Skip to player
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Comments
Bookmark
Share
Add to Playlist
Report
Why The Glazers Have Set Man United Up To Fail
FourFourTwo
Follow
18/07/2024
Manchester United manager Erik ten Hag has made mistakes at the start of the season – but the Glazers haven't exactly helped matters at Old Trafford.
Category
🥇
Sports
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
Manchester United finished their 3-1 defeat against Arsenal with Harry Maguire and Jonny
00:07
Evans as their centre-back pairing, the same two that Leicester City had four seasons ago.
00:12
It's an example of the stagnation at Old Trafford alright, and not something you could possibly
00:17
imagine at Manchester City, Liverpool, even Arsenal these days.
00:21
Ex-club captain Gary Neville berated the Glazer ownership on Sky Sports after yet another
00:25
away defeat for their lack of investment, and yes it's well known to everyone that
00:29
those at the top of the tree aren't particularly invested in the club, but is that the biggest
00:34
reason for Manchester United's failure to catch up with rivals in the last few years?
00:38
Really?
00:39
This is why the Glazers have set Eric ten Haag up to fail.
00:44
The Glazers are a polarising topic within the world of English football.
00:48
Ask any Manchester United fan and they'll tell you that US businessmen are parasites
00:51
proceeding over a slow demise of a once great institution, yet to some that's an excuse,
00:58
and it's true that the numbers don't quite stack up.
01:01
Chelsea have been handing out 8-year contracts to the past three transfer windows like they're
01:05
totally the norm, and so they have the highest net spend in the Premier League over the last
01:09
five years, yet second on the list is Manchester United, whose fans regularly call for more
01:14
investment from their owners.
01:16
It's not quite as simple as just going out and spending more money though.
01:20
United have spent huge sums in the past ten years, and that's thanks to the commercial
01:24
deals that the club has brought in.
01:26
United have shelled out £50m or more for a player 15 times in their history.
01:32
Neville pointed out on Sky at the weekend that with the revenue the club brings in,
01:36
his former side should be high up on any net spend list, but it's hard to argue that his
01:40
former employers have spent the money well.
01:42
Paul Pogba is still the club's record signing, ahead of Anthony who cost £80m.
01:48
The Brazilian has managed 11 goals and assists in 47 games at United, which isn't a particularly
01:53
great return, and he regularly starts ahead of Jadon Sancho, who's failed to impress
01:57
too, after moving for a similar amount of money.
02:00
Between Anthony and Sancho on the record signing list is the much maligned Harry Maguire.
02:04
Below them are Romelu Lukaku and Angel Di Maria, two big money buys who left shortly
02:09
after joining, and whom United were lucky to recoup big fees for from clubs on the continent.
02:15
Just on the list after that are two players at different ends of their careers, Rasmus
02:19
Haaland and Casemiro, with one thing in common, United paid far more than the going rate for
02:25
either.
02:26
Bruno Fernandes and Luke Shaw cost a lot of money and they're both in hits at Old Trafford.
02:30
Anthony Martial and Fred cost £100m combined, and the former has a Ballon d'Or clause in
02:36
his contract, which just now seems wild.
02:39
You can argue that the Red Devils had to pay a United tax for some of these players, but
02:43
clubs demand more money when they know a wealthy Premier League club are interested,
02:47
but clearly the club can still afford to compete for transfers without the Glacier's help.
02:52
Let's not forget here, United have outbid their rivals for players time and time again
02:56
over the last few years, and it has been celebrated by fans as a show of power.
03:14
Lissandra Martinez was wanted by Arsenal, but United outbid what the Gunners could afford.
03:19
Manchester City were interested in Fred, in Alexis Sanchez and in Cristiano Ronaldo.
03:25
Manchester United lured all three away from Pep Guardiola.
03:29
So let's just get this clear, it's not the Glacier's fault that Harry Maguire hasn't
03:33
worked out, it's not the Glacier's fault that Angel Di Maria didn't like Manchester,
03:37
or that Romelu Lukaku didn't recreate his Everton form, it's not the Glacier's fault
03:41
that Casemiro is starting to look his age just a year into his contract, nor is it
03:45
their fault that Anthony doesn't look a good fit for English football, or that Sancho isn't
03:49
explosive enough for a Premier League forward.
03:51
But it is the Glacier's fault for allowing the club to waste hundreds of millions of
03:55
pounds without any kind of clear plan.
03:59
Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results
04:04
according to Albert Einstein, and the Glaciers haven't seemed to realise that a world class
04:08
recruitment team is needed to support the manager.
04:11
Liverpool's first title win inside in 30 years was masterminded by Michael Edwards,
04:16
who brought in the likes of Gini Wijnaldum, Andy Robertson and Sadio Mane.
04:21
Jochen Klopp infamously wanted Julian Brandt as his right winger, Edwards vetoed the idea
04:26
to instead sign Mohamed Salah.
04:28
Mauricio Pochettino's Tottenham team had Paul Mitchell working behind the scenes, the
04:32
man who brought Dele Alli, Son Heung-min, Kieran Trippier and Tobias de Verelde to
04:37
the club.
04:38
At Arsenal now, Nikola Teta has Eddie Gaspar as his sporting director.
04:43
At Newcastle, Eddie Howe has Dan Ashworth.
04:45
At Aston Villa, Unai Emery has Munshi.
04:49
At Manchester City, Pep Guardiola has Chiqui Begadistain.
04:53
Manchester United do not have anything close to an equivalent.
04:56
United's football director John Murtough has history in analysis, but not as a scout
05:01
or someone directly involved in identifying talent.
05:04
Darren Fletcher is the club's technical director, after serving other roles at the
05:08
club, while CEO Richard Arnold has less to do with the playing side and more to do with
05:12
commercial operations at United.
05:14
While most other clubs have brought in sporting directors to oversee recruitment and ease
05:18
the burden of the modern day manager, United have a complete void in this area.
05:23
The Red Devils plan to bring in Ralf Rangnick on a consultancy basis following the German's
05:27
interim management post ending.
05:29
Rangnick reneged on the deal to manage Austria.
05:32
The club decided not to get a replacement.
05:35
Eriksen Haag spent most of last summer pursuing Frenkie de Jong, a player he worked with at
05:40
Ajax.
05:41
He instead signed Kristian Eriksen, a former Ajax player.
05:44
He also added Anthony and Lissandra Martinez, two other players he worked with at Ajax.
05:49
He signed two Dutch players, Foutveeghorst and Tyrell Malasia, and this summer he signed
05:54
two more former players, Andre Onana and Sofiane Amrabat.
05:59
Now there's nothing unusual in the odd reunion here and there, but the sheer volume of players
06:04
joining Manchester United who have a close connection to the manager is astounding.
06:09
Most of them either know him personally or have played against his side.
06:13
It certainly feels as if Ten Hag is not just the head coach of this side, but the most
06:17
important man on the recruitment side too.
06:20
Ten Hag has worked as a sporting director before, but that was almost a decade ago at
06:23
Utrecht.
06:24
It's incomparable to the job he's got to do at Manchester United.
06:28
It's similar actually to the problems that Ralf Rangnick faced.
06:31
Rangnick had spent just two years of the previous ten coaching players when he was appointed
06:35
the interim coach of the club.
06:37
He was a failure at Manchester United, but the people who hired him set him up for that
06:42
fail.
06:43
If Ten Hag is to blame for poor signings during his United tenure, that's perhaps because
06:47
he's underqualified to make them.
06:49
Yes, he has lots of money to sign players, but money does not guarantee success as United
06:55
have found in the past ten years, and who, well, Chelsea are finding out right now.
07:00
Asking the Glazers to invest in the squad is one thing, asking them to refresh the infrastructure
07:05
at the stadium to keep the club competitive, even to show they care a little is another,
07:10
but simply ploughing more money into Manchester United's playing squad won't get to the
07:14
root of how Ten Hag is strained to carry so much more than any of his contemporaries.
07:20
Last season, Brentford beat Manchester United 4-0 in just Ten Hag's second game.
07:26
The B's ran eight miles further than Manchester United's players in that game, and as a punishment,
07:30
Ten Hag made his men run eight miles to make up for it.
07:34
But Ten Hag did something incredible that day.
07:36
He ran with them.
07:38
He's not a professional athlete anymore, but he ran over eight miles to show his players
07:43
that they were all equal in the responsibility of failure in his eyes.
07:47
It helped bond the players together.
07:49
They ended up having a great season, winning a trophy and qualifying for the Champions
07:53
League, but who's doing the running with Eric Ten Hag in the transfer market?
Recommended
12:25
|
Up next
Why Erik Ten Hag's Man United Isn't Working Yet
FourFourTwo
18/09/2023
9:19
Why The Manchester United Takeover Isn’t What It Seems
FourFourTwo
26/03/2024
14:51
How Crystal Palace Destroyed Man United
FourFourTwo
15/05/2024
18:06
Why Man United Had To Sack Erik Ten Hag
FourFourTwo
05/11/2024
11:09
Why Man United's Problems Are Even Worse Than You Think
FourFourTwo
20/11/2023
11:26
Manchester United fans react to Ten Hag sacking and who they want next
NicheSportMedia
28/10/2024
4:15
Manchester United capitulation at Crystal Palace: What’s next for the team?
National World - LocalTV
08/05/2024
3:47
What’s going wrong at Manchester United?
National World - LocalTV
12/10/2023
17:30
The Reason Why Man United Had To Sack Erik Ten Hag
FourFourTwo
10/01/2025
2:37
Manchester United attacking conundrum needs managing
National World - LocalTV
06/09/2023
3:03
How much pressure is falling on Erik ten Hag at Manchester United?
National World - LocalTV
28/02/2024
0:56
Injuries an issue Manchester United have to solve - ten Hag
beIN SPORTS USA
25/10/2024
16:11
Why Man United's New System Needs Manuel Ugarte
FourFourTwo
13/09/2024
3:01
Manchester United travel to Arsenal in the Premier League
National World - LocalTV
30/08/2023
3:22
Manchester United changing youngster policy throughout club
National World - LocalTV
17/08/2023
0:56
NASA's Perseverance Rover Captured Martian Moon Phobos Transit The Sun
Space.com
today
1:07
Watch The Far Side Of Moon As It Comes Between Earth And Spacecraft
Space.com
today
1:06
Comet Nishimura's Tail Fails In The Solar Wind In Amazing Spacecraft Time-Lapse
Space.com
today
1:50
England beat Spain in Euro final after shootout thriller
Stadium Astro English
today
0:36
Goalscorer Russo reflects on England's 'incredible' Euro triumph
Stadium Astro English
today
0:47
Spain 'deserved more' in Euros final - Tome
Stadium Astro English
today
2:04
How To Cook Padron Peppers | Recipe
GoodtoKnow
today
1:41
How To Roast Pork | Recipe
GoodtoKnow
today
1:07
Mushroom Soup | Recipe
GoodtoKnow
today
5:28
Dide - Who Is The Premier League's Secret Rapper?
FourFourTwo
yesterday