Panayam kay Atty. Dindo Garciano, Governor, Philconsa | Unang Balita - video Dailymotion

GMA Integrated News

Unang Balita is the news segment of GMA Network's daily morning program, Unang Hirit. It's anchored by Arnold Clavio, Susan Enriquez, Ivan Mayrina, and Mariz Umali, and airs on GMA-7 Mondays to Fridays at 5:30 AM (PHL Time). For more videos from Unang Balita, visit http://www.gmanetwork.com/unangbalita.  #GMAIntegratedNews #GMANetwork #KapusoStream  Breaking news and stories from the Philippines and abroad: GMA Integrated News Portal: http://www.gmanews.tv Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/gmanews TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@gmanews Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/gmanews Instagram: http://www.instagram.com/gmanews  GMA Network Kapuso programs on GMA Pinoy TV: https://gmapinoytv.com/subscribe

Transcript

00:00Lumagdag ang Philippine Constitution Association of Filconsa

00:03sa mga kumakwestiyon sa pagbabalik na impeachment court

00:06ng Articles of Impeachment sa Kamara.

00:08At kaugnay po niyan, mga kapanayan po natin si Filconsa

00:11Governor Attorney Dindo Garciano.

00:13Magandang umaga po sa inyo, attorney.

00:15Si Maris po ito at live po tayo sa unang balita.

00:18Magandang umaga sa iyo, Maris, at sa inyong mga tagapaginig.

00:21Una po sa lahat, sir, may mga binanggit po kasi yung Filconsa

00:24na constitutional concerns, no?

00:26Kaugnay ng ginawa na impeachment court

00:28kabilang yung grave abuse of discretion,

00:31encroachment sa exclusive power ng House, at iba pa.

00:34Pakipaliwanag nga po itong pahayag po ninyo.

00:37Okay.

00:39First, let's go to the remanding.

00:42Order remanding.

00:44The case by the impeachment court to the House of Representatives.

00:49Ang tingin po namin doon,

00:50yan po ay isang order na nalimboy.

00:54Kasi yan po ay encroachment sa constitutional prerogative.

00:58ng House of Representatives to be the sole initiator of impeachment complaints

01:05against impeachable officials.

01:08That is the constitutional basis in saying that the order remanding the case

01:15to the House of Representatives is nalimboy.

01:19Now, it is also grave abuse of discretion

01:22because since it's an alimboy order

01:24and since it went beyond the authority of the impeachment court for them to do,

01:31then that is an exercise that's a grave abuse of discretion.

01:34It amounts to a whimsical, capricious, and despotic exercise of jurisdiction

01:42which is unamount to lack of jurisdiction.

01:45So, yan ang mga pinring-up namin.

01:48At saka yung sinasabi nga ni Chief Justice Puno rin

01:52na mayroong circumlocutory na mga pamamaraan na ginawaan.

01:59Ang term nga is circumlocutory.

02:00It means to say that the impeachment court seems to be exercising their jurisdiction

02:06but in effect, they are evading the exercise of jurisdiction

02:11because they are doing evasive maneuvers

02:15to be able to say that we are exercising our jurisdiction

02:19but in effect, we are not.

02:22So, that is dangerous.

02:24Ito po yung sinasabi ng Felconza na tila nagpapaikot-ikot daw po

02:28ang Senado para i-delay yung trial

02:30at ano po ba ang magiging implication nito kung sakasakali?

02:36Hindi nagpapaikot-ikot para i-delay.

02:39Pag sinasabi mong imi-ikot para i-delay,

02:44ginagamit mo yung exercise of jurisdiction mo in some ways.

02:48Ang sinasabi natin dito is

02:50they are exercise, they are parang, let's put it bluntly, parang lukuhan.

02:57Okay?

02:58Pinakikita namin, pinakikita namin sa tao

03:01na ine-exercise namin ang aming constitutional duty.

03:05Na-exercise namin ang aming jurisdiction over the case

03:10as an impeachment court.

03:12Pero in effect, hindi namin ginagawa yun.

03:14Yun ang ibig sabihin nun.

03:16In effect, hindi namin ginagawa yun

03:18at gumagawa kami ng mga pamumaraan o dahilan

03:22para hindi gawin yun.

03:24Pero ang pinalalabas sa tao,

03:28ang pinalalabas sa publiko ay

03:30ginagawa nila.

03:32Yan po ang ibig sabihin ni Chief Justice Puno

03:35dun sa SIRM Locatory.

03:38Attorney,

03:40ano po ang posibleng mangyari

03:41kung halimbawa manindigan ng Senado o Impeachment Court

03:43na sila talaga yung masusunod kaugnay po rito

03:45sa pagbabalik ng Articles of Impeachment sa Kamara?

03:47Ay, hindi naman sinasabi na sila ang masusunod

03:55because they are the ones that teach you the order.

03:57Kasi as an Impeachment Court,

04:00of course, korte sila, sila yung usgado,

04:03the prosecutors are the ones facing the order.

04:06So, to build yourself in a court setting,

04:09the judge is in front of you,

04:13is above you,

04:14and the prosecutors are lower than the judge.

04:17So, if you say, on that context,

04:19hindi kayo equal, no?

04:20But it doesn't necessarily mean

04:22that kung anong sabihin ng korte

04:24o Impeachment Court

04:26ay susundin ang prosecutors.

04:28Kaya nga may tinatawag tayong mga legal remedies

04:31na bago tayo sumunod sa isang kautosan,

04:35na inaakala natin hindi nahaayon sa batas

04:39o sa legal batas,

04:40ay marami tayong legal remedies na gawin

04:44para yun ay pasinungalingan

04:46o yun ay atakihin

04:48para sa tinatawag,

04:49ang ginagawa ninyo ay nabag sa batas.

04:52Yan ang ibig sabihin nun.

04:59Kaya, ano ang mga legal remedies?

05:01Yes, exactly. Ano po yun?

05:02Okay.

05:04Ang sinabi ni Congressman Joel Chua Kangina

05:07na ang kongreso daw ay may plano

05:09mag-file a motion for clarification.

05:12Okay?

05:13Okay.

05:15Sa...

05:16Pag nag-file ka ng motion for clarification

05:19sa aking pananahong mo,

05:22yan ay isang magbaaring magkaroon ng implied admissions.

05:27Implied admissions na tinatanggap mo na tama

05:31ang atlegal,

05:34ang inisong order ng Impeachment Court.

05:37Dahil humihingi ka nga ng clarification.

05:39Parang,

05:40kaya ka humihingi ng clarification,

05:42gusto mong sundin.

05:43Okay?

05:44Okay.

05:44Kaya,

05:46paki, ano mga sa sinasabi mo,

05:49pakilingwanag mo nga dahil,

05:51ano eh,

05:52gusto ka namin sumunod.

05:53Anong ibig mo sabihin?

05:55That is the,

05:56that is an implied admission.

05:58Okay.

05:59Okay.

06:00Pero para sa akin,

06:01para sa akin,

06:02yun ay

06:03mahinang remedy.

06:06Okay.

06:06Anong malakas

06:07na legal remedy?

06:10Yes.

06:10Ang sinasabi nga natin

06:11ay

06:12unconstitutional

06:14at not and void

06:15yung order ngayon.

06:17So mag-file,

06:18dapat nang gawin sana,

06:19eh mag-file ka ng motion

06:20for reconsideration.

06:22Atakihin mo yung order.

06:24Sabi mo mo

06:25that your order,

06:27with all due respect,

06:28your honors,

06:29is not and void.

06:30It's void of inisyo.

06:32Okay.

06:32Okay?

06:33From the very beginning.

06:34Why?

06:34Because it's

06:35violative

06:36of the Constitution

06:37which gives us

06:39in the House of Representatives,

06:40the prosecutors,

06:41the sole authority

06:43to initiate

06:44impeachment complaints

06:46against impeachable officials.

06:47And you have no business

06:49telling us

06:49to prove

06:51that our articles

06:53of impeachment

06:53or complaint

06:54is constitutional

06:56or not.

06:57It is not for us.

06:58The burden of proof

06:59is not on us

07:00to prove

07:01the constitutionality.

07:02It is for the defendant

07:04to prove

07:05that our articles

07:08of impeachment

07:10is unconstitutional.

07:13Pasabi-sasabi nila,

07:14wala kaming demanda.

07:16We do not have

07:16a cause of action.

07:18So it is the defense

07:19who should face that

07:20and who has to prove that.

07:22But not the impeachment court.

07:25The impeachment court.

07:26So very quickly,

07:30dahil ba sa nangyayaring ito,

07:31pwede bang sumiklab

07:32ang isang

07:32constitutional crisis

07:33at ano ang papel

07:35ng Phil Konsa

07:36sa mga

07:37constitutional processes

07:38na yan ganito

07:39gaya ng impeachment?

07:41Well,

07:42dapat talagang

07:43walang mangyaring

07:45constitutional crisis.

07:47Because

07:48a constitutional crisis

07:49will not good

07:50for the nation.

07:52Okay?

07:52There must be

07:53some sort of

07:55way

07:56that

07:57the impeachment court

07:59could proceed

08:00without delay

08:01and without

08:02any deadlocks.

08:04Okay?

08:05So sa tingin ko naman,

08:06the

08:07prosecutors

08:08and

08:09members of the Senate

08:10at the self-impeachment

08:12court

08:12are

08:12reasonable

08:14people,

08:15patriotic

08:16people

08:16who would rather,

08:18who would not

08:19allow

08:19a

08:21national crisis

08:23to

08:23happen

08:25by virtue

08:26of allowing

08:27a constitutional

08:28crisis.

08:29Alright.

08:29Huwag naman

08:30ilang gawin yun.

08:31Because,

08:32you know,

08:33if

08:33there will be

08:35a stalemate,

08:37then

08:37hindi naman sila

08:39ang mag,

08:39hindi naman sila,

08:40hindi naman yung mga

08:41pride nila

08:42ang

08:42magsasuffer.

08:44Ang taong bayan eh.

08:45Yes, yes.

08:46Ang taong bayan.

08:46Ang taong bayan

08:47na naglagay sa kanila dyan,

08:49sa mga

08:49kapangyarihan niyan

08:50para tuktukti nila

08:52ang kanilang mga

08:53katungkulan na silumpahan.

08:55So,

08:55huwag nila tayong

08:55idamay.

08:56Tayo naman ay

08:57nandito lang,

08:58nanonood,

08:59at gusto lang naman

09:00nating malaman,

09:01totoo ba

09:02ang mga bintang

09:03sa ating

09:04pangalawang Pangulo?

09:05Lahat tayong

09:06gusto malaman yun.

09:08Lahat po tayong

09:08gusto talaga malaman yun.

09:10Kaya maraming-maraming

09:10salamat po

09:11sa informasyon

09:12binigay niyo po sa amin,

09:13Attorney Dindo Garciano,

09:14Governor po

09:15ng Pilcons.

09:16Magandang umaga po sa inyo.

09:17Magandang umaga sa iyo.

09:18Magustang tayo.

09:20Gusto mo ba

09:21mauna sa mga balita?

09:23Mag-subscribe na

09:24sa GMA Integrated News

09:25sa YouTube

09:25at tumutok

09:27sa unang balita.

Panayam kay Atty. Dindo Garciano, Governor, Philconsa | Unang Balita

Category

Transcript

Recommended