ME [IFFAM 2019]
Fest Track
6/14/2021
13:33
Fest Track On Sirk TV Film Interview: THE VIRGIN OF THE QUARRY LAKE [Sundance Film Festival 2025 - Virtual] - Part II
Fest Track
7/6/2025
11:02
Fest Track On Sirk TV Interview: THE MOOGAI [Sundance Film Festival 2024] - Part I
Fest Track
2/8/2024