Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
FBR Ke Paas Logon Ko Filer Bananay Ki Capacity Hi Nahi, Saddar All Pakistan Anjuman-e-Tajran
ARY NEWS
Follow
8/30/2024
FBR Ke Paas Logon Ko Filer Bananay Ki Capacity Hi Nahi, Saddar All Pakistan Anjuman-e-Tajran
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
As a result of this week's high-profile strike, the business of this country has been shut down.
00:10
The economic experts say that they have not seen such an impactful strike before.
00:17
The problem is that there are some concerns about tax.
00:23
The tax evaluation table is being revised.
00:28
In addition to this, they are calling it a hooligan tax.
00:32
The situation is that the data of the FPR is in front of me.
00:35
And in the last year, in 2023-2024, which class has given how much tax?
00:39
What does the data of the FPR tell us?
00:41
The highest tax in this country is given by the salarymen, 375 billion.
00:45
Then the exporters are giving 111 billion.
00:47
Then the retailers are giving 34 billion.
00:49
Then the real estate is giving 8 billion.
00:52
And then Zaree Shobha is giving 8 billion.
00:54
That is, we have seen that the retailers, real estate, Zaree Shobha, and the exporters in total,
01:00
are giving less tax than the salarymen.
01:03
Mr. Shahbaz Rana has made an interesting story in the Express Tribune.
01:07
He says that after the protest, the government of Pakistan issued a tax return form.
01:13
In which the traders were excluded from giving details of bank accounts and assets.
01:18
According to the form, apart from collecting tax refunds,
01:21
the traders will not be required to give details of bank accounts.
01:24
But the traders want to be completely excluded.
01:26
According to the source, after the successful tax return protest,
01:29
the FPR seems to be in the mood to give more relief to the traders.
01:32
On the other hand, according to the government source,
01:34
the IMF program cannot be sabotaged.
01:36
And any relief given to the traders is dependent on the approval of the IMF.
01:41
According to the new scheme, the government had to collect 50 million rupees from the traders in the Rawa financial year.
01:46
Which is now seen as impossible.
01:48
Out of lakhs of traders, only 205 have come to the tax net.
01:53
From which 5 lakhs of tax has been collected.
01:56
According to Mr. Shahbaz Rana's story.
01:58
How far has this matter reached?
02:00
And does it seem that the government will have to step back after the protest?
02:04
With us in the program is Mr. Ajmal Baloch,
02:06
President of All Pakistan Anjuman Tajran.
02:07
Mr. Shahbaz Rana, former chairman of FPR.
02:09
He is also an expert in economics.
02:10
Thank you both very much.
02:11
Mr. Ajmal Baloch, let's start with you.
02:13
We have already shown your objections to tax.
02:17
Why don't you want to pay tax?
02:20
Because generally, the sentiment in this country is that the paid class pays more tax.
02:26
Whenever we try to bring the traders to the tax net, they protest.
02:30
In the last government, Mr. Ismail wanted to impose tax.
02:33
You got it reversed.
02:34
This time you want to reverse it again.
02:36
Look, there are two types of paid class.
02:39
One is government and the other is non-government.
02:41
Private people.
02:42
Private people are paying.
02:43
Government tax is paid from our tax.
02:47
Some money is deducted from it for tax.
02:50
Then they take 5 lakhs, 10 lakhs facilities from us.
02:53
That is also a burden on us.
02:55
When this trade scheme was brought,
02:58
we were told that this non-filer will give 1200 rupees to bring it to the net.
03:05
It will be registered.
03:06
And it will file its return after a year.
03:09
Like the old taxpayer, it will also become a taxpayer.
03:11
We welcomed it.
03:13
We gave access to the FBR.
03:16
These 63,000 people who have been registered,
03:20
they have been registered on our behalf.
03:22
Although, in every market, they do not have the capacity to bring people to the net.
03:27
It has been six months,
03:29
a total of 50,000-60,000 people have been registered.
03:32
We said, okay, everyone should come to the tax net.
03:37
The next thing we got,
03:39
when we got closer,
03:41
the chairman who was leaving,
03:43
we did not know,
03:44
the last meeting we had with him,
03:46
he said that this scheme is a valuation table.
03:51
We got worried.
03:53
What is a valuation table?
03:54
When we saw that your property,
03:57
the property belongs to the owner,
03:59
99% of the tenants are inside.
04:01
The DC value, the FBR value,
04:05
suppose the value of a shop is one crore rupees,
04:08
10% of that will be spent on income.
04:11
Now, you do not get a penny for one crore rupees.
04:15
The smallest shop,
04:17
I do not know, the owner has an income of six lakhs.
04:19
The law says that there will be no tax on it.
04:20
How much tax do you want to give?
04:22
We want to give on our income.
04:24
Everyone is giving on their income.
04:26
The thing is,
04:27
it has been 25 years since I have been in this business.
04:31
They have not been able to bring people to the net.
04:33
It is not easy to bring people to the net.
04:35
People do not come to the net.
04:37
The easiest way was,
04:38
the commercial meter holder,
04:41
the electricity bill is a government document,
04:44
he is paying an advance of 10% income tax on it.
04:48
I have been asking since 2001 to register him.
04:51
Send him a notice.
04:53
Four and a half lakh people,
04:55
to transfer the property,
04:57
to sell the car,
04:58
if you take the NTN,
04:59
they have come out of the FBR net.
05:02
Who is responsible for that?
05:03
Last time, you were not even ready to give a fixed tax.
05:06
No, it was not fixed.
05:07
Mr. Mifta Ismail was tweeted and said,
05:09
then he reversed the tax again.
05:10
You do not want to give, right?
05:11
No, no.
05:12
You always close the tax.
05:13
The government comes under pressure.
05:14
No, no, no.
05:15
The state does not close the income tax,
05:17
so it is okay.
05:18
The electricity bill,
05:19
I had imposed a tax of 3000.
05:21
What was that?
05:22
Already,
05:23
every trader,
05:24
10% income tax,
05:26
when it is totaled,
05:27
it appears to be 16%.
05:29
But 10%
05:30
filer or non-filer,
05:32
advance tax is being paid.
05:34
They wanted to take 3000.
05:36
He is giving 70,000,
05:37
50,000,
05:38
30,000,
05:39
40,000 per year,
05:40
which is non-filer.
05:41
Then why were you imposing 3000 more?
05:44
See,
05:45
till the time,
05:46
FBR,
05:47
the Prime Minister comes,
05:48
he says,
05:49
there is a problem in FBR,
05:50
we will fix FBR.
05:51
No one has done it right.
05:52
Sir,
05:53
but the 34 billion retailers who are paying tax,
05:55
is it right in proportion to your income?
05:57
Because,
05:59
See,
06:00
I say,
06:01
this is wrong.
06:02
How much are they paying?
06:03
How much are the retailers paying?
06:04
FBR,
06:05
I say,
06:06
1.25 crore traders.
06:07
Tell me,
06:08
even if a trader is sitting in Chaman,
06:11
he does not know how much tax I am paying,
06:14
he is still paying a tax of 30,000-40,000 per year.
06:16
Sir,
06:17
when you come to the tax act,
06:18
you will come to know.
06:19
You will be formalized.
06:20
This is the problem.
06:21
Actually,
06:22
people,
06:23
the situation is like this,
06:24
70% in the country,
06:25
there is a decrease in buying and selling.
06:26
Except for the grocery store,
06:28
and the medical store,
06:29
there are no customers.
06:31
When there are no customers,
06:32
when there are no buyers,
06:33
then what will the shopkeepers do?
06:35
See,
06:36
the country's landowners,
06:37
industrialists,
06:38
and shopkeepers,
06:39
all three are so worried,
06:40
all three are against the government.
06:42
In such a difficult time,
06:44
Mr. Shabbar Zaidi is with us,
06:46
we have not gone to Corona in such a difficult time.
06:48
Okay,
06:49
we will talk to Mr. Shabbar Zaidi.
Recommended
3:07
|
Up next
Pakistan Mein Razi Naame Ke Bad Mulzimaan Buri Honay Ki Riwayat Barqarar,
ARY NEWS
9/20/2024
6:21
Pakistan Mein Anokhay Muqadmaat Ki Tareekh Kya? ?
ARY NEWS
11/29/2024
6:06
Kkya Nai Aini Tarmeem Mein Practice and Procedure Tarmeemi Ordinence Bhi Shamil Tha???
ARY NEWS
9/21/2024
6:50
Kya Bani PTI Ke 190 Million Pound Case Par Asar Pare Ga ...
ARY NEWS
9/7/2024
2:45
Sirf Cricket Par Siyasat Karni Hai Bharat Ko Baqi Khelon Ke Liye To Un Ki Temen Pakistan Aati Hain
ARY NEWS
11/9/2024
4:13
" Pora Adalti Nizaam Zameen Bose Ho Jaye Ga, Yeh Tabahi Hai. ." Salman Akram Raja
ARY NEWS
10/18/2024
1:34
Karobar Ki Registration Nah Karanay Walon Ke Gird Ghaira Tang
ARY NEWS
9/26/2024
2:44
Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf Ne Qaumi Assembly Ke Liye Umeedwaron Ki Fehrist Jari Kar Di
ARY NEWS
1/12/2024
4:49
9 Hazar 7 So Billion Mein Se 54Ùª Hum Import Se. ... Baqi 34Ùª Hum 300 Companiyon Se Letay Hain,
ARY NEWS
8/30/2024
9:15
Bani PTI Ka GHQ Ke Bahar Ehtijaj Ka Bayan. .. Ali Mohammad Khan Ne Ahem Baat Btadi
ARY NEWS
7/22/2024
6:38
" PTI Qayadat Ki Ahliat Nahi Ke Dobarah Ehtijaj Ki Call Den," Kamran Murtaza
ARY NEWS
12/3/2024
9:41
Fouj Mein Court Marshal Ka Tareeqa Car Kya Hai? Kya Bani PTi Ke Liye Khatrah Barh Gaya?
ARY NEWS
12/10/2024
4:20
" ICC Ne Pakistan Aur Bharat Ko Keh Diya Aap Apas Mein Laren Hum Kuch Nahi Kar Satke. .. "
ARY NEWS
12/4/2024
4:15
Maulana Fazal-ur-Rehman Ki Hukoomati Aur Oppostion Rehnumao Se Ahem Mulakaatein... Maria memon
ARY NEWS
8/31/2024
6:32
" Bani Ne Kaha Mein Baqi Qaidyoun Ki Terhan Rahon Ga. ." Rehnuma PTI Shandana Gulzar
ARY NEWS
7/5/2024
4:02
Mazakraat Honay Chahiye Ya Nahi?? Noon League Aur PTI Ke Mutazaad Bayanaat
ARY NEWS
8/31/2024
7:21
" PTI Ka Thora Bohat Nuqsaan Howa Hoga Yeh Koi Bari Baat Nahi Hai," Rana Sanaullah
ARY NEWS
11/29/2024
5:12
"Pakistan Ki Tareekh Main Aik hi Banda Tha Jisnay IMF Program Kamiyabi Say Mukamal Kiya"Afnan Ullah
ARY NEWS
3/22/2024
6:33
Imran Khan case bhi military court ki taraf ja raha hai ??? Rana Sanaullah
ARY NEWS
12/14/2024
8:14
Takhat Lahore Ka Sab Se Bara Takra - Halqay Ke Voters Kis Party Se Tang ?
ARY NEWS
1/9/2024
3:11
Wukla Ka Ehtijaj, Tadaad Nihayat Kam. . Wukla Mein Ittehaad Nahi..? Salman Akram Raja Bol Pare
ARY NEWS
9/27/2024
0:24
pakistan stock Mein Aaj Bhi Mandi, 988 Points Ki Kami Record
ARY NEWS
12/22/2023
3:50
Election Commission Record Ke Mutabiq Ab PTI Azad Jamaat Hai, Kanwar Dilshad
ARY NEWS
12/22/2023
1:24
Islamabad : Khwaja Siraon Ki Numainda Nayaab Ali Election Laren Gi
ARY NEWS
12/22/2023
0:48
Bani PTI ki zamanat mai tausee - Latest News
ARY NEWS
2/24/2024