Ap_Pratidwani_19-48-53

ETVBHARAT

default

Transcript

00:00In IPS, they are in service for 62 or 63 years or 30 to 35 years.

00:10So, they are forgetting that and committing mistakes.

00:13We should note that they are experiencing the consequences of that.

00:16Mr. Padmanabha Reddy, if the government decides that a decision is wrong,

00:21how can the government deal with it if an officer is forced to sign it?

00:26What is your experience as an IFS officer?

00:29The government has not done anything to the officer.

00:32The maximum they can do is to transfer the officer.

00:35But, if the officer clearly states that it is against the law,

00:38or that it will result in a loss to the government,

00:41the minister can ask the officer to do it.

00:44It will be followed.

00:46But, there will be no loss to the officer.

00:49Because, there will be a lot of protection in the all India service.

00:52For example, let's say there is a district collector.

00:55If he takes 10 to 15 decisions every day,

00:58one or two of them can be wrong decisions.

01:00He is not God.

01:02He took the decisions in his own way.

01:04So, what they say is,

01:06he took the decisions with good intentions.

01:09In some cases, if there is a loss,

01:11a wrong decision can be made.

01:13I will tell you a couple of cases.

01:16In the ITDA, there was a collector named Chinthapandu.

01:20He was in the Vizag area.

01:22He said that the rate was low.

01:24So, he stopped the auction.

01:26He was the chairman of the IAS officer.

01:28It has been a year, but the rate has not increased.

01:30But, Chinthapandu has lost its value.

01:32So, he had to ratify it.

01:34But, the officer did not say anything.

01:36Because, he took the decision with the intention

01:38that the rate will increase if he waits a little longer.

01:41So, there is a lot of protection for them.

01:44Even if there is a wrong decision,

01:47or if they do something wrong,

01:51they will be punished.

01:53But, if they take the right decisions,

01:55whether it is the chief minister or the minister,

01:57they will be given a good name.

02:01Mr. Shankaran, who I met in the state,

02:03has a very good name.

02:05I still remember his name.

02:07But, according to the rules,

02:09there will be some problems.

02:13They will be transferred every 3 to 6 months.

02:15But, they will have a salary.

02:17They will have service protection.

02:19If there are 20 to 30 IAS officers,

02:21the ministers will stop them.

02:23They will stop them.

02:25Because, there are less officers who work hard,

02:27everyone is going through the same.

02:29So, we should not say,

02:31don't complain, don't complain.

02:33But, a few people are honest.

02:35A lot of people are saying,

02:37why did they come to us?

02:39They are saying,

02:41let us also go to the river bank.

02:43They are earning money.

02:45They are saying,

02:47let us also go to the river bank.

02:49They are earning money.

02:51They are retiring.

02:53This will cause a lot of loss to the people.

02:55Also, as Mr. Subbarao said,

02:57it is hard to believe.

02:59It is hard to believe.

03:01Even good people think corrupt people are bad.

03:03Even now,

03:05as Mr. Subbarao said,

03:07there are cases like Raheja.

03:09There are cases like this.

03:11Even after seeing this,

03:13senior officers,

03:15whether it is IPS or IPS,

03:17wherever they give wrong orders,

03:19oppose that.

03:21Otherwise, you may get transferred.

03:23Or, if you think about the Chief Secretary or CM,

03:25you will still have protection.

03:27So, please,

03:29in order to save the society,

03:31if there are no laws and orders

03:33given by the ministers and chief ministers,

03:35it is not possible to do this boldly.

03:37It will be good if you write it in a note file.

03:39You will also have protection.

03:41Mr. Subbarao, tell us in a fair way.

03:43Earlier, there was the Indian Penal Code.

03:45Now, there is the Indian Constitution.

03:47According to these laws,

03:49how did these laws behave

03:51according to the rights of the criminals?

03:53Are there any examples related to this?

03:55In this,

03:57when the criminals

03:59were under the criminal breach of trust,

04:01if you give them the right

04:03to protect their property

04:05with the government,

04:07when did you violate it?

04:09According to the old section,

04:11under section 409 IPC,

04:13there is a right to punish

04:15a person for life imprisonment.

04:17In addition,

04:19all the criminals

04:21under section 120B,

04:23according to the old IPC,

04:25all the criminals

04:27under section 120B

04:29can be punished

04:31for life imprisonment

04:33or 10 years of imprisonment.

04:35Secondly,

04:37under section 13

04:39they can be prosecuted.

04:41When there is a violation

04:43of the law,

04:45there is another danger.

Category

Transcript

Recommended