Skip to playerSkip to main contentSkip to footer
  • 7/7/2025
Kochi (Kerala) July 7, 2025 (ANI): Vice President Jagdeep Dhankhar says, "...Our judiciary had Ides of March on the night intervening 14th and 15th March...Cash in large amount was found at the official residence of a judge of the High Court...If that cash was found, the system should have moved immediately and the first process would have been to deal with it as a criminal act, find out those who are culpable and bring them to justice. But so far, there has been no FIR. The government at the central level is handicapped because an FIR cannot be registered in view of a judgment of the Supreme Court rendered in early 90s. I'm all for independence of Judiciary. I'm a strong votary of protecting judges...We must protect our Judges from frivolous litigation...But when something like this happens, it is worrisome."

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Certain constitutional authorities are not permitted to hold assignment after their office.
00:11Preamble of our constitution was changed during a time when hundreds and thousands of people were behind the bars,
00:18the darkest period of our democracy, the emergency era.
00:23Ideas of march is associated with misfortune and doom.
00:30Our judiciary had ideas of march officially put up by the Supreme Court
00:35that the official residence of a judge of the Supreme Court, judge of the High Court, cash in large amount was found.
00:50Certain constitutional authorities are not permitted to hold assignment after their office.
01:01Like a public service commission member cannot take any assignment under the government.
01:11CAG can't take that assignment.
01:14Chief election commissioner and election commissioners can't take that assignment.
01:18Because they must be free not to be subjected to allurements and temptations.
01:26This was not for judges.
01:32Why?
01:35Because judges were expected to be totally away from it.
01:39And now we are post-retirement, post-for judges.
01:43Am I right?
01:43And not all can be accommodated, only some can be accommodated.
01:50So when you can't accommodate all, you accommodate some.
01:54There is pick and choose.
01:56When there is pick and choose, there is patronage.
01:59It is seriously impairing our judiciary.
02:05We had turbulent times in judiciary recently.
02:09But good thing is, soothing, a big change has taken place.
02:16We are seeing good times now for judiciary.
02:21The present chief justice and his predecessor, immediate predecessor.
02:24Gave us new area of accountability, transparency.
02:36They are getting things back on the rails.
02:39But earlier two years were very disturbing.
02:43Were very challenging.
02:47The normal system was not normal.
02:49Thoughtlessly several steps were taken.
02:56It will take a while to undo them.
03:00Because it is very fundamental that institutions function with optimal performance.
03:08If Rajya Shabha engages in disruption and disturbance and does not function,
03:13well, that's a cause of worry.
03:15It will be alarmingly worrisome.
03:19There has been a lot of issue about preamble to the constitution.
03:25Well, first, let me tell you.
03:27Preamble of Indian constitution is something like parenthood to children.
03:33Howsoever you may try, you can't change your parenthood.
03:38Am I right?
03:39That's not possible.
03:40That is preamble.
03:41Secondly, historically, no country's preamble has ever been changed.
03:49Thirdly, preamble of our constitution was changed during a time when hundreds and thousands of people were behind the bars.
03:58The darkest period of our democracy.
04:01The emergency era.
04:02Then it was changed where the life of the Lok Sabha was also increased beyond five years.
04:17It was changed at a time when people had no access to the justice system.
04:23Fundamental rights were totally suspended.
04:25You need to examine it.
04:26We may do anything.
04:30We surely can't change our parents.
04:33My young friends, if you have heard of Idis of March,
04:38those of you who have read Julius Caesar,
04:42where the soothsayer caution Caesar,
04:46beware of Idis of March.
04:48And when the Caesar was going from the palace to the courtroom,
04:55he spotted the soothsayer.
04:59And he said,
05:00Idis of March has come.
05:04And Caesar said,
05:06the soothsayer said,
05:08yes,
05:09but not gone.
05:10And before the day was over,
05:15Caesar was assassinated.
05:18Idis of March is associated
05:19with misfortune and doom.
05:24Our judiciary had Idis of March
05:27on the night intervening 14th and 15th.
05:32March,
05:34a terrible time.
05:36there was cash over all
05:40at the residence of a judge
05:42in large quantum.
05:47I say so because
05:48it is now in public domain
05:51officially put up by the Supreme Court.
05:57That the,
05:58that are the residence,
05:59official residence
06:00of
06:02a judge of the Supreme Court,
06:05judge of the High Court,
06:08cash in large amount was found.
06:11Now the point is,
06:14if that cash was found,
06:17system should have moved immediately.
06:21And the first process would have been
06:23to deal with it
06:27as a criminal act.
06:30Find out those who are culpable.
06:32bring them to justice.
06:38But so far,
06:39there has been no FIR.
06:43The government
06:44at the central level
06:45is handicapped
06:46because an FIR
06:51cannot be registered
06:52in view of a judgment
06:55of the Supreme Court
06:56rendered in early 90s.
06:57You must read that judgment.
06:58I am all for independence
07:02of judiciary.
07:04I am a strong votary
07:06of protecting judges.
07:09Judges deal with
07:10very difficult situations.
07:13They decide cases
07:14against
07:16the executive.
07:20They deal in certain areas
07:22with legislature matters.
07:23We must protect our judges
07:26from frivolous litigation.
07:30So I am not
07:30against the mechanism
07:32evolved.
07:34But when something
07:36like this happens,
07:38some things are worrisome.
07:41the incident took place,
07:45boys and girls,
07:47on
07:47night
07:51and termining
07:5114th and 15th
07:53March,
07:55we did not come
07:57to know about it.
08:00It was only
08:01on 21st March
08:02this year,
08:05after about
08:06seven days,
08:07we came
08:10to know
08:10about this
08:10ghastly crime.
08:14Now
08:15question arises,
08:17did anyone
08:18know about it
08:19earlier?
08:20Yes,
08:22it was
08:23a
08:24fire incident.
08:28The
08:28fire
08:28fighting
08:29mechanism
08:29was there.
08:33Those
08:34involved
08:34with the
08:34system
08:35knew about
08:35it.
08:37why
08:38it was
08:39not
08:39shared?
08:41I am
08:42a concerned
08:42man.
08:45Whether
08:46this is
08:46an incident
08:47in isolation
08:48or
08:50there
08:50are
08:50other
08:50similar
08:51incidents,
08:53that is
08:55something
08:55which we
08:55have to
08:55deal
08:56with.
08:58I
08:58therefore
08:58strongly
08:59feel
08:59and I
08:59have
09:00said
09:00it
09:00on
09:00multiple
09:00occasions.
09:04Proceeding
09:04with the
09:04constitutional
09:05mechanism
09:06of dealing
09:06with the
09:07church
09:07in terms
09:09of
09:10constitutional
09:10provision
09:11is one
09:11way out.
09:13But that
09:14is not
09:15a solution
09:15because we
09:17claim to
09:18be a
09:18democracy
09:19which we
09:19are.
09:21The world
09:22looks at
09:22looks as
09:23a mature
09:25democracy
09:26where there
09:27has to be
09:28rule of
09:28law,
09:29equality
09:30before law,
09:31which means
09:34every crime
09:35must be
09:35investigated.
09:37If the
09:38money is
09:39so huge
09:39in volume,
09:42we have
09:43to find
09:43out,
09:44is it
09:45tented
09:45money?
09:48What is
09:48the source
09:49of this
09:49money?
09:51How was
09:52it
09:52stacked in
09:53the
09:53residence,
09:54official
09:54residence of
09:55a judge?
09:55it
09:57belong to
09:57whom?
10:00Several
10:01penal
10:01provisions
10:01are
10:02violated
10:02in the
10:03process.
10:04I do
10:05hope
10:05NFIR
10:08will be
10:08registered.
10:10We
10:10must go
10:11to the
10:12root of
10:12the matter
10:12because
10:13for the
10:15democracy
10:15it matters
10:16that our
10:18judiciary
10:18in whom
10:19the
10:19faith
10:20is
10:21unshakable.
10:23Its
10:23very
10:23foundations
10:24have been
10:25shaken.
10:27The
10:27citadel
10:27is
10:27torturing
10:28because
10:30of this
10:30incident.

Recommended