[ENG] EP.1 Beyond the Bar (2025)

Asian TV

Watch [ENG] EP.1 Beyond the Bar (2025) - Asian TV on Dailymotion

Transcript

00:00:00Transcription by CastingWords

00:00:30CastingWords

00:01:00CastingWords

00:01:29CastingWords

00:01:59Okay, let's go.

00:02:06Okay, let's go.

00:02:15Kim Soyeon.

00:02:16Yes.

00:02:17Yes.

00:02:18Yes.

00:02:19Yes.

00:02:20Yes.

00:02:21Mhmm.

00:02:25Let's go.

00:02:26court.

00:02:27영화관을 안으로 들어와주세요.

00:02:31강요민 지현자.

00:02:40혹시 그,가,그...

00:02:41강요민 부 Kiev 불렀나요?

00:02:44아, 네, 방금.

00:02:48강요민 지현자는 안 온 것 같습니다.

00:02:49Yes.

00:02:57Sorry!

00:03:00What's your name?

00:03:01My name is 강효민.

00:03:19My name is 강효민.

00:03:36It's good to go.

00:03:47Let's go.

00:03:49Yes?

00:03:51It's time to take care of the time.

00:03:55It's time to take care of the time.

00:03:59If you have a job, it's time to take care of it.

00:04:02Let's go.

00:04:06Well, it's time to take care of it.

00:04:09Let's talk about it.

00:04:11Let's talk about it.

00:04:13Let's talk about it.

00:04:15I like it.

00:04:17I like it.

00:04:19I like it.

00:04:21I like it.

00:04:23So I like it.

00:04:25I like it.

00:04:27It's not me.

00:04:29I think it's okay to me.

00:04:31It's not me.

00:04:33I like it.

00:04:35I like it.

00:04:37I like it.

00:04:39Okay.

00:04:46I'm going to go outside.

00:04:48If you're feeling better...

00:04:51I'm going to go outside.

00:05:22I am sorry.

00:05:24Oh!

00:05:25Eh...

00:05:27Ah...

00:05:28The first time I got wrong with you.

00:05:29Oh, you know, I'm not sure.

00:05:30You're not sure?

00:05:32I'm not sure.

00:05:34The first time I got to go to the law school.

00:05:37That's the one I got.

00:05:39Ah, that's the one?

00:05:41Merit to class.

00:05:42It's a private, reliable and effective.

00:05:45We can't be able to do this.

00:05:47It's a good thing.

00:05:49It's a good thing.

00:05:50However, if it's a big issue, it's a very high level exercise.

00:05:53And if it's a better job, you can't organise it.

00:05:58But if it's a good quality class, you can't stop it, and it's the best way to Portia.

00:06:08This is a good quality class choices, and it's better at that.

00:06:15The teacher's a kid who has a couple of years ago can't be a good thing to get into it.

00:06:22But this is the case of the teacher's values.

00:06:29That's what your son has to be done.

00:06:32Yeah, he was a member of the Rehensers.

00:06:37What is the reason for the New York Times?

00:06:40What do you mean by the New York Times?

00:06:43We must have the same emotions.

00:06:45We must be in a constant way.

00:06:49We must have the same emotions.

00:06:51We must have the same emotions.

00:06:53We must have the same emotions without us.

00:06:57We could be able to continue to live.

00:06:59In order to develop an emotional emotional care and to be a person with the poor.

00:07:05Yes.

00:07:07I don't know if she's a child.

00:07:17What?

00:07:19That's right, the president.

00:07:22I think he's going to stay here.

00:07:25Right?

00:07:27If you're going to go, do you want to go?

00:07:30Yes, I had to go.

00:07:35You know, you're going to be the most important part of the time.

00:07:41But...

00:07:43We've got three people in the last year.

00:07:46We've got four people in the same way.

00:07:51Yes, that's the idea of the idea.

00:07:56Yes, I understand.

00:07:57I'm going to ask you a question.

00:08:27당연히 원고의 승소입니다.

00:08:29이유는?

00:08:30그 팔의 주인은 원고이니까요.

00:08:32돌려줘야죠.

00:08:34법률상 주인의 정의는?

00:08:36소유권자입니다.

00:08:38그 팔의 소유권은 원고에게 있고,

00:08:40피고가 정의를 침탈하였으므로

00:08:42원고는 반환 청구가 가능합니다.

00:08:45승소할 수 있습니다.

00:08:48다른 지원자들도 같은 생각입니까?

00:08:52아니요.

00:08:55반환 청구가 기각될 수도 있습니다.

00:08:59왜 그렇게 생각하죠?

00:09:01팔의 소유권이 원고에게 있는지 불확실하기 때문입니다.

00:09:05팔이 원고의 것이 아니라면 누구의 것이라는 거죠?

00:09:09이건 일반상식 아닌가요?

00:09:12일반상식과 법적 논리는 다르다고 생각합니다.

00:09:17계속해 보세요.

00:09:19법이 신체의 일부를 소유권의 대상으로 인정한다면

00:09:23그런 신체의 일부를 임의로 처분하거나 매매할 권리도 있어야 합니다.

00:09:27즉, 법적으로 자살할 권리도 장기를 매매할 권리도 인정돼야 하죠.

00:09:32하지만 법은 신체의 일부나 생명에 대해 이런 권리를 인정하지 않습니다.

00:09:37따라서 소유권을 근거로 한 반환 청구는 성립되기 어렵습니다.

00:09:43반환을 원한다면 다른 법적 근거로 찾아갈 것입니다.

00:09:47자, 그럼 다음 질문 드리겠습니다.

00:09:50김모 씨가 운행하는 기차에 100명의 승객이 타고 있습니다.

00:09:54그런데 앞에 놓인 거대한 바위로 인해 기차가 곧 충돌하려고 합니다.

00:09:59김모 씨는 변환기에 스위치를 내려 기차의 방향을 오른쪽으로 바꾸려고 하는데

00:10:04기술자가 한 명 서 있습니다.

00:10:06하지만 스위치를 내리지 않으면 저는 다 사망합니다.

00:10:12변환기에 스위치를 내리면 기차의 방향이 오른쪽으로 바뀌고

00:10:16기술자는 기차에 치여 죽습니다.

00:10:19김모 씨는 결국 스위치를 내려 100명을 살립니다.

00:10:22하지만 철로에 있던 기술자는 기차에 치여 죽습니다.

00:10:26그렇다면 김모 씨의 행위는 살인죄로 성립이 될까요?

00:10:30아니요.

00:10:31살인죄로 성립되지 않습니다.

00:10:33저도 그렇게 생각합니다.

00:10:35다수를 살리기 위한 어쩔 수 없는 선택이었으니까요.

00:10:38살인죄가 성립합니다.

00:10:41왜죠?

00:10:43범죄의 구성 요건이 충족되었기 때문입니다.

00:10:46스위치를 내리는 행위가 있었고 그 행위로 인해 기술자는 죽었고

00:10:50김모 씨는 기술자가 죽을 걸 알고도 그 행위로 했기 때문에 살인죄가 성립됩니다.

00:10:56100명의 생명을 살렸는데도 살인죄로 처벌 받아야 한다고요?

00:11:02그게 정의입니까?

00:11:05처벌을 받아야 한다고 하진 않았습니다.

00:11:08질문은 살인죄가 성립하냐는 거였고 범죄의 구성 요건이 충족되었기 때문에 살인죄가 성립한다는 게 제 답변입니다.

00:11:15다만 위법성 조각 사유가 인정된다면 처벌은 면할 수가 있겠죠.

00:11:22도덕적으로 옳은 행동이라도 구성 요건이 충족되면 범죄가 되고

00:11:26반대로 도덕적으로 잘못된 행동이라도 구성 요건이 충족되지 않으면 범죄가 되지 않습니다.

00:11:32법은 완벽하지 않습니다.

00:11:35도덕적 잣대와 법적 잣대가 늘 동일할 수는 없습니다.

00:11:39법주인에게는 그게 늘 숙제죠.

00:11:45법적 잣대가 늘 숙제죠.

00:11:55법적 잣대가 늘 숙제죠.

00:11:57왜 이렇게 안 일어났냐.

00:11:58연진은 잘 안 일어났나?

00:12:01응?

00:12:02아휴...

00:12:04어떻게 됐어?

00:12:06아...

00:12:08꽝했어.

00:12:09왜?

00:12:10안 늦으려고.

00:12:12한 시간이나 미리 나가서 전차를 탔는데 옆자리 남자가 급히 내리다 놓고 간...

00:12:17책 읽다가...

00:12:20늦었어.

00:12:22못 산다.

00:12:24또?

00:12:25아니, 리헨서 얼리 컨범 받고 지각해서 못 간 건 세상 너밖에 없을 거다.

00:12:29그래서...

00:12:30안 늦으려고 한 시간이나 일찍 갔다니까?

00:12:33아니, 그럼 뭐여.

00:12:34결론적으로 늦었는디.

00:12:36아, 내 운명이 아닌가 보지 뭐.

00:12:38에휴, 정신.

00:12:39야, 그래도 너무 그러지 마.

00:12:41어쩌냐, 쟤.

00:12:44안녕하세요.

00:12:45법무법인 윤림입니다.

00:12:47귀하는 신입 변호사 채용 전형에 최종 합격하셨음을 알려드립니다.

00:12:54왜 저래?

00:12:55됐어.

00:12:56어?

00:12:57윤림.

00:12:59아, 됐다고!

00:13:00어?

00:13:01저랬어?

00:13:02됐어?

00:13:03대박, 대박.

00:13:04잠깐만.

00:13:05윤림아!

00:13:06야!

00:13:07야!

00:13:08야!

00:13:09야!

00:13:10랩 Ergebnis.

00:13:19안녕하세요.

00:13:21로댕.

00:13:22president 에피소비티에

00:13:38No, I don't know.

00:13:44Oh, Kamin?

00:13:47You're not supposed to be a thing?

00:13:49It's not supposed to be a thing?

00:13:52I'm sorry.

00:13:54You're wrong.

00:13:55I'm sorry.

00:13:57You're wrong.

00:13:59I'm sorry.

00:14:04First of all, I'm going to start the law of the U.S.

00:14:06and the law of the U.S.

00:14:08and the law of the U.S.

00:14:10and the law of the U.S.

00:14:12Yes.

00:14:20Hello.

00:14:22I'm currently living in the U.S.

00:14:25Young & Rich and Smart

00:14:28and the U.S.

00:14:29is going to be a perfect U.S.

00:14:31I'm trying not to say that the U.S.

00:14:35stoll is going to give you some experiences.

00:14:37감사합니다.

00:14:39윤립, 충, SO.

00:14:41안녕하십니까.

00:14:43서울대 로스쿨 졸업한 14일 변호사 G.

00:14:44D.

00:14:45떨려?

00:14:46rene Em, 겁네.

00:14:49설마 올해도 1지망이 0명은 아니겠지.

00:14:52설마.

00:14:57윤석훈 변호사님은 뭐래?

00:14:59I will tell you, you're still on the old age.

00:15:03I want to say just a little.

00:15:04I'll tell you something else.

00:15:05There's a lot of people.

00:15:09There's a lot of people.

00:15:14I'm going to tell you that I'm not going to do it.

00:15:18I'm going to tell you the role of my role.

00:15:22I'm going to tell you that my ability is to prove it.

00:15:27Thank you very much.

00:15:32Hi.

00:15:33I'm a PhD grad student 14th.

00:15:35I'm a PhD coach for the University of Taiwan.

00:15:37I'll be in the future of the university of Taiwan.

00:15:41Thank you very much.

00:15:49This was our PhD coach for the group.

00:15:51We used to be a PhD coach for a long time.

00:15:53Are you written?

00:15:54I'm not sure.

00:15:55No news about the fact that you've built you pretty much.

00:16:02Then we'll turn each team free tonight.

00:16:09Tyo is a bigger team from HR committee.

00:16:17There are two types left here.

00:16:22...

00:16:30...

00:16:32...

00:16:37...

00:16:42...

00:16:44...

00:16:46...

00:16:50...

00:16:56...

00:16:58...

00:17:00...

00:17:02...

00:17:06...

00:17:08...

00:17:14The team is going to take a while.

00:17:17Take a while.

00:17:20There's no need for it.

00:17:23If you come in, you'll be in the morning, and at the morning, leave.

00:17:27Of course, if you're doing good work, you'll be able to do it.

00:17:31But if you're doing that, you'll be able to do that.

00:17:34You need to have time.

00:17:36Not to be able to do it.

00:17:39What do you know?

00:17:40You know what I know.

00:17:42You don't want to be a dog, right?

00:17:48I'm going to go to the team of the team, so I'm going to go to the team of the team.

00:17:50That's what I'm going to do.

00:17:57Yes, we will have time for Q&A.

00:18:02Yes?

00:20:00Thank you very much.

00:24:00I want to be of good people.

00:24:04There's a lot of good people to go.

00:24:08And I want to be helpful.

00:24:11I want to be kind of a fun guy.

00:24:16So much fun?

00:24:17One of them is for the sake of time, and you can't talk about it.

00:24:19For the sake of time, for the sake of time, the sake of time, and the sake of time.

00:24:26And he's very clean.

00:24:31He's not really clean.

00:24:34It's not anything like that.

00:24:35You look at the mullet and headwear.

00:24:40You're the one in the classic years of Yulim, you've heard of it.

00:24:44No.

00:24:45You're the one in the morning, and the afternoon, 6am.

00:24:50It's a long time to get out of the morning, but it's a long time to get out of the night.

00:24:54Yes.

00:24:55I'm clear.

00:24:56He's on a plane.

00:24:57You'll know what.

00:24:59He's gonna get up your head.

00:24:59I'm sure.

00:24:59So we're going to bring up some.

00:25:00You can only get a burden.

00:25:01I've got a lot to see it.

00:25:02I'm sorry.

00:25:03But it's not.

00:25:04You have to pay attention.

00:25:05I got a lot.

00:25:05And I got a lot.

00:25:06And I got a lot.

00:25:07I got everything in order to take care of it.

00:25:09And I got everything in order to tell her.

00:25:11And then I got it.

00:25:12I got it.

00:25:13How to do it.

00:25:14And then I got it.

00:25:14And I got it.

00:25:16And now he got it.

00:25:17And I got it.

00:25:18I got this before he got it.

00:25:18And now I got it.

00:25:20Yeah, you got it.

00:25:24Bingo.

00:25:41Well...

00:25:43I'm going to go to the new team, I'm also going to go to the new team in the front.

00:25:49So, I'm going to go to the new team, and the new team took place in the first two.

00:25:55The new team will be able to join the new team.

00:25:58You're going to go to the new team and then the new team will be able to join the team up.

00:26:02I'm not a person who is not a person.

00:26:04How can I get this? What is important?

00:26:06What is important to you?

00:26:08Ah...

00:26:09That's right.

00:26:10Then, then.

00:26:11This is the first time of the job.

00:26:15Two of them are the two of the two.

00:26:17The two of them are the two of the law.

00:26:19The law of the law is the water.

00:26:24The two of them are the one of the law.

00:26:28The law of the law is the law.

00:26:30No, no, no, no.

00:26:32I've got no way to get there.

00:26:34So, you can see it.

00:26:36Okay.

00:26:38I'll do it again.

00:26:40Okay.

00:26:42Okay.

00:26:44Yes.

00:26:45Yes.

00:26:46Yes.

00:26:47Yes.

00:26:48Yes.

00:26:50Yes.

00:26:51Yes.

00:26:52Yes.

00:26:54Yes.

00:26:56Yes.

00:26:57Yes.

00:26:58Yes.

00:26:59Sorry

00:27:00I was wrong

00:27:01He's wrong

00:27:02Mr.

00:27:03John

00:27:04He's 6th

00:27:0525th

00:27:06No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, he's not

00:27:09He's not

00:27:10I should

00:27:11No

00:27:12I'm not

00:27:13I'm not

00:27:17No

00:27:18And

00:27:19I'm not

00:27:20I'm not

00:27:22He is

00:27:23He is

00:27:25He is

00:27:25I'm

00:27:25I am

00:27:27Please check the file.

00:27:29Please check that out.

00:27:31Please check that out.

00:27:33Okay, now let's go to the interview.

00:27:36Yes.

00:27:37Please check that out.

00:27:38Yes.

00:27:39Please check it out.

00:27:42Please check it out.

00:27:46What's your job to do.

00:27:48Right, gang-in.

00:27:50The law school's and the law school's and the law school's and the law school's.

00:27:54Why?

00:27:56Well, I think it's hard to get a lot of fun.

00:28:00I mean, we're going to have a lot of fun.

00:28:04So, I'm going to change my job, but I don't want to change my job.

00:28:08So, that's not what I learned.

00:28:13But I don't want to change my job.

00:28:16I don't want to change my job.

00:28:22Yes?

00:28:30Yes.

00:28:31Okay.

00:28:32I'm going to invite you to the next meeting.

00:28:34Yes.

00:28:35Yes.

00:28:36Yes.

00:28:37Yes.

00:28:39Yes.

00:28:40Yes.

00:28:41Yes.

00:28:42Yes.

00:28:43Yes.

00:28:44Yes.

00:28:45Yes.

00:28:46Yes.

00:28:47Yes.

00:28:48Yes.

00:28:49Yes.

00:28:50Yes.

00:28:52Okay.

00:28:53Yes.

00:28:54Yeah.

00:28:55It's a dog Whatever I did.

00:28:56It's married.

00:28:57He's married?

00:28:58Yes.

00:28:59They already were married?

00:29:01They'd like old sister.

00:29:02That dogmaid is sick.

00:29:04Of course they grew back in order to help.

00:29:05Yes.

00:29:06Yes.

00:29:07Well, back then you're married.

00:29:08Yes.

00:29:09Sometimes someonegsgsgsfuglyard has something else.

00:29:11Let's go.

00:29:12Oh, Hmm?

00:29:13Yes.

00:29:14I'd like old sisterhood at home.

00:29:16Yes.

00:29:17I'd like word.

00:29:19And then you can see the team's who we are?

00:29:21I'm the one who's right here.

00:29:23It's the one who's named Kim Ilseong.

00:29:25That's right.

00:29:27The name of the partner who is named the team is the same name as he did.

00:29:31He was a good team for the team and he was very passionate about it.

00:29:33And then we had to work hard.

00:29:34Yes?

00:29:35But I didn't think that's what the President did.

00:29:38He was very young when I was young.

00:29:45It's just so annoying.

00:29:49I'll just get back to you.

00:29:53Why did you even have to go to your house?

00:29:55I'll go back to you.

00:29:57Oh, that's right.

00:29:59It's new.

00:30:05You can't wait to go for me anymore.

00:30:07I'm not a good friend.

00:30:09You still need to go?

00:30:11I'm gonna go home for a while.

00:30:13I'm gonna go home and get back to your house.

00:30:17Yeah, I don't like him there.

00:30:19...

00:30:20...

00:30:22Any other ...

00:30:24Right?

00:30:24...

00:30:26Yeah, isn't it.

00:30:27I'm sorry.

00:30:28...

00:30:29...

00:30:31...

00:30:36...

00:30:37...

00:30:41...

00:30:42...

00:30:45Cornel성 변호사님이 뭐를 유명한지 알아?

00:30:47you 현 장업자?

00:30:49Oiogig aka ....

00:30:50KILL LIGHLR.

00:30:52gün 변호사님과 Go 변호사님이 기업금융자문으로 yulDeAN 지 lah I can置 be master.

00:31:01근래에는 승률이 높지 않으세요?

00:31:03맞아.

00:31:04요새 승률 좋지.

00:31:05근데 그게 누구 덕분이라고?

00:31:10설마.

00:31:11bingoko 허민정이지.

00:31:12Wow.

00:31:13Well, there's a lot of power.

00:31:15I mean, there's a lot of power.

00:31:19Yeah.

00:31:21Let's go.

00:31:39Yeah.

00:31:42아무리 신입이라도 가압류랑 가처분을 헷갈려요?

00:31:45죄송합니다.

00:31:47죄송합니다는 요즘 신입들 유행어입니까?

00:31:49어떻게 유행어가 10년 내내 안 바뀝니까?

00:32:05금전지급 청구 보조장 누가 썼어요?

00:32:08제가...

00:32:10법률에 맞춰서 논리 정연하게 잘 썼는데 최악의 서면입니다.

00:32:15오타 세 개나 놨어요.

00:32:17오타 하나는 그래, 인간이니까.

00:32:19두 개는 일이 많았나 보다.

00:32:22세 개부터는 성의 문제입니다.

00:32:24청구에게 났다고 소송의 무게가 달라집니까?

00:32:27의료인한테는 소송 하나가 일생일대의 사건이에요.

00:32:31성의 없는 서민이 제일 최악입니다.

00:32:34알겠어요?

00:32:35네.

00:32:36명심하겠습니다.

00:32:37다음.

00:32:38네.

00:32:39레퍼런스 넘버 231-73 의뢰인이 피고인에게 기지급한 매매 대금 반환을 청구하는 소송입니다.

00:32:45서명 추하는 누가?

00:32:47제가 썼습니다.

00:32:48강변이랑 오변에게 업무 분장되었습니다.

00:32:55이게 맞아요?

00:32:57네.

00:32:58여기 피고는 원고에게 이 사건 계약에 따른 매매 대금과 그 지급일로부터 다 갚는 날까지 이자를 가산한 금액을 원상회복으로 지급할 의무가 있다라고 되어 있잖아요.

00:33:17네.

00:33:18조언.

00:33:24조언.

00:33:40잘 썼네요.

00:33:42이대로 정리해서 내보내세요.

00:33:43네.

00:33:44제 거는.

00:33:46결론 읽어보세요.

00:33:50피고는 원고에게 이 사건 계약에 따른 매매 대금과 이 사건 소장을 받은 다음 날부터 완납일까지 속조법 12%의 비율로 계산한 지원손해금을 부당이득으로 반환할 의무가 있습니다.

00:34:15설명해보세요.

00:34:28네.

00:34:29계약을 해제할 경우 민법 제548조에 따라 원상회복 의무가 발생하나 의사표시를 취소한 경우 민법 제741조에 따라 부당이득 반환 의무가 발생합니다.

00:34:40따라서 취소에 따라 원상회복 의무가 발생한다는 것은 잘못된 표현입니다.

00:34:45또한 반환 범위도 매도인이 법정이자를 지급할 필요가 없습니다.

00:34:52일머리 없으면 엉덩이라도 무겁게 책상에 붙이고 앉아 보고 또 보고 생각하고 또 생각해서 아웃풋을 내야 될 거 아닙니까?

00:35:05죄송합니다.

00:35:06앞으로 신입들 죄송합니다 금지 죄송합니다가 무슨 만능 언어인 줄 아는데 내가 제일 싫어하는 무책임한 말입니다.

00:35:19다음.

00:35:20네.

00:35:21마지막 안건이었습니다.

00:35:26윤림에서 뭐뭐 C라고 불리는 사람 갓 입사한 비변호사 사원들 밖에 없어요.

00:35:36근데 내가 왜 신입들 변호사라고 안 부르고 C라고 부르는 줄 알아요?

00:35:41변 씨 통과하면 다 변호사입니까?

00:35:43법인 키워드 측면에서 그 사원들보다 나은 게 있어요?

00:35:48영미계에서는 변호사 이름 뒤에 SQ를 붙입니다.

00:35:54SQ요.

00:35:56변호사를 존중하는 의미의 존칭이죠.

00:36:02그렇게들 불리고 싶으면 걸맞게들 갑시다.

00:36:05네!

00:36:06네!

00:36:07네!

00:36:08네!

00:36:10네!

00:36:11네!

00:36:12네!

00:36:13아빠 안투� CBD

00:36:16체다ается

00:36:19찬�úng가요?

00:36:21오ía

00:36:24저의 전앤 greatest

00:36:27Created

00:36:30RC

00:36:32네!

00:36:34I'm ready.

00:36:38I'm ready.

00:36:43Oh, well?

00:36:49Hi!

00:36:52hungrys!

00:36:53Hold this aside, mate!

00:36:55Wow!

00:36:57Good exciting.

00:36:58Good fish, moved on.

00:37:02Terranos are on.

00:38:53Yes, it's a good day.

00:38:54Yes, I hope you've been looking for the details.

00:38:55I'm looking for a question now.

00:38:56I'm looking for some of the details, but I have to keep with it.

00:38:57So...

00:38:58What?

00:38:59Yes, so we'll be looking for some of the details.

00:39:01What's the test?

00:39:02What's the test?

00:39:03What's the test?

00:39:04It's not a test!

00:39:05It's not a test!

00:39:06But I'll have to go with it.

00:39:16I think it's a test of the bus.

00:39:18I can't wait to see it.

00:39:23Let's go.

00:39:53I'm sorry.

00:40:04You've been here for a long time?

00:40:06Why?

00:40:07Is it a lot of fun?

00:40:08No, no.

00:40:10It's just a bit of a tradition.

00:40:12It's been a year since then.

00:40:14It's been a year since then.

00:40:15Oh, so?

00:40:16It's been a year since then?

00:40:18Well.

00:40:1930 years ago, so?

00:40:21That's it.

00:40:22I'm sorry.

00:40:38I'm sorry.

00:40:39I can't do this.

00:40:41I don't want to know what is this.

00:40:43I can't do anything.

00:40:45I can't do anything so well.

00:40:48I was going to go to our school.

00:40:50When I went to the club, I was going to go to the club.

00:40:55I don't want to go to the club anymore.

00:41:02Oh!

00:41:04Oh!

00:41:06Why?

00:41:08Why?

00:41:09Why?

00:41:10Why?

00:41:11Why?

00:41:12Why?

00:41:13Why?

00:41:15Why?

00:41:17Why?

00:41:19Where'd you go?

00:41:22You формal?

00:41:24I left him a bit.

00:41:26Youuck.

00:41:27I will sit!

00:41:28Er, I'm sure you'reniester.

00:41:30Can you backburg?

00:41:31Let's go.

00:41:32You're with me.

00:41:35Yes.

00:41:38You're welcome.

00:41:43Yes.

00:41:51Yes.

00:41:55Yes.

00:41:56Yes.

00:42:00That's when the guy saw that,

00:42:03and it was a few minutes ago.

00:42:07I know she's got a lot of money from her.

00:42:11I'm not sure you've got my friend's experience.

00:42:13I am not sure what to do.

00:42:15She said, what is she going to do?

00:42:18It's not what I have to say.

00:42:19We're going to go.

00:42:20I'm sorry.

00:42:21I'm sorry.

00:42:22I'm sorry.

00:42:23I'm sorry.

00:42:24You're going to go.

00:42:25I'm sorry.

00:42:27I'm sorry.

00:42:28I'm sorry.

00:42:29You're going to go.

00:42:30Yeah.

00:42:31I'm sorry.

00:42:32I'm sorry.

00:42:33I'm sorry.

00:42:34I have to apply this once.

00:42:37I also have to apply this to my client.

00:42:40Let's go.

00:42:42That's not good.

00:42:44So we'll go and go and start.

00:42:47I was able to go home.

00:42:50I was a good technician.

00:42:52I was a good technician to go home.

00:42:54Is that my cousin happened there?

00:42:55Do you have to take my family home?

00:42:59I was just going to try to get you to the hospital.

00:43:01I was about to take a little time.

00:43:03It's my opinion.

00:43:07You're right.

00:43:08It's my opinion.

00:43:10We're all right.

00:43:12We're all right?

00:43:13You're right.

00:43:15You're right.

00:43:19You're right.

00:43:22It's the one-time job.

00:43:24It's the one-time job.

00:43:28Yeah.

00:43:29So, we're working on a job.

00:43:32Why did you do that?

00:43:37It's weird.

00:43:38There are a lot of people who are in the city,

00:43:42but they are in the city of 30 years.

00:43:45But it's weird.

00:43:48So I'm going to go to the city.

00:43:50That's right.

00:43:52The city of the city of the city of the city of the city of the city,

00:43:57Do you think he's going to go to the city of On천마을?

00:44:04Yes.

00:44:05I'm going to talk about the situation.

00:44:08I'm going to talk about the situation.

00:44:11I think it's going to be a judge.

00:44:16Well, that's right.

00:44:20Well, I'm going to talk about it.

00:44:22I'm going to talk about it.

00:44:24What?

00:44:25On천마을 목욕탕에 가보니 24시간 오픈하고 탕도 24시간 뜨거웠어요.

00:44:3030년 넘게 그렇게 운영됐답니다, 한 것도 빠짐없이.

00:44:3430년 전에도 24시간이었고 7년 전에도 24시간이었는데 7년 전부터 매출이 급격히 떨어진 게.

00:44:42도시가스 납부 금액이 기본요금 플러스 사용연량 곱하기 적용당가 곱하기 1.1이거든요.

00:44:49사용량은 검침량에 온압 보정 개수로 곱해서 구해지는 거고 단위연량은...

00:44:54여쭤만 말하세요.

00:44:56사용연량이 조작된 것 같습니다.

00:45:01화실에?

00:45:02네.

00:45:03조사한 자료 있어?

00:45:04네.

00:45:05네.

00:45:06조사한 자료.

00:45:25이야...

00:45:26강요면...

00:45:28이 정도면 고지해 줘야 될 것 같은데요.

00:45:32강동 도시과스 담당자는 누구죠?

00:45:34김석진 대리아.

00:45:37부장급으로 미팅 잡아보세요.

00:45:39예.

00:45:43이번 일로 무단결근하고 지각이 무말됐다고 생각하지 마세요.

00:45:47네.

00:45:48한 번만 더 이렇게 멋대로 울면 징계 처리할 테니까.

00:45:54네, 알겠습니다.

00:46:10피고인 변호인 출석했습니까?

00:46:13네.

00:46:14김지훈 변호사 출석했습니다.

00:46:16네.

00:46:17그럼 시작하도록 하겠습니다.

00:46:19피해자!

00:46:20강동 도시과스 변호사!

00:46:22윤림의 강현민 변호사도 출석했습니다!

00:46:24그...

00:46:26보자기는 옆에 내려놓으시는 게...

00:46:28아...

00:46:32출석 여부 조서에 남겨주십시오.

00:46:35피해자 쪽 법률 대리인이시라고요?

00:46:38예, 그렇습니다.

00:46:40소리는 안 지르셔도 됩니다.

00:46:45출석 여부 조서에 남겨주세요.

00:46:48피고인은 사우나 기관실에서 보일러와 연결된 도시가스관과 계량기의 약 25cm 부분을 뜯고,

00:46:55그 부분에 가스 배관이 아닌 사제 동관 배관을 끼어넣어 도시가스를 절체하였습니다.

00:47:00절체는 금액이 안 적혀있는데 어떻게 되나요?

00:47:03그게 그러니까 아직 확인 중입니다.

00:47:06절체 규모를 알아야 재판을 하죠.

00:47:10아, 네. 그렇죠.

00:47:11그런데 가스를 얼마를 사용했는지 계산하는 시스템을 조작했으니 절체 규모를 파악하는 데 시간이 걸립니다.

00:47:16다음 기일에 제출할 예정입니다.

00:47:18그렇겠네요.

00:47:20옆에 이거 정상적으로 돌아가는 계량기를 붙여놔서 같이 비교할 수 있는 것도 아니고.

00:47:26검사님.

00:47:27검사님.

00:47:28절체 추산 가능합니다.

00:47:32재판장님.

00:47:33잠시 피해자 변호사와 얘기 나눠도 될까요?

00:47:35네, 좋습니다.

00:47:36잠시 휴정하겠습니다.

00:47:40제가 계산해 본 바 7년간 절체한 도시가스는 2486,839 세제곱미터로 시가 13호 2327만 원입니다.

00:47:5813호?

00:47:59어떻게 계산했죠?

00:48:10우선 군의 사건의 절치가 일어난 사우나를 모두 다 돌아다니면서 보일러 성능, 개수, 온탕 온도, 온탕 개수, 온탕 유지 시간과 영업 시간 등을 고려하여 계산하였습니다.

00:48:20이러한 고려 사항들을 각 목욕탕별로 정리해 피해 회사와 함께 산식을 대입시켜 만든 합계입니다.

00:48:30우리 의뢰인만 13억 원 정도고 타 지역에서도 동일한 방식으로 절체했기 때문에 다른 피해 회사 될 것까지 합치면 한 38억 원 정도 되지 않을까 싶네요.

00:48:40아, 그리고 저희가 계산한 절치액은 최효율로 가동했을 때만 나오는 금액인데 실제로는 그렇게 최효율로 가동되기 힘들어서 실제 절치액은 더 클 것으로 예상됩니다.

00:48:55재판장님, 피해자 변호사 측에서 준비한 자료를 증거 자료로 제출하고자 하는데 허락해 주시길 바랍니다.

00:49:01네, 일단 들어볼게요.

00:49:03피해자 변호사 측에서 준비한 자료에 의하면 강동 도시가스에 대한 절치액만 약 13억 원.

00:49:1013억 원으로 예상되고 타 지역에도 동일한 방식으로 절치했으므로 다 합치면 약 38억 원 정도로 추정된다고 합니다.

00:49:1738억 원이요?

00:49:18네, 그렇습니다.

00:49:20절치액의 추정치가 커짐에 따라 피고인의 중대한 처벌이 요구되는 상황입니다.

00:49:24아, 반사님!

00:49:25말도 안 됩니다.

00:49:27저희는 그냥 영세한 소상공인이고 가스비 좀 아껴보려고 그런 거예요.

00:49:33잘못한 거 알고 있습니다.

00:49:36하지만 살려고 발버둥 치다가 어쩔 수 없는 선택을 한 겁니다.

00:49:39독점적으로 가스를 공급하는 거대한 가스 회사에서 윤림 같은 대형 로펌 변호사를 붙여서 우리처럼 힘없고 영세한 소상공인을 몰아붙인다는 게 이게 너무 불공평한 거 아닙니까?

00:49:51피고인, 진정하시고 자리에 앉으세요.

00:50:01피해자 변호사 하실 말씀 있으세요?

00:50:04예, 있습니다!

00:50:06소리는 안 지르셔도 됩니다.

00:50:09말씀하세요.

00:50:10감사합니다.

00:50:11제가 잠시 앞으로 나가도 되겠습니까?

00:50:14네, 그러세요.

00:50:19재판장님.

00:50:27피고인은 마치 본 사건이 영세한 소상공인과 거대한 가스 회사의 소송으로 자신이 전형적인 힘의 불균형의 피해자인 양 행세를 하는데 피해자인 강동도시가스는 피고인보다도 더 힘든 환경 속에서 업무하는 소시민들의 집합체입니다.

00:50:47눈이 와도 비가 와도 한여름에도 한겨울에도 집집마다 검침하러 돌아다니는 검침원들.

00:50:55뜨거운 한여름, 열기 가득한 보일러실에서 업무하는 엔지니어들.

00:51:01뿐만 아니라 누군가의 이득을 봤으면 누군가는 손해를 보겠죠.

00:51:05가스 회사가 손해본 금액은 그야말로 영세한 소상공인들의 주머니에서 부담되었습니다.

00:51:13도둑질하지 않고 하루하루 열심히 살아가는 우리 법이 응당 보호해줘야만 마땅한 그런 영세한 소상공인들이여.

00:51:25피고인, 안 계세요.

00:51:27법원에서 사퇴질하지 마세요.

00:51:31이 재판 무료입니다.

00:51:33말 안 되잖아요.

00:51:35말 안 되잖아요.

00:51:37안 쓰겠습니다.

00:51:39대형 용펌 변호사를 교체하겠습니다.

00:51:41이거 말 사세요, 진짜.

00:51:43언제 그만큼 안 해 먹었어요.

00:51:47그럼 연락드릴게요.

00:51:49네.

00:51:51감사합니다, 변호사님.

00:51:59안녕하세요, 변호사님.

00:52:01아시아 도시가스에서는 왔습니다.

00:52:03아, 네.

00:52:05본 건 관련해서 저희도 의뢰를 맡기고 싶은데 어떻게 해야 되나요?

00:52:09어...

00:52:11저는 송주 도시가스인데 저희도 대리 부탁드립니다.

00:52:15잘 부탁드립니다.

00:52:17저는 송주가스에서 나왔습니다.

00:52:19잘 부탁드립니다.

00:52:25대단하네, 우리 효민.

00:52:29잘했지?

00:52:30응.

00:52:31아이, 그러니까 더 아쉽네.

00:52:33우리 리헨서로 왔어야 했는데.

00:52:35일 잘한다는 소문까지 나면 더 바빠질 텐데 큰일이네.

00:52:38아프면 좋지.

00:52:40그러지 말고 우리 그냥 오늘부터 같이 살까?

00:52:44그래.

00:52:45아니, 로스쿨 때는 공부하느라 바빴고 변호사 되고 리헨서로 오면 매일 보겠다 싶었더니 경쟁 높음으로 가버리고.

00:52:52거기다 일까지 잘해버리면 매일 야근 당첨인데 제대로 데이트나 하겠어.

00:52:57나 율님 이제 막 들어갔거든?

00:52:59적응할 때까지는 혼자 좀 놀아.

00:53:02난 늘 효민이가 1순위인데 도대체 난 언제 효민이 1순위가 되는 거야?

00:53:07어, 변호사님.

00:53:13어, 한 변호사.

00:53:15어, 여기서 뵙네요.

00:53:17어, 여기서 저녁 먹었어?

00:53:19네.

00:53:20곧 결혼할 친구랑.

00:53:22결혼?

00:53:23야, 이거 듣던 중 반가운 소리네.

00:53:26반가워요.

00:53:28이름이...

00:53:29아, 강...

00:53:30강효민 변호사예요.

00:53:31이번에 율림 신입으로 조인했습니다.

00:53:33아...

00:53:34변호사시구만.

00:53:35율림도 아주 훌륭한 로펌이지?

00:53:36네.

00:53:37강일찬 부장판사님 외동딸이에요.

00:53:38어?

00:53:39강일찬 판사님 따님이시구나.

00:53:42하하하하.

00:53:43어머니는 서울대 로스쿨 교수 최은희 교수님.

00:53:46아이고, 이 대단하신 분이시네.

00:53:49하하하하.

00:53:50아, 어디서 이렇게 귀한 분을 만났어?

00:53:52아주 폭 터졌어?

00:53:54하하하하.

00:53:55제가 전 세계 나라를 구했나 봐요.

00:53:58아, 어디서 이렇게 귀한 분을 만났어?

00:54:01아주 폭 터졌어?

00:54:03하하하하.

00:54:04제가 전 세계 나라를 구했나 봐요.

00:54:07하하하하.

00:54:08하하하하.

00:54:09하하하하.

00:54:10하하하하.

00:54:11하하하하.

00:54:13하하하하.

00:54:17하하하하.

00:54:28괜찮아?

00:54:29응?

00:54:30아니, 아까부터 분위기가 좀 무거워서 말도 없고...

00:54:32아니야.

00:54:33왜?

00:54:34No.

00:54:35Why?

00:54:36Did you have a mistake?

00:54:39Why did you like it?

00:54:43I don't like it.

00:54:45Did you know why?

00:54:47Did you like it?

00:54:49Did you like it?

00:54:50No.

00:54:51I don't like it.

00:54:53I don't like it.

00:54:55I don't like it.

00:54:57It's hard to hear, but it's hard to say it's hard to say.

00:55:01You know what.

00:55:02That's a hard-to-date version.

00:55:03Well, if you're wrong, it will have to be a rest.

00:55:07I could not even do it.

00:55:09You're the good government.

00:55:11You'll have to have a long time in your life.

00:55:14You're not friends.

00:55:17average is.

00:55:19We can have the relationship with you.

00:55:21It's clear that you love me just because you love me as a result in your life.

00:55:28Sure.

00:55:29She's got me.

00:55:31I want to give you a good use of my children.

00:55:35I'm always a good with my wife.

00:55:39I can't live in a good environment.

00:55:41I'm getting my heart out.

00:55:45I love you.

00:55:53I have to say that.

00:55:55Yeah, I do.

00:55:57Later.

00:55:58What is it?

00:55:59I don't know what to do.

00:56:27Okay, let's go.

00:56:35Okay, let's go.

00:56:37Okay, let's go.

00:56:41Let's go.

00:56:55Let's go.

00:56:57Yes?

00:56:59밥 먹을까?

00:57:03뭐 해줄까?

00:57:05내가 줄게.

00:57:07아, 진짜?

00:57:09뭐 해줄 건데?

00:57:11뭐 먹고 싶은데?

00:57:13나?

00:57:15네 입술.

00:57:17Oh

00:57:47No.

00:57:50No.

00:57:52No.

00:57:53What am I doing?

00:57:57Me too.

00:57:59What am I doing?

00:58:00Me too.

00:58:02No.

00:58:04Me too.

00:58:06Yeah.

00:58:10Me too.

00:58:15I don't want to see you.

00:58:21I don't want to see you.

00:58:45I don't want to see you.

00:59:15I don't want to see you.

00:59:45I don't want to see you.

00:59:46I don't want to see you.

00:59:47I don't want to see you.

00:59:48I don't want to see you.

00:59:49I don't want to see you.

00:59:50I don't want to see you.

00:59:51I don't want to see you.

00:59:52I don't want to see you.

00:59:53I don't want to see you.

00:59:54I don't want to see you.

00:59:55I don't want to see you.

00:59:56I don't want to see you.

00:59:57I don't want to see you.

00:59:58I don't want to see you.

00:59:59I don't want to see you.

01:00:00I don't want to see you.

01:00:01I don't want to see you.

01:00:02I don't want to see you.

01:00:03I don't want to see you.

01:00:04I don't want to see you.

01:00:05I don't want to see you.

01:00:06I don't want to see you.

01:00:07I don't want to see you.

01:00:08I don't want to see you.

01:00:09I don't want to see you.

01:00:10I don't want to see you.

01:00:11I don't want to see you.

01:00:12I don't want to see you.

01:00:13I don't want to see you.

01:00:14I don't want to see you.

01:00:15I don't want to see you.

01:00:16I don't want to see you.

01:00:17I don't want to see you.

01:00:18I don't want to see you.

01:00:19I don't want to see you.

01:00:20I don't want to see you.

01:00:21I don't want to see you.

01:00:22I don't want to see you.

01:00:23I don't want to see you.

01:00:24I don't want to see you.

01:00:25I don't want to see you.

01:00:26I don't want to see you.

01:00:27I don't want to see you.

01:00:28I don't want to see you.

01:00:29I don't know.

01:00:59You

01:01:29You

Category

Transcript

Recommended