Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
Klaus Welle discusses EU dynamics, Ukraine war, and future of Europe
euronews (in English)
Follow
02/01/2025
Klaus Welle discusses the future of Europe, tackling issues like the EU dynamics, Ukraine war, US-EU relations, migration, social justice, and misinformation.
Category
đź—ž
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
Germany is set to go to the polls in February, but meanwhile the fate of Ukraine hangs in
00:12
the balance as the Trump administration is due to unveil its Ukraine policy. For the
00:17
Europe Conversation, I catch up with Klaus Welle, former Secretary General of the European
00:21
Parliament and now Chair of the Martin Center Academic Council. I caught up with them at
00:26
the Martin Center Forum for European Ideas 2024 and I started by asking him about leadership
00:33
in Europe.
00:34
You're welcome, Klaus, and thanks very much for joining us here. There's so much to talk
00:40
about, but I might just ask you a little bit, first of all, about the country you know best
00:43
and Germany and the German politics at the moment. And I suppose your own assessment
00:48
about how things are vis-Ă -vis the situation in Ukraine.
00:52
I mean, there are many people who are saying that because of the collapse of the government
00:56
now German leadership is missing. But the truth is that German leadership was already
01:02
missing during the last three years. We, you know, a new word has been coined which is
01:11
called the German vote, which means abstention. And the German ambassador to the European
01:17
Union had to write a kind of open letter back to Berlin saying, putting me in an impossible
01:23
situation because I have no position to defend.
01:27
Do you believe then with a new government in place the situation will change dramatically
01:31
regarding the support for Ukraine, military support for Ukraine, specifically terrorist
01:36
missiles and the use of them in Russian territory?
01:40
The leader of the German opposition of the CDU-CSU, Friedrich Merz, has said he would
01:46
allow Taurus missiles to be delivered. Of course, it will not be a one-party government,
01:51
it will be probably a two-party government, CDU-CSU plus Social Democrats or plus the
01:57
Greens. And I believe if it were to be in alliance with the Greens, Germany would more
02:04
strongly engage, including Taurus missiles. The Social Democrats have a problem because
02:10
their parliamentary group leader is also the leader, you could say, of the pacifist
02:15
faction. And therefore Olaf Scholz always had to do a balancing act with the left wing
02:20
of his party.
02:22
Chancellor Merkel in her autobiography has defended her position as Chancellor in relation
02:27
to accessing cheap energy from Russia, gas and oil and so on. What's your own feeling
02:36
around this? Because that's something that Germany's been heavily criticised for because
02:41
despite all the clear warning signs around Crimea, Georgia and interference in European
02:46
and American elections.
02:48
I do not agree that Angela Merkel is singled out on this issue because if you have a closer
02:53
look, Poland was completely dependent on Russian gas, Czech Republic was completely dependent,
03:01
Slovakia was completely dependent, Hungary was completely dependent. Austria is still
03:06
completely dependent, more or less, and Germany was. It didn't start with Merkel, it started
03:13
before. It didn't end with Merkel, it just ended because of the Ukraine war. So I think
03:21
to see the personal responsibility of Angela Merkel would not be correct.
03:28
Because the Baltic countries would say that they sounded clear warnings to Germany, to
03:33
the European Union over the past decade about a co-dependent or an interdependent relationship
03:39
with Russia vis-a-vis energy. Would you then argue that that wasn't the case?
03:43
I think they were very clear and I think we should have listened more. And the Baltic
03:48
countries have the advantage that they had to live in the Soviet Union. And when I say
03:54
live in the Soviet Union, this is too nice a word. Many of them were deported to Siberia.
04:01
We had an EPP Group Vice President who was born in the Gulag. This was an attempt for
04:08
genocide, you could say, for national extinction. And still they survived and they imposed themselves
04:15
and they became very important members of the European Union.
04:19
How do you assess the situation we're in now in relation to Russia when you're talking
04:23
about an escalation, at least 10,000 North Korean troops, Iranian support, Chinese support
04:31
for Russia? And not, I mean, huge criticism around the European Union, but what the future
04:38
holds with regard to joint procurement and supporting each other around defence?
04:43
I think that the defence needs are so urgent, especially if Russia should continue to produce
04:50
at the scale they are currently producing. And to be honest, you're Irish. I think the
04:57
times when Ireland could just relax and say, look, we don't have to participate in these
05:03
defence activities because we are very well protected, very well covered. The Irish economy
05:09
defence depends on undersea cables with the United States. And we've now seen several
05:15
attempts, the last one between Germany and Finland, to destroy this infrastructure. So I think
05:21
it's also time that Ireland deeply reflects how it can defend its vital economic, political
05:28
and military interests.
05:29
Are you confident that we are going to be unified in this confrontation with Russia for the next
05:35
few years? When you look at the hostility when it comes to, let's say, NATO membership for
05:40
Ukraine or even Ukrainian membership of the European Union from countries like Hungary,
05:45
Slovakia, when you have unanimous at the table, the voting table. I mean, this is going to be
05:50
problematic over the next while.
05:52
The support in the European Union is holding. Of course, we might see an acceleration of
05:58
events which is testing our resolve again. In case Donald Trump should be successful with his
06:05
push for Russia and Ukraine to agree on a ceasefire, in case they should do that, the next day,
06:15
the question will be on the table, who is guaranteeing the sovereignty of the free part of
06:22
Ukraine, which is still about 80 percent? And I think that question will be directed rather to the
06:28
Europeans than to the Americans.
06:30
How do you see, from a logical point of view, what is workable in terms of not Ukraine giving up
06:38
territory per se, but having areas temporarily occupied? That could mean an end to the war, that
06:44
Ukraine could move towards NATO membership. What would you say is a sort of a logical outcome?
06:51
It appears to me that the most likely scenario is that a kind of ceasefire will be agreed. Ukraine
06:59
will not agree to cede territory, but it will have to accept that for a time which is unknown, this
07:07
territory is under foreign control, under Russian control. And that, to a certain extent, is similar
07:13
to the situation of West Germany and East Germany. So West Germany was free, West Germany was
07:20
democratic, but the East was occupied by the Soviet Union. But we never gave up the hope, the vision,
07:28
the desire to see the country reunified. We had to wait 40 years, until 1989, and finally it happened
07:37
when the right moment was there. But this meant that West Germany was safe. We had American troops, we
07:46
had British troops, we had French troops. So I think what Ukraine can legitimately demand is that it will
07:53
also be safe. And I personally do not believe that it can be safe without the support also of foreign troops
08:02
in its own territory. And I believe that's most likely going to be European troops.
08:08
America would say, yes, not American troops, it would just be very specifically European troops that would
08:14
guard territory within Ukraine that would be covered by a NATO security guarantee, is that what you're saying?
08:21
I believe the Americans are focusing more and more on China. And I believe also they expect, with some
08:29
justification, that Europeans take more responsibility for the security on their own continent. And I think
08:36
that's what we have to do. And the way to do that in an efficient way is to strengthen cooperation in the
08:43
European Union and between the European Union and NATO. And there cannot be a successful economic development
08:52
in the free part of Ukraine without proper security. And those securities cannot be the guarantees of the
09:01
Budapest Memorandum. We all know the value of that, which was, let's say, very close to zero. So an end of
09:09
hostilities will need a real engagement for the security of the free part of Ukraine. It will need helping them
09:18
on their way, on their path to the European Union, because otherwise also there will be no foreign investment
09:25
in Ukraine, which is desperately needed. The Russian people are proud people. They will not be happy over the
09:33
long time to become a raw material colony of China. And that's what they're about to become. China has not yet
09:43
finalized the agreement on the delivery of gas from northern Siberia to China, because they want the prices to go
09:50
further down. Prices to go further down might mean that Russia has to sell below the cost of production. That's what's
09:59
called a colonial exploitation. So can Russia, which is a proud country, can they accept to become a raw material
10:08
colony of China? I don't think so. So I believe it's in Russia's self-interest to not just have one client and one
10:18
customer for the raw material or for their gas, but to become a more respected part of the global order and global
10:28
economy again.
10:30
But what would be the off-ramp for Vladimir Putin to agree to that? Because this sounds like a victory for Ukraine,
10:37
somewhat of a victory for Ukraine. You're not giving up permanently or formally territory with a view to taking it back
10:45
within a certain amount of time. Greater Russia hasn't been recreated. Putin has failed. NATO has expanded. Why would
10:55
he agree to this, notwithstanding all the important points he made about Russian influence in Syria and Africa being
11:02
under threat?
11:03
I mean, Russia, when they started the war, were hoping for a very quick victory. A week, four weeks, that is clearly not the
11:10
case. They probably have lost by now 200,000 Russian people, which is a lot. Russia already has a demographic problem,
11:18
which is major. So they also have limitations, which is, by the way, why they're bringing in North Koreans to die for them, or
11:26
why they've been using very much national minorities to die for them. So Russia will want to negotiate at least a partial
11:34
lifting of the sanctions. That might be on the plus side. But I think they will also be confronted by a tough position of the
11:43
United States.
11:44
Okay, well, Klaus Feller, Chairman of the Academic Council of the Martin Center, thank you very much for joining us at the Europe
11:49
Conversation. Really appreciate it. That was fascinating. Thank you.
Recommended
32:33
|
Up next
Brussels, my love? Ukraine moves closer to EU despite corruption problems
euronews (in English)
11/11/2023
2:10
EU countries set to endorse Ukraine as a candidate to join the bloc
euronews (in English)
23/06/2022
1:14
Big summit of European leaders kicks off, focusing on Ukraine and EU-UK ties
euronews (in English)
18/07/2024
2:29
European leaders discuss security as shadow of possible Trump presidency looms
euronews (in English)
19/07/2024
32:02
Brussels, my love? EU enlargement to the Western Balkans and the US Inflation Reduction Act
euronews (in English)
09/05/2023
2:17
EU and Ukraine pledge to deepen relations, call on Russia to respect peace deal
euronews (in English)
07/10/2020
32:36
Brussels, my love? The EU and Ukraine after a year of war
euronews (in English)
27/02/2023
32:37
Brussels my love? EU lawmakers discuss the climate, migration & the fate of Evan Gershkovich
euronews (in English)
22/04/2023
12:00
Ukraine is not ready to join NATO or the EU, Juncker says
euronews (in English)
06/03/2025
2:21
EU will step in and continue support for Kyiv, predicts Ukraine's Vice PM for European Integration
euronews (in English)
12/12/2024
2:34
Ukraine must align laws and standards with those of the EU as membership talks start
FRANCE 24 English
22/06/2024
2:13
'For the first time since its creation,' Europe has enemies, says EU Commissioner Moscovici
euronews (in English)
14/05/2019
12:00
Ukraine's growth in its own military capability a sign it can prevail - Bruegel thinktank
euronews (in English)
11/10/2024
1:27
Ukraine has fully met two of the seven conditions needed to start EU accession talks
euronews (in English)
22/06/2023
3:15
President Zelenskyy's emotional appeal to European leaders
Brut India
01/03/2022
8:00
Shoring up Ukraine and EU's defence
euronews (in English)
02/04/2025
0:30
EU chief says 'Europe's destiny is at stake' on third anniversary of Ukraine war
AFP English
24/02/2025
1:32
Moldovans and Ukrainians remain hopeful over potential EU membership
euronews (in English)
27/06/2024
2:53
What to expect from the EU's special summit on foreign affairs
euronews (in English)
01/10/2020
8:11
European Parliament president calls for “solid and swift” action if Ukraine crisis escalates
euronews (in English)
17/02/2022
1:25
EU accession process standards must be met, von der Leyen says
euronews (in English)
03/06/2022
17:00
Nicola Procaccini: Reformist group seeking balance of power shift in EU parliament
euronews (in English)
24/05/2024
8:00
From crisis to cooperation: how the EU handled the troubled 2019-2024 era
euronews (in English)
15/05/2024
0:24
Zelensky says 'geopolitical certainty' possible when Ukraine joins EU, NATO
AFP English
16/01/2025
1:45
EU leaders meet to discuss Ukraine aid, Syria's transition and Trump's comeback
euronews (in English)
19/12/2024