Skip to playerSkip to main contentSkip to footer

Recommended

4:31
0:07
Judge Judy
6 days ago
0:11
  • 2 days ago

Category

People
Transcript
00:00Keith McIsaac says his neighbor, Dennis Coletti,
00:02ran his truck over his lawn, destroying his cesspool.
00:06Dennis says Keith cracked his windshield.
00:09So you had the whole thing done?
00:11I didn't have it done yet. That's just an estimate.
00:13I have to... I'm trying to get the money, you know.
00:16All right.
00:22Sir.
00:23Yes.
00:24Your answer says that you did him a favor
00:26because the cesspool was 45 years old
00:28and would have caved in anyway sooner or later.
00:29That was your answer, right?
00:30Well, every other cesspool in the neighborhood
00:31has caved in at one time or another,
00:33except for maybe one or two.
00:34But you pushed his sort of...
00:36You pushed his a little bit quicker.
00:38Well, my truck didn't fall in with it
00:39after I left his property.
00:40A cesspool happened to cave in as a coincidence.
00:42That helped it out.
00:43It's a terrible coincidence, but it did happen that way.
00:44I...
00:45Oh.
00:49Now, now that I have a figure on here on the cesspool
00:52and the damage on the cesspool from these bills,
00:55let's talk about your counterclaim.
00:57Wait till you hear this counterclaim.
00:58Would you like...
00:59Would you like to see the pictures
01:00of him driving on my grass?
01:01I don't care about him driving on your grass, sir.
01:05I don't care about him driving on your grass.
01:07But it's just the manner in which we visit each other
01:09and, you know, maybe...
01:10It's not on the grass.
01:11The pictures that he has does not show the car in the grass.
01:12Maybe it...
01:13Maybe it's childish behavior, but...
01:14I'm gonna give you three.
01:15I'm gonna count to three.
01:16And then if you both don't shut up,
01:18I'm gonna throw you both out.
01:19I won't hear your case.
01:20Do you understand?
01:21All right.
01:22So you're counterclaiming for $300.
01:25You want to tell me what the...
01:27What kind of damage he did and when this was?
01:29Well, the...the amount...
01:31The dollar amount that I...
01:32The estimate was changed to $119.08.
01:34Based on an estimate I got,
01:36I was under bad information
01:39when I gave that $300 claim.
01:41$119.08 for what?
01:43A windshield.
01:44My wife's car.
01:45All right.
01:46Now tell me about the windshield.
01:48We...we went away on vacation,
01:50my wife and I and my child,
01:52and we were good friends,
01:54and Keith used to house it,
01:55and we...I have dogs,
01:57and he would at times when I left the house
01:59for extended periods of time,
02:01take care of the animals in the house
02:03and watch over the house
02:04and feed my dogs and whatnot,
02:06and we came back from our vacation
02:09to find our dogs were never fed,
02:12and my wife's windshield was broken on a car.
02:15That was the...the only damage
02:17that I could put a dollar amount on
02:19outside of everything else he did
02:20in disaster.
02:21$119.08 is for the windshield.
02:23Yes.
02:24What happened to the windshield on the car?
02:25I have no idea what he's talking about
02:26with the windshield on the car.
02:27When did this happen, sir?
02:29It...when we came back from vacation.
02:31When? When? When?
02:32Month? Year?
02:33Uh, June of 96.
02:35June of 96?
02:36Yeah.
02:37What a life.
02:38June of 96.
02:39I mean, you're gonna go back in history,
02:41we're gonna go back to the year of the flood.
02:43If he didn't fix the windshield on your car,
02:45when was the first time you told him
02:46you wanted him to fix the windshield on your car?
02:48When we came back from...
02:49after I realized it was broken.
02:50And he said he didn't break it.
02:52So? Did you sue him?
02:54No.
02:55So you waited until this?
02:56Yes.
02:57Good. Goodbye on the counterclaim.
02:58You owe him $2,825
03:00so he can fix his driveway
03:01and he can fix his, uh, cesspool.
03:03You're 28 years old,
03:04you're supposed to be a responsible human being.
03:06You have a wife, you have a child,
03:07you don't take a truck and drive it on somebody else's lawn.
03:10That's stupid.
03:11Goodbye.
03:12If bodies are excused, you may step out.
03:14Bye.
03:15Bye.
03:16Bye.

Recommended

4:31
0:07
Judge Judy
6 days ago
0:11