Labour government announces inquiry into Pat Finucane murder

News Letter

Labour government announces inquiry into Pat Finucane murder, Sept. 11, 2024

Transcript

00:00We now come to the next statement. I call the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland,

00:05Hilary Benn.

00:08With permission, Mr Speaker, I would like to make a statement about the death of Patrick

00:13Finucane. Patrick Finucane was a human rights lawyer. On 12 February 1989, he was brutally

00:21murdered in his home in North Belfast by loyalist paramilitary group the Ulster Defence Association

00:29in front of his wife Geraldine, who was wounded, and his three children, one of whom is now

00:36the Honourable Member for Belfast North. From that day onwards, Mrs Finucane and her family

00:43have campaigned tirelessly in search of answers about the killing of their loved one. In 1990,

00:50an inquest was opened and closed on the same day with an open verdict. Subsequently, a

00:57number of investigations and reviews were conducted. In 2001, following the collapse

01:04of powersharing, the UK and Irish Governments agreed at Western Park to establish public

01:10inquiries into a number of troubles-related cases, if recommended by an international judge.

01:18Judge Peter Corry was appointed to conduct a review of each case, and in 2004 he recommended

01:25that the UK Government hold public inquiries into four deaths—those of Rosemary Nelson,

01:32Robert Hamill, Billy Wright and Patrick Finucane. Judge Corry also recommended that the Irish

01:40Government establish a tribunal of inquiry into the deaths of former RUC officers Bob Buchanan

01:48and Harry Breen. Inquiries were promptly established in all of these cases,

01:56with one exception—the death of Mr Finucane. Meanwhile, in 2003, the third investigation by

02:05Sir John Stevens into alleged collusion between the security forces and loyalist paramilitaries

02:12had concluded that there had been state collusion in Mr Finucane's killing.

02:20That investigation was followed by the conviction in 2004 of one of those responsible, Ken Barrett.

02:29With criminal proceedings concluded, the then Northern Ireland Secretary,

02:33Paul Murphy, made a statement to Parliament, setting out the Government's commitment to

02:39establish an inquiry, but despite a number of attempts the Government were unable to reach

02:44agreement with the Finucane family on arrangements for one. In 2011, the coalition Government decided

02:54against an inquiry. Instead, a review of what had happened, led by Sir Desmond de Silva QC,

03:01was established. Sir Desmond concluded that he was left

03:07in no doubt that agents of the state were involved in carrying out

03:12serious violations of human rights up to and including murder.

03:20The publication of his findings in 2012 led the then Prime Minister, David Cameron,

03:26to make an unprecedented apology from this dispatch box to the Finucane family on behalf

03:34of the British Government, citing the, and I quote,

03:38shocking levels of state collusion, end of quote, in this case.

03:44In 2019, the Supreme Court found that all the previous investigations had been insufficient

03:52to enable the state to discharge its obligations under Article 2 of the European Convention

03:58on Human Rights. The court identified a number of deficiencies in the state's compliance with

04:03Article 2 in particular. Sir Desmond's review did not have the power to compel the attendance

04:09of witnesses. Those who met Sir Desmond were not subject to testing as to the accuracy of

04:15their evidence, and a potentially critical witness was excused from attendance.

04:21In November 2020, the then Secretary of State for Northern Ireland announced that he would

04:27not be establishing a public inquiry at that time, pending the outcome of continuing investigations,

04:34but that decision was quashed by the Northern Ireland High Court in December 2022.

04:43Mr Speaker, this Government takes its human rights obligations and its responsibilities

04:48to victims and survivors of the Troubles extremely seriously, and the plain fact is

04:56that two decades on, the commitment made by the Government, first in the agreement with

05:03the Irish Government and then to this House to establish an inquiry into the death of Mr Finucane,

05:10remains unfulfilled. It is for this exceptional reason that I have decided to establish

05:18an independent inquiry into the death of Patrick Finucane under the 2005 Inquiries Act.

05:26I have, of course, met Mrs Finucane and her family, first on 25 July to hear their views,

05:34and again yesterday to inform them of my decision. Mrs Finucane asked the Government to set up a

05:41public inquiry under the 2005 Act, and as I have just told the House, the Government have now

05:48agreed to do that in line with both the 2019 Supreme Court ruling and the Court of Appeal

05:56judgment in July this year.

Category

Transcript

Recommended