Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
'It's An Awful Act': Mark DeSaulnier Torches SAVE Act, Says It Is About 'Disenfranchising People'
Forbes Breaking News
Follow
4/17/2025
During a town hall on Wednesday, Rep. Mark DeSaulnier (D-CA) was asked about Democratic support for the SAVE Act, which would require proof of citizenship to register to vote.
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
The next question is from Desiree. Why would any Democrat vote for the SAVE Act?
00:09
Why didn't anybody?
00:11
Why would any Democrat vote for the SAVE Act?
00:14
I don't know why they would. I mean, it's an awful act. It's fortunately not going to get the votes in the Senate,
00:20
but it's about disenfranchising people and making it harder for people to vote.
00:24
And I think that's about as un-American as you can get.
00:27
But we want informed voters, but we also want to make it easy for people to vote.
00:32
It's, you know, people have two jobs, a lot of demands on their time.
00:37
We want to make it easy for people to be informed and to vote.
00:40
What could be more American than that?
00:42
So I don't know why anyone would vote for that. It was a horrible bill.
00:45
I will say on that subject matter, there are people in the Congress and in this country
01:00
who do make the argument that we're not a democracy, that we're a republic.
01:05
And they will usually refer to the founders when the country was founded.
01:09
That only white men who own property could vote.
01:14
The way I read the founders, and I've done a lot of reading,
01:18
is that they believed as literacy rates went up, Franklin in particular,
01:22
that people would be able to vote for their representatives.
01:27
So that's my argument against this.
01:29
But there are people in regards to that question, a lot of these questions,
01:33
who think when they convince average voters to vote against their own interests,
01:37
they're demonstrating their point, that it's supposed to be a republic in their view,
01:42
and a select group of people are supposed to make the decisions.
01:45
I don't feel that way. I hope most people don't feel like that.
01:48
I believe in everyday voters.
01:52
Sometimes they disappoint me recently.
01:55
But I ultimately have faith that...
01:58
De Tocqueville had many great lines, but when he came and looked at America,
02:01
one of his brilliant...
02:02
I think my favorite line for De Tocqueville was,
02:05
as he said, when he went back to Europe to explain what was happening in America in the late 1800s,
02:10
he says, America was founded, is founded on a simple premise,
02:15
that you can expect extraordinary things from ordinary people.
02:21
Not always.
02:23
And I guess you could say extraordinary could be taken two ways,
02:26
but I think in De Tocqueville's message, it was aspirational.
Recommended
1:49
|
Up next
Judge Blocks Trump From Mandating Proof Of Citizenship For Voting
Forbes Breaking News
4/24/2025
0:48
Elon Musk Says Those Against Bill Requiring Proof Of Citizenship To Vote Should Face Severe Penalty: 'Those Who Oppose This Are Traitors'
Benzinga
7/8/2024
1:20
Mark DeSaulnier Asked By Voter About Trump Invoking Wartime Alien Enemies Act For Deportations
Forbes Breaking News
4/17/2025
2:49
'Illegal Immigration Is Killing My Small Business': Mark DeSaulnier Responds To Question From Voter
Forbes Breaking News
4/17/2025
3:12
Mark DeSaulnier Pressed On Taking 'Real Action' Against Trump: 'Democrats Seem Weak, Unorganized'_ 'Democrats Seem Weak, Unorganized'
Forbes Breaking News
4/17/2025
0:34
Trump Blasts Truth Social, Saying, 'THE DEMOCRATS ARE TRYING TO ‘STUFF’ VOTER REGISTRATIONS WITH ILLEGAL ALIENS.' Urges Congressional Republicans to Push for Government Shutdown If 'Poison Pill' Bill Fails
Benzinga
9/11/2024
0:41
Divided Supreme Court Allows Partial Enforcement of Arizona Voter Law. RNC Celebrates Partial Victory
Benzinga
8/23/2024
3:06
Mark DeSaulnier Demands Due Process For People Arrested And Facing Deportation Under Trump Admin.
Forbes Breaking News
4/17/2025
0:54
Trump Asked: Is The SCOTUS Birthright Citizenship Decision ‘A Full Green Light For Your Agenda’?
Forbes Breaking News
6/27/2025
0:49
Trump Admin Faces Legal Defeats as Judges Block Key Orders on Immigration, Voting, and DEI
Benzinga
4/25/2025
2:09
SCOTUS Reversing Birthright Citizenship Would Be An 'Extraordinary' Move: Constitutional Lawyer
Forbes Breaking News
5/16/2025
1:06
'Our Laws Have Loopholes': Andy Harris Advocates For The SAVE Act, To Ensure Only Americans Vote
Forbes Breaking News
4/15/2025
1:13
'It Won't Allow Me To Vote': Chuck Grassley Grilled By Constituent Over The SAVE Act
Forbes Breaking News
4/15/2025
2:34
Trump's new electoral reform REVEAL: Proof of citizenship, voter ID,one-day voting and paper ballots
Oneindia
3/27/2025
3:37
Trump Executive Order Tightens Proof Of Citizenship Rules For Voting In Federal Elections
Oneindia
3/26/2025
7:47
'Discrimination Is Alive And Well': Jeff Merkley Calls To Pass Equality Act
Forbes Breaking News
4/30/2025
11:25
Lawyer Reveals How SCOTUS May Rule In Case On Nationwide Injunctions And Birthright Citizenship
Forbes Breaking News
5/15/2025
3:50
Supreme Court Says Trump Cannot Resume Deportations Under Alien Enemies Act
Forbes Breaking News
5/19/2025
2:13
Trump's Lawyer Makes Case To SCOTUS Why Judge Shouldn't Block Trump Birthright Citizenship Order
Forbes Breaking News
5/15/2025
1:23
Voter fraud? Non-citizen can register to vote in Arizona; officials, law enforcement investigating
ABC15
10/31/2016
3:19
ACB Questions Trump's Lawyer About Injunction Actions In Birthright Citizenship Case
Forbes Breaking News
5/15/2025
2:15
Voting rights controversy
23ABC News
6/23/2021
6:54
Jim Clyburn Asked Which Lawmakers 'Across The Aisle' Democrats Can Work With
Forbes Breaking News
4/23/2025
48:18
Trump signs big election executive order, praises India's voting model
India Today
3/26/2025
8:01
Jim Clyburn Calls On Town Hall Attendees To ‘Help Preserve This Great Democracy’
Forbes Breaking News
4/24/2025