Skip to playerSkip to main contentSkip to footer
  • 6/2/2025
When reason fails, the devil helps. | dG1fbk9PRHBWNlpjNTQ
Transcript
00:00The British justice system is in trouble.
00:04People no longer believe in it.
00:06Almost three quarters think judges' sentences
00:10aren't tough enough.
00:12Whether it's celebrities walking free after breaking the law.
00:16Hugh Edwards avoids jail.
00:19Or murderers sentenced to psychiatric care instead of prison.
00:23Enough is enough.
00:24Heads need to roll.
00:25They wanted him tried for murder, not manslaughter.
00:29Sentencing is the final part of every trial and the most controversial.
00:34I think it's outrageous.
00:35The problem is short sentences, it's too easy.
00:38It's the part that makes people very angry.
00:42So tonight, we're going to try and experiment.
00:45These offences fall into the highest category.
00:47We're going to reconstruct sentencing hearings.
00:51The whole matter arose from an extraordinary series of events.
00:55We're going to unravel real crimes.
00:59You flew back like a plank, smashed his head on the pavement.
01:02With convicted criminals.
01:04As soon as he picked that notebook, he meant to kill her.
01:08And when you've heard all the facts of the case, you can be the judge.
01:14What sentence would you give them?
01:16I've really struggled with this one.
01:18Where do we pitch it?
01:19I would say 12.
01:20Life in prison.
01:22You'll be watching with groups of people who have their own experience of the justice system.
01:28You can compare your judgement to theirs.
01:31Personally, I wouldn't jail them.
01:34And to the actual judge's sentence.
01:37I sentence you to be detained during Her Majesty's pleasure.
01:42Knock them up and throw away the key.
01:45Or let them off lightly.
01:47What will you decide?
01:49Let them in.
01:54What do you decide?
01:56Let them in.
01:57Let them in.
01:58Police.
01:59They have to be beaten.

Recommended