Ayse Tajir jinka Crore's ka Revenue hai agar wo 10 Hazar Tax Nahi... Senator Afnan ullah Aalysis

ARY NEWS

#shutterdownstrike #tradersprotest #tradersstrike #pmshehbazsharif #afnanullahkhan #11thhour #waseembadami   Ayse Tajir jinka Crore's ka Revenue hai agar wo 10 Hazar Tax Nahi... Senator Afnan ullah Aalysis

Transcript

00:00Now, PTI's Senator Humayun Mohamad,

00:02Mr. Humayun, tell us, he has explained this in full detail by Mr. Naeem Mir,

00:07which makes it clear that this is the first step to bring this class into the tax rate.

00:11And since it is practically not possible overnight

00:14to determine the monthly income of every trader in Pakistan,

00:18we all know, I'm sure you would also agree,

00:19that this mechanism cannot be made overnight.

00:21So, this imaginary income, which is adjustable,

00:23we have started with this.

00:24Now, if there is a political divide on this as well,

00:26and there is a government pressure,

00:28then how will we document the economy?

00:31What is wrong in it, Mr. Humayun?

00:58Mr. Humayun, you are right.

01:17A high-end shop is a good example of cooking.

01:19This is not how it started in the market.

01:21But, you and I are saying that

01:23we should improve the criteria.

01:25But, in principle, this approach is right,

01:27in your opinion as well.

01:29Look, in principle, direct taxation is better.

01:34But, in Pakistan, the same thing is that

01:36here, there is documentation.

01:40Secondly, we have legalized dishonesty at the government level.

01:46For example,

01:47what we call the DC rate,

01:50is basically dishonesty.

01:53Basically, you are making black money.

01:56You are legally showing a property worth Rs. 5 crores

01:58worth Rs. 2 crores.

02:00Okay, after that, let me tell you one thing.

02:02All the houses in Islamabad,

02:04all the houses in F6, F7, F8,

02:07which are of 2-4 canals,

02:10are not less than Rs. 15-20 lakhs.

02:12Go and see how much tax their owners are paying.

02:16They take cash from you.

02:19They don't pay you tax.

02:21So, Mr. Shabbar, when the government has taken a step

02:23to solve these problems,

02:24that a group of people should be brought in for taxation,

02:26and the merchants have organized a strike,

02:27and you are standing with them?

02:29No, no, no, look, the thing is,

02:31we are standing with them,

02:33that if you look at the whole package,

02:35there is dishonesty in the whole package.

02:38If you are with a merchant,

02:40I am telling you this because,

02:42in a way, I am working,

02:43I am paying tax, I am paying rent,

02:46I am doing everything myself.

02:47But, when you increase the net tax on me,

02:51they are putting indirect tax on me,

02:53they are taking advance tax from me,

02:55which later creates problems for me,

02:57so, in the end, I feel like

02:59I cannot earn anything from this business.

03:01So, what is happening is,

03:02people are going out of Pakistan,

03:04and then they are increasing the electricity bill.

03:07When you look at all these things,

03:08a lot of injustice starts happening.

03:11Mr. Afnaan, what is the solution to this,

03:13Mr. Afnaan, in government?

03:14Look, Mr. Shabbar was also saying this during the break,

03:16that we are stuck.

03:17On one hand, the merchants say,

03:19you are hitting me with electricity from here,

03:21the rent has increased so much from here,

03:22the purchasing power of the customer has died,

03:24so, the footfall has already decreased.

03:26On top of that, you are also hitting me with this,

03:28so, he is crying.

03:29The government is crying,

03:30that brother, if you want to run the country,

03:31if you have money, you will run the country, right?

03:33So, we are stuck.

03:35What is the solution to this, Mr. Afnaan?

03:39Look, the solution to this is that

03:41we onboard the merchant community with us,

03:46we review their legitimate demands

03:49and we want to take the matter forward.

03:52But you understand this,

03:54the representatives of the merchant community

03:56who were here, they said,

03:58that this number is not right,

04:00which I am telling you.

04:01They are listening to you.

04:02You tell me,

04:03how many businesses are there in Pakistan,

04:05which are in shops,

04:07which are working on cash.

04:09Millions.

04:11Where are they registered?

04:13Where are they registered?

04:16You tell me.

04:17It is happening in the air.

04:19Yes, I am saying that

04:21if you say that we are giving tax,

04:23then somewhere,

04:25it will be reflected,

04:27in the collection.

04:29So, this is what we have checked,

04:31and there is not so much tax,

04:33let me tell you.

04:35There are merchants

04:37who have revenues of crores of rupees,

04:39who do not even have such big shops,

04:41and the work of gold has been done,

04:43for example.

04:45There is a revenue of crores of rupees.

04:47If you cannot even pay

04:49a monthly tax of Rs. 10,000,

04:51then this is a matter of regret,

04:53and if you still have issues,

04:55then what can a person say?

04:57You were saying Rs. 10,000 earlier,

04:59which Mr. Javed disagreed with.

05:01I was talking to Mr. Ismail,

05:03he was saying that in Karachi,

05:05in Sindhi Muslim,

05:07every shop has been paid Rs. 60,000.

05:09If someone is fined,

05:11the tax is fine,

05:13but this is not even the final tax.

05:15In the final tax collection,

05:17if you think that

05:19your income has decreased,

05:21then you can claim tax credit,

05:23and you will get credit

05:25on the income.

05:27But the matter is,

05:29we have to take matters

05:31forward from somewhere.

05:33I also think that there is no harm

05:35in putting a point of sale.

05:37If someone thinks that

05:39they can put a point of sale,

05:41then there is no harm in doing so.

Category

Transcript

Recommended