要求法庭裁定禁烟令违宪   律师：禁烟令对吸烟者，构成歧视 - video Dailymotion

Hotspot热点

新闻报报看 | 自称是“资深烟民”的资深律师哈尼夫，昨天入禀诉讼认为办公室是私人场所，只要不影响他人，在办公室吸烟就不成问题。他还要求法庭裁定这项禁烟令违宪，理由是禁烟令会对吸烟人士构成不公平的歧视。(主播：颜江瀚、罗美伶)

Transcript

00:00Before watching the video, let me remind you that there is more content on the R.E.D.I.A.N. website.

00:30I still feel very dissatisfied.

00:32Former prime minister Mahatma Gandhi's lawyer Hanif

00:34challenged the judiciary in his own name yesterday

00:39and demanded that his law firm be excluded from the ban on smoking.

00:43That is, he can smoke in his office

00:45to defend his right to smoke in the office.

00:48Yes.

00:49Hanif, who claims to be an experienced smoker,

00:51was sentenced online

00:53and listed by the Tamil Nadu government and the Ministry of Health as the first and second defendants.

00:58His argument is that the office is a private space,

01:02so as long as it does not affect others,

01:04it is not a problem to smoke in the office.

01:06He also pointed out that smoking in China

01:08is a legal activity guaranteed by the law and the constitution.

01:12Smoking in the smoking area of the law is considered illegal.

01:16He believes that the government can of course supervise the smoking activity,

01:19but whether the office should smoke or not

01:21should be decided by the owner.

01:23If the owner wants to smoke in the office,

01:26he can apply for a ban on smoking by himself.

01:29This is reasonable.

01:31But this is not the first time Hanif has challenged the ban on smoking.

01:34In November last year,

01:36he wrote a letter to the Minister of Health,

01:39demanding that his office be excluded from the ban on smoking.

01:43But it was later rejected.

01:45Then he decided to go to court.

01:47He said he started smoking at the age of 21

01:50and smoked three packs of cigarettes every day.

01:53This is a very serious smoking addiction.

01:56Since the government issued a ban on smoking in October last year,

01:59he has posted notices outside his office

02:02to inform anyone who does not like to contact a smoker

02:05not to go to his office

02:07because his law firm is the smoking area.

02:11Yes, in addition to posting notices,

02:14Hanif also sent emails to inform his employees and customers

02:17to emphasize again that his law firm is the smoking area

02:21and also provided a replacement plan.

02:23If employees do not want to work in the smoking area,

02:26they can resign at any time

02:28and he will give them a certain compensation.

02:30As for customers,

02:31if they do not want to deal with lawyers smoking in the office,

02:34they can also find him at any time to retrieve these files.

02:38There is no need to force employees and customers

02:41to smoke in his office.

02:44Hanif also said that he is a senior smoker

02:47and he does not want his life to be interfered with,

02:49so he does not want his workplace and private space

02:52to be listed as a smoking area.

02:54In addition to asking the court to exclude the office from the smoking area,

02:57he also asked the court to rule that this ban is against the constitution.

03:01His reason is that the ban will cause unfair discrimination

03:04against smokers.

03:06In his view, the smoking area will become a private area for non-smokers,

03:10and smokers like him will be marginalized

03:13and will be discriminated against by others.

03:15And while waiting for the court ruling,

03:17Hanif also asked the court to temporarily terminate his smoking ban

03:21until the trial is over.

要求法庭裁定禁烟令违宪律师：禁烟令对吸烟者，构成歧视

Category

Transcript

Recommended

要求法庭裁定禁烟令违宪 律师：禁烟令对吸烟者，构成歧视

Category

Transcript

Recommended

要求法庭裁定禁烟令违宪律师：禁烟令对吸烟者，构成歧视